July 12, 2024 - 5:00pm

Several top Democrats have publicly expressed their preference that Joe Biden exit the presidential race, drawing a hostile and at times conspiratorial response from those who still believe he’s the party’s best chance at keeping the White House.

The President’s performance at last night’s widely anticipated press conference was an improvement on his showing at the Atlanta debate last month, reassuring his most ardent supporters while doing little to quell the concerns of the general public. He had fewer major gaffes, though he did refer to Kamala Harris as “Vice President Trump”, hours after introducing Volodymyr Zelensky as “President Putin” during the Nato conference. He also used a teleprompter and announced aloud that he would be selecting reporters from a pre-approved list to ask him questions.

The press conference, however, was sufficient proof of Biden’s mental fitness for some. The Washington Post’s Jen Rubin was optimistic, and called for the media to report that Biden is “on top of things in a way Trump is not and will never be”. For the President’s supporters, the sense of panic surrounding his candidacy is an unhelpful distraction from the more serious threat posed by Donald Trump. This was the thrust of the criticism directed at the New York Times over pieces calling for Biden to exit the race, which might have been the motivation for the outlet’s new editorial calling Trump “unfit to lead”. The same argument played out in response to Hollywood producer and devoted Democrat Rob Reiner’s Friday morning statement calling for Biden to step down. The post earned 2,000 comments in two hours, with critics dismissing Reiner and lauding the President’s Thursday performance.

This pro-Biden cohort has been consistently defending him and minimising his age problem for weeks. Former Barack Obama staffer Ben Rhodes was met with hundreds of critical comments after questioning the Biden team’s decision to pick a fight with actor George Clooney over the two men’s comparative stamina. Biden’s supporters accused Rhodes of attempting to tear down the 81-year-old, dismissed Clooney as an irrelevant celebrity, and pointed to Rhodes’s work as a paid commentator as disqualifying.

Jon Favreau, another former Obama aide and co-host of Pod Save America, has been subjected to wall-to-wall hostility for drawing attention to the challenges facing Biden’s reelection, particularly his cognitive issues. Prominent commentators and countless online accounts have called him a “coward” and accused him of “wetting the bed”.

Democratic Sen. Peter Welch garnered over 3,000 comments on his Washington Post piece calling for Biden to step down. Many of these comments were negative, including several that suggested Russia was responsible for the criticism of Biden.

Speculation about a cynical force behind the Democratic revolt has not been restricted to social media. Obama has himself been a key figure in the emerging theories surrounding Biden’s fall from grace, with a daytime television host promoting this version of events. “The Biden campaign and many Democratic officials do believe that Barack Obama is quietly working behind the scenes to orchestrate this,” Morning Joe host Joe Scarborough said in response to Clooney’s op-ed calling for the President, whom the actor had long supported, to drop out.

Many online accounts are veering into outright conspiracism, with some suggesting that the late Jeffrey Epstein’s associates are to blame for the groundswell of anti-Biden sentiment. They claim that Hollywood, the media, and elected Democrats are pushing an anti-Biden narrative to distract from incriminating Epstein files that would implicate both Trump and prominent media figures. As a result, a Miami Herald reporter who has reported extensively on Epstein has been exposed to numerous attacks suggesting she has neglected key evidence that could implicate Trump and expose a conspiracy driving the anti-Biden push among Democrats.

While Thursday’s performance may have been encouraging for those still holding out hope for Biden, it will likely do little to stop the expected outpouring of public calls from Congressional Democrats for the President to step down.


is UnHerd’s US correspondent.

laureldugg