Nov 21 2026 - 1:30pm

Can a nation-state define itself as the state of a particular nation while protecting the rights of minorities who do not belong to it? In the Israeli context, this question is usually framed as a simple one: can Israel be both Jewish and democratic? Michigan’s newly elected senator Abdul El-Sayed, for one, thinks not.

Speaking at the Atlantic Summit this week, El-Sayed was asked to spell out what he thinks Israel should be if not a Jewish state. He replied: “I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens, does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws.”

El-Sayed was right to identify the tension between liberalism and ethnic nationalism in Israel. The idea that a state should fundamentally belong to a particular ethnic group has deep roots in Zionist thought. Scholars such as Hans Kohn, George Mosse and Zeev Sternhell have traced Zionism’s affinities with romantic European völkisch nationalism: a conception of nationhood rooted not in shared political values but in a particular people’s ancestral connection to a territory, in which that people can secure a demographic majority.

Consider the Jewish National Fund, which still owns land in Israel — provided to it by the state — that its charter reserves for Jews. A Jew born in New York therefore has easier access to this Israeli land than an Arab born in the country, a clear violation of liberal principles of equal access to land, and a practice that has repeatedly been challenged before Israel’s Supreme Court.

El-Sayed’s most vehement critics might argue that this particular view of Israel stems from a supposedly concealed “Islamism”, or is motivated by ancestral animus rooted in his Egyptian immigrant background. In fact, this position is better understood as a product of his assimilation into American progressivism.

America does not define itself as a blood-and-soil nation-state. It has no established religion, enshrines birthright citizenship in its Constitution and sustains a national mythology of itself as a “nation of immigrants”, held together by the melting pot of a shared civic identity. American progressives can therefore be insufficiently self-conscious about the extent to which this is an unusual model of nationhood.

Much of the world places greater emphasis on ancestry, historical continuity, language, religion and shared ethnicity in defining national belonging. Citizenship by descent (jus sanguinis), rather than citizenship by birth on a country’s territory (jus soli), remains the dominant principle in many other countries.

As some of El-Sayed’s opponents have already pointed out, many Middle Eastern states officially define themselves as “Arab republics” or have Islam as their state religion, so why single out Israel? The Michigan senator-elect could fairly respond that he has criticized Egypt’s “right to be an ethnostate” and suggested after his midterm victory that more countries should look like the United States.

The broad position among US progressives is that a country which is strictly ethnic and religious in its self-conception is regressive, even racist. For them, this essentialism is reminiscent of the dreaded “heritage Americans” and “Christian nationalists” who want to define America in explicitly racial and religious terms. Following this logic, the idea of Israel being a “Jewish state” can’t be anything but racist in their eyes.

Almost every nation has a religious and cultural shadow. In Britain, for instance, the Sabbath falls on a Sunday. Yet this does not mean that the rights of non-Christians are meaningfully curtailed: liberal principles take precedence over religious and cultural particularities. The same should be possible for Israel. Being a state for the Jewish people does not intrinsically require Israel to confer privileges on Jews at the expense of other citizens. What really matters is not the national identity a state proclaims, but whether Jews and non-Jews enjoy the same rights under the law.


Ralph Leonard is a British-Nigerian writer on international politics, religion, culture and humanism.

buffsoldier_96