by UnHerd
Monday, 19
July 2021

China’s most famous novelist is compromised

Liu Cixin joins a company that spies on the country's Uyghur population
by UnHerd
Liu Cixin

Liu Cixin may be most important science fiction writer alive today. His trilogy Remembrance of Earth’s Past has been translated into twenty languages and sold eight million copies worldwide. It’s first volume, The Three Body Problem, will be adapted for Netflix by the showrunners behind Game of Thrones. 

Cixin’s fans include Barack Obama, Mark Zuckerberg, former Chinese Vice President Li Yuanchao, and the London Review of Books. It described his trilogy as “one of the most ambitious works of science fiction ever written.”

Like what you’re reading? Get the free UnHerd daily email

Already registered? Sign in

On July 11th, Chinese state-media outlet The Global Times reported that the author had joined the AI company SenseTime as director of the “Science Fiction Planet Research Center.”

Cixin told the World Artificial Intelligence Conference in Shanghai that he hoped to collaborate with SenseTime on new immersive worlds. Users would soon be able to “experience the vastness of the universe, the insignificance of human beings, and the infinite possibilities in the future”, he said. 

SenseTime does not just make games. It is also one of several firms involved in developing surveillance technology to help the Chinese government track and control the Uyghur population around Xinjiang, and elsewhere in China

According to the New York Times, SenseTime, along with four other companies, is the first to use to explicitly use this technology for racial profiling. As many as two million Uyghurs are currently detained in forced labour camps and re-education centres in Xinjiang.

Cixin lives in China and is a supporter of the Communist Party. He was asked about the Uyghurs in a 2019 New Yorker profile. Cixin’s defence of Chinese government policy followed the party line:

“Would you rather that they be hacking away at bodies at train stations and schools in terrorist attacks? If anything, the government is helping their economy and trying to lift them out of poverty… I know what you are thinking — ‘What about individual liberty and freedom of governance?’ But that’s not what Chinese people care about. For ordinary folks, it’s the cost of health care, real-estate prices, their children’s education.”
- Liu Cixin, 2019

André Gide once said that every good writer ought to navigate against the current. Cixin is a great writer, but he is clearly willing — or feels obligated —  to swim with the tide. In the context of his comments to The New Yorker, his work with SenseTime comes as little surprise.

Cixin’s importance operates at two levels. There is the sheer imaginative brilliance of the Remembrance of Earth’s Past Trilogywhich takes place over the course of 18 million years, and details a brutal, Hobbesian struggle between humanity and a technologically advanced alien race.

Then there is Cixin as a representative of China at this moment in its history. Just as H.G. Wells’ science fiction probed deep anxieties in Britain at at time of unprecedented scientific change, Cixin writes speculative fiction as China expands and advances as a 21st century superpower.

Wells, like many progressives in Britain at the turn of the last century, looked forward to the inevitable arrival of a  rational World State ruled by an elite caste of scientists and engineers. Cixin has no such vision. In his novels, kindness gets characters killed, idealism is a luxury, and realpolitik is the only sane approach to geopolitical conflict. Unlike Wells, who also wrote fine social comedies, Cixin’s views human beings as they interact in systems and institutions. It is a cold view.

It would be easy to draw a line from the bleak outlook of Cixin’s fiction to his decision to work for a company that is involved in what is being described as a genocide. “In a time of war”, says one of his characters, “we can’t afford to be too scrupulous.” Cixin doesn’t appear to have many scruples about Xinjiang.

Then again, the pressures Cixin may be under as the most celebrated writer in a totalitarian society are not known. They can be guessed at though. Consider what he wrote in the afterword to the English edition of The Three Body Problem:

“I cannot escape and leave behind reality, just like I cannot leave behind my shadow. Reality brands each of us with its indelible mark. Every era puts invisible shackles on those who have lived through it, and I can only dance in my chains.”
- Liu Cixin

H.G. Wells was not bound by ‘invisible shackles’ like Liu Cixin.

Join the discussion

To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Notify of
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Galeti Tavas
Galeti Tavas
1 year ago

This is the mindset which is being given the world to exploit, by us greedy and cowardly Westerners. People think the response to covid was a great inconvenience, and will take some budgeting to pay back before full growth pushes us to greater prosperity.

No, to ‘save granny’ it is likely the West has lost the war by destroying our economy, paying people at home wages to not work, and then buying all the goods and services not produced with borrowed money from Chinese workers – who never stopped production for such a thing as covid.

It is almost certain the covid response by the West will result in magnitudes more misery than if we just used common sense and kept going. The politicos who ran this all act as we just sacrificed to do the right thing, it is very possible we sold our nation’s and children’s future as well. By 2023 we will know if we just committed the greatest act of self harm a people have ever done to themselves. It may all be fine, but I am not very confident.

Jonathan Ellman
Jonathan Ellman
1 year ago

He’s brilliant. I won’t judge.

Francis MacGabhann
Francis MacGabhann
1 year ago

Why not? That’s what judgement is for.

Natasha Felicia
Natasha Felicia
1 year ago

So being a great intellect means you get to be immoral? Sounds horrifying.