by Robin Aitken
Friday, 5
June 2020

Tim Davie faces a perfect storm at the Beeb

Falling revenues, a hostile government and growing competition signal tough times ahead
by Robin Aitken
Tim Davie, the BBC’s new director-general

In appointing Tim Davie, a marketing man, as its new Director-General the BBC is clearly signalling it fears lean times ahead; Tony Hall, the man he is replacing, is a journalist by training and went on to successfully run Covent Garden, before becoming D-G. Mr Davie, in contrast, has few creative or artistic credentials; he’s a marketeer who cut his teeth flogging Pepsi-Cola and bathroom products at Proctor and Gamble. This is not to sneer: the BBC has no shortage of creative types but what it may soon face is an acute shortage of money. Flogging stuff profitably is going to be crucial in the coming years.

Mr Davie has already proved himself adept at that in his role as chief executive at BBC Studios, the Corporation’s commercial arm, which netted him a handsome salary last year of £642,000. In his new role he’ll have to scrape by on £450,000 because the BBC is operating under a self-denying ordinance which trimmed back top salaries after the grotesque inflation of the Mark Thompson years (when he retired in 2012 to move to The New York Times Thompson was being paid £825,000). And money-matters will be item No.1 on the new boss’s to do list.

Consider this: the BBC has already announced that it needs to find savings of £125 million this year because of falling revenues — but a much bigger challenge awaits. From the autumn the BBC is pledged to assume the full cost of providing free TV licenses to all over-75s in the country at an estimated cost of around £700 million; that’s around 15% of the BBC’s total revenue. All this against an ominous political background; the BBC has few friends in government and events of recent weeks further darkens the outlook.

An under-reported aspect of the Emily Maitlis affair last week was just how bitter relations between the BBC and Downing Street have become. In March Maitlis presented ‘Taking Control: the Dominic Cummings Story”; it was a very hostile profile of Cummings, a man who dislikes the BBC and mistrusts its journalism. After Maitlis’s attack last week, the mood in No10 was said to be sulphurous and with Cummings still in place the Beeb can expect no favours.

A mid-term review of the BBC’s Royal Charter is slated for 2022 with an implicit threat that the license fee (cherished by the Corporation because of the secure revenue it guarantees) might be abolished. And even before that the government is said to be considering de-criminalising non-payment of the license fee which would mean a further loss of revenue. And behind it all is the widespread feeling among the Brexiteers in the Tory party that it’s payback time for the perceived bias against them which the BBC has demonstrated over decades.

In taking over the reins of the Corporation at this moment Tim Davie faces a perfect storm of challenges; falling revenues, a hostile government and an ever-growing array of muscular competitors like Netflix and Amazon. He will need first-rate commercial and political acumen if the BBC is to prosper.

Join the discussion

To join the discussion, get the free daily email and read more articles like this, sign up.

It's simple, quick and free.

Sign me up
Notify of
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Fraser Bailey
Fraser Bailey
2 years ago

One can only hope that Mr Cummings does to the BBC what he did to the Remoaners. Essentially, the BBC has appointed itself as the government’s unofficial opposition. This is an outrage when it is funded by a compulsory tax that is levied on millions and millions of people who support, or at least voted for, the government and Brexit. Essentially, it’s like supporting the Tories but paying to be a member of the Labour Party. This is unconscionable, an act of theft, pure and simple, and it has to change.

The best solutions would be to simply abolish the license fee. I did this on a personal level by throwing out the TV 20 years ago because I could not bear to fund the BBC even then – and they are far, far worse now. I believe tens or even hundreds of thousands of people are now doing the same. Good. There are much better things to do with your time than watch TV. And if you want news and commentary there are countless great podcasters from the left, right and centre out there, many of whom broadcast from their basement or garage and achieve vastly higher viewing figures than, for instance, Newsnight.

Paul Pelosi
Paul Pelosi
2 years ago

The storm Davie faces is not at the BBC but outside the BBC. At the BBC all is essentially ‘normal’. He will insert himself effortlessly into the scheme of BBC things and no one will notice any difference. Political correctness fanaticism, diversity obsession, woke mania; nothing will or is expected to change. Thus will the BBC continue on its spiral to destruction at the hands of a viewership thoroughly fed up with identity television, ‘up to date’ moralising and brainwashing.

Jonathan Jones
Jonathan Jones
2 years ago

“From the autumn the BBC is pledged to assume the full cost of providing free TV licenses to all over-75s in the country at an estimated cost of around £700 million”

The free licence for over-75s is being scrapped, is it not?

2 years ago

There’s a very simple solution to the BBC problems. Present unbiased, high quality news alongside top quality drama and entertainment.

This will mean presenting both sides of issues on which the BBC has already made up its mind such as climate change and Brexit.

Make sure it is all politically neutral.

I’ve been watching Springwatch this week which is a proper piece of unbiased public service broadcasting and proves it can still be done. I can’t see much else in the schedule.