January 24, 2022 - 7:00am
One might expect the Governor of California to praise his state at every opportunity. But here’s what he had to say last week: “What the hell is going on? We look like a third world country.”
It wasn’t a gaffe. His words were spoken directly to camera. Given the backdrop, it was hard to disagree. In recent weeks, the Los Angeles railway system has suffered a looting epidemic. At sites across the network, goods wagons have been broken into and ransacked. Thousands of discarded, empty packages have been left strewn over the tracks, adding to the chaos.
In the best traditions of the political photo-op, Newsom decided to lead a clean-up operation. Quite how long he was personally picking up the trash I don’t know, but it was long enough to be filmed by the media.
His remarks are worth watching in full (for instance, here starting at the 9:20 mark). That’s because they reveals a political culture that has lost the plot on law-and-order. Newsom begins by acknowledging the systematic nature of the looting: “this is organised theft, these are organised gangs of people…” And then something odd happens: he stops to apologise — not to the victims of the crime wave, but for using the word ‘gangs’.
“Forgive me for saying ‘gangs’”, he says, “that’s not a pejorative.” Reaching for a more acceptable term he settles upon “organised groups of folks”. Later, he uses the forbidden word a second time — and apologises a second time: “again forgive me, that word is loaded”. And so there you have it. Public order may be breaking down in the most advanced economy on the planet, but at least its officials are making strenuous efforts not to offend anyone.
To be fair to Newsom, he was clear that looting trains is “not acceptable” and that “we’re not condoning this behaviour.” However, he was rather less clear as to why it’s happening: “I don’t think anybody particularly cares who’s to blame.”
In fact, a lot of people blame California’s politicians for their ultra-liberal criminal justice policies. In a letter to the authorities, the Union Pacific train company complains that even when perpetrators are arrested, “charges are reduced to a misdemeanor or petty offense, and the criminal is released after paying a nominal fine.”
Newsom didn’t want to get into a policy debate: “we all want the simple reason, but it’s more complex than it appears.” And he’s partly right — crime is a complex phenomenon. However, the essence of maintaining order is not. At an absolute minimum, it requires that the most blatant offenders be caught, arrested and prevented from immediately reoffending. California shows what happens when you allow ‘progressive’ ideology to override this basic standard.
You can always try tolerating petty crime. The trouble, though, is that it doesn’t stay petty.
Peter Franklin is Associate Editor of UnHerd. He was previously a policy advisor and speechwriter on environmental and social issues.
peterfranklin_
Join the discussion
Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber
To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.
Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.
SubscribeMearsheimer (and fellow travellers) frequently make assertions with no evidence. I am not pro-Israel or pro-Palestinian but I find it frustrating that so many assertions are not challenged with obvious counter arguments, if only to better understand Mearsheimer’s intended meaning.
You can’t kill an idea – Basque separatists, Badder Meinhof, Red Brigade, Nationalists in Japan/Germany?
Genocide in Gaza – at 20,000 civilians killed in a year it would take 300 years, at this rate, to equal the 6 million killed in the Holocaust.
Israel is losing in Gaza and Lebanon – evidence of Hamas or Hezbollah victories or territorial gains?
Ethnic cleansing in Gaza – we lauded the removal of up to 4 million Ukrainians from Ukraine but did not call it ethnic cleansing nor 1 million Syrian refuges. Only escaping Gazans are considered “ethnic cleansing”. Millions of Germans, Poles, Greeks and Turks were moved after the war, presumably to prevent further ethnic conflicts.
Illegal Settlements in the West Bank – and yet 10 million “irregular migrants” entered the USA in the last 4 years along with how many into Europe? We do not call these “Illegal Settlements”.
Right to a Palestinian State – with the exception of the approximately 70% of “Palestinians” that live in Jordan under Jordanian rule, with no vote and no state? No state for Basques, Catalonians, Kurds?
Killing Hamas or Hezbollah fighters creates more fighters in the future. If this statement is true then all armed struggle is self-defeating including the killing of Israelis by Hamas and Hezbollah. All armed conflict leads to unending war and therfor Germans, Japanese and Vietnamese must hate Americans and British for perceived past wrongs, this is not the case.
At 39.55 mins in…Completely opposite analysis (with satellite photos) https://www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/israel-inflicted-severe-damage-on-irans-missile-program-and-air-defenses-207aafae
Mearsheimer’s description of the recent Israel attack on Iran is contradicted by an article in the Wall Street Journal on Nov 2 that states that all three waves of Israeli jets reached their targets and that extensive damage was inflicted supported by satellite photos.