by Peter Franklin
Monday, 12
April 2021

Why we won’t cancel Yuri Gagarin

His statue in London will be safe from the woke iconoclasts
by Peter Franklin
Yuri Gagarin was the first human being to reach outer space. Credit: Getty

Sixty years ago today, we became a spacefaring species. It was, of course, Yuri Gagarin who took that giant leap — becoming the first human being to reach outer space.

It wasn’t a long trip. Lift off was at 6.07 am and he landed back on Earth less than two hours later. However, during his time away he orbited the planet, endured eight gees of acceleration (without blacking out) and completed the last ten minutes of his journey by parachute (having ejected four miles up).

What did you do before breakfast?

His achievement surely places him among the great explorers. However, if he were a Columbus, a Livingstone, or a Lewis and Clark, you can be sure that today there’d be an effort to ‘contextualise’ Gagarin and the Vostok 1 mission.

And by contextualise, I mean problematise. We’d expect some committee of eminent persons to sit in judgement upon Gagarin and the programme he was part of. They’d then take the necessary steps to remind us of any deviation from contemporary ethical standards.

As far as we know, outer space has no indigenous life forms. Therefore, the explorers of the high frontier cannot be accused of exploiting them. However, if one wanted to take away from Gagarin’s achievements there’s plenty else you could get him on.

He was after all, the servant of a murderous totalitarian regime. After his groundbreaking flight, he was a deputy in the Supreme Soviet, to which elections were hardly free and fair. His trips abroad had enormous propaganda value for the Kremlin — so much so that President Kennedy barred him from visiting the United States (an early example of deplatforming).

Gagarin was even dragged into the regime’s renewed anti-religion campaign. A Soviet propaganda poster shows a cosmonaut floating in space looking for God and gleefully not finding Him. (Ironically, there’s evidence that Gagarin was a religious man.)

One might also note that the Baikonur Cosmodrome, the literal launchpad for the Vostok 1 mission, isn’t in Russia, but southern Kazakhstan — a non-European land colonised by the Russian Empire and then by the Soviet Union.

But, of course, there’ll be no handwringing revisionism in this case, because the achievements of the USSR do not count as western achievements. Gagarin’s statues — including the one unveiled ten years ago in London opposite the monument to Captain Cook — will be entirely safe from the woke iconoclasts.

As important as it is to tell the whole truth about humanity’s greatest feats, let’s not imagine that the current vogue for accentuating the negative is an objective endeavour. It is a specifically anti-western project.

Maybe, one day, we’ll contextualise that.

Join the discussion

  • Marvellous, needed saying.
    Gagarin came to Manchester soon afterwards, and was made a Freeman of the City.
    Can we hound the living relatives of those who agreed this calumny? Can we throw tiny tins of Hunbrol paint at Russian dolls and yell at Russian salad dressing as and when we see it?
    Or do we just suck it up?
    And how about that poor dog Laika that they sent to her death too at that time?
    Come on your greeny leftards? Maybe a sponsored clear up of space detritus with your motorbike helmets on might help please Gaia?
    Certainly would please us, you thick Muppets!

  • If only there was even the slightest effort to “contextualize” history, just to spare the wokerati from looking even more ridiculous than they already do. Few things show more evidence of an inability to think than judging people and events of the past through the moral prism of the present. Not only does that approach fail to see things within their time, it purposely ignores any changes that have occurred since then. Purposely.

  • Take a look at how the left divide, subdivide and subdivide again in their relentless pursuit of ideological purity. There are those on the left who wish to believe that the young and woke are not of the “true” left at all – even though the baby boomer Left-liberals created the fertile ground in which fanatical woke activism has flourished.
    As for castigating Hitler – despite the endless stream of WW2 era documentaries and entertainment the MSM are strangely reluctant to tell the whole truth about the great Communist mass murderers of the 20th century. Perhaps they believe that Stalin, Mao, Ho Chi Minh, Fidel Castro etc, etc really meant well so best not make a fuss about their crimes against humanity.

  • To get involved in the discussion and stay up to date, become a registered user.

    It's simple, quick and free.

    Sign me up