by Timandra Harkness
Friday, 25
December 2020

Christmas cancelled? Here’s why you should party like It’s 1656

'Tis the season for a 'festive' throwback
by Timandra Harkness
Take Away That Bauble, Cromwell Dissolving the Long Parliament. Credit: Getty

Christmas Day 1656 was just another working day in Parliament under Lord Protector Oliver Cromwell. Joachim Matthews, MP for Maldon in Essex, brought forward a Bill to reinforce the ban on Christmas. MP Luke Robinson complained that he had been kept awake all night by noisy festivities outside his lodgings, while another member said that he had walked from the Tower of London to Westminster and seen not a shop open.

Thanks to the Puritans, the public holiday of Christmas had been abolished in 1647, and was only restored along with the Monarchy in 1660. The Scots, ahead of the game as usual, first banned Christmas in 1583, under threat of excommunication.

Like what you’re reading? Get the free UnHerd daily email

Already registered? Sign in

But the British didn’t take kindly to having their winter festivities curtailed. Resistance ranged from satirical pamphlets to riots. A 1647 protest in Canterbury started with smashing up shops that dared open on Christmas day, and culminated in seizing control of the city in outright rebellion against the government.

So since we’re all having to re-think our Christmas celebrations this year, here’s how to party like it’s 1656:

  1. No mince pies, no Christmas pudding, and no sweets. Mince pies were never explicitly banned, but the Puritans disapproved of indulgent feasting, so best stick to something simple like stewed duck and mustard pickle.
  2. No pantomime. The Puritans banned all theatrical performances in 1642 for lascivious mirth and levity. Restoration theatre, following Charles II’s coronation in 1660, did its best to prove them right.
  3. But you can go shopping. Keeping shops open was a visible sign of normality, so Parliament insisted that shops must stay open on Christmas Day. You’ll have to limit your Christmas day shopping to the internet, where you won’t run into a crowd of rioters with Royalist sympathies.
  4. No carols. Singing irreligious seasonal songs was prohibited. At least this year you can sing outdoors. In 1656, that might have got you arrested.
  5. Worry about the Plague. Though 1656 was a good plague year compared to 1636, when 1 in 14 Londoners died, or 1665, which killed 1 in 6, Bubonic Plague never went away completely. During outbreaks, infected households were padlocked into their homes for 40 days, with a red cross and ‘Lord have Mercy’ painted on the outside.
  6. Drink coffee. The first coffee houses in England opened in 1652, in Oxford and then London, and the coffee house rapidly became an important meeting place for commercial, political and social meeting. Depending on your tier, you may have to drink your coffee sitting at either end of a park bench, but you can still talk politics and gossip.
  7. Worry about Europe. The Treaty of Brussels, signed in April 1656, committed Spain, already at war with England, to restoring Charles II to the English throne. Unlike today’s Brexit wrangling, the Anglo-Spanish War involved a lot of blockading ports, sinking ships and seizing islands in the Caribbean. There, you feel better about the lorry parks in Kent already.
  8. Post your cards and parcels at the last minute. Oliver Cromwell gave control of the post office to John Thurloe in 1655, and by 1656 a letter from London could reach Winchester in a day. Thurloe was also Spymaster General, so he might read your letter before it arrived, making it about as private as social media today.
  9. Complain that we’re being ruled by arbitrary regulations coming straight from Government. Major-Generals with extensive powers, backed by militias and answerable only to Whitehall, ran the country in 1656. The last debate in Parliament on Christmas Day was a call to limit their powers, in favour of more local rule. Their regime came to an end the following year.
  10. Get a dog. The pug was introduced to Britain by Dutch traders, probably around 1656 in an interlude between Anglo-Dutch wars. And walking a dog will help you burn off the calories from the stewed duck.

Join the discussion

To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Notify of
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Fraser Bailey
Fraser Bailey
2 years ago

So, apart from number one on the list not much has changed, at least with regard to this year. Even worse, in 2020 it will probably take longer than a day for a letter to get from London to Winchester.

What about playing football? Did Cromwell ban that? I will be playing this morning, before social events involving at least one proper Christmas dinner and multiple varieties of alcohol including a magnum good of Cote-Rotie.

7882 fremic
7882 fremic
2 years ago
Reply to  Fraser Bailey

No social Distancing Frasier? Get ready for the visit from the Police to break the party up, issue thousand pound fines, and same as then, lock you down in your house for 14 days and not even a ‘Lord Have Mercy’ painted on your door.

For me it is work as usual. I have a cold, it seems, so am isolating from my ancient parent and family, and may as well go to the job site and paint baseboard I am putting down next. Outside is chilly but bright and I have sawhorses set to paint on. Normally I do a turkey but tonight will be a hamburger and some dreadful Netflix thing, if there is anything on it I can tolerate. Maybe Henry VIII again, with an antihistamine and a juiced grapefruit with tonic water.

2 years ago

And just as today Scotland had to one up England.

2 years ago
Reply to  katrinaangus

The return of a puritan Christmas past that could still be experienced in the UK as late as the 1970s.