18 Nov 2026 - 7:00am

Hilary Cass has seen the light. The distinguished paediatrician has withdrawn her support for the Government’s proposed conversion therapy ban, warning that it would have “serious unintended consequences”. She is worried about its “chilling effect” on doctors, who could face up to five years in prison if a patient claims to have been put under pressure to change their sexual orientation or gender identity.

Cass authored a landmark 2024 report that led to an overhaul of the prescription of puberty blockers. But she has now revealed that she was given only an hour to read the draft bill on banning conversion therapy before the publication of a press release, suggesting that ministers were in a rush to attach her name to it. In normal circumstances, losing the support of such a prominent figure would be enough to make supporters of the legislation think again. But it’s becoming clear that the impetus behind the bill is ideology, not necessity, and Labour MPs are demanding that it should become law as soon as possible.

That’s despite the Government’s own admission that the “problem” the bill supposedly addresses has been greatly exaggerated. The Telegraph revealed last week that four years ago, a Cabinet Office tender for an official hotline to report cases said the number of callers could be as high as 15,000 a year. But an updated tender put out this summer acknowledged that the figure could be as low as 300 — fewer than one a day. There is, of course, no way of knowing how many of these cases would be malicious, or how many might represent an attempt to coerce parents, teachers and doctors into accepting someone’s gender identity.

To its critics, who include many lesbians and gay men, the proposed law looks like a way of sneaking the concept of gender identity onto the statute books. Trans activists have experienced a series of setbacks in the 19 months since last year’s Supreme Court judgment asserting the primacy of biological sex. All sorts of institutions, including the NHS and schools, have reluctantly admitted that their policies — allowing trans-identified men and boys to use female facilities — had no legal basis.

The current House of Commons, elected in 2024 at the peak of ideological capture, is out of step with public opinion, which supports the judgment. Many MPs are more willing to listen to activists who see “transphobia” everywhere than to women who have had to fight to regain rights wrongly taken from us. They’ve turned the Conversion Practices Bill into a down payment on the foolish promises that leading politicians have made to trans activists. Banning questions about gender identity treats it as real and definable, despite the widespread disagreement over what it actually is.

Cass’s warning about the bill potentially leading to vexatious complaints against doctors is timely. She points out that young people who haven’t got what they want from medical professionals could be sufficiently angry to make a complaint, whether or not it is justified. Doctors, parents, and teachers, no matter how well-meaning, could all come within the scope of the bill. But it’s far from clear whether legislators in the grip of gender ideology are willing to listen even to a voice as authoritative as hers.


Joan Smith is a novelist and columnist. She was previously Chair of the Mayor of London’s Violence Against Women and Girls Board, and is on the advisory group for Sex Matters. Her book Unfortunately, She Was A Nymphomaniac: A New History of Rome’s Imperial Women was published in November 2024.

polblonde