by John Milbank
Saturday, 10
April 2021
Reaction
07:00

Prince Philip’s Socratic sense of duty

His chivalric devotion to the Queen became his main task in life
by John Milbank
His chivalric devotion to the Queen became his main task in life

The death of a monarch always comes as a shock because the Crown is haloed with immortality. When the present Queen dies it will be a double shock, because her long reign is coterminous with the lives of so many. But it is a tribute to Prince Philip that his death today comes as nearly as great a shock. He is inseparable from the Queen in our minds and it is poignant to think of her left old and alone in her echoing palaces.

We ourselves are left with the sense of the beginning of the passing of an era. And Prince Philip would seem to represent in an acute form the best of the values of that era, which in many ways jar with today’s.

At the core of those values was an attempt to transform and yet maintain much older inherited traditions and attitudes.

For Philip was the lost scion of a European dynastic network. As such he retained a fundamentally international outlook, but one which fully recognised that humanity can only be nurtured in specifically national and religious identities.

For this reason he remained unbounded within a tightly bounded circumstance. Although he fully accepted the limitations of public service, he did not see this as any reason for passive self-abnegation, but actively, if ironically, identified with his potentially undignified role. It is this bold and humorous embrace of fated restriction which many now find irksome: one is no longer supposed to mix public performance with private self-expression in quite this manner.

Yet such a mix is authentically Socratic: the proof that the doing of one’s duty can also be the way of self-fulfilment. The Duke’s sacrifice of career to romance and ceremonial office is all the more impressive for his not hiding some annoyance. The combination of his restless temperament and his deeply felt devotion to duty found fruitful expression; for instance, in the creation of the Duke of Edinburgh Award scheme, the work of Saint George’s House Windsor, and in catalysing the engagement of the great religions with contemporary environmentalism.

Above all he developed a way to be male that was both traditional and modern. He served one woman with chivalric devotion as his main task in life while fulfilling his public engagements in a bold and active spirit. He eventually embraced the opportunity to read and contemplate more. And yet, he remained loyal to the imperatives of his mentor Kurt Hahn in seeking to combine imagination with action and religious devotion with practical involvement.

Prince Philip took more pride in the roles he had accidentally inherited than in the personal gifts which he was never able fully to develop. He put companionship before self-realisation and acceptance of a sacred symbolic destiny before the mere influencing of events. In all these respects he implicitly rebuked our prevailing meritocracy which over-values officially accredited attainment, and our prevailing narcissism which valorises the assertion of discrete identities.

Now he has passed out of this life, our times need to heed his example more than ever.

Join the discussion


To join the discussion, get the free daily email and read more articles like this, sign up.

It's simple, quick and free.

Sign me up
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
10 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Claire D
Claire D
1 year ago

What a profound and insightful article, thank you.

Cynthia Neville
Cynthia Neville
1 year ago

I’m with Claire D on this. Wonderful piece, and so refreshing to read. Ferrusian’s comment should be deleted.

A Spetzari
A Spetzari
1 year ago

Not deleted. Left to be hanged on its own merit.

Chris Milburn
Chris Milburn
1 year ago

I agree with Spetzari – let his comment stand there so everyone knows what an idiot he is (note the downvotes!)

Ian Barton
Ian Barton
1 year ago

I had previously thought that KBO stood for “Kindly Bugg** Off’.
Either way, it’s good advice for the “snowflakes”

Last edited 1 year ago by Ian Barton
LCarey Rowland
LCarey Rowland
1 year ago

He were a very parfait gentil knight.

Ferrusian Gambit
Ferrusian Gambit
1 year ago

If this jeremiad against developing personal gifts was from someone who had worked in a factory all their life, or was a monk who had made vows of poverty it might command more respect from me. But we’re talking of a man with numerous degrees and a cushy academic job so pull the other one.

Lou Campbell
Lou Campbell
1 year ago

Did you need to be snotty?

Weyland Smith
Weyland Smith
1 year ago

Please read the article on p17 of today’s DailyTelegraph recounting a few things he did in his early twenties, then pop back and tell us what you’ve done.

Fennie Strange
Fennie Strange
1 year ago

Are you referring to John Millbank or to HRH Prince Philip?