by Neil O'Brien
Tuesday, 16
June 2020
Reaction
10:58

Let’s hire unemployed youngsters to clean graffiti

Now is the time to clean up the country and insulate houses
by Neil O'Brien
A graffiti cleaning specialist steam cleans the walls of the Hayward Gallery (Photo by Bruno Vincent/Getty Images)

Today’s unemployment numbers may seem reassuring, and show that the furlough scheme is working: the headline measure of unemployment was unchanged for now.

But the day also showed us what’s about to hit in the coming months. A record drop in job vacancies and self-employment. The unemployment benefit claimant count soaring from 1.2 million people in March to 2.8 million now. These are the first signs of an unprecedented economic storm.

Early 1980s levels of unemployment could be back soon. Shops and hospitality, normally employing a large amount of young people, are going to struggle to back on their feet. GDP has plunged back to where it was in 2002.

Rishi Sunak has had a good crisis, shredding Treasury orthodoxy with schemes for the government to pay people’s wages. But things are only going get tougher from here.

There’s a thousand things we need to do to fight the recession, but above all we have got to fight to get unemployment down.

UK Claimant Count level increased by 125.9% since March 2020. Credit: ONS

In previous recessions we had schemes to help young people get jobs: the “YTS”, the “New Deal”, etc. In a “normal” recession, the evidence suggests focusing such schemes on matching people to jobs, getting them work experience, and so on.

But in a cluster-recession of this magnitude, we need more.

One lesson I take from previous jobs schemes is that you need a backstop. You need a block of jobs government can place people in, to guarantee hope to people who don’t find work after months of trying.

Economists are pretty clear that long-term unemployment has a sort of “scarring” effect. People on the dole get de-skilled, detached, and their mental health suffers. Years later they are still earning less than similar people who weren’t unemployed. There’s even evidence their kids earn less.

If this storm is as bad for unemployment as it looks, we need the government to create useful work. Now is the time to put long-held national missions into practise.

Let’s get an army of young people to eliminate the graffiti that disfigures this country.

Let’s tidy Britain until it looks like Switzerland, where you can eat your dinner off the pavement.

Let’s insulate thousands of houses… or turn National Citizen Service into something way bigger than it is… or plant trees. Take your pick.

The economics are clear and the politics I think are too. Last year’s election proved the concept, fusing centrist economics with sensible social conservatism and national self-confidence. In a tough spot, people are going to want an egalitarian kind of conservatism, long after the furlough scheme has ended.

Join the discussion


  • Better idea! Catch the criminals defacing property. Put them on chain-gangs cleaning up the defacement. Sleeping accommodations would be pup tents with a wool blanket. Chow would be beans three times a day.

  • This is a good idea – other areas where we need many more people to be trained and employed are in caring, infrastructure maintenance (especially roads/paths) and horticulture Skills training (both ‘soft’ and ‘hard’) can be given alongside the work.

  • A lot of very useful work was done in the U.S. of the 1930s under the programmes instituted by the government. It wasn’t all just communist plays and socialist murals.

  • To get involved in the discussion and stay up to date, become a registered user.

    It's simple, quick and free.

    Sign me up