by Peter Franklin
Thursday, 9
December 2021

Elon Musk is right: declining birth rates are a threat to civilisation

He may have cynical motives, but his point stands
by Peter Franklin
Credit: Getty

Elon Musk has described declining birth rates as one of the “biggest threats to civilisation”. Speaking at a Wall Street Journal event earlier this week he said: “If people don’t have more children, civilisation is going to crumble. Mark my words.”

This isn’t the first time he’s issued this warning. In an interview back in September, he remarked that “a lot of people think there are too many people on the planet; in fact there’s too few.” He also reiterated the point on Twitter yesterday.

But is he right? Birth rates are certainly in decline across the world. Yesterday, The Guardian reports that Australia’s total fertility rate (TFR) fell to a record low 1.58 babies per woman in 2020. Though the impact of Covid and lockdowns may have contributed, the latest fall is consistent with a long-term trend. Furthermore, it doesn’t just apply to Australia and the other advanced industrial nations, but to many emerging economies too.  

So far, only a few countries are experiencing outright population decline — because longer life expectancy and immigration is topping up the head count. However, there are limits to both these compensating factors: biological limits in the case of human lifespans and political limits in respect to migration. So, if birth rates remain below the replacement level across two or more generations — and in countries like South Korea they are less than half what is required — then dramatic population decline is inevitable.

Musk is thus absolutely right to raise the alarm. The only question is whether he’ll be listened to. As the most entertaining and outspoken of the tech lords, his opinions can be easily dismissed as Elon being Elon. Indeed, the cynics will accuse him of promoting his own pet projects like the Tesla Bot — a bid to develop a humanoid robot. Getting us to believe in a future where human workers are in chronically short supply would be a good way of attracting investor interest.

But there’s more to Musk than hype. Some of his ventures have already had a transformative impact on their sectors — for instance Tesla on car manufacturing and SpaceX on unmanned spaceflight. Other breakthrough products are promised, including a commercially-viable, fully-automated car and Neuralink, a brain/computer interface that could be used as treatment for brain injuries. His rockets might even get us to Mars.

If these wonders do come to pass then he’ll have done more than any person alive to make the 21st century. It will become increasingly difficult to dismiss either the man or his message. At any rate, his pronouncements on the future ought to be taken more seriously than his current hairstyle.

Join the discussion

  • In South Africa, the country of his birth, births exceed deaths by more than double and frankly the country is headed for disaster. Give me some of what he is smoking.

  • This is why it is argued immigration is a good thing. But at the end of the day it is nonsense. 100 years ago most people died shortly after retirement. Of course the modern trend to early retirement with years of healthy living ahead and then a number of years of care home living supported on the backs of the diminishing working population is unsustainable We have been gifted the benefit of a longer healthy life through modern medicine the least we can do is to continue working longer. Of course, some jobs are physically demanding and those that do them need to retire to less physically demanding jobs when they can’t continue. It is a piece of fantastic self-indulgence to believe we are entitled to 30, 40 or 50 years of retirement to be supported by the young.
    Furthermore there is massive waste in the system currently. Look at Sir Philip Barton sunning himself on a beach while his underlings clock off from home after 8 hours during a period when all hands should have been on deck. Look at the Tribunal award of £10,000 for hurt feelings to a fat Police detective who had been off sick for a third of the time for ten years because a police sergeant suggested she drink less coke. Without all this waste we could afford to be a bit more supportive of the old.

  • To get involved in the discussion and stay up to date, become a registered user.

    It's simple, quick and free.

    Sign me up