Shabana Mahmood yesterday launched an oddly veiled attack on the police for things they supposedly aren’t doing, but which the public thinks they are. At least, that’s the impression she gave: the Home Secretary’s comments were couched in so many layers of irony that one must be careful not to misrepresent her.
Speaking at the joint annual summit of the National Police Chiefs Council (NPCC) and the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners (APCC), Mahmood said that police forces must address “the corrosive and growing perception of two-tier policing”. She noted that “there have been examples of differential treatment and they have harmed policing, allowing people — often motivated actors — to whip up the idea that there is two-tier policing.”
It is just over two years since Mahmood’s former boss Keir Starmer described the concept of two-tier policing as “a non-issue”, adding that “there is policing without fear or favor — exactly as it should be.” The official Labour line was that accusations of police partiality were a far-Right “trope”, and that responsibility lay with unscrupulous media actors and a gullible public. But now, without quite disavowing the previous position, the Home Secretary has suggested that the police are responsible for providing the Right with ammunition that can be used against them.
Mahmood described the now-suspended Police Anti-Racism Commitment as “patently absurd” for telling officers that fair policing “does not mean treating everyone the same” and that they should not be colorblind. She said that “misguided attempts at course correction, where the pursuit of equality leads instead to differential treatment” had been “distortive” and undermined public confidence in the police, but also added that the notion of two-tier policing as put forward by Reform UK and other opponents was “utter, complete, ridiculous rubbish”.
Nowhere in Mahmood’s observations was there any analysis of why the British police — hitherto reckoned by many in Labour to be a somewhat reactionary bunch — might suddenly have embraced schemes like the Police Anti-Racism Commitment. Nor did she question why the public might have begun to perceive officers as biased against white people. Did the police leadership undergo some kind of personality change in the 2000s after experiencing a severe blow to the head, perhaps?
In truth, the modern British police are the creatures of Labour policy, and their transformation was totemic of New Labour’s mission to recast the British state in its own image. The 1999 Macpherson Report set the stage for a complete restructuring of the culture of policing. The subsequent suite of legislation — including the Race Relations (Amendment) Act 2000, the Police Reform Act 2002 and the Criminal Justice Act 2003 — instilled a culture of permanent vigilance in police forces regarding supposed discrimination. Detecting, opposing and safeguarding against racism became the primary obligation for those looking to move up through the ranks.
The Equality Act 2010, and the Public Sector Equality Duty which it created, was the previous Labour government’s last gift to British policing, and is directly responsible for wheezes such as the Police Anti-Racism Commitment. It can also be credited with the institutional growth of HR departments and “staff networks” in the police and the rest of the public sector. Naturally, 14 years of Conservative-led government saw this law preserved in political amber.
There is something vulgar about a Labour minister attacking the police for the inevitable manner in which they have been shaped by this decades-long political onslaught. However sensible her defenders in the press insist Mahmood is being behind the scenes, she is a member of a party and government that has perpetuated the ideology responsible for the changes in policing over the last 25 years, and which acts as the primary bulwark against removing the offending legislation.
Of course, there is much cowardice and weakness at senior levels in the police, as well as an institutional culture that forces good people out. But at its root, the rot is political and legislative. Officers know their careers are far safer if they err in the direction of things like the Police Anti-Racism Commitment, rather than genuine impartiality.






