Alan Milburn’s review of youth unemployment is published today — and the need is urgent. There are nearly one million 16- to 24-year-olds out of work, education or training in the UK. It is as much a moral failing as an economic one.
In his review, Milburn is set to recommend doubling the threshold for employer National Insurance (NI) from £5,000 to £10,000 for 21- to 24-year-olds, starting in retail and hospitality, but — worryingly — only when the Treasury feels “fiscal conditions allow” such a change. He also wants to replace Personal Independence Payments and the health element of Universal Credit for under-25s with a youth allowance paid at the same basic rate as UC. In return, there would be a legal guarantee of a job, training or help finding work. With carrot comes stick: turn down the offer and you could lose financial support.
The NI cut makes sense, but it’s an admission that Labour has made hiring young people more expensive. In April 2025, then-Chancellor Rachel Reeves raised the employer rate from 13.8% to 15% and cut the threshold from £9,100 to £5,000. On top of that, the national minimum wage rose this year to £10.85 for 18- to 20-year-olds and £12.71 for those aged 21 and over. Employers also face expensive rules on guaranteed hours and short-notice shifts. Since Labour came into office in 2024, the cost of hiring a 21-year-old has increased by 15%.
Milburn’s intervention does little to change this state of affairs. The job guarantee, for instance, has cause and effect the wrong way round. The Government is giving young people a legal entitlement without giving an employer a reason to take them on. And if the sums don’t add up, the taxpayer still has to pay the difference, whether the job is at the café or the council. Indeed, the proposed guarantee has been likened to councils’ obligations to find homeless people a bed.
Ministers are already expanding a scheme that does exactly that, offering eligible young UC claimants six months of fully funded work. A placement might give a young person crucial experience, but what happens in month seven if the employer still can’t afford to keep them due to high taxes and red tape?
Milburn’s review would do nothing to tame public spending. Despite pushing young people off benefits — and replacing this with yet another cost for the Government — he has said it will still take a decade for the benefits bill to come down. That suits Andy Burnham fine. He can spend the run-up to the next election talking about tough decisions while leaving voters to judge the savings sometime in the 2030s.
And yet the need for spending restraint is urgent: the Office for Budget Responsibility expects annual spending on health and disability benefits to rise from £90 billion this financial year to nearly £110 billion in 2030–31 — roughly the GDP of Bulgaria. How much more will the Treasury have to spend up front, and how much of Milburn’s plan depends on cuts that Labour MPs can still block?
A good gauge of how tough Burnham is willing to be will come after the first sob story about a young person losing their disability benefit lands on the BBC. The easiest thing for him to do when Labour backbench MPs inevitably get restless is to keep the jobs guarantee and quietly drop the cuts. The harder — and correct — course is to admit that it is his own party which made it more expensive for a young person to get a job in the first place. Labour is learning the hard way that you can’t tax Peter to hire Paul.






