X Close

Just how authentic is Taylor Swift?

Taylor: 'As long as you stay true to yourself, that's enough'. Credit: Getty

December 1, 2023 - 6:00pm

Few people have ever taken being “real” as seriously as Richey Edwards of the Manic Street Preachers. In 1991, Edwards was being interviewed by journalist Steve Lamacq who — being interested in authenticity at the time — asked the band if their “slogans and gesturing and glam rock look” undermined their art. In response, Edwards carved “4 REAL” into his left forearm with a razor blade.

Taylor Swift is unlikely to ever do the same. But she’s the inspiration for American dictionary Merriam-Webster naming “authentic as their word of 2023. Swift is one of the celebrities, says the dictionary, who “made headlines in 2023 with statements about seeking their “authentic voice” and “authentic self’”. 

The singer-songwriter has been steadily re-recording her back catalogue in order to wrest back control of her songs’ masters, with the new editions identified by a parenthesis in the title: “(Taylor’s Version)”. It’s hard to imagine that these re-releases would have been so commercially and critically successful without the importance that we put on authenticity. By being blessed by her, Taylor’s new versions become more valuable than the near-identical originals.

Merriam-Webster also cites technology for their 2023 “authentic” choice because AI-generated photos, videos and audio which seem real but aren’t are rife online. The Pope posed in a white Balenciaga puffer jacket and Sadiq Khan declared “I don’t give a flying shit about the Remembrance weekend.” Neither actually happened, but many people believed the bogus evidence. Why? Because it seemed truthful. The Pope wears cool clothes why not a puffer jacket? Sadiq Khan, according to some on the Right, hates Britain’s heritage why wouldn’t he slag off Remembrance weekend?

Merriam-Webster defines authentic as “not false or imitation”; a synonym of “real” and “actual”; and “true to one’s own personality, spirit, or character”. That last definition is less about truth than about “truthiness” — coined by Stephen Colbert in 2005 to denote a kind of truth that’s as much in the eye of the beholder as in objective reality. It gets at an old idea that art is the best route to the deepest truths. In his 16th-century essay The Defence of Poesy, Philip Sidney made a case for the superiority of poetry to history and philosophy. History was “captive to the truth of a foolish world”, and philosophy was too abstract, he said. But poetry could convey meaning by describing the world “as it should be”.

Our modern notion of authenticity owes much more to truthiness than truth. People insist on their own reality, and sometimes it pays off. In 1991, a few months after Edwards got to work with his razor blade, Caroline Calloway was born in Virginia. She became an icon of our age of scammers: faking her academic transcript to get into Cambridge University, building a Gatsby-esque brand by throwing parties in photogenic hired rooms, signing and then withdrawing from a six-figure book deal, selling literal snake oil on her website, then finally releasing a (quite well-received) book this year called Scammer. The lies eventually became the product: if you can’t fake it until you make it, turn faking it into making it.

And why not? The custodians of apparent objective truths notably, the neoliberal economists who insisted that there was no alternative system have been revealed to be just as hopelessly subjective as the rest of us. Political authenticity is now judged by “vibes” truthiness rather than policy, hence why dedicated Swiftie Liz Truss won her short-lived Downing Street residency. Being real is overrated: authenticity these days is in vibes, not truth.


Josiah Gogarty is assistant editor at The Knowledge, an email news digest, and a freelance writer elsewhere.

josiahgogarty

Join the discussion


Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber


To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Subscribe
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

16 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Lesley van Reenen
Lesley van Reenen
11 months ago

She is the fakest of the fake.

Sharon Overy
Sharon Overy
11 months ago

How so? She writes her own songs, sings on the recordings and at live shows.
Or is there some discrepancy between her public and private persona that you refer to?

Lesley van Reenen
Lesley van Reenen
11 months ago
Reply to  Sharon Overy

The second. Just such constant studied and curated photo ops. Travelling the world in her private jet for a party. Besides the Joe guy, inability to have a mature romantic relationship that is authentic. But she sure moves through the guys. Sick to death of seeing her all over the internet. People fawn all over these celebrities and she is one of the least attractive to me.

Last edited 11 months ago by Lesley van Reenen
Dominic A
Dominic A
11 months ago

She’s an authentic all-singing all-dancing one woman worldwide entertainment product.

UnHerd Reader
UnHerd Reader
11 months ago
Reply to  Dominic A

She famously doesn’t dance, probably because she’s a writer and a musician.

Dominic A
Dominic A
11 months ago
Reply to  UnHerd Reader

It’s an expression, a turn of phrase, meaning ‘does it all’.

Last edited 11 months ago by Dominic A
Kitty Thomas
Kitty Thomas
11 months ago
Reply to  Dominic A

Product being the essential word in the descriptor.

Dominic A
Dominic A
11 months ago
Reply to  Kitty Thomas

Indeed – As Archie Leach was well (self)aware: “everybody wants to be Cary Grant; even I want to be Cary Grant”.

David Lindsay
David Lindsay
11 months ago

Omid Scobie’s reliability may be deduced from his assertion that King Charles III invited Taylor Swift to perform at the Coronation, but she declined.

Steve Murray
Steve Murray
11 months ago

Anyone who needs to inscribe 4REAL into their flesh with a razorblade is play-acting… or is that the point?

John Riordan
John Riordan
11 months ago

Sometimes I read one of these articles and can’t work out why any of it matters. This is one of those times.

Andrew R
Andrew R
11 months ago

Not very

Champagne Socialist
Champagne Socialist
11 months ago

The Unherd misanthropes come for Taylor Swift. No great surprise.
Let the 2 minutes hate commence!

Dominic A
Dominic A
11 months ago

All part of a long proud British tradition of deflating the overinflated – a tradition you hold up very well on these pages!

Lesley van Reenen
Lesley van Reenen
11 months ago

24 hours and still going.

Andrew R
Andrew R
11 months ago

So glad that you have finally embraced unfettered capitalism that Tyler and her peers represent, with such concepts as dynamic ticket pricing.