X Close

‘Elite overproduction’ isn’t the problem

The man who started it all. Credit: Getty

July 20, 2023 - 6:15pm

“Elite overproduction”, which Conservative MP Miriam Cates bemoaned in a recent article for the Daily Telegraph, can be a misleading phrase. After all, it is hard to see how a society could suffer from a surfeit of very able people.

Of course, it makes more sense in its original context. Peter Turchin, who coined the term, explained in an interview with UnHerd that it really refers to overproduction of “elite aspirants”: people who want, and expect, to gain an elite position, but for whom there are insufficient positions available.

Crucially, this definition of “elite” refers purely to status, not ability. It has nothing to say about the character or calibre of the people at the top of the pyramid, or if the process for replenishing their number selects for good characteristics.

Looking at our ever-expanding mediocrat class and its mounting pile of failures, one might argue Britain actually suffers from elite underproduction: either our system produces too few who merit the label “elite”, or it at least keeps them out of public life.

That this should cause problems is much more intuitive: there is nothing more dangerous than a downwardly mobile middle class, whose members have both stronger habits of political organisation and more resources committed to their cause.

In Britain, the most obvious vector for this phenomenon was Tony Blair’s massive expansion of tertiary education. Ever since he first declared his aspiration for 50% of school leavers to go to university, we have funnelled ever more young people into them. This has “shifted the UK to the Left”, as the Telegraph puts it (and as New Labour advisers privately admit was always the intention). 

But Cates’s focus on graduates adopting “high-status opinions” misses this initiative’s most damaging effect: the way in which society and the economy have adjusted to artificially inflate the value of degrees.

Many employers now use a 2:1 as a first-stage filter on job applications, even for roles which a generation ago would have been open to school leavers. This locks young people into a vicious cycle, forced onto the higher education debt treadmill just to stand still in economic terms. Not only do they end up effectively paying usurious marginal tax rates due to loan repayments, but it also delays their entry into the world of work by at least three years. 

Flat wage growth, not to mention both house prices and rents climbing remorselessly, in turn delays their getting on the housing ladder, or acquiring capital of any sort, by even longer — trapping these people in a twilight late adolescence into their thirties.

Deprived of the opportunity to mature into adulthood, they don’t. Instead of combatting this, British institutions have indulged it. The Government recently faced calls to ban under-25s from carrying passengers in their cars; more seriously, the Scottish Sentencing Council recommends lenient treatment for even serious criminals below that age because “the brain is not fully developed”.

Britain does not have a surplus of elites, then, but instead a surplus of adolescents. All the while, the remorseless march of the degree continues. In the face of a childcare cost crisis, Labour’s Bridget Phillipson proposes to make looking after pre-school-age children a graduate profession. It was only in November that Home Secretary Suella Braverman axed plans to require all police officers to have degrees.

Universities are not geared towards the economy. That’s why we have at once a record number of graduates and a skills crisis. The easiest way to palliate their discontent has been to create passably paid, high-status, low-accountability white-collar jobs in the public sector. What do many of those people do? Generate and service the vast amount of paperwork it takes to do anything productive. Which, in the long run, makes the economic situation even worse.


Henry Hill is Deputy Editor of ConservativeHome.

HCH_Hill

Join the discussion


Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber


To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Subscribe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

26 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David McKee
David McKee
1 year ago

Excellently put, and in well under 700 words too.
Some years ago, I was in the Barbican in London, for some errand or other. I saw a line of young people, in graduation robes. This was the graduation ceremony for the University of East London. Almost all of the young people came from an ethnic minority. I felt intensely sorry for them, as I knew they were about to get an education they would not enjoy at all – how much their degrees were worth on the jobs market.
Some of these young people might have been very able, and capable of graduating from a better university. But then, careers advice in schools is not always of good quality.
I was witnessing a tragedy – a cheerful, giggling tragedy, but a tragedy from which there is almost no escape.

David McKee
David McKee
1 year ago

Excellently put, and in well under 700 words too.
Some years ago, I was in the Barbican in London, for some errand or other. I saw a line of young people, in graduation robes. This was the graduation ceremony for the University of East London. Almost all of the young people came from an ethnic minority. I felt intensely sorry for them, as I knew they were about to get an education they would not enjoy at all – how much their degrees were worth on the jobs market.
Some of these young people might have been very able, and capable of graduating from a better university. But then, careers advice in schools is not always of good quality.
I was witnessing a tragedy – a cheerful, giggling tragedy, but a tragedy from which there is almost no escape.

Matt M
Matt M
1 year ago

My hunch is that IA will replace most white collar jobs in the next five years. This could lead to an inversion of the current system with money and status shifting from office workers to skilled manual workers. What happens then to the millions of people currently treading water in consultancy, project management, marketing, finance, HR, PR and accountancy?

Susan Grabston
Susan Grabston
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt M

Already happening in the US where top plumbers on ip to $300k per annum.

Last edited 1 year ago by Susan Grabston
Erik Hildinger
Erik Hildinger
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt M

I suspect you are right. I’m not sure quite how to feel about it. If, as I’ve read, something over 62% of high school graduates in the U.S. attend a college or university of some sort, it must be the case that the classes have been significantly dumbed down, therefore the degrees are not meaningful, and this may become evident even to the graduates themselves. If this is coupled with AI taking away low-level white collar jobs, then what is a university education good far, apart from the STEM classes? And the DEI agitators are already doing their best to undermine them.

Peter Johnson
Peter Johnson
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt M

This is also going to hit women harder than men since they make up the majority of mid and lower level office workers. Ironically the male worker clearing drains that everyone looked down on is in a much more secure position than a HR professional.

Susan Grabston
Susan Grabston
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt M

Already happening in the US where top plumbers on ip to $300k per annum.

Last edited 1 year ago by Susan Grabston
Erik Hildinger
Erik Hildinger
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt M

I suspect you are right. I’m not sure quite how to feel about it. If, as I’ve read, something over 62% of high school graduates in the U.S. attend a college or university of some sort, it must be the case that the classes have been significantly dumbed down, therefore the degrees are not meaningful, and this may become evident even to the graduates themselves. If this is coupled with AI taking away low-level white collar jobs, then what is a university education good far, apart from the STEM classes? And the DEI agitators are already doing their best to undermine them.

Peter Johnson
Peter Johnson
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt M

This is also going to hit women harder than men since they make up the majority of mid and lower level office workers. Ironically the male worker clearing drains that everyone looked down on is in a much more secure position than a HR professional.

Matt M
Matt M
1 year ago

My hunch is that IA will replace most white collar jobs in the next five years. This could lead to an inversion of the current system with money and status shifting from office workers to skilled manual workers. What happens then to the millions of people currently treading water in consultancy, project management, marketing, finance, HR, PR and accountancy?

Jim Veenbaas
Jim Veenbaas
1 year ago

Great essay. Short but insightful. As the author notes, the ever-expanding university grad class has created more credentialization, which is shutting out capable people from decent jobs that really don’t require post-secondary education.

Jim Veenbaas
Jim Veenbaas
1 year ago

Great essay. Short but insightful. As the author notes, the ever-expanding university grad class has created more credentialization, which is shutting out capable people from decent jobs that really don’t require post-secondary education.

Right-Wing Hippie
Right-Wing Hippie
1 year ago

This has “shifted the UK to the Left”, as the Telegraph puts it (and as New Labour advisers privately admit was always the intention).
Has there been any political event in Britain since Gavrilo Princip’s impromptu street theatre that hasn’t shifted the UK to the Left?

Ian McKinney
Ian McKinney
1 year ago

The Falklands War.

J. Edmunds
J. Edmunds
1 year ago

The 1983 general election
The Miners Strike

Ian McKinney
Ian McKinney
1 year ago

The Falklands War.

J. Edmunds
J. Edmunds
1 year ago

The 1983 general election
The Miners Strike

Right-Wing Hippie
Right-Wing Hippie
1 year ago

This has “shifted the UK to the Left”, as the Telegraph puts it (and as New Labour advisers privately admit was always the intention).
Has there been any political event in Britain since Gavrilo Princip’s impromptu street theatre that hasn’t shifted the UK to the Left?

Peter Kwasi-Modo
Peter Kwasi-Modo
1 year ago

Of the 2,800,000 higher education students, I am guessing that only a small minority would define themselves as elite or even elite aspirant. For example, of the 48,000 studying media, journalism and communication, I suspect very few aspire to be Polly Toynbee, let alone Rupert Murdoch. 
When Alison Rose started out as a NatWest trainee with a history degree from a provincial university was she an elite aspirant who dreamed that one day she might cancel Nigel Farage’s banking facilities on a woke whim.

Last edited 1 year ago by Peter Kwasi-Modo
Jim Veenbaas
Jim Veenbaas
1 year ago

Are there 48,000 kids studying media, journalism and communication? Ouch. Reality will be ugly for this bunch.

Last edited 1 year ago by Jim Veenbaas
Peter Johnson
Peter Johnson
1 year ago
Reply to  Jim Veenbaas

I don’t buy into the idea that AI is going to take away everyone’s job. But ChatGPT writes better than 90% of people in my organization. AI is going to crush media and journalism because writing is all they do – and many of them do it poorly.

Peter Kwasi-Modo
Peter Kwasi-Modo
1 year ago
Reply to  Peter Johnson

Peter, I totally concur with your point that ChatGPT produces well-written, nicely structured documents. But the trouble is that you have to check every “fact” in the document: it is not very reliable. To make matters worse, it is poor at explaining the provenance of what it presents as “facts”. But of course, that is also true of some journalists.

Peter Kwasi-Modo
Peter Kwasi-Modo
1 year ago
Reply to  Peter Johnson

Peter, I totally concur with your point that ChatGPT produces well-written, nicely structured documents. But the trouble is that you have to check every “fact” in the document: it is not very reliable. To make matters worse, it is poor at explaining the provenance of what it presents as “facts”. But of course, that is also true of some journalists.

Peter Kwasi-Modo
Peter Kwasi-Modo
1 year ago
Reply to  Jim Veenbaas

Jim, those are the numbers proudly presented by the UK Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA):
https://www.hesa.ac.uk/news/19-01-2023/sb265-higher-education-student-statistics/subjects

Peter Johnson
Peter Johnson
1 year ago
Reply to  Jim Veenbaas

I don’t buy into the idea that AI is going to take away everyone’s job. But ChatGPT writes better than 90% of people in my organization. AI is going to crush media and journalism because writing is all they do – and many of them do it poorly.

Peter Kwasi-Modo
Peter Kwasi-Modo
1 year ago
Reply to  Jim Veenbaas

Jim, those are the numbers proudly presented by the UK Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA):
https://www.hesa.ac.uk/news/19-01-2023/sb265-higher-education-student-statistics/subjects

Cassander Antipatru
Cassander Antipatru
1 year ago

We encourage people basically from primary school to emulate famous celebrities and to change the world. I don’t know how many would explicitly say “I want to be part of the elite”, but that’s what we’re grooming them to want.

Jim Veenbaas
Jim Veenbaas
1 year ago

Are there 48,000 kids studying media, journalism and communication? Ouch. Reality will be ugly for this bunch.

Last edited 1 year ago by Jim Veenbaas
Cassander Antipatru
Cassander Antipatru
1 year ago

We encourage people basically from primary school to emulate famous celebrities and to change the world. I don’t know how many would explicitly say “I want to be part of the elite”, but that’s what we’re grooming them to want.

Peter Kwasi-Modo
Peter Kwasi-Modo
1 year ago

Of the 2,800,000 higher education students, I am guessing that only a small minority would define themselves as elite or even elite aspirant. For example, of the 48,000 studying media, journalism and communication, I suspect very few aspire to be Polly Toynbee, let alone Rupert Murdoch. 
When Alison Rose started out as a NatWest trainee with a history degree from a provincial university was she an elite aspirant who dreamed that one day she might cancel Nigel Farage’s banking facilities on a woke whim.

Last edited 1 year ago by Peter Kwasi-Modo
Simon Neale
Simon Neale
1 year ago

When I taught in Further Education, there was relentless pressure to get students into Universities. Entry requirements were shockingly low, such that you needed to have serious intellectual problems to be turned away. Those that needed special help to cope with level 3 courses (extra time in exams, IT, amanuenses, etc) were guaranteed the same in H.E.

As we all said would happen when Blair’s reforms began to take shape, students would merely face a “21 plus” before dead-end office jobs.

Simon Neale
Simon Neale
1 year ago

When I taught in Further Education, there was relentless pressure to get students into Universities. Entry requirements were shockingly low, such that you needed to have serious intellectual problems to be turned away. Those that needed special help to cope with level 3 courses (extra time in exams, IT, amanuenses, etc) were guaranteed the same in H.E.

As we all said would happen when Blair’s reforms began to take shape, students would merely face a “21 plus” before dead-end office jobs.

Charles Hedges
Charles Hedges
1 year ago

G M Trevelyan ( one of Britin’s greatest historians ) in the 1940s pointed out that expansion of secondary and tertiary education would create an intellectual proletariat.
Standards have been dropping since Oxford stopped requiring undergraduates to pass a Greek paper for entry in 1920 and PPE was started in 1922. The decline in Britain mirrors the expansion of the PPE degree.
What is an elite? A gentleman, lady, a scholar a Renaissance figure? A gentleman knows Latin, gentleman and scholar knows Latin and Greek. A Renaissance ( for example Sir Phillip Sydney, Ralph Bagnold ) figure must be a soldier, scholar, dancer, courtier, musician, poet, athlete, etc.
I suggest G M Trevelyan got it slightly wrong we are producing a lumpen intellectual proletariat because we are not producing people who are scholars and athletes. What is then point of going to university if scholars are not produced?
Ruth Sutherland of The Observer said G Brown’s investment was just an increase in public sector employment in the regions.

J. Edmunds
J. Edmunds
1 year ago
Reply to  Charles Hedges

What’s a PPE degree?
A qualification in fleecing the taxpayer to supply duff overalls and masks.

J. Edmunds
J. Edmunds
1 year ago
Reply to  Charles Hedges

What’s a PPE degree?
A qualification in fleecing the taxpayer to supply duff overalls and masks.

Charles Hedges
Charles Hedges
1 year ago

G M Trevelyan ( one of Britin’s greatest historians ) in the 1940s pointed out that expansion of secondary and tertiary education would create an intellectual proletariat.
Standards have been dropping since Oxford stopped requiring undergraduates to pass a Greek paper for entry in 1920 and PPE was started in 1922. The decline in Britain mirrors the expansion of the PPE degree.
What is an elite? A gentleman, lady, a scholar a Renaissance figure? A gentleman knows Latin, gentleman and scholar knows Latin and Greek. A Renaissance ( for example Sir Phillip Sydney, Ralph Bagnold ) figure must be a soldier, scholar, dancer, courtier, musician, poet, athlete, etc.
I suggest G M Trevelyan got it slightly wrong we are producing a lumpen intellectual proletariat because we are not producing people who are scholars and athletes. What is then point of going to university if scholars are not produced?
Ruth Sutherland of The Observer said G Brown’s investment was just an increase in public sector employment in the regions.

Derek Smith
Derek Smith
1 year ago

The photo at the top. Yikes! Can anyone else see that and hear the cackling laugh of Skeletor?

Richard Craven
Richard Craven
1 year ago
Reply to  Derek Smith

I thought everyone knew that Skeletor was really the antisemitic former MP Chris Williamson.

Ian McKinney
Ian McKinney
1 year ago
Reply to  Richard Craven

Don’t know why the downvotes, I had a chuckle!

Ian McKinney
Ian McKinney
1 year ago
Reply to  Richard Craven

Don’t know why the downvotes, I had a chuckle!

Richard Craven
Richard Craven
1 year ago
Reply to  Derek Smith

I thought everyone knew that Skeletor was really the antisemitic former MP Chris Williamson.

Derek Smith
Derek Smith
1 year ago

The photo at the top. Yikes! Can anyone else see that and hear the cackling laugh of Skeletor?

Alison Wren
Alison Wren
1 year ago

Given the Bell curve of IQ, why are we sending so many to universities. In the 1960s 5% went to university, 1% got first class degrees which made those an intellectual elite. Now it appears some universities award firsts to about 1/3rd of their students (some 40% of the age cohort). Unsurprisingly these degrees don’t confer the status of a 1960s 1st class degree.

Alison Wren
Alison Wren
1 year ago

Given the Bell curve of IQ, why are we sending so many to universities. In the 1960s 5% went to university, 1% got first class degrees which made those an intellectual elite. Now it appears some universities award firsts to about 1/3rd of their students (some 40% of the age cohort). Unsurprisingly these degrees don’t confer the status of a 1960s 1st class degree.

Paul Curtin
Paul Curtin
1 year ago

Universities are no longer for education, they are industries.

Paul Curtin
Paul Curtin
1 year ago

Universities are no longer for education, they are industries.

Adrian Smith
Adrian Smith
1 year ago

The answer is to encourage far more apprenticeships which can lead to HNC, HND and Degrees where those qualifications are needed post apprenticeship.

Adrian Smith
Adrian Smith
1 year ago

The answer is to encourage far more apprenticeships which can lead to HNC, HND and Degrees where those qualifications are needed post apprenticeship.

Gary Taylor
Gary Taylor
1 year ago

All true, but they self identify as elite hence the epic sense of entitlement, etc.

Gary Taylor
Gary Taylor
1 year ago

All true, but they self identify as elite hence the epic sense of entitlement, etc.

David Mottershead
David Mottershead
1 year ago

Our elites are wonderfully narcissistic. They exist everywhere in both the public and private sector. But they are completely ineffective and do not hold the respect of the ‘non-elite’ at all.

David Mottershead
David Mottershead
1 year ago

Our elites are wonderfully narcissistic. They exist everywhere in both the public and private sector. But they are completely ineffective and do not hold the respect of the ‘non-elite’ at all.