It’s also very important to recognise that criticising ultra-conservative Muslim dress is a political right, because the “choice” to adopt fundamentalist dress is a valid societal choice that must equally be subjected to scrutiny — like any religious conservativism must be.
No. Racism is not the same as criticising my religious choices, or lack thereof. You can (politely) criticise my religion, because it’s an idea, and all ideas must be scrutinised. But one cannot insult another’s race, without being rightly deemed a racist.
Jews are both a people and a religion. European anti-Semitic tropes against Jews concern their supposed habits as a “people”, not their religion. It is indeed racism to suggest that all Jews are secret greedy capitalists, for example, as several party members have been found saying.
On the Israel issue, no serious Jewish voice or organisation has ever said it’s racist to criticise the country. This is a complete strawman. I criticise Netanyahu’s policies regularly and know many Jews and Israelis who do so too.
The issue is about four things.
1) Traditional European antisemitism flooding back into Labour, illustrated by the east London “Freedom for Humanity” mural that Corbyn defended, and which perpetuated ideas about Jewish world domination.
2) Holding Israel’s Jews to a higher standard than the rest of the world.
3) An obsessive focus on Israel for errors that are far worse elsewhere.
4) Supporting or otherwise praising genocidal, Jew-murdering terrorist groups.
There are numerous examples of all four of these, and plenty of evidence to be found.
People like Baroness Warsi totally miss the point. The Tory peer seems to have made a career of late deflecting the anti-Semitism issue in Labour by attacking her own party instead over “Islamophobia” (sic).
Yet Boris Johnson, or any rogue Tory MP or member, can and do say racist or borderline racist things, but does the party with a Muslim-origin Chancellor really discriminate against Muslims institutionally? Does it then double down and deny its racism?
This Muslim believes not, and I have never voted Tory in my life, and will not do so this time either. There are problems in the Conservative Party, yes. I disagree with them, yes. But they are yet to meet the test of being institutionally anti-Muslim.
The comparison of Tory anti-Muslim bigotry would only be appropriate if Boris Johnson had called the Neo-Nazi Christchurch killer his “friend” and had taken money, personally, from a state that funded that killer.
If Johnson, Jo Swinson, or anyone other party leader, let alone individual MPs, had shared a panel in Parliament with members of the now banned terrorist group National Action, almost all of us would be disgusted by now.
Yet Corbyn not only shared platforms with Jew-killing Hezbollah and Hamas terrorists, he not only called them friends, but took anything up to £20,000 from their sponsor, the Holocaust-denying theocratic dictatorship of Iran. Now…imagine you’re Jewish, and then imagine Corbyn in No.10 as PM. Precisely
Until the day that Boris Johnson flirts with actual Muslim-killing terrorists it’s disgusting to draw such analogies, because they are deeply insensitive to our Jewish friends. What’s also disgustingly insensitive is to compare any policy of the Israeli state with a terror group
Truth is, there is only one major political party right now that has had senior former cabinet members resign over this alleged institutional racism. There is only one party that is being investigated by the Equalities and Human Rights Commission over said racism. That party is Labour.
After the Holocaust, we vowed in Europe Never Again — then Bosnia happened. Europe is not immune to repeat offending. We must never be too arrogant to think we are. Brexit or Remain, we do have choices other than Labour. We must not betray our Jewish cousins over a tribal vote
After all this, if we still choose Labour, at least let’s stop pretending we are “progressives”, or that we care about racism and minorities or that we “listen to victims when they tell us we’re hurting them”. It’s all BS.
Just admit that you really don’t give a damn about Jews.
Join the discussion
Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber
To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.
Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.
SubscribeOK, you are invited to the party Mr Brown ( tongue ).
1) Traditional European antisemitism flooding back into Labour, illustrated by the east London “Freedom for Humanity” mural that Corbyn defended, and which perpetuated ideas about Jewish world domination.
This incident actually disproves the antisemitism allegation. Corbyn endorsed a mural whose message was that a global capitalist class is exploiting the rest of us. It had to *pointed out to him* that one of the characters had a hook nose, and that could be interpreted as antisemitic. That is, in glimpsing the mural, Corbyn did not even notice that feature, and if he did, he did not in *his* mind make the connection: hook-nose = Jew.
But the people making the antisemitism accusation *did* make that connection; so, if anything, the accusers might be the antisemitic ones.
2) Holding Israel’s Jews to a higher standard than the rest of the world.
3) An obsessive focus on Israel for errors that are far worse elsewhere.
Those two are ‘whataboutery’: ‘Why point the finger at Jews/Israel when that country over there is behaving even worse.’
4) Supporting or otherwise praising genocidal, Jew-murdering terrorist groups.
Some quotes would be helpful. (Even Tony Blair has in the past suggested that we should negotiate with Hamas.
1) Traditional European antisemitism flooding back into Labour, illustrated by the east London “Freedom for Humanity” mural that Corbyn defended, and which perpetuated ideas about Jewish world domination.
This incident actually disproves the antisemitism allegation. Corbyn endorsed a mural whose message was that a global capitalist class is exploiting the rest of us. It had to *pointed out to him* that one of the characters had a hook nose, and that could be interpreted as antisemitic. That is, in glimpsing the mural, Corbyn did not even notice that feature, and if he did, he did not in *his* mind make the connection: hook-nose = Jew.
But the people making the antisemitism accusation *did* make that connection; so, if anything, the accusers might be the antisemitic ones.
2) Holding Israel’s Jews to a higher standard than the rest of the world.
3) An obsessive focus on Israel for errors that are far worse elsewhere.
Those two are ‘whataboutery’: ‘Why point the finger at Israel when that country over there is behaving even worse.’
4) Supporting or otherwise praising genocidal, Jew-murdering terrorist groups.
Some quotes would be helpful. Even Tony Blair has in the past suggested that we should negotiate with Hamas.