by Giles Fraser
Tuesday, 21
July 2020
Seen Elsewhere

What has human sacrifice got to do with Twitter? Ask René Girard

by Giles Fraser
Rene Girard (1923-2015)

What has human sacrifice got to do with Twitter? Quite a lot, in fact. As Geoff Shullenberger explains in a fascinating article in The Tablet this week, the social mechanisms that informed human sacrifice are remarkably similar to those that are being used on social media platforms like Twitter.

Ok, on Twitter no curly dagger is pressed into the breast of an innocent victim. But, as Shullenberger explains, in theoretical terms, the biggest difference is that whereas ancient sacrifice had the social purpose of establishing human solidarity, on Twitter the collective digital pile-on is a part of the very business model of the platform.

Several people have already and quite rightly suggested that human behaviour on social media, especially on Twitter, can be profitably illuminated through the work of French cultural theorist and theologian, René Girard. But Shullenberger adds layers of fascinating and highly persuasive analysis. Of Twitter, he writes:

It is an arena for perpetual conflict driven by an accumulation of grievances collected in a mass program of decentralized surveillance. We are incentivized, by the coded logic of the social media platforms where public engagement now takes place, to find reasons to hate each other.
- Geoff Shullenberger, The Tablet

In this highly vituperative context, where pile-ons are incentivised with ‘likes’, “attacks upon individuals is a feature of the platforms, not a bug.”

Girard is useful here not just because of his theory of mimetic desire — that so much of our behaviour and desire is copied — maps extremely well onto Twitter. But also his story that in non-policed (ancient) societies, the collective blame that comes to be focused on some individuals has the social purpose of uniting a society around a kind of mob viciousness, with mob attacks culminating in an ordered sacrificial climax, the priest who does the sacrificing both ordering/formatting the social viciousness and bringing it to a close.

This is the core idea of Girard’s understanding of sacrifice. It unites society by refocusing all its pent-up discontent on an innocent victim. And Twitter is the perfect breeding ground for pent up discontent.

As a Roman Catholic theologian, what is always at the back of Girard’s mind is the crucifixion of Jesus. Having had the privilege to meet René Girard a couple of times before he died, I have argued with him about this. And theologically, I think there is a real problem with the way his theory works — not least, the role that his analysis ascribes to Jews in the crucifixion story. Because in Girard’s analysis, it’s just too easy to cast Jews as the one’s shouting “crucify”, whilst Jesus stands as the innocent victim. It’s a very ancient and very nasty trope.

But back on Twitter, the Girardian analysis works much better:

The more of us that are transfixed by spectacles of victimization, the greater the revenue the platform brings in. Like a bloodthirsty god, the platform business feeds off of sacrifice.
- Geoff Shullenberger, The Tablet

Brilliantly explored in this article, this is the basic theology of cancel culture.

Join the discussion

  • July 24, 2020
    Having read ( and studied ) the New Testament scores of times ( as well as Girard ), I concur that Jesus should be viewed through a first-century CE Jewish lens. That being said, the story of the crucifixion is the culmination of a much larger Jewish story regarding the Messiah. It is most... Read more

  • July 23, 2020
    I think it helps to understand Girard's work to remember that, although he did a great deal of work based upon Biblical study, he was not a theologian. He began as a literary critic and his interest expanded into other areas; his principal interest was the study of human nature and its hidden... Read more

  • July 22, 2020
    I'm a bit of a Girardian. I think he describes mob mentality and herd behaviour in a way that makes perfect sense to me. In an obituary for Girard the following was stated: Mr. Thiel, of PayPal, said that he was a student at Stanford when he first encountered Professor Girard’s work, and that... Read more

To get involved in the discussion and stay up to date, join UnHerd.

It's simple, quick and free.

Sign me up