It is Russian land. It always was.It is Russias most vulnerability area because it is flat with no natural.barriers like mountains or rivers. And it’s peopled by ….Ukranians oh yuk.
Well, quite…there’s the ignorance, the misunderstanding of ‘humanitarian idea’, the comb-over… the FT could more usefully interview Matthew McConaughy’s goldfish.
jane baker
3 months ago
I’m glad a “famous person’ even though I don’t know a thing about him has said exactly what I feel. I do not care about Ukraine one jot. This so called War is fomented by USA in order to take over ALL the territory of Russia and own all the rich resources.
Who-the-heck: a typical French literary attention seeker.
B Emery
3 months ago
“What do I care?” he responded when told that Ukrainians want to liberate their own territory. “At the start of the war, I was surprised because I thought Ukraine was Russian. It’s better for nature to take its course.”
The bleakest ignorance.
‘People who have humanitarian ideas are a catastrophe’
Some of those people put their life on the line to protect your national security and freedoms.
What a d*ck.
To some degree he’s right, Humanitarians are always calling on us to fight oppression wherever it appears. It never ends for them because they think we should fight every battle on every front. I’m not really aware of humanitarians putting their life on the line to protect our security and freedoms. How do you mean that?
Humanitarian means relating to the value of human life, and the practice of helping others to improve their lives and reduce suffering. It can also refer to:
Humanitarian aid
Short-term material and logistic assistance given to people in need, such as refugees, the homeless, and victims of natural disasters, wars, and famines. The goal of humanitarian aid is to save lives, alleviate suffering, and maintain human dignity.
Humanitarian careers
Jobs that work on global issues, such as food and water shortages, malnutrition, environmental disasters, political unrest, and health care emergencies. Humanitarians can be volunteers or paid employees.
Digital humanitarians
People who use social media to map areas in need of support. For example, during the 2010 Russian forest fires, Russian bloggers used social media to coordinate relief efforts after the Russian government was unprepared to deal with the disaster
So I understand what you are saying, too much humanitarian utopian type thinking can be too much and go too far, ending up in the rise of the nanny police states, however people that work in state sectors like the police, army, security sectors are humanitarians of sorts and the institutions they work in come from humanitarian ideas, ie they are concerned with protecting human life and improving living conditions. If you believe all humanitarian ideas are a catastrophe then you can say goodbye to the rule of law, state education, state healthcare, an army to protect your country and police to protect your property and person. These people do put their lives on the line and do these jobs to protect other people, as far as I know, this is a form of humanitarianism.
You’re not? How about WW2? How about the Berlin airlift? How about post WW2 with the Soviet Union slowly swallowing up as much of Europe as it could? The only thing that prevented all of Europe from becoming soviet states was the ‘humanitarianism’ (or whatever one wants to call it) of the US.
Of course, that’s all old news. It’ll never happen again. Europe and Russia are over that kind of silliness.
The USSR controlled only what had been agreed at Yalta as being in its control. It had no plans to take Western Europe, and couldn’t even if it had wanted to, let alone hold it.
The USSR was utterly devastated. It had a huge army but its economy was in ruins and had lost twenty million people. Furthermore it didn’t even support the Greek Communists in their attempts to take over the country.
Regrettably the reality is that the USSR was a “paper tiger”, as Mao would have it, in comparison to the Western Allies, as led by the colossally wealthy USA. The real surprise is that it actually lasted so long given its utterly ineffective economic system.
The Greeks, Italians, Austrians, Koreans and Vietnamwse, as well as Cubans might dare to disagree.
Derek Smith
3 months ago
“DiAngelo has come out with a statement explaining how the Daily Wire spent thousands of dollars duping her into the interview, and said the documentary was “designed to humiliate and discredit anti-racist educators and activists”.”
Well someone had to do it. ‘Robbin de Anglo’ and her fellows need all the discrediting they can get.
Tyler Durden
3 months ago
Good man (MH). Personally, I patently don’t like the Ukraine; all those nationalists collaborated with the N-zis during the war and significant numbers of concentration camps were built in their terroritory.
Matt Walsh is brilliant and his comedic timing is spot on. If his new film is anything like “What is a Woman” then I can’t wait to see it. Would UnHerd host a screening?
UnHerd Reader
3 months ago
Geography and history seems to have avoided him, otherwise he would recognise that one can cause a war without starting one.Alas, yet another cultural heavyweight seemingly out of his league when he leaves his sphere.
Martin M
3 months ago
Houellebecq is French. It is no surprise that he doesn’t care about Russia invading Ukraine. The French barely cared when Germany invaded France (not enough to put up a credible fight anyway).
Main Edition
US
FR
Join the discussion
Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber
To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.
Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.
SubscribeSo-called anti-racists really are stupid woke munters.
Why should anyone care about Houllebeq?
The so-called “thinker” sounds like a creep.
because he’s funny
At least he is honest about his own illiteracy
“At the start of the war, I was surprised because I thought Ukraine was Russian.”
It is Russian land. It always was.It is Russias most vulnerability area because it is flat with no natural.barriers like mountains or rivers. And it’s peopled by ….Ukranians oh yuk.
deleted
You are absolute idiot.
You cared enough to comment
There is literally nothing too trivial for him to comment on
But he is still saying what most “ordinary’ people think.
Well, quite…there’s the ignorance, the misunderstanding of ‘humanitarian idea’, the comb-over… the FT could more usefully interview Matthew McConaughy’s goldfish.
I’m glad a “famous person’ even though I don’t know a thing about him has said exactly what I feel. I do not care about Ukraine one jot. This so called War is fomented by USA in order to take over ALL the territory of Russia and own all the rich resources.
Fool
Who-the-heck: a typical French literary attention seeker.
“What do I care?” he responded when told that Ukrainians want to liberate their own territory. “At the start of the war, I was surprised because I thought Ukraine was Russian. It’s better for nature to take its course.”
The bleakest ignorance.
‘People who have humanitarian ideas are a catastrophe’
Some of those people put their life on the line to protect your national security and freedoms.
What a d*ck.
To some degree he’s right, Humanitarians are always calling on us to fight oppression wherever it appears. It never ends for them because they think we should fight every battle on every front. I’m not really aware of humanitarians putting their life on the line to protect our security and freedoms. How do you mean that?
From Google:
Humanitarian means relating to the value of human life, and the practice of helping others to improve their lives and reduce suffering. It can also refer to:
Humanitarian aid
Short-term material and logistic assistance given to people in need, such as refugees, the homeless, and victims of natural disasters, wars, and famines. The goal of humanitarian aid is to save lives, alleviate suffering, and maintain human dignity.
Humanitarian careers
Jobs that work on global issues, such as food and water shortages, malnutrition, environmental disasters, political unrest, and health care emergencies. Humanitarians can be volunteers or paid employees.
Digital humanitarians
People who use social media to map areas in need of support. For example, during the 2010 Russian forest fires, Russian bloggers used social media to coordinate relief efforts after the Russian government was unprepared to deal with the disaster
So I understand what you are saying, too much humanitarian utopian type thinking can be too much and go too far, ending up in the rise of the nanny police states, however people that work in state sectors like the police, army, security sectors are humanitarians of sorts and the institutions they work in come from humanitarian ideas, ie they are concerned with protecting human life and improving living conditions. If you believe all humanitarian ideas are a catastrophe then you can say goodbye to the rule of law, state education, state healthcare, an army to protect your country and police to protect your property and person. These people do put their lives on the line and do these jobs to protect other people, as far as I know, this is a form of humanitarianism.
You’re not? How about WW2? How about the Berlin airlift? How about post WW2 with the Soviet Union slowly swallowing up as much of Europe as it could? The only thing that prevented all of Europe from becoming soviet states was the ‘humanitarianism’ (or whatever one wants to call it) of the US.
Of course, that’s all old news. It’ll never happen again. Europe and Russia are over that kind of silliness.
The USSR controlled only what had been agreed at Yalta as being in its control. It had no plans to take Western Europe, and couldn’t even if it had wanted to, let alone hold it.
The USSR was utterly devastated. It had a huge army but its economy was in ruins and had lost twenty million people. Furthermore it didn’t even support the Greek Communists in their attempts to take over the country.
Regrettably the reality is that the USSR was a “paper tiger”, as Mao would have it, in comparison to the Western Allies, as led by the colossally wealthy USA. The real surprise is that it actually lasted so long given its utterly ineffective economic system.
The Greeks, Italians, Austrians, Koreans and Vietnamwse, as well as Cubans might dare to disagree.
“DiAngelo has come out with a statement explaining how the Daily Wire spent thousands of dollars duping her into the interview, and said the documentary was “designed to humiliate and discredit anti-racist educators and activists”.”
Well someone had to do it. ‘Robbin de Anglo’ and her fellows need all the discrediting they can get.
Good man (MH). Personally, I patently don’t like the Ukraine; all those nationalists collaborated with the N-zis during the war and significant numbers of concentration camps were built in their terroritory.
Fool
Matt Walsh is brilliant and his comedic timing is spot on. If his new film is anything like “What is a Woman” then I can’t wait to see it. Would UnHerd host a screening?
Geography and history seems to have avoided him, otherwise he would recognise that one can cause a war without starting one.Alas, yet another cultural heavyweight seemingly out of his league when he leaves his sphere.
Houellebecq is French. It is no surprise that he doesn’t care about Russia invading Ukraine. The French barely cared when Germany invaded France (not enough to put up a credible fight anyway).