by John Lichfield
Thursday, 6
May 2021
Explainer
16:00

Don’t believe the hype: there is no ‘cod war’ in Jersey

The British press is, once again, getting carried away
by John Lichfield

Don’t believe the British press. This is not a new cod war. It is a whelk war. Lobsters, whelks and scallops are the species mostly fished by French boats in the waters around the Isle of Jersey. 

To begin to understand the storm which has suddenly blown up in the Gulf of Saint Malo, you need to ask a basic question: why are the French threatening to cut off electricity to Jersey but not to Guernsey or the other Channel Islands? 

“The answer is quite simple,” said one senior French regional official. “We have very correct and friendly relations with Guernsey. They play by the friendly rules which have governed relations between Channel Islands and France for centuries. Not on Jersey. There is a new group of leaders there who are fiercely nationalistic and hostile to France.”

“They have dishonestly and unilaterally — and we believe illegally — imposed restrictions on French boats that were not raised during the talks on how fishing here should be organised post-Brexit.”

For centuries, fishing rights around the Channel Islands were governed by bilateral deals between France and the islands. The “Iles Anglo Normandes” are the last part of Duke William’s fiefdom. They are not part of the UK and were never part of the European Union.

But, surprise, surprise, it was agreed on 24 December in the last-minute dash for a post-Brexit trade deal that the islands’12-mile zones would be included in arrangements for continuing access by EU boats to all UK waters. Where deals used to be made locally, everything now had to go through, London, Paris and Brussels.

French and other EU boats could continue to fish up to six miles from the English coast and up to three miles in places around the Channel Islands. Licences would be granted to those boats which had regularly fished those waters in recent years.

This proved complicated to organise (especially with Paris, London and Brussels involved). Boats under 12 metres long don’t have satellite gear to leave a trace of where they have fished. Guernsey agreed to roll over access until June while negotiations continued.

Jersey did the same for small boats but issued licences for 41 bigger French boats, with 17 others pending. When the licences appeared last Friday, they were shot through with unexpected restrictions. Some boats got 170 days of fishing; others a few hours. Boats which fished lobsters were licensed for whelks. Some waters were excluded. 

The reaction of the French government — threatening to switch off the 90% of Jersey electricity which comes by cable from Normandy — was vastly over the top. Regional elections are six weeks away; presidential elections 11 months away.

The reaction of the Norman and Breton fishermen — organising a protest flotilla to St Helier — was perfectly normal, for French fishermen.

What happens now? With goodwill, all could be solved in an afternoon. The Jersey government appears shocked by the way things have spiralled out of hand. 

But French fishermen’s leaders fear that Boris Johnson’s government is too intoxicated by the stick-it-to-the-French headlines in the UK press to seek an early calming of the waters.

Join the discussion


  • BoJo needs to tread water carefully, Les Malouines was the original name of the Falklands after their discovery by St Malo seafarers and having been mistaken for English tourists in a St Malo bar many years ago during the battle for the Malvinas the name Thatcher and L’Exocet were muttered loudly for us to hear to the embarrassment of the Patron .

    There is a growing tension in France against Macron over extreme acts by Islamic groups including the beheading of a teacher and the burning of another Catholic Church…France is one of the oldest Catholic Churches in Christendom, and there are many retired military who are watching Macron with great anxiety to see if he has the bottle for the battle…I wouldn’t risk a war over a few whelks !
    Besides and possibly of greater import, Britain has dispatched an Aircraft carrier to the South China sea and needs to act carefully and consistently so that the CCP cannot find excuses for their oft repeated designs on Taiwan

  • Back in 1993 under perhaps the feeblest PM since records began there was a very similar humiliating incident that received very little coverage at the time.

    A confrontation with French fishermen led to the capture of our Patrol Boat,
    H.M.S. Blazer.*. Her crew were confined below decks, she was towed into Cherbourg harbour in triumph and her White Ensign ceremonially burnt!
    The intervention of the French Navy finally secured her release.

    How Nelson,Hawke,Rodney and others too numerous to mention must have “rolled in their graves”!

    Let us hope History is not about to repeat itself.

    (* the eponymous Jacket, beloved of Cricket Clubs etc, takes its name from a previous H.M.S. Blazer)

  • Thanks for this analysis of the fishing dispute in Jersey, I only wish our broadcast media offered such clarity.

  • To get involved in the discussion and stay up to date, become a registered user.

    It's simple, quick and free.

    Sign me up