It has been the week of celebrity handwashing. Every showbiz reporter in London has spent the days since Russell Brand’s rape conviction and David Walliams’s unmasking as the superinjunction celeb fielding “not me guvs” from anyone famous enough to have shaken the hand of one of these radioactive men, including Jonathan Ross and the deputy leader of the Labour Party.
Normal people, too, are conducting their own moral exercises, disgusted by a celebrity culture which seems, once the stone is turned over, to be hiding a bevy of bugs. One of these exercises is earnest discussion around the possibility of a staggered age of consent — such that, for example, a person over the age of 20 would be breaking the law by having sex with a 16 or 17-year-old. The government has even signalled that it is considering such a change in the law.
As things stand, 16-year-olds in the UK can consent to sex with adults of any age. The separate Brand and Walliams allegations involve coercion of all kinds, leveraging money, fame, and charisma; inappropriate age differences, though, were allegedly also a factor. If this worries the public more than other imbalances of power, it is because age gaps are a universal problem: here, at least, we feel we can do something.
It is true that two teenagers having sex, where one is 16 and another 18, is not the same as the younger party sleeping with a middle-aged man. Part of our natural response is revulsion — especially among us women, most of whom remember the frightening feeling of being perved on by fogeyish chancers in our teens. These memories tend to curdle further as we age, and realise just how young 16-year-olds are. Unfortunately, finger-wagging does not work. We might post snarky things about Stephen Fry’s 30-years-younger husband or, in America, the NFL coach Bill Belichick (a 74-year-old who met his girlfriend in 2021, when she was 20). Nevertheless, our queasiness stops nothing. So we want to legislate.
The problem with taking radical action in the wake of a horrifying scandal is that it becomes difficult to look at the facts neutrally. After the biggest celebrity news story the UK has perhaps ever had — the revelation that Jimmy Savile was a prolific nonce enabled by a permissive establishment which valued his fundraising power and national treasure-status above the safety of girls — there ensued a wave of paranoia that furnished the lies of Carl Beech. In our frenzy to correct other wrongs, we bulldozed sense and held aloft a fairly conspicuous nutjob whose claims, in any other moment, would have seemed ridiculous.
Staggered consent could become another example of this. While few of us want to encourage men in their fifties to go for girls of 16 — reasonable people of both sexes recognise this to be morally repugnant, if not despicable — it is sensible to consider the unintended consequences of legislating against it.
The idea of a new law would be to remove the burden on the young victim to demonstrate coercion, and for their age to be proof enough. But for many child-protection experts — whose opinion, after all, matters the most — our existing legislation suffices. Professor Roger Ingham, who runs the University of Southampton’s Centre for Sexual Health Research, told the Guardian that “tinkering with the law” risked diverting attention from better sex education. He also suggested it might deter teens from seeking help for contraception, or stop them coming forward in cases of abuse, worried that they’ll be in trouble.
Criminal law is a blunt instrument in the complicated reality of teenage sexuality. There are two paths ahead: one which treats teens as passive potential victims, and one which both recognises this potential and equips them with honest education and access to support. A bright-line rule may reassure us that we’re doing something, but we risk confusing criminalisation with protecting the vulnerable. Any ruling that makes young people less likely to tell adults what’s happening should be considered extremely carefully.
Caution makes perfect sense when we look at things with a measure of sobriety — the question is whether we are capable of that after the month of news we’ve had. My suspicion is that we are not.






