Joe Biden’s new memoir is mired in criticism for everyone but himself. Credit: Getty
Traditionally, presidential memoirs are the airport Sbarro pizza of nonfiction, so I didn’t expect Joe Biden’s Promise Me, America to be a literary feast. Still, this is the first one I’ve encountered that reads like it was authored by Autopen. Promise Me, America is bone dry, blows past 400 pages, and several of them are a glorified list of laws the 46th president signed, with the CHIPS and Science Act sharing space with something called the Working Dog Health and Welfare Act. (Good boys, all.) The rest is largely a cliché-fest: America is a beacon of freedom, democracy delivers, and, yes, good presidents are good.
Occasionally, though, the Autopen scrawls something that sounds unmistakably Joe. It usually involves somebody who hurt his feelings, and a lot of people hurt his feelings. He’s mad at Vladimir Putin, Benjamin Netanyahu, and, of course, Donald Trump, but also at Volodymyr Zelensky, who, we learn, could be a bit of a dick behind closed doors.
Biden is also cross with Nancy Pelosi, who said publicly that quitting the 2024 race was his decision while working the phones to peel off his delegates, and who told him that if he passed the torch, he’d go down as a modern George Washington. He’s angry with Chuck Schumer for driving out to his beach house in Rehoboth, Del., to tell him that his campaign was over. He’s mad at special counsel Robert Hur for noticing what everyone else could plainly see: that he was a “well-meaning elderly man with a poor memory.” The one person he seemingly isn’t mad at? Joe Biden.
Most politicians would be happy to leave him in his happy place, an old man nursing grudges while the country moves on. The exception, obviously, is Donald Trump, who blames his predecessor for so much that from here it looks like Biden Derangement Syndrome. On Sunday, Trump was blaming Biden for America’s air-traffic-control troubles, which means that, almost two years after leaving office, Sleepy Joe apparently remains awake enough to sabotage the nation’s airport infrastructure.
It’s almost as if there’s some age-old mystical bond between the two men, the kind you see in Batman and the Joker. Neither man would admit it, but they’re a lot alike — both a little Batman, and a little Joker. They’re two overachievers born in the 1940s, more than a little loose-tongued. Both run on personal loyalty and keep a tidy ledger of who comes up short. Both got caught with classified documents in their homes and drew a special counsel. Both took care of family with the pardon pen. Each is completely convinced that the country can’t manage without him. One interesting aside in Promise Me, America is that Biden was stunned when Trump told him, after the 2024 election, that if it weren’t for politics “we’d spend all our time golfing together.” I wasn’t stunned. They’re the Odd Couple: West Wing edition.
The resemblance goes past personality and into policy. Because for about two years — 2021 and 2022 — something resembling Blue MAGA actually existed. A decade ago, Trump’s MAGA promised a realignment: in forgotten places hollowed out by deindustrialization, America would make things again and stop accepting the freeist of free trade and the disappearance of good manufacturing jobs as the price of progress. Biden took much of that promise seriously but had the misfortune of selling it as Bidenomics.
The CHIPS Act and the Inflation Reduction Act promised to set off a factory-building boom, a lot of it in US counties that would sooner eat a Cybertruck than vote for a Democrat. The American Rescue Plan provided pandemic relief to households and public services. Its expanded child-tax credit helped push child poverty down to 5.2% in 2021.
Then, too, Biden kept Trump’s China tariffs and expanded them in the electric-vehicle sector, which makes it very funny that Promise Me, America spends a page explaining how badly Trump’s China tariffs failed. Biden, moreover, got out of Afghanistan on the deal that Trump had cut with the Taliban. Trump announced Infrastructure Week so many times it became a late-night talk-show punchline, and then Biden later made it happen to the tune of $1.2 trillion with the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. He put the anti-monopoly crusader Lina Khan in charge of antitrust and walked a United Auto Workers picket line, which no sitting commander in chief had ever done. He even kept Trump’s Title 42 immigration order in place until May 2023 and expelled more than 2 million people in America illegally.
If you’d been offline since 2016 and somebody read you that list, you’d likely assume Trump had delivered on his MAGA promises. He hasn’t, really. The second Trump term has delivered even more tariffs, but haphazardly so, as if fired from a Gatling gun. The administration has closed the border, but also delivered a tax cut tilted toward the rich, Medicaid cuts to help pay for it, a front row of tech billionaires at the inauguration, a Bush-style Iran war, and an expensive new White House ballroom. Ironically, Biden’s first year was more MAGA than MAGA turned out to be.
In his 2023 book, Ours Was the Shining Future, the New York Times writer David Leonhardt wrote wistfully for a neo-populism in which “social and cultural conservatism can be paired with government intervention in the economy to lift mass living standards.” In other words, go Left on economics and ease off the culture war. Biden did the first and never touched the second, which is tragic. Consider that this was a 78-year-old Irish Catholic from Scranton, Pa. — maybe the one Democrat alive with the standing to tell the party’s activist class to cool it, Jack — and he never tried. The memoir is candid about this, if not self-aware. He writes that he never supported defunding the police yet explains in the next breath that he made sure every bill he signed had racial justice built into it, from vaccine distribution to where he was replacing lead pipes.
Biden may not have insisted that everyone use the doomed term “Latinx” or insisted on Oval Office drag storytime hour. Still, his first executive order, signed on Inauguration Day, mandated that the entire federal government work on DEI. He promised a black woman for the Supreme Court during the South Carolina primary, before he had a name. His Education Department rewrote Title IX around gender identity. Some of this was inoffensive, but Biden never made a convincing case to the voters it put off, or seemed to notice there was any blowback.
He treated the whole 2010s woke package as something that came preinstalled as the Democratic Party’s updated operating system, and clicked “agree” without reading the terms. The irony is that he writes a whole section in his economics chapter on how Reagan-style trickle-down economics never worked, without asking whether the Democrats’ version, putting black faces in high places, ever trickled down to working-class black people. It didn’t, even eight years after the first black presidency.
Biden doesn’t admit this; he insists that all four years of his presidency were pretty terrific. But they weren’t, especially after Year One. He really should have pushed harder to reopen schools soon during the pandemic. Inflation hit 9.1% in June 2022. Biden admits his rescue plan accounted for part of that and pins the rest on Covid and Vladimir Putin; as a fan of that spending, I’d still give it more of the blame than he does. Then there’s Israel-Gaza, where Biden now writes that he carries the weight of dead Palestinians with him. (An odd thing to hear from the man who kept the aid and weapons flowing to Bibi, one paused shipment of heavy bombs aside). Through it all, he was getting visibly old in public while his staff told us we weren’t seeing what we were seeing — senescence.
That last part ultimately did him in, and it’s what the book can’t bring itself to examine seriously. He concedes that his flubbed line, “We finally beat Medicare,” became Exhibit A that he was too old for the job, and then spends pages and pages explaining why he was still the only man for it. By the end, a chapter covering the weeks between the debate and his withdrawal, the book has quietly changed its title from Promise Me, America to You Promised Me, America! It’s the most heartfelt stretch of the book, and yet the part that most makes you want to launch it into the Delaware Bay.
Few will notice. Two weeks ago, Democrats had their best midterm election in decades; they took both chambers of Congress, and have been passing out credit ever since. Barack Obama appeared at rallies and got the wise-elder treatment, and so did Bernie. The viral image of election week was a fake Vogue cover of the party’s stars — Zohran Mamdani, Abdul El-Sayed, Obama, Jon Ossoff — and even the AI that crafted it knew to leave out the 46th president. I have yet to see a single think piece thanking Biden, and nobody will be wheeling him out in 2027 to announce that it’s time to Build Back Better… Again.
That’s a little unfair. Affordability, the word every winning Democrat ran on this year, is a tidier name for what Biden was trying to do with his Diet New Deal in 2021. But the memoir also contains a scene that explains why Biden gets none of the credit. A week before the 2022 midterms, Bernie Sanders’s old campaign manager, Faiz Shakir, went on TV and urged him to scrap his big, high-minded “let’s-save-democracy” speech at Union Station and talk about the cost of living instead. Biden, by his own proud account, wasn’t deterred. Three years later, a 30-something democratic socialist running for mayor of New York took Shakir’s advice, and this month the Democratic Party followed him.
Biden draws none of these lessons in the epilogue of Promise Me, America, nor much of any lesson, really. To its credit, there are just enough folksy asides about grandpops, salt-of-the-earth folks from Scranton, and ambling Amtrak rides to distract from the fact that it reads like the longest-ever placard on the wall of the future Biden Presidential Library, one that hardly anyone seems interested in building.
Perhaps Trump will.



