The images beggared belief. Palestinian gunmen driving through an Israeli city, firing at passers-by from the bed of a pickup truck. The body of a dead Israeli soldier, his green uniform stained red, being dragged from a car inside Gaza and trampled. An elderly woman, seemingly in shock, taken hostage and paraded through the streets in a golf cart.
It is hard to make sense of the day’s events — because they are unprecedented. What should have been a quiet holiday-weekend Shabbat began with Hamas firing more than 2,200 rockets at Israel. The massive barrage seems to have been cover for an even bigger operation: infiltrating dozens of militants into Israel. Some went to Sderot, the biggest city near Gaza; others fanned out to the small kibbutzim that run the length of the border.
By evening the death toll stood at 150, with at least 1,100 Israelis wounded. Both numbers will almost certainly rise, and the Israeli army says it is still fighting in 22 locations. Hamas also claims to have abducted 35 Israelis and brought them to Gaza. While the exact number is unconfirmed, footage shared on social media suggests they do indeed have captives, both civilians and soldiers.
The most obvious question is what went wrong: this is Israel’s biggest intelligence failure in half a century, since the surprise Arab invasion on Yom Kippur in 1973. Its security services have a network of informants in Gaza. Every call from a mobile phone in the territory is routed through an Israeli network.
Hamas must have needed many months to plan such a complex operation — and Israel knew the group wanted to conduct one like this. During its 2014 war with Israel, Hamas smuggled commandos through a tunnel and landed a group of frogmen on an Israeli beach. The Israeli army has warned for years that the group would try more such infiltrations. Yet when it finally happened, the army seems to have been caught entirely unaware.
Nor was this just an intelligence failure. Israel has kept Gaza under a tight blockade for a decade and a half. Heavy restrictions on the flow of goods and people have crushed its economy: two-thirds of Gazans live below the poverty line, and three in five are unemployed. But the blockade has not unseated Hamas — nor, apparently, stopped it from planning sophisticated attacks.
Join the discussion
Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber
To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.
Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.
SubscribeCould the intelligence failure be as the Israeli democracy has increasingly turned Woke and takes NGO activism on the streets more seriously? With significant sections of judiciary, civil services and even the armed forces more concerned about human rights than taking on terrorists?
Of course it would be difficult to get such clarity from an Economist writer since all that the venerable journal does is to look for villains in the ” Far Right” and “populists” while alternatively celebrating every form of globalist and borderless identity politics.
Who owns the Economist ?
Certainly not the ” Far Right”. It’s spin shows it to be Guardianista with great dollops of WEF, at least in my humble reading.
Your humble reading is utterly nonsensical.
No, they just took their eye off the ball. You are disingenuously exploiting this tragedy to discredit “woke” ideas, which could be more honestly and constructively achieved on its own terms. The fact that you make your point as a rhetorical question, not backed up by any facts or references, exposes your weak arguments.
Sadly now, many innocent people on both sides will lose their lives. A new concerted effort to solve the Palestinian problem needs to be found, although for now, the immediate problem is to stop the violence.
There is no solving that problem. Hamas, Hezbollah, most Arabs in general live in a world of hate and venom inspired by their book. There is no amount of negotiating or money or nation building in the world that will fix that embedded hate. It has nothing to do with “oppression” (through this lie is fed to the gullible leftists world-wide) and everything to do with religion. Its in their DNA . And they don’t hide it. Annihilating Israel off the face of the world isnthe objective and there’s no changing that. How do you talk with people who hate you that much.
It’s both Islam and oppression, not either or.
I agree with you about the terrible loss of life, but the idea that you can ‘solve this problem’ seems laughably unrealistic.
Some situations (like our own ‘bête noire’ in Northern Ireland, or the smorgasbord in Kosovo) are like perpetual sores that just have to be managed and endured by everyone involved.
The Good Friday agreement has largely worked, at least in keeping violence away. It doesn’t mean that the NI problem is solved, but things were far worse in the decades preceding.
Col Tim Collins said the people of Northern Ireland were handed over to the PIRA and Protestant Gangs.
The terrorist groups were being degraded rapidly from 1990 to 1997 and then Blair threw in the white towel. Roy Mason came within three weeks of destroying the PIRA according to M McGuiness in 1979. Blair should hve appointed Roya Mason to run N Ireland.
Exactly.
” Woke ideas can be honestly achieved”? Startling conclusions.
Discrediting them. You didn’t read my post properly.
I did, and it seems you are foisting rather garbled conclusions when you were not calling me names.
It’s tedious to recount what is easily available in the public domain about the activist protests in Israel since Netanyahu came back to power.
I presume you are the type to only acknowledge ‘facts and references ” when it is cherry picked from the ideological stable you propound.
You clearly didn’t read my post properly if you conflated “discredit ‘woke’ ideas, which could be more honestly and constructively achieved on its own terms”, with ”woke ideas can be honestly achieved”
What a word salad! Even if I read your constructions a thousand times I confess that gobbledygook is not my cuppa!
Try harder to keep up.
….if they took their eye off the ball what were they looking at then? Mr Gupta is correct, like the rest of the western democracies they were distracted by woke trivia.
The Economist indeed selected a leaderless Italy as one of its favoured European nations before Meloni when and precisely because it had dispensed with messy democracy in favour of a globalist technocrat.
They are sometimes forced to make appropriate noises about the lives of the people the economies are meant to exist to serve, but it’s merely a distraction from the bottom line.
Frankly I haven’t seen any political analysis in the recent past from the Economist which is not steeped in pre- judged tropes fused in the ideologies I describe. Other than some columns on lifestyle ( notably Bartleby) , obituaries and an occasional unbiased book review, everything else is majorly filtered through a globalist, mostly Woke lens.
It’s a sad journey as I still recall better editorial stances it took many moons ago.
The Economist’s position on most things is laissez-faire, globalist, small state and economically liberal, hardly woke. You should cancel your subscription if that’s not your thing.
What is Liberal today? Henry Ford said ” People can have any colour they want provided it is black “. Liberal today means you can have any opinion you like provided I agree with it.
The Economist stopped being laissez- faire when it came to opinions, decades ago. In reality it is modern Butskellism.
It was Butskellist long ago pre-Thatcher. Always looking for the middle way in the out and out power struggle between Moscow backed unions and milquetoast governments.
If you are right it has changed a lot since I cancelled my subscription of forty years two years ago.
The Economist is quite economical on actual economics topics or discussion. Better is the very dry but at least technical Rand Journal of Economics.
Congratulations on your century SGJ.
My team too?! Pulled it off well despite Kohli missing 100.
What happened to the subject matter of the article?
This is just demagoguery, you don’t think that Netanyahu’s policies and actions amount to terrorism? The Palestinians have been ethnically cleansed and thrown out of their lands, and they are terrorists? You mention ‘woke’ on here and you get 138 up votes, how embarrassing…
The “intelligence failure” is a strange line to lead on. Like it’s Israel’s fault. If only they’d done even more surveillance than one of the most highly monitored states in the world, so more surveillance was called for. Instead of questioning the morals of attacking and kidnapping civilians for political aims, not least because of the repercussions that will follow.
Maybe the overestimation of surveillance’s value is the point. What surveillance provides is information at best?
Along the lines of information is more than data, knowledge is more than information and wisdom is more than knowledge.
To understand the backdrop, we need to look at the wealthy and powerful pro-Iran NGOs and think tanks in the US. Robert Malley was head of the International Crisis Group. First-term Obama had to distance himself from Malley because of Malley’s prior relationship with Hamas, but second-term Obama put Malley in charge of the Iran nuclear deal. Now Malley is under a hushed investigation over his handling of classified information, and we’ve learned in the last week that some of his closest associates in the Biden Administration are high-level moles for Iran who were somehow approved for their sensitive positions despite their past contacts.
And guess what?
The same Americans who fund the pro-Iran International Crisis Group also fund far-left NGOs inside Israel. It’s no surprise at all, then, that Iran felt emboldened to activate its proxy in Gaza in an unprecedented invasion of Israel. What remains to be seen is whether the Israeli left will snap back into reality or whether they will remain captive to the NGO reality distortion field.
Phil Can you identify those far-left NGOs inside Israel?
first link on duckduckgo
https://www.thetower.org/article/how-non-governmental-organizations-became-a-weapon-in-the-war-on-israel/
Interstitial article. NGOs are a pernicious threat across the west.
We need to examine charities and NGOs; namely where they obtain funds and their political objectives. Charities used to mean people giving up their time freely and money to help the less fortunate. Now many charities employs people on salaries of £100K plus, claim tax exempt status and spend money on lobbying;
In some ways they are more secure than unions and companies.
The Roman Catholic Church saved Western Civilisation 410 AD but by 1400 AD had become corrupt and needed reform. The desire for power corrupts all.
The Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Church effectively DESTROYED Classical Civilisation after circa 390 AD/1143AUC.
Only a feeble imitation survived.
Here, here! This is well explained in detail in the recent “The Darkening Age” by Catherine Nixey.
You’ve been around awhile
Cultures stuck in the 9th century just cannot be integrated into peaceful modern society.
How did they pull this off though?
I keep writing about crime tech going to the highest bidders irrespective of purpose based on my ongoing experience with what Australia’s bikies keep showing off – having government insiders like police and cyber-experts on their payrolls.
Are there tech sabotage capabilities, or information poisoning capabilities provided to terrorists? If yes, by whom and why?
This would be a hell of a distraction if any entity on planet Earth ever needed one.
I am pleased with Australia’s bikies and their government insiders signing up to UnHerd 🙂
Keep it up hunies!
I just lost Internet connection typing this too – in a part of Melbourne, Australia, where no one has Internet disconnection issues 🙂
7th century.
Not that it makes a difference!
The justification for Zionism goes back to the 9th century BC. The irony.
We are watching events closely… Jewish wife and children, my eldest may yet fly to TA and volunteer for the IVF. It’s an existential crisis.
Never again.
Palestine belongs to Palestinians not New Yorkers.
First priority should be expelling all Jihadis still on Israeli territory – preferably killing them.
Next up, an operation to free all hostages possible.
After that, the entire West Bank and Gaza strip should be razed to the ground and the inhabitants sent home to Syria and Jordan.
Plenty of time after all that is accomplished to ask how this happened.
What have you been smoking?
Exactly!!
He’s in the Israeli cabinet
What would be your response to the massacre of several hundred Israeli civilians?
Sanctions on Israel?
The world has become too woke to accept that solution.
A 1 day war
Elliot, you’re a racist abomination – an evil monster.
It took Ghandhi a little over 30 years to win India’s independence from Great Britain using non-violent resistance. It has been 75 years since the Palestinians have resisted Israel using violence and they are no closer to an independent state now than in 1948. We can only wonder where they would be if they chose non-violence or if they just sought civil rights inside Israel.
The people of Gaza and the West Bank will pay a horrible price for Hamas’ actions. Palestinians will gain nothing through violence but violence and oppression. They have brought it on themselves, and they deserve it.
“We can only wonder where they would be if they chose non-violence”
Expropriated. A few of the early zionists were honest about it: they would capture the entirety of the Promised Land one way or another. It might happen sooner or it might happen later but there was never any doubt what the final outcome would be.
Not a particularly fair comparison.
By 1948 the UK had effectively bankrupted itself TWICE in pursuing two Pyrrhic victories in the previous 30 years, and was no longer in a position to resist even Ghandhi.
You keep pushing these alternative histories but never explaining how Germany dominated Europe would be in long term British interest?
It wouldn’t have been, but 1914-18 was NOT the answer.
So they caved when he threatened to remove his loin cloth.
We don’t know if it was an intelligence failure, or whether the Israeli government just chose to ignore warnings because Bibi thought it would never happen.
Love an overly complicated conspiracy
Maybe they did have the warnings and let it happen because it would provide the perfect justification for cracking down?
“Israel’s biggest intelligence failure in half a century” – can the assumed benefit of tech used in intelligence gathering erode value?
Hamas will never, ever agree to Israel’s existence. They want the complete removal of all Jew’s from the land. Palestinian leadership over many decades has never conceded anything from the initial offer to form an Arab state alongside Israel before modern Israel came to be, to recent initiatives like Camp David and Oslo where Israel gave up many things. All this with the added background of the surrounding states attacking Israel. The continuing existence of modern Israel is a miracle. And despite its many weaknesses and problems it’s a beacon in a region dominated by another religion and culture that is not known for its forward thinking.
What is striking and repellent about Hamas’s actions is how brutal and inhuman they are, a continuing expression of Palestine nationalism’s violent anti-Semitism. You can look back at other intensely fought wars of national liberation, from India to Ireland, and not find similar levels of barbarism. No Ira member would have have smashed a baby’s head against a rock, as a PLO leader once did to a Jewish infant nor propose poisoning the drinking water in Haifa. These are tactics more appropriate to the Palestinian’s real inspiration, the German Nazi party. After all, it was Arafat’s uncle, the Mufti of Jerusalem, who eager planned a “Final Solution” in collaboration with Hitler that would have been implemented if Rommel has headed east.
Indeed. These are extraordinary times that call for extraordinary leaders who are in short supply.
The IDF will kill all of Israel’s enemies. But this looks like the end for Netanyahu.
One hopes it will be the end of Netanyahu.
You may well be right about Netantahu, but can you think of anyone better? I can’t because most of his peers look like lightweights to me.
It’s hard to look away from the atrocities but at some stage an agreement must be reached that provides for a stable and enduring Israel as well as a stable and enduring Palestine.
absolutely; and Israel as the strongest party must start the process, however difficult; they don’t seem to be willing
The well behaved kid must bend to the bully. No wonder the UK is in such a mess.
There is no talking to 7th century religious fanatics who have a pathological hatred of Jews and would, if they could, annihilate every man woman and child in Israel. That I’d all they want. There will be no peace u till that happens. So there will be no peace. For Israel it is existential and they should do whatever it takes to protect their people. Everything.
Exactly – KILL ALL ARABS. Even the kids. As a well-known Israeli once remarked, shrugging his shoulders while excusing the killings of Palestinian kids by the IDF, “nits make lice”. Kill ’em all, total war etc. Yet I bet you’d be first in the queue to urge “peace” on the Ukrainians.
Frank, I think the irony went over the head of whoever downvoted your comment. Some people are just too literal. Your comment reminded me of Johnathan Swift.
That’s because on this site it’s hard to tell what might be ironic because there are extreme leftists.
Margie, if that is the only thing you can see, not that they are also and mainly men and women and children like you and me, then indeed there will not be peace. It is difficult but responsible leadership from both sides is needed.
Decisions are not made by the men, women and children though, who are like you and me. Agreements may or may not be adhered to either, may give a false sense of security to the weaker party.
In the dyings days of WW2, Hitler Youth were fighting; they had been completely indoctrinated by the Nazis. Hamas control over the youth of Gaza is even greater than the Nazis.
The Camp David Accord under Clinton was supported by Israel but Arafat walked away. The Saudis created the Jeddah Accord but the Palestinians walked away.
The reality is most Arab countries have stopped supporting the Palestinians and Pakistanies have said to me they stopped supporting them because of Arafat.
The one country prepared to support Hamas is Iran which only reduces their support from the GCC countries.
The actions of Palestinians in Kuwait in mid 1950s, Jordan 1970, Lebanon in mid 1970s and support for Hussein in invasion of Iraq in 1990 reduced support and money for Palestinians from Arab countries.
At present most GCC countries consider Iran their biggest threat so Hamas acting as their proxy may provided them short term gains but not long term ones.
They cheer the murder of women and children in the streets. they send their sons to be suicide attackers. They are NOT just like you and me.
Exactly.
Netanyahu said he would like to throw all the Arabs into the sea. Sounds like a n—- to me!
The Palestinians don’t want a two state solution. They want a one state solution with all the Israelis dead. Any concessions to them just strengthens their hands for the next round of violence.
Palestine belongs to Palestinians not New Yorkers.
Who thinks this will happen after this weeks events? I’d say this is off the table for decades now, until much more blood is spilled.
Guess it’s existential for both sides, so we just have to see who exists at the end of it.
The Saudis are onboard. The Palestinians are doomed.
People who set out to cold bloodedly slaughter and kidnap civilians are not militants they are terrorists. Your use of BBC apologist language disgusts me.
How long will it take for AOC, Omar and the rest of the squad to be out making statement saying Israel brought this on itself and the Palestinians are just venting?
Biden is in another bind. The far left and the college crowd are all anti Israel. He already reversed on the border wall, he backs Israel too much or if Israel pushes into Gaze with lots of troops and he will have these people turning on him even more.
Trump is gonna take another lap too. He was a big supporter of Israel. Even moved the embassy.
Not a comfortable place to be if you are on the left justifying these attacks as images of grandmas in wheelchairs being taken hostage and womens bodies stripped naked and dragged through the street show up on TVs and social media.
Could international pressure(looking at you U.S) have played a hand in Israel’s approach to date? In 2001, the US was also compacent and exacting revenge cost billions(trilions?) in tracking terrosists and security measures world-wide.
Israel on the other hand, has a focused mission, to eliminate terrosists in their “backyard”. Personally, I would like to see a full scale attack on Hamas murderers in Gaza and Palestine. Israel has justification to reach beyond its borders to obliterate the enemy.
Remember this, Hamas is only interested in death and chaos. They do not represent a viable peaceful and should be treated as ‘ISIS” extremists. I am hopeful that conventional forces and the Mossad will eliminate all Hamas leaders as well as those who celebrated the death of innocent Israeli citizens. Death to Hamas.
Thinking that Israel is gonna need to purge Gaza. They are gonna need to go in in force and basically engage in ethnic cleansing. Push all the Palestinians to the West Bank.
But now Hamas is talking about attacking Arab countries that have made peace with Israel or done business with it.
That happens, and my guess is Iran gets involved. That happens and the whole middle east goes up in flames.
Yesterday, when Netanyahu said he wouldn’t “let this happen again” or something like that I almost laughed out loud. Many who follow him have been expecting this day for quite some time.
“Yet when it finally happened, the army seems to have been caught entirely unaware.”
Maybe not. Perhaps Bibi wants a casus belli for his plans to reconquer Gaza. True, a few hundred Israelis had to die, OTOH he’ll now feel free to kill ten times as many Palestinians and steal their land to boot.
It’s hard to believe Bibi had no intelligence about such a massive attack.
My thoughts on this are that Hamas targeted this event on this day because there were so many young women in attendance. The parading of young women, dragged by their hair, through the streets, the dead body of the young woman in the back of the truck – animals did this. I know the conflict itself has blame on both sides, blood as well. But the things done in this attack were specifically done to women by men who regard them as less than human. I try to be open-minded and respect all cultures, but I have a hard time stomaching cultures where women are property, not human beings, to be abused and disposed of with no mercy. Those images hardened something in me, as I am sure they did many other people. Civilized nations don’t fight wars this way.
This is going to kick off an aggressive Israeli response. Iran who at the moment is an ally of Russia in the Ukraine war also supports Hamas and Hezbollah in Palestine. Let’s drag Iran into a direct conflict with Israel? Let’s muddy the waters. Let’s stir it up. All the while innocent people are being killed for the sake of power and greed. All wars are bankers wars.
Israel has the best spies in the world, and anyone could have foreseen that this would have been attempted over this Yom Kippur, the fiftieth anniversary of that Yom Kippur. But even by his standards, Netanyahu needs a lot of political cover both at home and abroad. So here we are.
Anyone could have forseen it?
Did you? Why didn’t you warn us?
Well, of course, this was going to happen. Israel provides a forecast of what will Europe will be like in about thirty years. Consider yourselves warned.
Except that Yom Kippur was a little less than two weeks ago (24th-25th September this year). It’s quite possible that the security services were geared up to counter an attack then, and relaxed when nothing much happened.
The attacks occurred on another holiday, Simhat Torah. I was in synagogue celebrating when young men (including my son) were summoned to report for duty. But I agree that the fiftieth anniversary of the Yom Kippur War is not a coincidence.
Already, we see the same split as over Ukraine, between an “international community” that agrees with the United States, and the huge global majority that does not. Interestingly, Israel is in the latter camp on Ukraine. It was not all that keen on the Iraq War, either.
The media are still peddling the hallucination that this attack “came as a surprise”. That is the “weapons of mass destruction” of this war, with the nuance that it was particularly surprising on Yom Kippur. When it has happened before. Netanyahu has told the two million inhabitants of the Gaza Strip to leave, but he has not lifted the 16-year blockade, so they cannot do so. Does he think that they have remained there voluntarily hitherto?
Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus or Pompey the Great, captured Jerusalem in 63 BC thus ending the independence of the Jewish state.
It remained under Roman control for approximately 700 years, until 637/8 AD, when it was reconquered by fellow Semites under the the command of of one Caliph Umar.
Nearly another 1300 years would pass before Israel finally achieved independence in 1948.
The Palestinians have a very LONG wait ahead of them.
Israel did not ‘finally achieve independence’. It did not exist, even as an idea. It was because of many centuries of vicious persecution of Jewish people by Europeans that Zionism arose.
It’s amazing that Israel had no forewarning of this considering it has the best Spyware on the planet, Pegasus/NSO included.
Sivan Kurzberg of the Urban MovingSystems said, “We are not your problem. Your problems are our problems. The Palestinians are the problem.” The other Israelis in the van who cheered the bombing of the World Trade Center were his brother Paul Kurzberg, Yaron Shmuel, Oded Ellner and Omer Marmari formerly of Mossad.
Up to last week, since 2008, 6,407 Palestinians killed; and 308 Israelis killed. 167 Palestinians killed in 2023 so far, v limited / no media reaction. 150 Israelis killed, world media goes nuts. Very obviously, a dead Israeli is worth far more than a dead Arab. How come the Americans who are hostile to supporting far away Ukraine are so enthusiastic about pumping billions into supporting a statelet in the Middle East which is even further way than Ukraine?
Did you see the young woman’s naked, dead body in the back of the truck, like a dead deer, a hunting trophy? Did you see the young women being dragged by their hair to certain rape and death? I try to respect all cultures, but is it a “culture” that regards women as subhuman and treats them like property, disposed of when no longer of use? Child brides, honor killings, murdered for trying to be educated in Afghanistan, for not wearing a hijab in Iran. Do you think it was an accident that this event, a concert full of free young women dancing in shorts and tank tops, was chosen for this attack?
I pray for the women and children of Palestine, but this “culture” has not evolved over thousands of years. How do you possibly negotiate with them? There is killing and blame on both sides, but not naked dead girls in trucks paraded about like big game trophies. That’s the stuff of psychopaths.
.
“Netanyahu’s efforts to overhaul its judiciary”… overhaul?? Is the Economist’s Middle East correspondent just another craven courtier anxious to protect his access? The corrupt Netanyahu is intent on crippling the judiciary’s independence in order both to acquire more powere and to protect himself from bribery amd other charges. Oh, but it’s just an overhaul, folks.
When you invade someone else’s country, ethnically cleanse them and steal their land, you better be ‘prepared for war’.
Jews and Arabs (mainly Muslims) co-existed for many centuries in and near what is now Israel.
Jews did not “invade” or “steal” anyone’s country before 1948. The early Zionists bought land, piece by piece, from the owners–not local Arabs, unfortunately, but absentee landowners in Constantinople (because this region was a province of the Ottoman Empire before World War I).
Nor did the Israelis do so in 1948. On the contrary, they accepted the United Nations’ partition plan (giving Jews the smaller and least fertile part of Britain’s mandated territory). The Arabs demanded all of the mandated territory, not part of it, and refused the partition plan. To back up that demand, several Arab countries–Egypt, Transjordan, Syria and Iraq —invaded the Jewish territory (with fervent support from many other Islamic countries).
I can’t argue that the Israelis have never succumbed to hatred or always refrained from terrorism, but I can argue not only that the peaceful and secure co-existence of two states would have been eagerly accepted by most Israelis at any time since 1948–and there have been several proposals–but also that the Palestinians (and their allies) have consistently rejected that solution (doing everything possible to sabotage every proposal).
Yippee, let’s go kill some rag heads
This what you get when you elect a crook and grifter to lead a coalition of religious maniacs.
I think Hamas has a dislike of Israel whoever the PM is. It’s not as if Hamas would have said:
“No we can’t attack – this Israeli PM is too honest and has too much integrity. Best leave it.”
You have missed the point entirely. No great surprise there.
A competent leadership would never have allowed this to happen.
I would let this thread drop Samuel. This anonymous troll never offers insight.
The stated goal of Hamas and Iran is to wipe Israel off the map of the world regardless of its internal politics. Do come out of your champagne induced delusion.
Well said, although they are not all maniacs, just a lot of them, they are the ‘chosen people’ though, right?
A ray of hope for all the oppressed people in the world. Hope springs eternal!
Ignorance and violence deserve to be oppressed!