X Close

Did Freya the Walrus deserve to die?

Hot Freya summer (Photo by Tor Erik Schrøder / NTB / AFP)

August 17, 2022 - 11:46am

If you visited Oslo earlier this summer, you might have met a celebrity walrus named Freya. Freya showed little fear of humans, and charmed the public with her antics; dozing, chasing ducks, and reducing boats to splinters as she heaved herself out of the water to sunbathe. Crowds gathered wherever she stopped on her tour of the coast, and she allowed them to approach and take photos or even swim in the water with her.

Sadly, Freya was put down on Sunday, after officials decided that her close encounters with the public were unacceptably risky. Walruses are wild animals, weighing around a ton. While it is rare for them to attack humans, a stressed or over-friendly walrus could kill a person alarmingly easily — as in fact happened at a Chinese zoo in 2016.

Was there really no option other than killing Freya? Apparently not: it seems moving her would have been prohibitively difficult, and evidently people could not be trusted to keep a safe distance. Those responsible judged it was not a risk they were willing to take.

Predictably, there are some who vehemently disagree with this assessment. Frank Bakke-Jensen, the Norwegian fisheries director, has reportedly received death threats from around the world after announcing the decision.

I don’t know whether I agree with the call that was made. But the decision was not my responsibility. If a child had been crushed or drowned, I wouldn’t have been the one apologising to the parents — and neither would any of the people currently harassing Mr Bakke-Jensen.

Difficult choices like this invariably seem to attract waves of sentimental outrage. Take the now infamous case of Harambe the gorilla, shot and killed to protect a three-year-old boy who fell into his enclosure in Cincinnati zoo in 2016. Or Geronimo, the alpaca who was euthanised last year after testing positive for bovine TB, but not before 140,000 people signed a petition urging Boris Johnson to intervene to save him. I doubt any of the people loudly horrified by either decision would be queuing up to take responsibility for the spread of a serious infection, or for the death of a toddler at the hands of a gorilla.

These cases attracted enormous international media attention. There are 30,000 walruses in the north Atlantic. Caring for this population and its habitats is ultimately more important than the life or death of one walrus. But the public have been much less interested in the way, say, oil and gas exploration harms these animals in the long-run than the bitter arguments over Freya in recent days.

This tendency towards outrage is even worse when it attaches itself to human, rather than animal, tragedy. In unutterably painful cases where a judgement is made to withdraw life support from a child, rather than give the family privacy, onlookers flock like vultures to offer their two cents or send abuse to the medics involved.

There’s something ghoulish in these loud emotional displays from people who are ultimately not the ones affected. Feeling pain for the fate of an unrelated person or animal is widely regarded as a moral good. But when this develops into righteous anger (“the most delicious of moral treats”); when it’s not tempered by reason; when it’s indulged at the cost of those involved; then it’s not moral. It’s selfish.

Ellen Pasternack is a PhD student in evolutionary biology at Oxford University.


Join the discussion

Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber

To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Notify of

Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Andrew Wise
Andrew Wise
1 year ago

Fair comment
I suspect its always been the case, but social media is an amplifier of these stories, too easy for people like me to dive in and make an ill informed comment because I want my 15 seconds of fame (now reduced from 15 minutes due to overcrowding)

John Murray
John Murray
1 year ago

They don’t go killing bison in Yellowstone park just because some morons get too close from time to time and pay the price. Idiot humans getting too close to a a one ton animal, well, play stupid games, win stupid prizes. By contrast, Harambe was dragging a kid around and the alpaca had a deadly disease, so not much choice in those cases.
The people with a real say in it would be the boat owners I’d say, not sure I’d appreciate the insurance arguments about Freya-related damages if I was them. I can see doing the cost-benefit and deciding Freya had to go, but no doubt it is a bit cold.

Noel Chiappa
Noel Chiappa
1 year ago

The reaction is just one more example of the infantilization of Western populations; people whose understanding of the hard choices of life is that of children, not adults,
‘Defund the police’ (especially in a violent America), anyone? How about mass adoption of solar and wind power – which are inherently intermittent, and thus unreliable?
Look at the bright side: being misguided about euthanizing one wild animal is a lot less consequential than making bad choices about the electricity sources on which modern civilization depends.

Sasha Marchant
Sasha Marchant
1 year ago

The hysteria is ridiculous and death threats are unacceptable. Nevertheless, the killing of this animal troubles me. The reasons given were (1) safety of the (idiotic) people coming into contact with her and (2) that moving her would be stressful for her. Firstly, I find it distasteful that so many people think nothing of automatically killing wild animals for the sin of coming a little to close to human habitat (I accept that in some cases this may be necessary). Humans really need to learn to live with the other animals on this planet and that includes accepting a level of risk. Secondly, did someone really decide that that Freya would be better off dead than stressed? Just last week in Malawi 263 elephants and 431 other animals were airlifted between national parks. For the elephants this involved being hoisted upside-down by crane! The authorities can dress it up in any way they please – hard choices etc. but, ultimately, Freya was killed because she got in the way. A most dispiriting story that reflects poorly on all involved.