X Close

The end of the Boris cult His audience wanted jokes not politics

Held to global ridicule. (Credit: Kois Miah/Getty)

Held to global ridicule. (Credit: Kois Miah/Getty)


October 12, 2024   5 mins

Boris Johnson presented his memoir, Unleashed, at Cheltenham racecourse last week, amid the ghosts of bookies. They, at least, would appreciate him for who he is: a risk-taker who won, then lost, and hopes to win again. But the venue isn’t full. The Boris Johnson cult is over:  he is the only one who doesn’t know it yet. The audience is old, rich, and white, and they are here to gawp and giggle. They want jokes, not policies: they always did. And all their choices — including him — flow from that. Johnson was a leader for an age of decadence, and unseriousness: we thought we could afford him, but we couldn’t. Now he is less a G7 leader than a toastmaster.

There was, beforehand, a limp kind of excitement. It felt closely held, protected. Johnson appealed to people who wanted to live through him. Too scared to drive supercars or flirt with strangers or prorogue parliament, they chose someone who would. They still speak fondly of him, because he is still the only politician they have ever liked, and I can’t think of a better measure of our failure. They still talk about his “charisma” because they don’t know him. They just think they do. He has what Kemi Badenoch’s supporters call an ability to “cut through” in the age of attention deficit disorder: in the leadership election she will depend on it. They “hope he will be back” but he “probably won’t be because MPs don’t like him”. The current Tory Party is, “individualist” and “too weakly led”. “I don’t think anyone led the party like he did.”

His entrance is downbeat. He shuffles in, hair shining and dishevelled. He looks, for an instant, mock terrified, and then does the nodding dog with his head. The downbeat entrance is deliberate: his small penance. He can’t say it in words because he doesn’t really feel it. Unleashed is not an apology for how he promised hope and set it on fire, nor is it a fair assessment of what he really unleashed, which is a more toxic populism that even he gave us. It is propaganda, written in the fake intimate style of the lifestyle columnist. I searched in the book for passages on his failure, and how he felt about it. They aren’t there.

“Johnson was our first modern populist politician and his danger was always in his precedent.”

He says he’s sorry he’s late, but it’s not his fault this time: “I understand everyone was being frisked for handguns”. They laugh: that’s not their England. The interviewer offers a trivial question first, for the fans. It’s about the zipwire at the London Olympics 2012, when he dangled with a Union Flag: the Johnson stunt by which all others are judged. “Although I was held to global ridicule,” he says, “it had exactly the effect I wanted: not for the first time!” The next day, he says, Britain “began to win medals”. This is Johnson the magician who expresses, entirely unconsciously, a universal boredom with conventional politics. It is also Johnson the Fisher King. His wounds mirror ours — that is his peculiar power — but neither are healed.

He is asked about the Brexit bus and its promise of £350 million a week for the NHS. “It’s the bus of truth!” he cries, even now. This is not a place to analyse the rotting political discourse, and what part he may have played in it. Such agonies are for Leftists. “It’s a significant sum,” he says, “people were right to ask what they were getting for it.” He adds, “Being unleashed from the EU gave us the freedom to do things differently,” and if they weren’t better, that is not his fault. Brexit saved lives during pandemic, he says. She asks about other “concrete dividends”. He looks nervous, cites giving lethal weaponry to Ukraine, makes a joke about William Hague’s baldness, and I remember that there are at least five different people inside him.

Johnson is happiest on diversions: Nicola Sturgeon, for instance. “Princess Twinkle-toes investigated by the fuzz for possession of a campervan. The Nationalist dog barked while the campervan moved on”.  It’s a mash-up of metaphor and slang: and it’s meaningless. His serious point, when he gets there, is this: Reform polled low when he was prime minister. He kept us “bubble-gummed together”. But he didn’t.  Rather, he opened the doors to them.

He is asked about his Covid. “A lot of people say I was shamming,” he says. But he was ill, he insists. And he realised, “I’ve done some pretty worthwhile things. I need to keep going. I thought I had a lot to live for and I had a country to look after”. Now I think: if he’s telling us he loves us, he wants to come back. He’s waiting for the party to fall so low they take him back.

The audience is restless. It wants Johnson the avatar of joy, and he’s talking about the nearness of Death, and defending his government. “We acted as vigilantly as we could, given what we knew”. He thinks Covid-19 came from a laboratory: “Do you really believe that this was the result of the love that flowered accidentally between a small slice of pangolin and a bat?” He doesn’t despair about a Trump presidency, even if he hated the Capitol riots: “He is not going to spend the first few months of his presidency trying to make the Soviet Union great again”. He says this last part in an accent thieved from Paint Your Wagon.

But then he reveals something. Being mayor of London was “great” because “I was a monarch”. And that’s it. Johnson was always more suited to absolute monarchy than parliamentary democracy, and, like an absolute monarch, he doesn’t think he did anything wrong, because an absolute monarch is the law. To Tory voters who hated him because he betrayed them, and, worse, made them betray themselves, he offers nothing. To the Tory romanticism he destroyed while pretending to share it he says nothing. The wine in the suitcase was a Downing Street ritual that long preceded him. His defenestration was all, “a bit of a put-up job”.  His advice to the audience – a response audience question, they still think he has something to offer, is: “there’s no earthly point in being too self-deprecating”. Is that what he thinks he was?

At Cheltenham, Johnson offers us, as ever, a mirror, because that is what he is. He mirrored our hope. Now he mirrors our confusion. The Tory Party is in ruins — he essentially endorsed Truss, his closest allies voted for her — and it had nothing to do with him. He doesn’t talk about the leadership contest. He talks about himself.

At the end, there are no cheers, as if he has disappointed them, but the disappointment should be with themselves. Johnson was our first modern populist politician and his danger was always in his precedent: now there will be other, less charming populists walking the paths he made. His damage to the polity was incalculable — the prime minister who lied to parliament — and they don’t even mind. Nor, it seems, does he. Out they go, holding copies of Unleashed. It wasn’t what we — or even he — thought it would be. It is something infinitely sadder, and that, of his legacies, will endure.


Tanya Gold is a freelance journalist.

TanyaGold1

Join the discussion


Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber


To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Subscribe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

11 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
NIGEL PASSMORE
NIGEL PASSMORE
2 months ago

A leader (never mind a great one) requires many qualities: vision, strength of purpose, temerity and to be unburdened with the necessity of being liked to name a few. Al Johnson, demonstrably, has none of these attributes. Anyone who applies a scintilla of analysis to his time as PM could have no doubt about it.

It”s all very well having the stardust to shine for 5 weeks of an election campaign. It is an altogether different matter for someone with the attention span of a gnat to apply the focus necessary to govern a country well for 5 years.

It is often said of Al he enjoyed the idea of being PM but not the reality. Now he’s an ex PM, and there is no role of World King, he comes across as a man so bereft of clear direction the only thing he craves is for history to repeat itself in the delusion that somehow it will be different; Churchillian no less. The problem is on his comeback tour it’s the same old tired act. Only his most diehard groupies will want to be fooled again.

Johnson the classicist should remember the ancient Greek observation that we all carry two bags in our life and reflect.

Regards

NHP

Martin M
Martin M
2 months ago

I miss Boris. He was that rarest of things – a politician who could laugh at himself. Plus, he Got Brexit Done.

Michael Cazaly
Michael Cazaly
2 months ago
Reply to  Martin M

But he wasn’t really laughing at himself, he was laughing at us. And yes he did get Brexit done sort of…and promising to get Brexit done was how he got elected. After that he had no idea what to do and just went with whatever Carrie told him to…

Martin M
Martin M
2 months ago
Reply to  Michael Cazaly

I prefer to think of him as laughing with us….

John Lamble
John Lamble
2 months ago

Johnson Derangement Syndrome writ large (too large).

Janko M
Janko M
2 months ago
Reply to  John Lamble

Why? Because she pointed out that he was an incompetent leader with no self-awareness? I really don’t understand how any self-respecting conservative could stomach this complete failure of a leader. Wokeness entered every level of government and civil society on his watch, immigration got worse, Brexit was pulled off only to be squandered and then the whole pandemic business. I don’t think the derangement syndrome is on her side.

John Lamble
John Lamble
2 months ago
Reply to  Janko M

I think people who are not leaders often don’t understand leadership. Biden is a poor leader because he doesn’t have an impressive team around him, presumably because he fears being outshone. Trump is a good leader because he has the essential quality that he is not afraid to assemble a really impressive team, as he did when president. Another essential is a positive genius for getting on with people and getting the best out of them. Johnson clearly has those qualities and most of the criticisms of him arise from hate ‘because he was responsible for a pandemic’. So, an essentially good leader is being cast out into the wilderness. It happened to Churchill, of course, even though brickbats galore were aimed at him during the 20s and 30s. If the Tories have the slightest sense they will rehabilitate Johnson over the next few years but I’m not sure they have.

Chris Amies
Chris Amies
2 months ago

Then there were weird takes like the ‘pint bottle of wine,’ which went viral only because everyone could, without even thinking about it, see three good reasons why it was a stupid idea, and clearly a distraction to stop us from considering other matters for a while.

Andrew Armitage
Andrew Armitage
2 months ago

The corporate world is full of people with outrageous chutzpah talking complete bullshtt and grown ups realise we need them. Every entrepreneur running a startup is – to some extent -faking it til they make it.
A leader needs to be able to sell a dream, whether it’s real or not. Or haven’t you seen the Wizard of Oz?
I thought people realised that when they voted for him.
What I regret about BJ ousting was the ease with which his opponents were able to infantilise the population into tantrums over trivia.
And I think the cause of tackling climate change was put back by another 10y. We’ve lost all momentum on one of the major issues the world is going to face

Mangle Tangle
Mangle Tangle
2 months ago

Excellent article, whether or not one is a Johnson fan. Actually, that’s rather her point. We shouldn’t be fans of politicians, even if we like them. Instead, we should ask: are they actually any good?

Neil Ross
Neil Ross
2 months ago

Meanwhile Keir Starmer is proving every day how useless Johnson was – Oops!