Zohran Mamdani boldly announced on Friday that he will close Rikers Island — New York City’s huge centralized jail complex — by the end of 2032.
He omitted to mention that, under a 2019 law, Rikers was supposed to have closed already, replaced by four new jails built next to the county courthouses in Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn and the Bronx. Construction of these jails is underway, behind schedule and well over budget.
One major hitch in the plan to reorganize how the city imprisons people awaiting trial or serving sentences of a year or less is that the new, smaller jails will have a maximum capacity of between 3,300 and 4,100 inmates, whereas the average daily population of Rikers today is over 6,000. By state law, New York counties must have sufficient space to hold detainees, so the city will have to figure out a way to reduce its jail population significantly by the time it closes Rikers.
This discrepancy between tight jail capacity and the reality of New York’s carceral needs was observed in 2017 when the city began seriously pursuing this goal. Indeed, it was noted by critics that the real point of closing Rikers was to place a hard cap on the number of people who could ever be jailed, thus satisfying the loud demands of the growing “abolitionist” movement, which wants to eliminate jails, prisons, and even policing.
Addressing this question, Mamdani proposes a series of “evidence-based” reforms that he claims will reduce the city’s jailed population. These reforms include investments in mental-health treatment, community-based support to “reduce recidivism”, diversion programs for low-level offenders, and an improved online bail-payment system.
Cynics might question both the novelty and the effectiveness of such proposals. The city already spends untold billions on mental health services, with little to show for it so long as participation remains voluntary. There is no proven way to stop serial criminals reoffending other than locking them up. The courts already divert or simply overlook low-level offenses, while bail is imposed on almost no one awaiting trial except murder suspects.
Chief Administrative Judge of New York State Joseph Zayas spoke optimistically about shrinking the number of people in jail, noting: “I know that we can accomplish this because we reduced the population in Rikers Island to under 4,000 detained persons in 2019.” This reduction was achieved partly by decriminalizing a host of “minor” crimes, eliminating bail requirements for most offenses, and simply letting many people out under “supervised release”.
Zayas didn’t mention that, since 2019, major crime has risen by roughly 25%, with felony assaults up almost 48%, robberies 9% and reported rapes 19%. Murder, by contrast, is down. Nor did he mention that the jail population only fell below 4,000 in 2020, during the pandemic, rather than in 2019.
There appears to be a relationship between street crime and the number of people kept in jail, because incapacitation is the most effective form of crime prevention. The social determinants of crime have been studied extensively, and policing and the judiciary have tweaked and reformed their practices repeatedly, but there remains a stubborn level of serious crime that can’t be eliminated despite mayoral hand-waving.
Closing Rikers remains a priority for progressive administrations because of their ideological commitment to dismantling what they see as a carceral system rooted in class warfare and institutional racism. Imposing a hard cap on the number of people who can be imprisoned will, in their view, force society to recalibrate its tolerance for criminality and pave the way for more radical change.






