by Peter Franklin
Friday, 11
December 2020
Response
11:00

Without Brexit, things would have been much worse

by Peter Franklin
Prime Minister Boris Johnson and European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen meet for a dinner to discuss our elusive Brexit trade deal. Credit: Getty

Yesterday, my colleague Ed West wrote about changing his mind — in this case, about his previous sympathies for Brexit. The same day, in a column for Bloomberg, Tyler Cowen described his journey in the opposite direction. I say “journey” because he hasn’t quite gone all the way:

“I no longer think Brexit is a bad idea. I’m not ready to endorse it, because I don’t feel comfortable with the nationalism and populism surrounding so much of the Leave movement, but I no longer wish the referendum had gone the other way.”
- Tyler Cowen , Bloomberg

Nevertheless, he believes that “in the last year, the EU has become a less workable political union, especially for the UK.”

For instance, he makes the under-appreciated point that if the EU is to deal with the growing challenge from its disruptive member states — especially Hungary and Poland — then that would “require weakening the EU’s unanimity requirements on many decisions”. Had Britain voted to remain, then that further dilution of sovereignty would have applied to us too.

Another worsening problem that Cowen identifies is the strain on the single currency. Until this year, the Stability and Growth Pact just about held things together. However, the economic impact of Covid-19 means that the hard limits on what national governments are allowed spend and borrow have been abandoned. Thus the overwhelming focus of the EU in the years ahead is going to be on saving a monetary union that the UK was never part of. Had we remained, it would have been in a club whose “focus is going to seem increasingly irrelevant” to British concerns.

Actually, I don’t think that’s the whole story, because the struggle to stabilise the Euro would have been made very relevant to Britain — but not in good way. As I explain here, the EU is propping-up the single currency by borrowing money through the European Commission — with all EU member states having to make the repayments.

On top of these fiscal demands, we’d also have seen our monetary independence come under attack. The Covid rescue package agreed this year is huge (€750 billion) and yet not big enough to see the Eurozone through the post-Covid recovery. Each member state will need to keep borrowing and the European Central Bank will need to keep buying a big chunk of the bonds they issue. Already there are calls for this ECB-owned debt to be cancelled — or, failing that, sat upon indefinitely. This will be hugely controversial because while these debts are national, the costs of cancelling them are shared.

In these circumstances, the existence of a major EU economy free from such concerns by virtue of being outside the single currency would have become intolerable to the ‘European project’. In the current Brexit negotiations we’ve seen just how desperate the EU is to constrain UK divergence. Well, nothing says divergence like controlling your own currency — and, had we remained, we’d have come under growing pressure to give up this privilege. Upon electing a Labour-led government the process of monetary assimilation would have begun — the Pound becoming a satellite of the Euro, just like the Danish and Swedish currencies are.

In the difficult days and weeks ahead we’re going to see a lot of people lamenting Brexit. But they should also consider where we’d be without it.

Join the discussion


  • December 14, 2020
    Sarcasm is funny if done well. You need to take lessons. Read more

  • December 14, 2020
    What do you think ECB has been doing since 2012? Digging a massive hole that the EU can never climb out of, without debt mutualisation. Good luck with that. Read more

  • December 14, 2020
    True - all true, but that doesn't mean that the Euro has been good for Greece. So the country had corrupt and venal politicians who cooked the books. That doesn't make their decision irrevocable. Read more

To get involved in the discussion and stay up to date, become a registered user.

It's simple, quick and free.

Sign me up