X Close

Could Montreal riots bring down Justin Trudeau?

The PR mishaps are piling up for Canada's Prime Minister. Credit: Getty

November 26, 2024 - 10:00am

The fallout from a riot in Montreal on Friday afternoon has reverberated across the Canadian news landscape in the days since, with citizens and politicians reacting to the chaos and disturbing signs of overt antisemitism from the event. Though the violence was speedily quelled and widely condemned, questions remain about the state of Canada’s multicultural society and whether it can withstand the mounting internal and external pressures on its integrity and cohesion.

As a routine Nato Parliamentary Assembly meeting took place in the city’s Palais des Congrès, demonstrators gathered around the venue carrying Palestinian and Russian flags, as well as signs with anti-Nato and anti-Israel messages. Participants made a show of burning an effigy of Benjamin Netanyahu, just as Canada joined several other Western nations in signalling support for a controversial International Criminal Court arrest warrant for the Israeli leader.

Coming on the heels of similarly motivated political disturbances at campuses across Quebec last week (advertised by organisers as a coordinated anti-Zionist “strike”), the Friday protest escalated into a violent riot once participants began throwing objects at police, smashing windows, and setting two nearby vehicles ablaze. Soon after, Montreal police announced a number of arrests. Meanwhile, photos of a woman later revealed to be the owner of a coffee shop in the city’s Jewish General Hospital making a Nazi salute and uttering threats about “the final solution” circulated on social media the following day. Antisemitic threats and incidents have reportedly increased by over 600% in Canada since 7 October last year.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau was quick to denounce the “hatred and violence” as “appalling” on social media, but he was also heavily criticised for appearing at a Taylor Swift concert in Toronto the same night. The images of the PM exchanging friendship bracelets with fellow Swifties as the riot took place in Montreal prompted comparisons to Nero, further confirmation to critics of his deeply unserious approach to what could prove to be the unravelling of Canada’s once-celebrated multicultural mosaic. In his own reaction to the event, Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre minced no words in attributing blame directly to Trudeau: “You act surprised. We are reaping what you sowed.”

The same social media channels also featured defenders of the Prime Minister, who pointed out that he was simply “a dad enjoying a night out with his daughter”. Others argued for a more level-headed perspective, comparing the riot to past instances of violence by “window smashing anarchists” naturally inclined to cause havoc at high-level meetings.

But the fact is that the Montreal riot has taken place in the context of rising social tensions across Canada along the lines of race, ethnicity, ideology, and religion, with comparable flare-ups happening in other cities and provinces over various issues. It cannot be viewed in isolation from these broader trends. And while it has become easy to pin all the blame on the Prime Minister and his “post-national” vision, as Poilievre likes to do, the true challenge for him and others will be in finding positive and substantive ways to stitch Canadian society, including citizens from many of the same affected communities, back together again. Until then, Canadians can expect incidents like this to occur with greater frequency and intensity.


Michael Cuenco is a writer on policy and politics. He is Associate Editor at American Affairs.
1TrueCuencoism

Join the discussion


Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber


To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Subscribe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

26 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
UnHerd Reader
UnHerd Reader
3 hours ago

Writing from Canada here. The author of this article assumes it is possible to “stitch Canadian society, including citizens from many of the same affected communities, back together again”. We have let in so many people who hate everything Canada stands for that I am not sure there is a way to stitch Canadian society back together. I have had to walk through some of the “pro-Palestine” protests, and as far as I can tell, they are just a front for antisemitism and hate of all Western values. A lot of these people are foreign students (the primary way that we have allowed our immigration problem to balloon) so maybe rather than suggesting that we need to stitch people together, the author might want to consider 1. returning lawbreakers to their country of origin, and 2. halting the flow of people who hate Canada.

Caradog Wiliams
Caradog Wiliams
3 hours ago
Reply to  UnHerd Reader

Cancelled comment

John Tyler
John Tyler
2 hours ago
Reply to  UnHerd Reader

I’m in UK, but from my childhood experience of living there regard Canada with immense fondness and respect. It’s a huge sadness to see our two countries sinking into the swamps of extremism and irrationality.

On the bright side: Go Leafs!

Walter Lantz
Walter Lantz
1 hour ago
Reply to  UnHerd Reader

Western fools like Trudeau have spent so much time bragging about and defending the righteous wonder of their multicultural ideology that they don’t even realize the entire project is now under the control of Islamists and born-again communists.
Canada’s points-based immigration system, originally meant to bring in the best and brightest, is in a shambles. Latest stats say one in five immigrants eventually leave Canada. Current processing time for migrant applications is almost four years. Migrants and asylum seekers languish on the public dime. Employers can’t find workers.
Happy ending side note. The Adolph-saluting coffeeshop woman was identified as a Second Cup franchise owner. Her franchise agreement was cancelled the next day. So at least one corporate entity isn’t playing along.

anthony henderson
anthony henderson
17 minutes ago
Reply to  UnHerd Reader

You could write the very same comment about Australia. I can’t believe what’s happening down here.

Frank Fransen
Frank Fransen
4 hours ago

Trudeau is the perfect example of what is currently wrong with Western leaders.

Jim Veenbaas
Jim Veenbaas
45 minutes ago
Reply to  Frank Fransen

It’s like they’re all clones – Trudeau, Starmer, Scholz, Harris, anyone in the SNP. It’s weird.

Lennon Ó Náraigh
Lennon Ó Náraigh
2 hours ago

Multiculturalism. Chickens. Home. Roost.

Simples.

Danny Kaye
Danny Kaye
2 hours ago

NATO member Turkey has been bombing the Kurds in Northern Syria for years, and with particular intensity in the last month, cutting water and electricity off to more than a million civilians.
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c79zj7rz3l4o
So when NATO is convening in Montreal, what is more natural than that the progressive left would demonstrate violently against …
Israel.

Archibald Tennyson
Archibald Tennyson
4 hours ago

The Cuckolding of the Canadian Mind.

Josef Švejk
Josef Švejk
4 hours ago

I’ve never liked Castro nor any of his offspring. How did this chappie ever become Prime Minister. Canadians !

RR RR
RR RR
39 minutes ago
Reply to  Josef Švejk

Political Nepobabe – just enough downsteam good will from his Dad being PM and a weak opposition until last couple of years.

RR RR
RR RR
3 hours ago

Trudeau joins Call Me Dave and Macron at having ‘better things to do’ whilst the city is in flames.

RR RR
RR RR
2 hours ago

Like all good, liberal, open bordered globalists who fail to deliver for their actual voters of long standing – housing, jobs, education that doesn’t involve Woke Religion, Trudeau is going to be annihilated at the next general election.
I doubt it will be as bad as the previous Conservatives dissolution in 1993 but it will be like the Tories here.

Caradog Wiliams
Caradog Wiliams
3 hours ago

“And while it has become easy to pin all the blame on the Prime Minister…”
This worries me. In Canada they blame Trudeau, in the UK they blame Starmer. Does this mean that Trudeau and Starmer can be sacrificed and all will be well. Of course, they will be sacrificed.

Sylvia Volk
Sylvia Volk
2 hours ago

Good. I’m a Canadian and I say sacrifice him, because his government’s incompetent. A competent team is waiting in the wings, and really, any change will be an improvement, because forget ideology, Mr Trudeau’s about as good at governing as my gerbil and I don’t own a gerbil.
A different government won’t magically make everything fine, but just getting in some adults with working brain cells will make things so much better.

Lancashire Lad
Lancashire Lad
2 hours ago
Reply to  Sylvia Volk

Unfortunately, that’s what many who voted Labour at our recent election thought they were doing, but were disabused of that notion in quick order.
I expect Starmer may have been on the phone to Trudeau with “advice” on how to quell rioting (of whichever political flavour) but given Trudeau’s behaviour towards his own citizens during Covid, advice might seem unnecessary. Let’s see if he can react the same way towards those peddling hate rather than just trying to protect their own bodies and livelihoods.

Caradog Wiliams
Caradog Wiliams
1 hour ago
Reply to  Sylvia Volk

I have family in Vaudreuille, at the edge of Montreal. They like Trudeau for two reasons – his father and he speaks French well. It seems to me that this French/English thing is more important than anything else in Canada.

Richard Ross
Richard Ross
1 hour ago

It IS more important than anything – to French Canadians. The rest of us are either just irritated at the much-longer French print on all retail goods, or cowed by the state media into thinking French = good/Anglo = bad.

Christopher Barclay
Christopher Barclay
1 hour ago

My guess is that Trump’s proposed tariffs on imports from Canada would be slashed if Trudeau was replaced as PM.

Alex Lekas
Alex Lekas
48 minutes ago

We are reaping what you sowed is exactly right. This didn’t happen by accident. People have seen who and what Trudeau is. He’ll seize the money of truckers but let jihadis run wild. When you import people who are hostile to the native culture, it’s not going to go well.

El Uro
El Uro
1 hour ago

Meanwhile, photos of a woman later revealed to be the owner of a coffee shop in the city’s Jewish General Hospital making a Nazi salute and uttering threats about “the final solution” circulated on social media the following day.”
.
Sorry, that’s a mistake. She’s Arab. Check again, please:
https://x.com/jace2020/status/1860530933184487925
.
PS. BTW, this is how Queer-fascism looks like

El Uro
El Uro
3 hours ago

deleted

Last edited 21 minutes ago by El Uro
El Uro
El Uro
3 hours ago

I’m surprised at the haste with which you deleted my comment about the true nationality of a woman giving a Nazi salute. Following Starmer?

Last edited 3 hours ago by El Uro
Michael Miles
Michael Miles
26 minutes ago

We are not going anywhere until the careerist leaders of all our institutions are cured of the mind virus described by Gad Saad. This virus is turbo boosted by Canadian politeness and self righteousness. The two tier enforcement inspired by CRT has to stop along with our preoccupation with not causing offence. Our dependence and our deference to government needs to be scaled back too, with more emphasis on individual responsibility and initiative. It is a generational problem.

Charlie Walker
Charlie Walker
21 minutes ago

Seems that unlike the old saying that we follow America, we are almost in step with Canada. Assisted dying or Maid as it’s called there accounting for 3.4% of all deaths, our wonderful leaders watching Taylor Swift – no doubt freebies in return for blue light escorts, and Antisemetic, anti western, anti cultural Palestinian apologists rioting while the worlds great and good sign up yo the lunatic ICC bull!