X Close

The Left should welcome Matt Gaetz as attorney general

More than a bombastic MAGA supporter. Credit: Getty

November 13, 2024 - 10:35pm

Donald Trump announced today that he will elevate Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., as his next attorney general, a post with sweeping powers over the Department of Justice.

Gaetz may be known as a bombastic MAGA supporter in the eyes of the media. He livestreams, he podcasts, he trades barbs with political enemies with acidic bluster. But for those who have closely followed his legislative career, the Florida lawmaker represents a sharp break from the corporate-friendly orthodoxy of the modern Republican Party. Indeed, Gaetz’s elevation will provide sprawling prosecutorial powers for continuing his push against special interest influence and corporate malfeasance.

His record speaks for itself. From his perch on the House Judiciary Committee, Gaetz has promoted a surprisingly consumer-friendly agenda, routinely breaking with his GOP colleagues on crucial votes. He previously supported legislative measures to break up Silicon Valley monopolies, sharply regulate the online data broker industry, ban noncompete employment contracts, and an end to the practice of forced arbitration, among other corporate accountability votes. He has also taken maverick positions on reducing FBI surveillance powers, cutting certain arms supplies to Saudi Arabia and legalising marijuana.

In addition, Gaetz has staked a position at times to the Left of some establishment Democrats. In the fight over the Ending Platform Monopolies Act — a bill designed to curb anticompetitive practices by Amazon and Google — Gaetz ended up supporting the legislation, while California Democrats close to the tech industry, such as Zoe Lofgren and Eric Swalwell, voted against it.

In an era of severe political polarisation, the Florida representative has found opportunities to support actions of the Biden administration. In August, Gaetz wrote a letter to Alphabet chief executive Sundar Pichai, urging him to “adhere fully” to the antitrust ruling against the company secured by the current Department of Justice. He has called on Trump to continue a corporate law enforcement pattern started by the Biden administration. “I would hope that whoever is the next FTC chair would continue many of the cases that Chair Khan has brought against predatory businesses,” Gaetz told the Wall Street Journal.

Gaetz’s dealings with the populist Left do not end there. Not only did he push for a crackdown on the influence industry in Washington, he teamed up with Leftist firebrand Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on a demand to end congressional stock trading over concerns that lawmakers have enriched themselves using insider knowledge. “AOC is wrong a lot,” Gaetz said, explaining the bipartisan push. “But she’s not corrupt. And I will work with anyone and everyone to ensure that Congress is not so compromised.”

It is possible that Trump’s choice of Gaetz rests largely on his loyalty and his criticism of the handling of the January 6 investigation. He has been an outspoken critic of government overreach in prosecuting nonviolent participants in the riots. In his new role as attorney general, the Department of Justice will face a variety of challenges over the next year, including questions over how to pursue corporate mergers, government waste, and a variety of fraud cases pending before the courts.

If his recent actions are any indication, Gaetz may be the perfect man for the job to solidify the drift away from the GOP’s corporatism. “As the Republican Party becomes more working class, we’re less captive to the neolibertarian view that everything big business does to people is OK,” he once told reporters. That means, he added, the party “can’t be whores for big business and be the voice of the working class at the same time.”

Reform may be on the horizon. The Gaetz nomination represents the second most significant personnel choice towards a more consumer-centric GOP.


Lee Fang is an investigative journalist and Contributing Editor at UnHerd. Read his Substack here.

lhfang

Join the discussion


Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber


To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Subscribe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

42 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
michael harris
michael harris
1 day ago

I have not been paying nearly enough attention and only (half) knew the cartoon version of Matt Gaetz. I stand educated; thank you Lee Fang.

Robert Doe
Robert Doe
22 hours ago
Reply to  michael harris

Gaetz might be the walking proof of something I felt a decade ago. If one could get past the dramatic rhetoric of each side you might discover the Tea Party and OWS had more than a few ideas in common.

Martin M
Martin M
19 hours ago
Reply to  michael harris

Let’s see if he gets confirmed (Carlos Danger has guaranteed that he won’t), and if he does, let’s see which version shows up for work.

Jerry Carroll
Jerry Carroll
10 hours ago
Reply to  Martin M

I wonder if there are any RINOs bold enough to stand against the pressure the all-powerful Trump can bring to bear in the early days of his administration. I think Carlos is wrong on this score.

M C
M C
10 hours ago
Reply to  michael harris

I haven’t been paying attention to Gaetz either – was only aware of him through the allegations that he was trafficking underage girls. Do we know if these were ever proven to be false?

UnHerd Reader
UnHerd Reader
1 day ago

Going against oligopolies and predatory behaviour will be a huge task for the new AG. There are far too many entrenched and monied beneficiaries of the current system – especially big tech, big pharma and big food.
Good luck!

Martin M
Martin M
19 hours ago
Reply to  UnHerd Reader

There are far too many entrenched and monied beneficiaries of the current system“. Elon Musk springs to mind, but I doubt anyone in the Trump Administration will go after him.

Hugh Bryant
Hugh Bryant
18 hours ago
Reply to  Martin M

Never seen any evidence that Musk makes his billions by bribing politicians. Perhaps you have some?

M Ruri
M Ruri
13 hours ago
Reply to  Hugh Bryant

Not to mention, Musk has come out and said that he will personally bank a primary against any Senator that decides they’re going to vote against Trump’s appointments.

Jerry Carroll
Jerry Carroll
10 hours ago
Reply to  M Ruri

Money talks in D.C., principles only whisper.

UnHerd Reader
UnHerd Reader
12 hours ago
Reply to  Hugh Bryant

I haven’t heard anything either and since he bought Twitter/X the left would have let the world know about it if there was any evidence, true or circumstantial. I will admit Musk’s wealth largely comes from the government though. I doubt Tesla is even viable without tax credits for buyers and emission credits from other car manufacturers. I’m sure one of SpaceX’s biggest customers is the Federal government.

M Ruri
M Ruri
10 hours ago
Reply to  UnHerd Reader

At least he made his money by inventing things that contribute to society, unlike George Soros who made his money by driving currencies into the ground.

Jerry Carroll
Jerry Carroll
9 hours ago
Reply to  UnHerd Reader

We should be thankful there is an alternative to the lethargic bureaucratic wasteland that NASA has become.

Martin M
Martin M
1 hour ago
Reply to  Hugh Bryant

He has grown extremely fat off the government dollar, as far as I can see.

M C
M C
13 hours ago
Reply to  Martin M

You’re onto something. Musk’s companies would not have survived this long without taxpayer support through regulatory credits and government contracts. I don’t understand how he’s any different than the “beneficiaries of the current system”. But his rep with Trump has garnered enough good favor for him to not be lumped in. To me, it really contradicts any message that Republican Party is the party for the worker class.

Johann Strauss
Johann Strauss
1 day ago

I suspect that Matt Geartz is an enlightened choice for AG. No wonder Washington is going bonkers.

J B
J B
1 day ago

(The Party) “…can’t be whores for big business and be the voice of the working class at the same time…”
Bodes well.

Steve Hamlett
Steve Hamlett
1 day ago

Did I miss something? If Gaetz ‘represents the second most significant personnel choice towards a more consumer-centric GOP’ who ranks first?

Carlos Danger
Carlos Danger
1 day ago
Reply to  Steve Hamlett

That puzzled me too. Perhaps Lee Fang is thinking of Joe Biden’s appointment of Lina Khan, the head of the FTC. (Her term expired in September but she is staying on until her successor is confirmed.) As Lee Fang tells us in his article, Matt Gaetz is a Khanservative, along with JD Vance and Josh Hawley. They think that Lina Khan and her hipster-antitrust, neo-Brandeisian Democratic colleagues like Tim Wu, Jonathan Kanter and Barry Lynn are great.
UPDATE: No, it couldn’t have been Lina Khan, she’s a Democrat. Could he have been thinking of JD Vance?

Last edited 19 hours ago by Carlos Danger
Kevin Braun
Kevin Braun
9 hours ago
Reply to  Steve Hamlett

I assumed the writer was anticipating RFKjr being appointed to FDA or something.

Jerry Carroll
Jerry Carroll
10 hours ago

I have watched Gaetz through many hours of Congressional hearings. He has a razor-sharp mind and the doggedness of an American XL Bully. These qualities will serve him well when he wades into the DOJ sector of the murky deep state.

UnHerd Reader
UnHerd Reader
11 hours ago

I think that President-elect Trump is being very clever. Think about how Mike Goetz has been a disruptive influence in the house recently. Even with the 10-vote plurality that the Republicans now have in the House of Representatives, they are still going to have trouble getting legislation passed through a continuingly obstructive Democratic minority. What better way than to elevate Goetz to a position in which he has to first resign from the House of Representatives to take the position as Atty. Gen. If he has many enemies, they are concentrating on preventing him from becoming Atty. Gen. then Trump kills two birds with one stone by nominating him: he gets him out of the House of Representatives, where he was becoming a pain to Republicans, and he then gets another opportunity to nominate somebody he really wants the second time around. This would put pressure on the Democrats ( and Rhinos) to have to confirm the second person nominated or, if they attempted to deny that one, this would paint them as obstructionists and against the total mandate that Trump was handed by the American people in the last election. So, Trump is playing the chess game, sacrificing a piece for the position, then attacking again and winning the game.

j watson
j watson
19 hours ago

Not a serious pick. Won’t get approved by Congress. Gaetz has too many enemies.
Which begs question what’s Trumpster up to you? One gets the sense he’s developed a Monty Pythonesque humour and even for his opponents it must offer some amusement.
The day before he creates a couple of non jobs in a new quango for Elon and Vivek to share and titles it the Dept of Govt Efficiency. Yes, an additional Govt dept to tackle the sprawl of Govt, and furthermore given a year and a half to produce a Report. Doh! I thought they knew where all the waste was already? Straight out of an episode of Yes Minister. And ‘to share’ !! You heard that right too. Jeez it’ll be fun watching those two egos look to out headline each other whilst dragged into a quagmire of employment law shortly followed no doubt by the mass firing of, for example a bunch of Food inspectors, followed by the inevitable salmonella outbreak somewhere. Welcome to the reality and responsibility of Govt boys. It’s not so easy is it etc. Trumpster is teaching them a lesson – don’t get ahead of yourselves there is only one Star in this operation and it’s me. Quite funny.

Hugh Bryant
Hugh Bryant
18 hours ago
Reply to  j watson

You still don’t get, do you? Probably never will.

M Ruri
M Ruri
13 hours ago
Reply to  j watson

Remember in Trump’s first term how he wanted Congressman Dan Ratcliffe as the Director of National Intelligence and the Senate refused to confirm him… so Trump simply appointed someone they liked even less as acting director (Ric Grennell) until they relented and confirmed Ratcliffe? Yeah, I think the Senate will eventually see the light. They are playing on the same gameboard this time around.

Jack Robertson
Jack Robertson
21 hours ago

For F’s sake, get a grip. By all means enjoy the Trump victory and relish what sort of sorely-needed creative disruption some of his bolder picks might bring. But Matt Gaetz as AG?! Come on, you might as well pick Jeffrey Epstein’s rotting corpse.
Gaetz is almost certainly a serial sexual grub and he is at the very least a deeply-compromised figure who can’t possibly deal in any way usefully with the DoJ. I mean that in every possible sense. He’s also despised by most of his own party and there’s every chance he won’t last two minutes in confirmation hearings.
Absolutely Trump should select his team to leverage his eye-popping clean-sweep mandate to drain the swamp, etc. But Gaetz is one of the slimiest creatures in, and most decadent creators of, the thing in the first place.

Last edited 21 hours ago by Jack Robertson
Jack Robertson
Jack Robertson
21 hours ago
Reply to  Jack Robertson

On reflection: see Carlos Danger post/my reply. This pick is pure hustle.

Troy Savage
Troy Savage
10 hours ago
Reply to  Jack Robertson

And there you go repeating the slanderious lies of the current DOJ who sought to frame Gaetz and defame him. Way to be part of the swamp

Jerry Carroll
Jerry Carroll
9 hours ago
Reply to  Jack Robertson

And here we thought all the left-wing tears had been shed.