X Close

Michel Barnier’s fall won’t save Macron

Jupiter has lost his shine. Credit: Getty

December 5, 2024 - 7:00am

After attempting to force through his budget without a majority in the National Assembly, French Prime Minister Michel Barnier has been deposed by an ad hoc coalition of the Left and the Rassemblement National. He managed only 246 votes in support, out of a possible 577.

When Emmanuel Macron appointed Barnier to be his next prime minister in September, the former Brexit negotiator knew he was signing up for perhaps the most difficult job in his long career. Just three months later, he now holds the record for the shortest-serving French government since 1958. The parliamentary arithmetic had become too complicated over the looming budget. Barnier and his minority government knew they were at the mercy of Marine Le Pen should she decide to join forces with the Left for a no-confidence vote. After weeks of toying with the Prime Minister, she has decided to end her transactional support for the centre.

As for Barnier’s successor, we are in uncharted waters. Macron could decide to appoint another member of Les Republicains in his stead. It would not be a particularly conciliatory sign, but crafting an alternative majority seems difficult. The centre-left does not appear any more willing to prop up Macron than it did last summer. A coalition with Le Pen is an obvious non-starter. And so the President will have to start again and hope that Barnier’s scalp appeases an angry public.

But as this political crisis continues to engulf France, fingers will increasingly be pointed at Macron himself, who is ultimately responsible for the current parliamentary chaos thanks to his decision to dissolve parliament in June. While he cannot call for another snap vote until next summer, he could break the deadlock by resigning and triggering anticipated presidential elections.

At present, this seems unlikely. But should the deadlock persist, Macron will be the target of attacks from all directions, including from within his own ranks. Within his increasingly fractious orbit, many have already been marking their ground for the next presidential race — including three of his four previous prime ministers — and now consider the President to be a disconnected lame duck solely responsible for the disastrous snap vote of this summer.

Giving weight to this vision, Le Monde paints an unflattering portrait of an isolated monarch surrounded by a small inner circle of obsequious advisors. In pompous Gaullean fashion, Macron now allegedly talks about his French compatriots as “mon peuple”. While Le Monde’s article should be taken with a grain of salt given the paper’s hostility to the President, Macron has undeniably lost his magic touch and lacks the political capital to wield any meaningful power.

In the background, another crisis is brewing — this time concerning Marine Le Pen. Accused of illegally using European Parliament funds for RN party staff, she could be hit with severe financial sanctions and, most importantly, deemed ineligible for the next three years, which would rule her out of the 2027 presidential election. Though a ruling is not expected until 31 March and Le Pen can appeal, she knows that this affair looms over her presidential ambitions.

One might connect this affair with her growing resolve to topple Barnier after being content for months to hold him under her “surveillance”, as she used to boast. Over the last few days, Le Pen has kept increasing her demands to the government in an apparent desire to see the Prime Minister trip over one of her many red lines and provide her with a casus belli, all the while hoping for the whole Macronist edifice to collapse. Le Pen made that clear on the day of the no-confidence vote when she urged Macron to leave: “It’s up to him to conclude if he is in capacity to stay […] and to determine if he can ignore the obviousness of the massive popular defiance which I consider definitive.”

The ever-ambitious Le Pen would have much to gain from an anticipated presidential election. On the Left, Jean-Luc Mélenchon of La France Insoumise would eagerly run for a fourth time. A charismatic but ageing figure with many staunch opponents on the Left, he would also benefit from a quick election which might preempt the emergence of potential rivals. But with what feels like the full span of the French political spectrum sharpening their blades, the throne they both covet might come with a painful bill.


Pierre-Louis Bodman is an independent French politics analyst.

Join the discussion


Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber


To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Subscribe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

6 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
A Robot
A Robot
4 days ago

Back in the 1960’s, the cover of an edition of Private Eye was a photo of de Gaulle with the speech bubble “Pendant moi la déluge”. They could re-cycle it just now.
Le Pen might fall victim to lawfare, but my impression is that this would not be such a disaster for the RN. My French friends might be a biassed sample, but they seemed to be enthused by M. Bardella.

Santiago Excilio
Santiago Excilio
3 days ago

I am starting to think we might be witnessing the beginning of the end of the EU in all this. The long stored seeds of its destruction (sequestering member states ‘competencies’ to itself) are now finally finding nutrient-rich compost in the spiralling government debt, energy prices, deteriorating economic conditions and rising, immigration driven societal tensions, in its two principle players France and Germany. Furthermore, neither country is any longer in possession of the tools it requires to address these issues. If it were just one or the other in a state of increasing stagnation, then it might be possible to recover. However, with both the political engine (France) and the economic engine (Germany) of the EU facing unsolvable domestic situations how long can the centre hold? Germany’s government has already collapsed, now France’s – the auguries are not looking good.

Emmanuel MARTIN
Emmanuel MARTIN
4 days ago

Our political situation is mess, with no easy or good option.
The press is burgeoning with trending names for candidates, but last time it took two months to form a government. New snap elections are impossible (unless Macron resigns).
When Belgium had a year with no government (due to no working coalition), it was a great economic year where most indicators improved. Maybe it could be an option for France.

Last edited 4 days ago by Emmanuel MARTIN
Hugh Bryant
Hugh Bryant
3 days ago

Obviously, devaluation is the only way out.

Oh, wait…

Jim Haggerty
Jim Haggerty
3 days ago

It’s the economic problems that are impacting the German and French Govts. The deep seated structural issues are manifesting and the decline is underway. Hopefully, a new direction for those countries and the EU can be sorted out. Starting with a common capital market structure in economies reliant primarily on banks to finance new initiatives. Credit to Wolfgang Munchau for pointing this out. It will be messy and fractured until then

ERIC PERBET
ERIC PERBET
21 hours ago

‘In pompous Gaullean fashion, Macron now allegedly talks about his French compatriots as “mon peuple”’ : comparing Macron to De Gaulle is a bit like comparing Ed Sheeran to Benjamin Britten…