Nov 18 2026 - 2:00pm

When Times journalist Claire Cohen was 22, a well-known pop star in his late 30s romantically pursued her. In an article published last week — nearly two decades later — Cohen expresses some discomfort about the power dynamic caused by gaps in age and level of fame. In the end, nothing physical happened: by her account, he realized that she was too young for him and she slept in his spare room.

Cohen wrote about this story after watching the ITV documentary, in which several women recount alleged encounters with David Walliams that began when they were teenagers, including girls as young as 15. Despite the fact that there was no sexual encounter, Cohen describes a “pang of recognition” between her experience and those of Walliams’ accusers, and discomfort with the “power imbalance” of the situation. In a similar vein, it has been suggested that Russell Brand’s wife, Laura, is, if not quite a victim, then perhaps victim-ish.

But in what context, then, do we actually trust an adult woman to make her own decisions?

There are credible psychological arguments for treating our early twenties as a distinct developmental stage. In 2000, the psychologist Jeffrey Arnett coined the term “emerging adulthood” to describe the years from late teens through the twenties. He noted that the responsibilities most commonly associated with adulthood, such as marriage or parenthood, were increasingly being put off by people in this age group. Indeed, in 2018, researchers writing in The Lancet Child & Adolescent Health proposed extending adolescence to the age of 24, citing the delayed assumption of adult responsibilities.

But does any of that mean a 22-year-old woman cannot decide whom she wants to sleep with? As a psychotherapist, I think not. Indeed, I am more interested in why we are so quick to imagine a young woman as powerless. There is something specifically regressive about the infantilization of young women. A woman can hold down a job, pay her rent and make decisions about her future, yet apparently revert to being a bewildered teen when an older man takes an interest in her. If we insist that every encounter with a richer, older man renders a young woman powerless, what exactly are we saying about young women’s capacity to run their own lives?

Perhaps, it is easier to sympathize with someone we regard as childlike. A young woman who knows she is attractive and enjoys the opportunities this brings is a more unsettling figure. There is something familiar about granting women our approval only when they appear to be submissive, vulnerable, devoid of desire, ambition or calculation.

Few of us can really be sure of the rules anymore. Is a 22-year-old a fully-grown adult? And are other adults free to have sex with 22-year-olds so long as they give consent freely? Must we now create a power-balance spreadsheet before every sexual encounter?

A 22-year-old can be dazzled by a celebrity. So can a 42-year-old. A young woman might enjoy an older man’s money and connections while he enjoys her youth and beauty. These situations can involve vanity, ambition, selfishness and hurt feelings — but they are not immoral. Do we seriously have to examine everyone’s motives for each sexual encounter in order to ascertain the appropriateness of it? Must a young woman demonstrate her ability to be judicious before we agree that her decisions are her own?


Stella O’Malley is a psychotherapist and bestselling author. She is Founder-Director of Genspect, an international organisation that advocates for a healthy approach to sex and gender.

stellaomalley3