by UnHerd
Friday, 7
May 2021
Seen Elsewhere
07:00

Did Covid-19 come from a lab?

A former NYT reporter makes a compelling case...
by UnHerd

A good piece of journalism might be worth five or ten minutes of your time. However, this, by Nicholas Wade, is worth at least an hour.

You’ll need that long to read the thing — and to absorb the detail. However, it’s worth the effort because it concerns one of the most important and controversial questions of the decade: where did the Covid-19 virus come from?

You may not have an hour, so here, in a nutshell, is Wade’s argument: the theory that the virus was cooked-up in a lab and accidentally released isn’t just a possibility, it’s the most likely explanation.

Of course, as yet, there’s no definitive proof of either a natural origin or a lab leak. However, the evidence that we do have leans towards the latter. 

Early on in the crisis, a number of prominent virologists tried to dismiss the notion of a laboratory origin. Wade exposes the gaping holes in their arguments — and attacks the anti-scientific arrogance of shutting down a reasonable line of enquiry. 

Occam’s Razor is often invoked in this debate. Basically, it states that the simplest explanations are most likely to be true — or at least those that rely on the fewest untested assumptions. 

Applying this rule of thumb to the SARS-CoV-2 question might favour the natural origin hypothesis. After all, there are documented cases of similar viruses arising in animal populations and spreading to humans. If it’s a simple explanation we’re after, then that’s one right there.

Then again, the pandemic started in Wuhan — a city that hosts a world famous scientific institute that conducts research into coronaviruses. There’s a long history of accidental releases of deadly organisms from laboratories — so this too could be seen as a simple explanation.

To determine whether these explanations really are simple you have to look at the details. For instance, the precise pattern by which the virus spread through the host populations — or its precise genetic makeup. 

What’s so compelling about Wade’s deep-dive is that he shows how the key details are easier to explain within the context of a lab leak origin. He doesn’t claim that they definitively rule out a natural origin — just that it’s more of a stretch to get all the pieces to fit together.

But what about the missing pieces of evidence required to actually prove either hypothesis? For instance, if the original form of SARS-CoV-2 is hanging out in some wild animal population, then where are these creatures? No such organism has been discovered.

On the other hand, where are the lab records that show that the particular experiments required to create SARS-CoV-2 were ever conducted? Or that a breach of containment might have taken place at the same time? These things haven’t come to light either. 

Of course, with missing links we need to ask why they’re missing. In regard to a natural origin, the Chinese government has the means and motive to find the necessary evidence — should it exist. In regard to a laboratory origin… well, need one spell it out? 

Join the discussion


  • I was saying from the beginning that it is mathematically so small probability for the virus to emerge spontaneously at the same place where it is cultivated in the lab that it should be considered impossible. Of all the places on Earth it emerged spontaneously in one of the few where there is a lab that conducts experiments with the same sort of the virus.. Come on!

  • Why the left were so keen to discredit the lab leak theory is a very important question.

  • Absolutely spot on! And rather like the killing of Ms Ashli Babbitt it will remain unpunished as long as the US is under the control of its current’Mafia’.

    The obvious expletive to describe Fauci must be F****r Fauci? F is an unfortunate letter in English for a surname, I suggest he change it to something urbane like Capone for example.

  • To get involved in the discussion and stay up to date, become a registered user.

    It's simple, quick and free.

    Sign me up