When my aunt met my uncle, he was a pipe-smoking deerstalker, employed by a Highland estate to manage a herd of reds across some 20,000 acres. He had a team of terriers for fox control, he often rehabilitated injured birds of prey, and he helped reintroduce ospreys. He is also the only person I’ve ever met with a taxidermy wildcat, a beautiful bit of roadkill that he stuffed himself. Wildcats were once numerous in the ancient forestry around his house, but interbreeding with errant domestic tabbies means they are now all but gone.
Forty years ago, there would have hardly been a house on the peninsula that wasn’t lived in by somebody who wasn’t working the land. But like so much of the Highlands, its beauty has been its undoing and after the estate was sold off, a busy period of house-building began. My cousins got on board. Over the years, as well as farming, they’ve made hay out of holiday properties. But I do wonder, when my uncle’s out after deer at dawn, up on the hill, if he looks down to the coast and wonders about the part he’s played in taming a wild place he loved.
Last year, I drove through the West Highlands and on up to the Isle of Skye to talk to a young crofter about corncrakes. A little over 100 years ago, the corncrake’s strange “crex crex” call could be heard in spring, in most British counties. The latest counts suggest there are now fewer than 1,000 male corncrakes returning each year, almost all of them bound for Scotland’s northwestern periphery.
The crofter I was going to see, Cheryl, lives right at the other end from where the ferry docks, so I stopped for a beer in Armadale on my way. I realised, perched on a wall there, that I could see right across the water to my cousin’s house on the other side. “Your aunt won’t go to Skye anymore in the summer,” my mother replied when I texted her. “Traffic jams all across the island.” She was right. During my stay there were caravans backed up on the road to the Fairy Pools, there was never any parking in Portree, and an old farmer told me he’d given up on Highland cattle and gone into Galloways instead. “There were folks taking photos just non-stop and it doesn’t do to harass the cattle like that”.
The precipitous decline in corncrake numbers, in mainland Britain, has been largely caused by agricultural intensification. Corncrakes traditionally nested in hay meadows and the bulk of them would have fledged by the time the hay was cut. But with the advent of the tractor and the transition to silage, which is cut earlier, countless nests and chicks die beneath the blades. The crofting system in the Western Isles is far less intensive and there are schemes that provide financial incentives for crofters to delay cutting until the corncrakes have taken flight.
As Cheryl pointed out, lots of farmers have just given up completely on their marginal crofting operations and turned to tourism. “The corncrakes do need the grass to be cut, they don’t like rank vegetation, but people just stop farming. Instead now you’ve got sometimes three holiday houses per croft”. Climbing up into her tractor to get back to cutting the field, Cheryl said to me she’s not yet heard a corncrake on the island. A lot of her day-to-day life is taken up with crofting in a way that doesn’t theoretically endanger the few birds that remain, but she suspects there haven’t actually been any corncrakes in her part of Skye for some 20 years.
Still, the impact of tourism is more complicated than many people pretend. Magnus Davidson, whose work at the University of the Highlands and Islands focuses on setting out a new vision for rural Scotland, told me that he no longer goes to Skye in the summer either. It’s very easy, he admits, to condemn tourists, but in lots of places they are the lifeblood of rural economies and achieving any sort of balance is next to impossible. “When tourism starts to negatively affect things like roads or the environment, infrastructure can help alleviate the impact but when it comes to cultural degradation” — the loss of dialects and languages and even ways of living — “you can’t infrastructure your way out of that”. Magnus admits that there probably are parts of the UK where the tourism is harmonious but it’s ever-evolving. “It could be that somewhere is only ever one Instagram post away from the scales being tipped”.
Magnus was also keen to point out that too much low-cost tourism risks a place becoming flooded, but make it too expensive and you run the risk of exclusivity. In some instances, locals have to contend with both. Last month, in North Norfolk, where coastal cottages often change hands for over a million quid, I met an environmentalist who was on her way to a meeting about beachgoers peeing on the dunes at Wells. The quantity of urine there has become so great that it is having a serious ecological impact.
Tourism has been the ruin of many places, but parts of Scotland desperately need more of it. A little over six months ago, my parents left Dumfriesshire, a place of remarkable tranquillity, where most summer evenings, the sun casts the hills in heavy golden light. But the village pub had closed, like the village butcher, and the village shop before it. They could all have done with a few well-heeled holidaymakers in search of some local ales and a bit of beef for their smart new barbecues.
On Skye, the truth is that a crofter with three camping pods — on what was once fine corncrake habitat — can make more in a month out of people than they ever made in a year out of cattle. But that’s not to say that tourism is always necessarily terrible for wildlife. There are some places, such as Knepp Castle in Sussex, where the extraordinary recovery of birds has been facilitated by it. Nature was suffering there because of intensive agriculture, but the shift to making money out of people — out of shepherds’ huts, yurts, and pleasant places to pitch a tent — has meant they can manage the land in a far gentler and more ecologically sound way. In a binary world, we tend not to realise that there are different flavours of agriculture. Where the corncrakes of the Hebrides need farming, to keep the grass sward in check, farming in Sussex has done for turtle doves by tearing out hedgerow habitat in order to make fields bigger.
It was five or six years ago that I last went north to see my cousins. Beneath snipe drumming and harriers cutting circles in the air, I fished for a couple of days — just a few small brown trout and one sea trout lost. On the last evening I was there, my uncle said I could go down to his farm the following morning and shoot a goose if I fancied it — the greylags had been eating his animals’ grass for too long.
I drove to the bay before dawn and picked my way across the marsh before settling in behind a cattle trough. For 20 minutes the geese grew louder and louder out on the sand. Just before the sun rose they got up and passed me 30 yards to the right, dark shapes against a cold blue sky. I took one out of the back of the skein. Two shots sent it tumbling into the reeds and the marsh lifted with the crying shadows of curlew, lapwing, and dunlin.
Then behind me, all around the bay, lights came on in houses that I hadn’t realised were there. I wandered back along the lane with the warm goose tucked under my jacket. I didn’t want to spoil things for any of those holidaymakers, as they sat down to croissants and the picture postcard view.
Patrick Galbraith is a journalist and author whose work has appeared in The Times, Granta, The Spectator, and The Times Literary Supplement. His first book In Search of One Last Song was recently published by William Collins.
PaddyCGalbraith 
Join the discussion
Join like minded readers that support our journalism by becoming a paid subscriber
To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.
Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.
SubscribeThank you for this balanced article. It’s not easy to find he balance between tourism, agriculture, local life and making a living. Whatever people do some others will complain.
Everyone who wants to be able to enjoy wild places should be able to do so. Are there just too many of us? There are many problems with overpopulation: this is one that seldom receives attention.
A few years ago I visited the Norwegian fjords and was struck by how populated and verdant the landscape was, with woodland and meadows beneath stark rocky mountains. By the fjords,at least, it wasn’t really a wilderness.
I am sceptical that Highland Scotland is a wilderness either. Surely it is an artificial landscape , a result of deforestation, depopulation and managed estates?
It has always struck me as an empty and barren landscape. Visiting Norway confirmed this, given that it has a similar Gulf Stream maritime climate, actually slightly north of Scotland.
Yes. It would have looked very different before the Clearances and the advent of sheep. And very different again, before the Great Caledonian Forest was cleared. Until circa one thousand years ago, there were beavers and bears. Until a couple of thousand before that, there were aurochs. The last wolves survived into the 16th century.
But all that is of course broadly true of England and Wales as well.
And everywhere else where mankind has established itself.
If you like a place don’t post it. No need to boast on Instagram or Facebook, tell your friends or nice people you meet. Best places are found by word of mouth.
“make it too expensive and you run the risk of exclusivity.”
But make it too cheap and available and you risk ruining much of the quality that made the place desirable and end up with sites of “tourist experience” rather the genuine article that drew people there in the first place. The crowds at many tourist destinations now ruin the experience unless you go out of season or out of the usual hours.
Interesting article pondering a very real conflict – we do indeed destroy the things we love.
Sorry to carp incidentally, but I think your uncle is a deer stalker; a deerstalker is a hat.
Excellent post. It’s a global problem and one without satisfactory solutions. I always grow annoyed with urban environmentalists who lambast ranchers for slaughtering wolves, who often lay waste to their cattle. I also completely understand the importance wolves play in the ecosystem and the carnage Wisconsin unleashed on its wolf population in a span of a week a year or so ago.
Tourism is a frustrating endeavor. Western North Carolina 20 years ago was still very much a hidden jewel that has now morphed into overbuilt and overrun tourist traps. There are still many good places in that area but summer is hell.
I live in the Lake District and we’re having similar problems. Businesses are starting to close because they cannot find staff to work for them. (There aren’t affordable places to live and public transport is costly.)
The problem with tourism as a whole is complex. I think there’s little to no balance. Whilst the Lake District thrums with activity, packed car parks and high streets. A little over the National Park border is a different story. (Despite being just as beautiful)
The issue is giving places ‘special’ significance. It doesn’t allow balance. It gives tourists a false incentive that one place is ‘better’ than another. I personally believe that we can do something about this.
Apparently, Patrick sees no irony in his driving thru this nearly pristine wilderness in a pollution spewing vehicle … (sarc off)
And does anyone else think it strange that he is happy to shoot an inoffensive goose, and then make a sarky comment about the influx of holidaymakers settling in to enjoy croissants and the picture-postcard view?
Interesting post. 2 points I would make though are crofting and farming are different things. Crofters are not farmers and vice versa. Secondly Skye is not part of the Western Isles. Lewis, Harris, Scalpay Berneray, N and S Uist, Benbecula and Barra plus a host of smaller, uninhabited islands make up the Western Isles. Skye is part of the Inner Hebrides, a different group. If you want to hear corncrakes, they are still to be found on the Western coast of Lewis, Harris and N and S Uist. I have heard their particularly annoying call many times this summer.