This is so true – but at all technical interfaces in government and not just IT. One had only to watch the preposterous Kwarteng the other day on ‘talking very directly’ to the power companies about the response to the Arwen event. Has he the very slightest idea about what is involved in time, equipment resource allocation and manpower needed replacing damaged power distribution infrastructure – moving large poles with helicopters in rough terrain for example?
For technocrats, the entire apparatchiks’ class in the UK don’t actually understand tech and tech reach, and the implications of the fact that it can bypass most aspects of non-digital world infrastructure – making the laws and regulations they bring to the fore irrelevant. They know about the technical staging of law, processes and regulation in a hierarchical, non-digital setting. They are highly structured old-world style managers. They think tech can be governed in the same way as other aspects of the non-tech economy. They are finding to their cost that it can’t. There is only one currency that matters in the 21st century, and that is ‘Tech Heft’ – to amass which tech must permeate all levels of governance in the country, for it to succeed through this century.
I mean my ‘amass’ and ‘Tech Heft’ the kind of thing China has consciously done through incentives and pouring in money, setting up huge tech hubs in Shenzen, Hangzhou, Shanghai and so on, rivalling Silicon Valley – to engender complete tech ecosystems with attendant infrastructure. like feeder universities for STEM graduates, and other surrounding services. China has a record of many STEM qualified administrators at all levels of governance.
Ferrusian Gambit
2 years ago
Of course. Although one has to wonder why he thought Boris Johnson was up to shaking it up. Gove, maybe, but Boris was obviously not going to stick it out making any difficult decisions.
Last edited 2 years ago by Ferrusian Gambit
Malcolm Knott
2 years ago
Cummings’s departure was a terrible loss to this administration.
Boris is the worst PM in history. I think his brush with death broke him – I watched his change, almost overnight. My theory is he always thought himself like the old upper class, the warrior’s steel nerve and courage in the Verbose, eloquent, classically educated charmer – I think seeing death he found he is an utter coward and a fake – and came out finally what he is – a nothing but a frightened, glib, popinjay. Nut Nut leads him around on a string and every fear is all he can react to.
Drahcir Nevarc
2 years ago
The number one priority has to be that we start treating Marxists, communists, and the woke exactly as we treat fascists, and this policy should be reflected in our civil service hiring policy.
Whitehall is NOT the same as government. They are an obstacle most of the time AND has been ideologically captured by the Left. I would out money on some of their failures being deliberate in order to undermine a govt they don’t like. They don’t get blamed for the failures, the minister at the top does, when in reality they have very little influence over it.
Margaret Thatcher – she managed to get radical change through! You have to have political will for a start, Johnson simply does not.
The Civil Service has many often analysed problems, but
Douglas Murray rightly has little time for this right wing buck passing whingeing. The British Prime Minister has more powers than most Western leaders. The fact that Boris is not remotely interested in these issues, and apart from his entirely self interested and transactional support of Brexit, why do we think he actually wants any radical change.
G A
2 years ago
Dominic Cummings was right about 99% of everything. He really fucked us all over with his castle trip. He should be in Whitehall right now herding cats.
This is so true – but at all technical interfaces in government and not just IT. One had only to watch the preposterous Kwarteng the other day on ‘talking very directly’ to the power companies about the response to the Arwen event. Has he the very slightest idea about what is involved in time, equipment resource allocation and manpower needed replacing damaged power distribution infrastructure – moving large poles with helicopters in rough terrain for example?
He doesn’t – but his advisors should
For technocrats, the entire apparatchiks’ class in the UK don’t actually understand tech and tech reach, and the implications of the fact that it can bypass most aspects of non-digital world infrastructure – making the laws and regulations they bring to the fore irrelevant. They know about the technical staging of law, processes and regulation in a hierarchical, non-digital setting. They are highly structured old-world style managers. They think tech can be governed in the same way as other aspects of the non-tech economy. They are finding to their cost that it can’t. There is only one currency that matters in the 21st century, and that is ‘Tech Heft’ – to amass which tech must permeate all levels of governance in the country, for it to succeed through this century.
Rather like the managers in old companies being made obsolete by technology, from experience.
Deliberate obfuscation in order to save their own pencil pushing golden pension jobs
“amass” – do you mean “assess which tech”?
I mean my ‘amass’ and ‘Tech Heft’ the kind of thing China has consciously done through incentives and pouring in money, setting up huge tech hubs in Shenzen, Hangzhou, Shanghai and so on, rivalling Silicon Valley – to engender complete tech ecosystems with attendant infrastructure. like feeder universities for STEM graduates, and other surrounding services. China has a record of many STEM qualified administrators at all levels of governance.
Of course. Although one has to wonder why he thought Boris Johnson was up to shaking it up. Gove, maybe, but Boris was obviously not going to stick it out making any difficult decisions.
Cummings’s departure was a terrible loss to this administration.
Boris is the worst PM in history. I think his brush with death broke him – I watched his change, almost overnight. My theory is he always thought himself like the old upper class, the warrior’s steel nerve and courage in the Verbose, eloquent, classically educated charmer – I think seeing death he found he is an utter coward and a fake – and came out finally what he is – a nothing but a frightened, glib, popinjay. Nut Nut leads him around on a string and every fear is all he can react to.
The number one priority has to be that we start treating Marxists, communists, and the woke exactly as we treat fascists, and this policy should be reflected in our civil service hiring policy.
Yes, we should not discriminate on grounds of opinion. Except opinions which lead directly to serious crimes, eg. ISIS.
Is this a joke?
Whitehall is NOT the same as government. They are an obstacle most of the time AND has been ideologically captured by the Left. I would out money on some of their failures being deliberate in order to undermine a govt they don’t like. They don’t get blamed for the failures, the minister at the top does, when in reality they have very little influence over it.
Margaret Thatcher – she managed to get radical change through! You have to have political will for a start, Johnson simply does not.
The Civil Service has many often analysed problems, but
Douglas Murray rightly has little time for this right wing buck passing whingeing. The British Prime Minister has more powers than most Western leaders. The fact that Boris is not remotely interested in these issues, and apart from his entirely self interested and transactional support of Brexit, why do we think he actually wants any radical change.
Dominic Cummings was right about 99% of everything. He really fucked us all over with his castle trip. He should be in Whitehall right now herding cats.
Thanks