“It has left me feeling neither alarmed nor comfortable.”
Agreed although the phrase “existential threat” is still hanging there. The speaker might be correct that there is no real military reason for Putin to use a tactical nuke, but if he feels his losses and humiliation might be too great he might use a battlefield nuke to prevent a complete rout or force a negotiated settlement.
Given his willingness to pound Ukrainian cities to rubble with conventional munitions I doubt the possibility of heavy civilian casualties would deter him from using a nuke.
Thank you, Freddie, for asking this question (about the use of nuclear), which, I agree, no one seems to be talking about and is vitally important. However, it isn’t all down to Putin. How about we allow Ukraine to negotiate with Russia, as it has tried to do at least twice (if not more) without then bribing them away from the agreements they make by offering them billions of pounds (or is it euros or dollars) worth of arms? How about the West, instead of continuing to use Ukraine as its proxy in this war (to Ukraine’s great detriment – they are the meat in the sandwich!), stops its aggressive tactics towards Russia (eg persuading Finland and Sweden into NATO – more red rags to a bull)? I agree about ‘hope’ but, for me, that’s in God alone. Hope can’t be one-sided, ie that Putin will behave in what we consider a responsible fashion (personally I believe that he would, since he generally supports orthodox Christian values, unlike most of the Western governments); we need also to hope that the West will also behave more responsibly and stop its aggression towards Russia. Unfortunately, this latter hope seems a forlorn one to me. From what I have seen, Putin has been behaving in a far less aggressive manner than the West, despite his so-called ‘invasion’ of Ukraine, which, whatever anyone says, has been restrained and was mainly to rescue the ethnic Russian population of the Donbas. Historians such as John Mearsheimer (and others) have always said that NATO incursion into Ukraine would prompt the scenario that has now evolved. Long before (perhaps for ten years or so) the Russians crossed the frontier, US/UK arms training teams were ensconced with the Ukrainian armed forces.
Those training teams were there because Putin had invaded Ukraine in 2014, after his failed attempt to use proxies in Slavyansk.
And if those training teams had not been there, Putin would be well on his way to taking back Poland and the Baltics.
We are here because of Putin’s incompetence. After Maidan, he idiotically tried to start an insurrection in Donbas. It was doomed to fail, so he then had to send in the Russian army.
If he had simply done what he always did: play Russophones off against Ukrophones, the country would have probably remained neutral. He drove all Ukrainians into the arms of the West.
A Russian Own Goal.
So what is your point?
Thank you, an important interview bringing some clarity to the question. It has left me feeling neither alarmed nor comfortable.
“It has left me feeling neither alarmed nor comfortable.”
Agreed although the phrase “existential threat” is still hanging there. The speaker might be correct that there is no real military reason for Putin to use a tactical nuke, but if he feels his losses and humiliation might be too great he might use a battlefield nuke to prevent a complete rout or force a negotiated settlement.
Given his willingness to pound Ukrainian cities to rubble with conventional munitions I doubt the possibility of heavy civilian casualties would deter him from using a nuke.
me too… comfortably numb
Thank you, Freddie, for asking this question (about the use of nuclear), which, I agree, no one seems to be talking about and is vitally important. However, it isn’t all down to Putin. How about we allow Ukraine to negotiate with Russia, as it has tried to do at least twice (if not more) without then bribing them away from the agreements they make by offering them billions of pounds (or is it euros or dollars) worth of arms? How about the West, instead of continuing to use Ukraine as its proxy in this war (to Ukraine’s great detriment – they are the meat in the sandwich!), stops its aggressive tactics towards Russia (eg persuading Finland and Sweden into NATO – more red rags to a bull)? I agree about ‘hope’ but, for me, that’s in God alone. Hope can’t be one-sided, ie that Putin will behave in what we consider a responsible fashion (personally I believe that he would, since he generally supports orthodox Christian values, unlike most of the Western governments); we need also to hope that the West will also behave more responsibly and stop its aggression towards Russia. Unfortunately, this latter hope seems a forlorn one to me. From what I have seen, Putin has been behaving in a far less aggressive manner than the West, despite his so-called ‘invasion’ of Ukraine, which, whatever anyone says, has been restrained and was mainly to rescue the ethnic Russian population of the Donbas. Historians such as John Mearsheimer (and others) have always said that NATO incursion into Ukraine would prompt the scenario that has now evolved. Long before (perhaps for ten years or so) the Russians crossed the frontier, US/UK arms training teams were ensconced with the Ukrainian armed forces.
So that’s what you’ve been doing since Big Billy Goat Gruff knocked you off the bridge.
….a “so-called invasion” and a “restrained one” too….? Wow comrade!
Those training teams were there because Putin had invaded Ukraine in 2014, after his failed attempt to use proxies in Slavyansk.
And if those training teams had not been there, Putin would be well on his way to taking back Poland and the Baltics.
We are here because of Putin’s incompetence. After Maidan, he idiotically tried to start an insurrection in Donbas. It was doomed to fail, so he then had to send in the Russian army.
If he had simply done what he always did: play Russophones off against Ukrophones, the country would have probably remained neutral. He drove all Ukrainians into the arms of the West.
A Russian Own Goal.
So what is your point?