Main Edition
US
FR
November 15, 2024 - 5:30pm
Last night, Donald Trump signalled a seismic shift in American science and public health. Fulfilling his campaign promise, he endorsed Robert F. Kennedy Jr as secretary of the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), the largest federal department with a $1.7 trillion annual budget and over 80,000 employees. Kennedy’s statement in response vows to “bring together the greatest minds in science, medicine, industry, and government to put an end to the chronic disease epidemic”, as well as to “clean up corruption” and return the health agencies to “gold-standard, evidence-based science”.
Left-leaning outlets, such as the Atlantic, Washington Post, PolitiFact, and Forbes — as well as the predominantly Left-leaning medical establishment — were quick to lambast the choice, using selective quotations and a narrow focus to smear Kennedy. But establishment mandarins who focus on his sometimes eccentric scientific claims, from vaccines to AIDS, overlook the single most important factor in his success: the anti-science, authoritarian policies of the Covid years. As a result, they miss what matters most in the Kennedy phenomenon: his broadly appealing, and thoroughly centrist, reform agenda.
This knee-jerk reaction hides the dilemma that members of the medical establishment face: do they position themselves as defenders of an increasingly untenable status quo, or do they embrace the opportunities of RFK Jr.’s reform agenda, much of which aligns with values and concerns that they have been raising for years?
Medical officials failed badly in the Covid era by supporting lockdowns, school closures, toddler masking, and mandates. Their championing of anti-science policies has caused massive health and social harm, which reverberates today. The 2024 US election was a vote against the establishment and in favour of fundamental reforms; it is unsurprising that the same establishment which endorsed lockdowns and mandates now fights kicking and screaming against oncoming change.
The rot, having accumulated over decades, was plain for all to see. The National Institutes of Health (NIH), whose annual budget is $45 billion, orchestrated under the leadership of Francis Collins and Anthony Fauci a massive suppression of scientific debate and research. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) exaggerated risk and issued policy guidance with little evidence in support of unprecedented vaccine mandates. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA)’s conflicts of interest with the pharmaceutical industry meant vaccines and therapeutics were approved with little to no evidence, sometimes based on faulty modelling. And the Biden administration pushed all of this with orchestrated PR campaigns, spreading falsehoods and misinformation.
Clearly, the status quo is no longer tenable. Trust in American physicians and hospitals dropped from 71% to 40% between 2020 and 2024, according to a July study in JAMA. A Covid-era political realignment facilitated Trump’s electoral win last week, with a coalition that included disenchanted Left-liberals who rejected the centralised power of scientific bureaucrats and found an ally in Kennedy. Yet the officials continue to deny their own culpability, avoiding a long look in the mirror.
Kennedy can be that mirror. A successful environmental lawyer and erstwhile darling of the centre-left — so much so that Barack Obama floated him to lead the Environmental Protection Agency in 2008 — he is the most high-profile figure to tackle these problems head-on. His rebranding of MAGA to Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) can carry broad appeal for Americans.
Join the discussion
Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber
To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.
Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.
SubscribeThe disinformation campaign against RFK Jr in the past few days shows that he is right over the target.
Thank you for the first fair article I’ve read since his nomination.
He is a true Patriot.
There was a particularly slimy one in the Telegraph this morning, sponsored by ‘Global Health Security’. Well Bill Gates has an awful lot to lose doesn’t he? Even if you forget the Epstein files.
This article mirrors my own assessment – much more articulately, of course. But I don’t think the medical-industrial-complex is going to go down without a fight. They are one of (many) reasons members of both houses of Congress are elected either middle-class or moderately wealthy but come out retired with utterly inexplicable increases in net worth.
I’ve listened to countless podcasts which list the obscene amount of that is spent by big pharma on lobbying. It is a disgrace.
Editors forgot to mention that Jay Bhattacharya was a co-author of the Great Barrington Declaration, which says a lot about his honesty as a scientist and courage as a man!
And remember how this declaration was pilloried by so many of their colleagues. Am so pleased I was AWAKE during the Covid fiasco. Now I’m still awake, but even more angry.
Amen!
What does this mean? Looking back, the GBD was clearly the most sensible response.
Quite. Jay Bhattacharya is a courageous citizen speaking truth to power, and a fearless scientist standing by science in defiance of “the narrative”.
Not a word out of place. People distrust the institutions – not because of misinformation and disinformation – but because the institutions have utterly failed the people they serve.
I disagree. It is precisely because of misinformation and disinformation – pretty much all of it purveyed by our “trusted” government institutions.
The costs of medical care have ballooned in recent decades, while people’s health has declined. Why is this? RFK Jr. is asking the questions that need to be asked. Good for him!
Is this the RFK who thinks that covid was ethnically targeted to avoid Jews and Chinese people?
Big pharma won’t be reformed by putting a bug eyed loon in charge of the US healthcare system, trust me on that
Right on cue and straight from Central Casting.
Are you denying he said that? While also acknowledging my movie star charisma and good looks?
Biden clearly thinks the better option for health is grown man who dresses like woman and is about 50 lbs overweight. I’ll take my chances with RFK.
You forget, we need evidence to demonstrate a loon won’t be able to reform Big Pharma. I’m sure in time all the people downvoting will have the humility and grace to admit they were wrong about RFK Jr and not immediately pivot to “well, not THAT loon of course, but this loon…”.
I like how the authors try to glean over all of the alarming beliefs RFK Jr holds.
“The central argument against Kennedy from the medical establishment pertains to some of his scientific claims, for example about vaccines, wireless radiation and cancer, raw milk, and neurodevelopmental disorders caused by water fluoridation.“
Yeah, sounds exactly like someone who listens to evidence-based science and changes his opinions accordingly!!!