Main Edition
US
FR
November 14, 2024 - 10:00am
Donald Trump is surprising even his most ardent fans. The President-elect’s nomination of Rep. Matt Gaetz to serve as attorney general managed to catch the MAGA faithful off guard on Wednesday afternoon. One senior House GOP staffer told UnHerd the reaction was “Veep-ish” when asked about the mood behind the scenes.
Gaetz is liked by Trump’s hardcore base but much less popular in DC — not just with the establishment, but also with MAGA-aligned members of Congress. This is more for personal reasons than ones related to policy, which will come as no surprise to those who’ve followed his rapid ascent to the top of the conservative movement. Despite Gaetz’s heterodox tendencies, the Congressman carries the baggage of an ongoing House ethics investigation — which he says is politically motivated, but was at the very least brought about by his penchant for hard partying.
Trump’s roster of deputies is shaping up to be just as weird as the eclectic coalition that delivered him the presidency. It’s true that his national security picks are, as a whole, more hawkish than most of the GOP base at this point, but Trump followed up his nomination of Marco Rubio as secretary of state by picking Tulsi Gabbard as his director of national intelligence. While Pete Hegseth’s foreign policy may have evolved in the years following his deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan, he’s also likely to seek major structural reforms that will infuriate the Pentagon establishment. They may not be successful, but if he’s confirmed they’ll surely be on the table.
Does Trump actually think Matt Gaetz can survive a confirmation? Is the plan to sneak him into the cabinet with a recess appointment, leave him as an acting AG without formal confirmation, or use a fight he’ll inevitably lose for political purposes? The same questions could be asked about his nominations of Hegseth and Gabbard, both of whom will undoubtedly face uphill confirmation battles.
So Trump kept Elon Musk out of it. On Tuesday night, Trump announced that Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy would head up a new Department of Government Efficiency — dubbed DOGE for the memes — that will operate outside the Government while collaborating with the White House and Office of Management and Budget. While the specifics of the arrangement are still unknown, this allows both men — but especially Musk — to keep their business interests entirely intact and skirt any regulation meant to crack down on conflicts of interest.
Musk, for example, can maintain his work as the head of the world’s most consequential companies — some of which are major defence contractors and recipients of Government subsidies — while potentially recommending big cuts that advance his own bottom line and hurt his competitors. On the other hand, it’s likely that his ability to actually make cuts will only come in the form of recommendations without the weight of formal power. Trump pitched himself back in 2016 as the right man for the presidency in part because he’d partaken in the corrupt system, and it’s possible Musk can make a similar argument.
Join the discussion
Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber
To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.
Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.
SubscribeLove Hegseth as the Secretary of Defence!! The guy served on the front lines, has all the educational credentials and he HATES what has happened to the U.S. military. He just wrote a book called the War on Warriors. A lot of generals are very nervous right now. Any general that supports all the DEI and CRT crap that has infected the military will be given the boot. The swamp will hate Hegseth. The regime media will hate Hegseth. Soldiers on the front line will love Hegseth.
Gabbard is great as well. The intelligence community will hate her too. She was actually put on the terrorist watch list, which is hysterical. So she knows intimately how effed up the intelligence community is. The Dems actually loved her too, rising to chair of the Democratic National Committee shortly after arriving in Washington. No one will tell Gabbard what to do. She’s fiercely independent so Trump might grow to hate the pick too.
At one level this feels like it is being played for the entertainment value – put in people to oversee departments that have targeted those individuals in the past, and see what happens, with the expectation of some form of explosion.
In practice, changing things will be much more about culture than browbeating or replacing figureheads. Public servants know full well how to work-to-rule, stick to the letter of the rule, add delays, tie things up via meetings and reports, and how to leak against their leaders if they are asked to implement policies they don’t believe in. And there are built-in restrictions on hiring, firing and closing departments and safety in numbers. So it’s not like a private company with a profit motive and clear outcome-driven targets where employees are fully committed and motivated to delivery the mission statement.
Wrestling the Washington interagency consensus will need very different thinking. Not least because Congress and Senate like pork barrels, and spending money wins more votes than making cuts and making Federal agencies unhappy.
That means trying new stuff. Things like red versus blue teams. Bonuses for delivering within budget. Increased levels of responsibility and accountability (tied to those bonuses). More out-of-DC involvement. And generally more engineers and fewer lawyers (for instance a limitation on the number of individuals with a law degree employed in non-legal jobs). I actually have no idea what would actually work, but just firing and yelling at people isn’t likely to be it.
Vivek seems to think you can just get rid of a lot of people through executive order. With Gaetz as AG, they’re ready for the legal battles too.
Surely – surely – the common element among Trump’s new appointees that will strike the biggest chord with the American public is their political non-conformity. Whether or not this new effort towards swamp-draining will be an a measurable success remains to be seen but I would imagine an electorate sick of years of gaslighting and neglect will lap it up.
The public perception of their efforts (as opposed to their actual achievements) could see Trump’s coalition maintaining their popular standing all the way through to a 2028 Republican presidency, if they’re smart about it. We’ll see!
Or, then again, it could just be a mess.
Pete Buttigieg. Alejandro Mayorkas. Heaven forbid Trump’s cabinet is “a mess”.