Subscribe
Notify of
guest

43 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Geoff Cox
Geoff Cox
3 years ago

Well written article and not a bit cynical. Young people have got themselves all worked up in the ways only young people can – on slight evidence and even less knowledge. But unlike the peace movement of the 60s or the environmental movement of the 80s which nudged the world in a new direction, this movement is so large (thanks to social media) we are in severe danger of doing great damage to our society before these youngsters realise what fools they’ve been.

It is more imperative than ever that right now politicians and older people stand up and criticise and put a huge break on the wokery. What we really don’t need is politicians and older people joining in with the foolishness.

Peter Branagan
Peter Branagan
3 years ago
Reply to  Geoff Cox

Well said. I couldn’t agree more.

Liscarkat
Liscarkat
3 years ago
Reply to  Geoff Cox

You’re right, but these young people have been brainwashed since they entered school at the age of five, and they have been raised by parents who were brainwashed before them when the decay that began in the sixties engulfed everything. They will never realize what fools they’ve been, or listen to older people’s criticism of wokery. And tragically, many older people and politicians have already joined in with the foolishness.

trentvalley57uk
trentvalley57uk
3 years ago
Reply to  Liscarkat

Shows what weak foolish cowards they are. Its easier to virtue signal than face the reality of the destruction they are creating.

Adamsson
Adamsson
3 years ago

Same reason that no one cares the 3 gay men stabbed to death in Reading this is about stopping Trump getting re elected nothing else

Fraser Bailey
Fraser Bailey
3 years ago

This article mainly seems to state the obvious. And anyway, you will never get this rabble to understand that the Chinese represent a far greater threat to their freedoms than Trump or whoever it is they’re complaining about today. They are simply too dumb, having sat in the West’s schools, colleges and universities for up to 20 years.

Stephen Follows
Stephen Follows
3 years ago
Reply to  Fraser Bailey

Well, indeed. But when neither politicians, the police or most of the media seem able to notice the obvious, it needs to be continually rammed down their throats.

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago

Young international hashtaggers might boost multinational woke capital but they are degrading their own national economies upon which they depend. The longer they continue to kick away the props which have underpinned and sustained our culture – equality before the law, basic scientific objectivity, deep seated ideas of personal liberty emerging out of Christianity etc. – then the easier it will be for other countries to drive a coach and horses through our economies and freedoms.

Frederick B
Frederick B
3 years ago

“Equality before the law”? I bet that chap who was sacked for daring to proclaim that ” White Lives Matter” would like some of that

trentvalley57uk
trentvalley57uk
3 years ago
Reply to  Frederick B

The criteria for equality differs depending on who is calling for it

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago

Too many graduates, many of whom not suited to Higher Ed, taking superficial non-scholarly degrees in grievance and resentment studies. As stated elsewhere, they’re thick and short of humility, civility and any sense of their own culture beyond their university. The fact is it’s much easier and simpler to blame something closer to home than understand global complexities.

Fraser Bailey
Fraser Bailey
3 years ago

Yes, here in the West we now have an education system in which many or most people are virtually from the age of 4 to 24. And after 20 years of incarceration and indoctrination they leave knowing precisely….nothing. It’s an incredible achievement on the part of the educational establishment – to be paid fortunes for churning out hordes of people who know nothing about anything. Nice work if you can get it.
Quite frankly, the West deserves to fall.

Mark Corby
Mark Corby
3 years ago
Reply to  Fraser Bailey

Hang on! We still have an excellent Public School system that is the envy of the world. As I write, hordes of Chinese, male and female students are clamouring for entrance, which is laudable, although unsettling.
The appalling grovelling by the Eton head the other day, was just an aberration and does not represent the feelings of most of the school or the system in general.
Whilst the rest of England may have “gone to the dogs”, the Public Schools remain the bastion of common sense, fair play and old the virtues that made us the greatest Empire on Earth, since Ancient Rome.
Do not despair even if only 7% of our children have the luxury of a Public School education, it is enough to lead the way, eradicate the cancer of Wokedom, defeat the Asiatic peril, and return the land to sanity.

Stephen Follows
Stephen Follows
3 years ago
Reply to  Mark Corby

Sadly, a lot of the wokes seem to have come from the private schools.

Mark Corby
Mark Corby
3 years ago

Yes agreed, that will have to cease, there is no excuse! I suspect it’s due to ‘upwardly mobile’ pushy parents dictating the agenda. The staff must stand up against such nonsense and stop ‘kow towing’ to Woke drivel.
If parents really want Woke, there are literally hundreds of State Comprehensives only too willing to poison young minds, and they have the inestimable advantage of being free.

trentvalley57uk
trentvalley57uk
3 years ago
Reply to  Mark Corby

Dont agree. Many teachers are concerned about kids learning right wing sentiments at home that may override the left wing marxism taught in schools. They are looking for ways to combat this

Mark Corby
Mark Corby
3 years ago

That is quite a conundrum, the battle for the soul of the youth.
How did we get it so wrong? Too busy stuffing our faces, planning Tuscan holidays, and heading for the Alps perhaps?
Off course if you were fortunate enough to afford private education you ignored everything else. A valid reason but not a reasonable excuse. Now we must reap what we have sowed.

David Barnett
David Barnett
3 years ago

Even those who are otherwise suited to University, are products of a huge indoctrination machine that so narrows their outlook, that they become visibly agitated even hearing views contrary to their taught dogma. And the academic establishment is now so badly infected that even our once great universities no longer merit the name.

Roger Laville
Roger Laville
3 years ago

Klemens von Metternich (1773 ““ 1859) coined the phrase “When Paris sneezes, Europe catches a cold.” I don’t think he was that concerned with the US.

Chris Jayne
Chris Jayne
3 years ago
Reply to  Roger Laville

He was probably concerned with the source of European cultural hegemony though.

Fraser Bailey
Fraser Bailey
3 years ago
Reply to  Roger Laville

Yes, I thought that quoting Metternich here was a bit strange given that the US was hardly a Great Power – and certainly not really interconnected with Europe – during Metternich’s time.

Dennis Wheeler
Dennis Wheeler
3 years ago
Reply to  Fraser Bailey

Hello Roger and Fraser, do pay attention. The author states that he has ADAPTED the phrase he borrowed from Metternich to make it apply to the USA. He was not implying that Metternich was “concerned with the US,” much less that the original quote referred to the US (in fact he clearly states that Metternich’s original line was about France).

Mark Corby
Mark Corby
3 years ago
Reply to  Roger Laville

Indeed, where did Ben Sixsmith pick that up. Surely Metternich’s dates were the obvious clue?
In 1859 the US was a Pygmy as far as Europe was concerned. They had ‘chastised’ the Japanese in 1853 but had done little else of note. Slavery would soon catapult them into a brutal internecine Civil War.

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago

Some form of contest will always occur when industry and agriculture decline, and when higher education swells in response, as there is so much status, and wealth, waiting to be claimed.

Too many graduates, many of whom not suited to Higher Ed, taking superficial non-scholarly degrees in grievance and resentment studies. As the earlier comment makes clear, they’re just really really thick and lack humility, civility and any sense of their own culture beyond their university. The fact is it’s much easier and simpler to blame something closer to home than understand global complexities. The young international hashtaggers that Mary identifies might boost multinational woke capital but they are degrading their own national economies upon which they depend. The longer they continue to kick away the props which have underpinned and sustained our culture – equality before the law, basic scientific objectivity, deep seated ideas of personal liberty emerging out of Christianity etc. – then the easier it will be for the likes of China to drive a coach and horses through our economies and freedoms.

Steve Craddock
Steve Craddock
3 years ago

We, the older generation should stand up and be honest enough to admit that it is our cohort that has permitted a lot of the problems to arise that we so frequently hear about such as higher education where there is insufficient work places at that level, the clear rise of mob rule and not forgetting the self appointed thought police we see in action so often in the news. I have tried writing to my government rep but they have now seemingly walled themselves off after organisations like 38 degrees totally destroyed the process with their templated email campaigns. The scariest thing we see every day now but do not possibly recognise it for what it is, is the real world power the Twitter mobs wield or more correctly their shadowy promoters or leaders, with seemingly no checks or balances in place at all. Fancy losing your job, your friends, being physically attacked or potentially worse, no problem just make a statement online that someone disagrees with… the late night knock on door so feared in the ex-soviet countries has been replaced by the quiet repeated chime of your news feed being updated or tweet update arriving or perhaps an email from work that HR would like a word, and yes best bring a friend or colleague with you.
Once we can get past the denial phase and accept that we are part of the problem, only then can we start to consider and drive for solutions. Our kids are only working with what we have given them.

David Bell
David Bell
3 years ago

It is interesting that talking about a town called Reading when discussing incidents like this gets your comment deleted

Clive Mitchell
Clive Mitchell
3 years ago

Deleted

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago

Too many graduates, many of whom not suited to Higher Ed, taking superficial non-scholarly degrees in grievance and resentment studies. As the earlier comment makes clear, they’re just really really thick and lack humility, civility and any sense of their own culture beyond their university. The fact is it’s much easier and simpler to blame something closer to home than understand global complexities. The young international hashtaggers that Ben identifies might boost multinational woke capital but they are degrading their own national economies upon which they depend. The longer they continue to kick away the props which have underpinned and sustained our culture – equality before the law, basic scientific objectivity, deep seated ideas of personal liberty emerging out of Christianity etc. – then the easier it will be for other countries to drive a coach and horses through our economies and freedoms.

Andrew Roman
Andrew Roman
3 years ago

This is an excellent article, but leaves unanswered questions: how and why are all these supposedly spontaneous demonstrations happening so quickly? The answer is the large and well-funded national and international protest organization industry. For example, when Greta Thunberg advocated for international children’s demonstrations the millions of children in numerous countries didn’t suddenly walk out onto the streets without parental knowledge. Likewise with Black Lives Matter demonstrations, even in countries where there are very few Black people and few if any reported incidents of killing by police. It isn’t that the citizens of these countries are mesmerized by US culture, but rather, they are organized by branches or chapters of the same multinational protest organizations.

These organizations can use social media followers and past protest attendees to organize protests on short notice. They design the memes like “No justice, No peace” and “Defund the Police” and distribute the signs or organize their preparation in several countries. TV and social media then present these well-organized theatrical demonstrations as spontaneous displays of public support.

The purpose of organizing demonstrations in such countries is for media coverage of this political theatre. This gets the organizers more donations and more political influence. While people all over the world are opposed in principle to racism, most people outside the US wouldn’t ordinarily be sufficiently motivated to go out into the streets in protest. This is especially true where police racism is minimal to nonexistent (in countries like Iceland, where most people are of the same race).

Of course political theatre cannot exist where the government won’t permit it. Greta supporters and BLM protesters were not organized to protest in Tiananmen Square in Beijing. Theatre requires an audience and a media chorus that is available only in certain countries. So racism is seen as an evil only where demonstrations are permitted, and everywhere else it is RAU — racism as usual.

Liscarkat
Liscarkat
3 years ago

The accompanying photograph of white college-age children taking a knee with fists upheld for BLM, in Poland, with 0.05 percent black population and about 2 people (most likely white) killed by police each year, is ludicrous. One one hand it’s hilarious in its absurdity. On the other hand it’s tragic that the world has been so deeply infected by mindless wokeness.

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago

Some form of contest will always occur when industry and agriculture decline, and when higher education swells in response, as there is so much status, and wealth, waiting to be claimed.
Too many graduates, many of whom not suited to Higher Ed, taking superficial non-scholarly degrees in grievance and resentment studies. As the earlier comment makes clear, they’re just really really thick and lack humility, civility and any sense of their own culture beyond their university. The fact is it’s much easier and simpler to blame something closer to home than understand global complexities. The young international hashtaggers that Mary identifies might boost multinational woke capital but they are degrading their own national economies upon which they depend. The longer they continue to kick away the props which have underpinned and sustained our culture – equality before the law, basic scientific objectivity, deep seated ideas of personal liberty emerging out of Christianity etc. – then the easier it will be for the likes of the Chinese to drive a coach and horses through our economies and freedoms.

Steve Dean
Steve Dean
3 years ago

Is it me or are you repeating yourself?

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago
Reply to  Steve Dean

Yes! It’s the dratted comment-censoring software having its way again.

Steve Dean
Steve Dean
3 years ago

Does make reasoned ‘discussion’ quite hard doesn’t it! Everything gets out of sequence, in ones mind, anyway! Maybe we need to earn the trust of the ‘forum police’ before being allowed to post almost live!

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago
Reply to  Steve Dean

Yes it does. Nearly all of my unremarkable comments on this site never appear. I’ve basically given up.

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago
Reply to  Steve Dean

each and every comment of mine is met with this: “Hold on, this is waiting to be approved by UnHerd”.

Is it just me?

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago

Too many graduates, many of whom not suited to Higher Ed, taking superficial non-scholarly degrees in grievance and resentment studies. As stated elsewhere, they’re thick and short of humility, civility and any sense of their own culture beyond their university. The fact is it’s much easier and simpler to blame something closer to home than understand global complexities. Young international hashtaggers might boost multinational woke capital but they are degrading their own national economies upon which they depend. The longer they continue to kick away the props which have underpinned and sustained our culture – equality before the law, basic scientific objectivity, deep seated ideas of personal liberty emerging out of Christianity etc. – then the easier it will be for other countries to drive a coach and horses through our economies and freedoms.

Jonathan Oldbuck
Jonathan Oldbuck
3 years ago

Too many graduates, many of whom not suited to Higher Ed, taking superficial non-scholarly degrees in grievance and resentment studies. As stated elsewhere, they’re stupid and short of humility, civility and any sense of their own culture beyond their university. The fact is it’s much easier and simpler to blame something closer to home than understand global complexities. Young international hashtaggers might boost multinational woke capital but they are degrading their own national economies upon which they depend. The longer they continue to kick away the props which have underpinned and sustained our culture – equality before the law, basic scientific objectivity, deep seated ideas of personal liberty emerging out of Christianity etc. – then the easier it will be for other countries to drive a coach and horses through our economies and freedoms.

Andrew Baldwin
Andrew Baldwin
3 years ago

Shawn Mendes is Canadian, not American, the pride of Pickering, Ontario, but it is delightful to here that he has a following in Poland. I hope Ben is aware of this; I noticed in the paragraph where he brings up Shawn he suddenly starts talking about the “English-speaking” media rather than the American media. Unfortunately, Canadians are easily conflated with Americans, because there isn’t much difference between Canadians and Americans in accents or vocabulary, certainly less than between Brits and Americans.

Dennis Wheeler
Dennis Wheeler
3 years ago

Social media is a cancer eating away at society. Historically and culturally illiterate “hashtag” campaigns and “influencer” culture will destroy everything. It’s especially sad to see how these US-based phenomena and pathologies are also doing such damage to Europe as well.

Steve Gwynne
Steve Gwynne
3 years ago

Our global Internet is like a virtual human brain 😊

Has anyone read The Aquarian Conspiracy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/

I often get the feeling this movement was influential in shaping the birth of a global network society. Maybe this movement merged with the civil rights movement with ‘rights protectors’ trying to claim higher virtual status.

The Internet is like a virtual world that we inhabit but one which can have real life consequences as we know only too well.

To think we are all influencing each other in our global virtual brain is quite mad really. However, it seems to have taken human competition over resources to another mental level with the virtual society facilitating virtual wars rather than physical ones, if you know what I mean.

Hopefully with a global virtual brain, we can sort out our human growth crisis before it is too late.
🏵️🌸

Jordan Flower
Jordan Flower
3 years ago

“It is an expression of self-image as much as a meaningful protest.”

I would change “as much as” to say “much more than”. I know Sixsmith is trying not to be cynical, so I’ll just pick up his slack.

These kids do not have a bone of principled consistency in their bodies. They march for the virtue signal photo op. If it wasn’t so, they would be shouting from the rooftops about the Uighurs. But they do not give a sh*t because this cause contains zero social clout.

What’s more, is the featured image used for this piece is of polish protestors, which of course is dominated by white girls, which for some reason seems to be the global trend. As the caption bluntly states, Poland has 0.05% black and their police kill ~2 people per year. What the hell else could these white girls be doing except harvesting content for their instagram feed?

I wonder if these polish protestors have ever raised a placard for the fact that a disproportionate amount of sex slaves in Europe”including children”are taken from Poland. I would wager a large bet that the answer is no.

happybim
happybim
3 years ago

Does anyone recall the Free Speech Movement, started I believe at Berkeley about 1968? The induction of young men to fight in Vietnam was clearly in the background. It went other places, including Frankfurt according to a friend of mine. It certainly did not have the mega- phone of the internet and I believe things settled down quickly. Were there massive marches or confrontations in classrooms?