by Freya Sanders
Friday, 27
September 2019
Event
14:36

Hissing at dissent, at women’s event

Inevitably, a recurrent theme at last night’s Intelligence Squared ‘Women in Power’ event was the importance of avoiding aggression and listening to other points of view. 

And so, there was condemnation of Boris Johnson’s rhetoric. Classicist Mary Beard called the PM “juvenile”. Tory Peer Sandip Verma said that this sort of language can spill “out onto the streets”. Rachel Reeves MP reminded us that her friend, Jo Cox, died believing we have far “more in common than that which divides us”. As the discussion continued, there was support for language policing and all-women shortlists; the overwhelmingly female audience nodded approvingly. I did, too.

But there wasn’t much evidence of those “other points of view”. When the discussion opened up to questions, most audience members were keen to show that they, too, were united in approval of the speakers. There was a cosy sense that we were all part of the same club.

And then a woman stood up and asked: What if men and women are just biologically different? And men are biologically better suited to power?

People actually hissed. The woman who had asked the question tried to keep speaking; everyone on the panel started speaking over her. Cosiness was replaced by overt hostility, even aggression. Because suggesting that men are biologically better at some stuff has become, to modern feminists, the ultimate taboo.

I don’t think men are biologically better suited to power. But a lot of people probably do. It’s not a marginal opinion, it’s a mainstream one. And I have no model to argue against it, because in so many feminist circles it is too horrific to even discuss.

The panel was originally supposed to include Priti Patel, and it suffered from her absence. The evening might have been less cosy, less clubby – it might have shown that just because women need to be protected from violence, it doesn’t mean we need to be protected from disagreement.

Comment


    Invalid API Key

To get involved in the discussion and stay up to date, join UnHerd.

It's simple, quick and free.

Sign me up