X Close

Should the rich pay more tax? Our polling suggests that the parties' high-spending manifestos are a good reflection of public sentiment

A protest against university fees. Credit: AFP / JUSTIN TALLIS / Getty

A protest against university fees. Credit: AFP / JUSTIN TALLIS / Getty


December 6, 2019   3 mins

The British political Establishment is in the middle of a reorientation ‚Äď towards a social and cultural outlook which is more communitarian, and an economic outlook which is shifting to the Left.

The 2016 Brexit vote has focused minds on the recalibration of our social politics, but the leftward economic shift of the Establishment, who are in some ways following the public, is less commented on. Indeed, while the Brexit vote explained the Conservatives‚Äô rise in the Midlands and the North in the 2017 General Election, it was the popularity of Corbynomics which propelled Labour to near parity with the Conservatives two years ago ‚Äď a spectre which haunts this election.

The figure of Corbyn obscures the fact that Labour’s economic statism and red-in-claw socialism is popular and has been for some time. A recent YouGov poll indicates that the unpopular Labour leader, with the worst opposition leader ratings of all time, has a manifesto whose contents, when polled, have majority support across the board.

Survey after survey, and vox pop and after vox pop indicates that the British public are tired of austerity, tired of a battered and shabby public realm and now fully support better funding for public services, and more investment ‚ÄĒ even if this means higher taxes. The 2019 party manifestos reflect this new normal, with the Tories committed only to modest spending and tax rises, with Labour committed to shifting the country‚Äôs economics to the far Left.

UnHerd has commissioned polling which indicates that only 30% of the public agree that “Tax rates for high earners should be minimised to keep the UK competitive”,¬†with 42% actively disagreeing with this statement. In terms of electoral geography, FocalData has estimated that only 22 of Britain‚Äôs 632 parliamentary constituencies have more people than not committed to tax competitiveness. Indeed those high spending manifestos are a reflection of these sentiments.

Of the 22 seats that support minimising tax on high earners, 17 are in London ‚Äď including, somewhat ironically, the constituencies of Jeremy Corbyn and Emily Thornberry; yet another issue on which the capital finds itself out of step with the rest of the country. In fact, it‚Äôs easy to assess how likely an area is to support minimising the tax burden on the richest simply looking at how high house prices and average wages are in a constituency.

Just as interesting, though, is people’s perception vs reality on where the tax burden in this country really lies. The Government’s own data suggests that the Top 1% pay a staggering 30% of all tax, while taking only 13% of income. Tax change after tax change has shrunk the tax base, and while the many may want the few to pay a bit more, what happens if the 1% decide, in a world of global capital and free movement, that they don’t fancy paying for 1/3 of all Britain’s public services. We may be about to find out…

Source: HMRC


James Kanagasooriam is a partner at Hanbury Strategy and an advisory board member of the think tank Onward.

JamesKanag

Join the discussion


Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber


To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Subscribe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

3 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Esmon Dinucci
Esmon Dinucci
3 years ago

A very entertaining and informative piece – thank you.

Neil Papadeli
Neil Papadeli
3 years ago

Fascinating topic, thanks.

Antony Hirst
Antony Hirst
3 years ago

Well, I have gone 50% part-time now. As a result, my net earning per hour have gone from £53 to £71 and the state is now a staggering £26,000/year worse off and I am 25% poorer but 50% happier.
This is what high tax rates do to the economy. They reduce productivity and tax revenue.