<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	xmlns:unherd="https://www.unherd.com"
	>

	<channel>
		<title>Founding fathers - UnHerd</title>
		<atom:link href="https://unherd.com/tag/founding-fathers/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
		<link>https://unherd.com/tag/founding-fathers/</link>
		<description>think again</description>
		<lastBuildDate>Tue, 14 Jul 2026 21:12:01 +0000</lastBuildDate>
		<language>en-US</language>
		<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
		<sy:updateFrequency>12</sy:updateFrequency>
		<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4</generator>

 
<site xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">241381703</site>				<item>
					<title>America’s other constitution</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2026/07/americas-other-constitution/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2026/07/americas-other-constitution/?edition=us#respond</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/GettyImages-1298273231_cropped.jpeg?w=576</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>America 250</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Vincenzo Barney]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/Blue-7.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[The legacy of the Second Continental Congress has been stolen. Credit: Getty]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<div>Vincenzo Barney is a <em>Vanity Fair</em> contributor and publishes the Substack <a href="https://barneysrubble.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://barneysrubble.substack.com/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1774098993040000&amp;usg=AOvVaw09APj6IJbZxm8_xTlHXt-i">Barney<span style="font-weight: 400;">’</span>s Rubble</a>.</div>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>BarneysRubble0</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[<div>Vincenzo Barney is a <em>Vanity Fair</em> contributor and publishes the Substack <a href="https://barneysrubble.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://barneysrubble.substack.com/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1774098993040000&amp;usg=AOvVaw09APj6IJbZxm8_xTlHXt-i">Barney<span style="font-weight: 400;">’</span>s Rubble</a>.</div>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 02 Jul 2026 23:00:39 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 14 Jul 2026 21:12:01 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[American Founding]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Anti-Federalists]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Articles of Confederation]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Bill of Rights]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Federalists]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Founding fathers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Ken Burns]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Samuel Bryan]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The Constitution]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://unherd.com/?p=1065699</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The Articles of Confederation were our true liberty document]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><img decoding="async" class="aligncenter" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/America-250.jpg" alt="America 250" /></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">We may now speak of an ancient America. You’ll forgive me such bold pronouncements, for there isn’t the time to waste trapped in tired registers of speech, and I have several more shockwaves to get through before we’re done. Furthermore, the ambition to push my country’s mind into new modes overrides all possibility of modest thought and all hope of modest deliverance. Add to this motive the jolly of no ordinary birthday: We the People have reached our 21st century and are now old enough in the eyes of arbitrary law to grow brave on the vintage Madeiras our Founding Fathers left aging in the cellars of the republics </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">plural</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, for 13 republics and counting we were meant to be, never the one. With this intimation you may catch on the air of my intoxicated breath the first whiff of America’s founding hornswoggle and her hogsheads of secret history. But I warn you, there are secrets in the swigs of these old wines that some of our fathers are illegitimate and so some of us are illegitimate Sons of Liberty. I should know, for I have been conducting vigorous research among the casks and deliver myself presently to the top of the cellar stairs, fresh from a choice cache of reds, with a maximum of confidence and high patriotic focus, not to mention every wine-lover’s intention of pouring generously. But I said we may speak of an ancient America, so let us speak.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">After 250 years, we have hurtled such a distance from our origins that the histories, philosophies, and intentions of our founders equal the lost secrets of Greece, the sacked libraries of Alexandria, the </span><a href="https://medium.com/not-be-condemned-to-repeat-it/could-rome-have-invented-the-steam-engine-7a3b03d6b37f"><span style="font-weight: 400;">aborted steam engine of Rome</span></a><span style="font-weight: 400;"> and an Industrial Revolution a millennium early, all of it abandoned to Barbary. The year 1776 is an ancient date to the American eye staring across the dilation of our epoch’s accelerated speed. For we did in but two centuries what historically took most civilizations 1,000 years, and we are a little warped from the pace. You think I speak of the betrayals of the Constitution, and while there is certainly much of that, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">I am speaking of what the Constitution betrayed</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. I am speaking of a betrayal equal to discovering that Romulus did not kill Remus with any masculine honor, but sent a goon to sneak up on him with an icepick while he slept, and lay in an anxious sweat until dawn when the head was delivered to his slick and clammy bed. I speak of a revelation equal to learning there was an even more ancient and mysterious people slipping the sock up the boot of Italy before the Romans did.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Half the mystique of anciency is the intimacy it shares with oblivion: there is awe in what has been lost, and will never be known. We await bold innovations in physics to storm limbo, for like the particle horizon round our domain in the universe, there is a shrinking horizon to the past which knowledge can make very few enduring incursions beyond. For instance, where it was once casual knowledge to any Roman, today we are left to wonder, “Who were these Etruscans who came to Italy before Rome; whence these Italianate people who gave Rome her Tarquin kings, her arch, her Cloaca Maxima, and her regal </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">purpura</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">; these people who taught the Romans how to read portents in the lightning and in the thunder, and predicted down to the century their own nation’s 1,000-year lifespan and the eventual Roman eclipse; who wrote from right to left against the arrow of time in a lost and still unsolved language; who sailed defensive navies so powerful, they terrified a Greek people fresh from Ilium; whose protectionist polity was structured to preclude the doom and ruin of imperial expansion; yes, who were these Etruscans and their </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">confederation</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">? For political morphology tells us that republics decline and fall into empires, but a daring charge into Etruscan and, now, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">American</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> oblivion reveals a new morphological truth: </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">confederations precede republics</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. On this note, I lift to your lips the first sip of the olde vino.</span></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>* * * * *</strong></p>
<p>The uniform perception<span style="font-weight: 400;"> of American history tells us that we declared independence from Britain in 1776, fought a revolutionary war that ended in victory in 1782, became the first glimmering modern republic by ratifying our noble Constitution after a good-humored and lively debate in 1789, and, because we were in an expansively democratic mood, added in the handy first 10 amendments, the Bill of Rights, in 1791. This myth is our Romulus, and everyone from Ken Burns to the folks of the 1619 Project take it for fact. </span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“America’s first constitution was <em>not</em> the Constitution, but the Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union.”</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Anarchist-anthropologist David Graeber on the Left and Fox News’s Sean Hannity agree that the Constitution but resolved the chord of the 1776 Revolution. But this is a Romulus myth that </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">hides</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> its integral fratricide. The seven years between 1782 and 1789 are short enough, I suppose, to give no hint they were seven of the only eight years </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">that the United States of America actually existed</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. For America’s original constitution was </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">not</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> the Constitution. Decorum, please, with your wine, sir! It is an ancient vintage — don’t be so surprised to find it spiked with a little of the Eleusinian ergot. Your mind must be open for this historical trip. You are going to be asked to think in </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">plurals</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> and </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">simultaneities</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> and the paradox of their attendant contradictions. Drink deep.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">No, gentlemen, I say again, slowly for the timorous: America’s first constitution was </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">not </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">the Constitution, but the Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union, created by the same Second Continental Congress that issued the Declaration of Independence. The astute among you will note the word “Confederation” right up there near the front of the name, conveying a definite impression of the type of government the document describes. No, this was not one of Benjamin Franklin’s elaborate jokes in the vein of his “Fart Proudly” columns. Rather, the word “Confederation” names precisely what America was established to secure for all time: a loose confederation of 13 independent, sovereign states. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Whereas the Constitution has taught us to think in </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">singulars </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">— one nation, indivisible — our true nature is </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">plural</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> and decentralized. There are geologies to a nation’s psyche, and the idea that a citizen of Maine can cast a vote for president that will affect the governance of the citizens of Arizona 2,500 miles and 300 million people away, is so entrenched a modern American expectation that the pre-Constitution psychology is nearly incomprehensible. Attempt to take in America’s original intent: if you were a citizen of, say, Massachusetts in 1784, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">that was your country</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. You did not have weighing on your mind the election of a national president in Washington, DC, but rather the election of your governor, lieutenant governor, and legislators. In 1776, the separate states of America were not the vestigial provinces and administrative arms of Washington they are today, but sovereign </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">countries</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. And these 13 original countries each had their own constitutions. They printed their own money. They regulated their own commerce. They levied their own taxes. They banded their own militias. They decided the boundaries of their own liberties. They decided their own political structures, and there was no national government that could or would intervene. Contrary to the high-school-history fairy tale promoted by the likes of filmmaker Ken Burns — in which America was a rambunctious gaggle of independent states just </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">yearning</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> deep down to be one people under a common yoke, and learning step by improbable step to get out of its own libertarian way — </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">the opposite was the case</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. The Revolution of 1776 was not fought to replace one entrenched central power with another, but</span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> to dissolve the principle of central power altogether</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. For the oppression that spurred the rebellion was the totalism of a distant monarch and aristocratic parliament, enforced by a standing army. American militias did not take up arms or turn their farms into battlefields to dissolve the sovereignty of their home state and establish a new central government, nor to simply swap nomenclature: a king for a president, Parliament for Congress. No, the movement was genuinely a </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">revolution</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> in that it aimed for the decentralization original to Western Civilization, and succeeded in restoring mankind to a governance like the confederations of Etruria and pre-Socratic Greece, the latter the very structure that birthed Western philosophy in the Tragic Age. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/05/invasion-of-the-literary-bots/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/05/invasion-of-the-literary-bots/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Image-5-19-26-at-5.16-PM.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/05/invasion-of-the-literary-bots/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author </span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/05/invasion-of-the-literary-bots/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Invasion of the literary bots</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/05/invasion-of-the-literary-bots/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Vincenzo Barney</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Articles of Confederation were commissioned by the Second Continental Congress on June 11, 1776, the same day Thomas Jefferson began work on the Declaration, that first masterpiece of American-English prose. They were drafted by a committee of 13 members, one from each state, including John Dickinson from Pennsylvania and Samuel Adams of Massachusetts. The committee finished its work in 1777, and the Articles became the de facto law of the land until official ratification in 1781. What Jefferson expressed in poetic precision, the Articles expressed in political precision. More than an equal masterpiece, they are the definitive text of America’s original intent. The Articles established a one-year president of Congress, a presiding officer who was already a member of Congress </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">elected</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> by Congress with no veto or other executive powers; congressional term limits with officials under the power of recall by their state legislatures at any time; no standing army or power to conscript soldiers; no power to compel taxes directly on the people or states nor alter or override state constitutions; and a unanimous majority of all states to amend the Articles. Power over the actions of the state rested </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">with</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> each of the separate states, and the national Congress was there merely to mediate matters such as border disputes or to coordinate response to threats such as foreign invasion. “Weak and ineffectual,” says Ken Burns — “As intended!” answer the Patriot Dead. Yes, we’ve woken some ancient spirits.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Now, it may be the wine talking, but I would just love to saddle you and ride you horse-breathed through a bit of history, for you simply will not get this education anywhere else and a gallop of 18th-century air is good for the </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">constitution</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. But this anticipates. </span></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>* * * * *</strong></p>
<p>In 1782, the West was won<span style="font-weight: 400;"> and the plural republics of the United States, having dissolved central power for all time, settled into a dream of perpetual confederal union under the Articles. But two antagonistic forces were in the wings preparing a sleight of hand: a large national debt held by chafing creditors, and Lin-Manuel Miranda — sorry, </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Alexander Hamilton</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, the nation’s first secretary of the Treasury. That is, with the Articles’ weak powers of </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">national</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> taxation, the states were not exactly racing to pay off their war debts. This doubly roiled the monied class of bankers, lawyers, merchants, and reintegrated Loyalists, who made their fortunes under London’s central power and now couldn’t sleep at night for all the moolah they were missing out on, because with Red Coats gone, there was no more central power to exploit financially, nor monarch around whom to form a new aristocracy. There was no purse string because there was no purse —</span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> as intended</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Lucky for these chafers, Hamilton and James Madison,</span> <span style="font-weight: 400;">the future president, were dreaming up just such a wealthy national government and colluding in secret with other “founders” about reshaping the country into a polity that looked familiarly British, familiarly overthrown — and reeking of windfall. Madison engineered the national Annapolis Convention in 1786 under the guise of discussing the federal Congress’s powers over interstate commerce. Only five states bothered to show up. Madison and Hamilton used this gathering</span> <span style="font-weight: 400;">to foment national anxiety. In Hamilton’s “Annapolis Report” and Madison’s “Vices of the Political System” memorandum, lax dispassion was spun into a deeper national crisis about the union of the states, then used as a pretext to call for another national convention “with the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation,” specifically and unambiguously its powers of taxation. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">If powerful cards had been gathering in the hands of the wealthy, the time to play them came in 1787 at what was then known as the </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Philadelphia</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> Convention. (Bad boy, Ken Burns — this was </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">not</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> called the Constitutional Convention until the late 18th century! Go to your crate!) Madison and Hamilton enjoyed leverage in the selection of delegates and the fomenting of ulterior motives. Several pro-Articles politicians declined to attend, citing the Convention as extra-legal, finding the Articles sound, and confident in the track record of past conventions that states wouldn’t even show up. Virginian Patrick Henry declined based on the power of his nose. “I smell a rat,” he said, an accurate reading, but a miscalculation that freed Madison to hand-select ardent nationalist delegates in Virginia — aristocrats who would go on to propose such pro-democratic statutes as life tenancy for presidents and for congressmen. </span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“The secret treasonous proceedings took four months before the public was alerted that the Articles had not been amended, but rather <em>dissolved</em>.”</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">According to the historians Charles and Mary Beard’s analysis of the portfolios of the Convention members, the majority of these delegates were lawyers, merchants, large landowners and creditors — the ones who held much of the public debt and, buying citizens’ debts for mere pennies on the dollar, stood to make </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">exorbitant sums</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> if the debt could be paid off in full. If a new national government could be created, these creditors were poised to become aristocrats. Madison then secured the key that unlocked the convention hall: a retired, wooden-toothed, tight-lipped general who never won a battle, George Washington. General Washington, who retreated his way to victory, had previously refused to attend, but he too much enjoyed his role as American statuary and omen. It is not hard to court a statue and, by putting Washington on display, Madison legitimized the Convention in the national eye. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Despite the pretext of amending the Articles, Madison arrived weeks early in Philadelphia with a draft of the future Constitution in hand and established a nationalist bloc, including Virginia, Pennsylvania, and various other states, with the sole intention of subverting the Convention and dissolving the Articles of Confederation. On Day One, Hamilton proposed a strict measure of secrecy. Guards were posted at the doors; publishing or communicating about the proceedings was prohibited. It was then, in secret, that the plan to replace the Articles outright was raised.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Operating like a modern, private, extra-legal corporation, the secret treasonous proceedings took four months before the public was alerted that the Articles had not been amended, but rather </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">dissolved</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> and replaced with what was called simply “the Constitution” — conspicuously with no Bill of Rights yet in sight. Furthermore, the new document bore striking resemblance to the monarchical system it had just overthrown. The president was an elective monarch with alarming powers, including to “refuse his Assent to Laws” (veto) and make “Judges dependent on his Will alone” (nomination of judicial officers) — two points that were among the declaration’s stated grievances against English monarchy. The Senate was designed to have an aristocratic makeup similar to that of the House of Lords, and the ambiguously expansive “Necessary and Proper” and “Supremacy” clauses equaled Parliament’s 1766 Declaratory Act, which established no limit to Parliament’s power over the colonies and first inflamed America to revolution. To name a few more betrayals of the Revolution, the language of the Constitution gave this new central power unlimited direct taxation and established a permanent standing army in peacetime. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">This last English resemblance seems like nothing today — we have had a standing army forever, what of it? But it was arguably the biggest </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">fear</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> of revolutionary Americans. In the 18th century, standing armies were recognized as the coercive forces of dictatorial empires. Militias were the republican American solution: it was the duty and the honor of the common man to defend his state, a principle that thwarts imperial expansions. Whereas standing armies create occasions for their own use and can be used to suppress citizenry, militias </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">are </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">the citizenry and organize themselves only for common defense in legitimate existential crises. Militias are citizens and laborers who disband to private life at the end of conflict, unlike career soldiers and officers. Most important, they answer to themselves and their state, not a national executive branch. Under the pseudonym Centinel IV, Pennsylvania dissenter Samuel Bryan summed up the Constitution in the local press: “An evil genius of darkness presided at its birth, it came forth under the veil of mystery, its true features being carefully concealed, and every deceptive art has been and is practising to have this spurious brat received as the genuine offspring of heaven-born liberty.”</span></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>* * * * *</strong></p>
<p>So the Constitution rendered<span style="font-weight: 400;"> the American Revolution an American </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">reformation </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">of British tyranny and centralization. If you can beat ’em, join ’em. Madison knew that very few state legislatures would ever agree to dissolve their own sovereignties under a Westminster replica, and so concocted a novel ratification process. The Constitution was sent to state </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">conventions</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, only nine of which had to assent in order to bind all 13 states forever. The state conventions were assembled with fresh delegates, not state legislators, and framed to the public as therefore allowing “the people” to ratify the document. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/size-mattered-for-the-founding-fathers/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/size-mattered-for-the-founding-fathers/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/GettyImages-544285512.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/size-mattered-for-the-founding-fathers/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/size-mattered-for-the-founding-fathers/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Size mattered for the Founding Fathers</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/size-mattered-for-the-founding-fathers/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Andrea Wulf</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Now, not only did the Constitution enumerate a system of central power almost identical to Britain’s, it was to be shoved down the victorious revolutionaries’ throats. In Pennsylvania, Gouverneur Morris — the leader of the state’s nationalist bloc, a man who argued the president should serve for life and pick the members of the Senate, who he also believed should serve for life — argued for accelerated speed in the assembling state conventions and ratifying the Constitution. According to Madison’s </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Notes on the Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, published in 1840, Morris’s “object was to impress in stronger terms the necessity of calling Conventions in order to prevent enemies to the plan from giving it the go by. When it first appears, with the sanction of this Convention, the people will be favorable to it. By degrees the State officers, and those interested in the State Governments, will intrigue and turn the popular current against it.” Things were so speedy in Morris’s Pennsylvania that dissenters who refused to form a quorum were forcibly escorted to the state house by a sergeant at arms. The state legislature had not seen the Constitution. During the proceedings, the dissenters were prohibited from voting, and their objections were not entered into the official record.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">This is the moment when Madison and Hamilton began issuing the pro-Constitution propaganda now known as </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Federalist Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, which coerced and frightened the public into support. The authors framed the manageable issue of paying back debts as an existential crisis whose only solution was to undo everything the Revolution had achieved, save official reattachment to Britain. Of course, there was an outcry, presently muffled by Ken Burns and PBS. Recognize now the voice of our true fathers, those who argued against the Federalists and their Constitution: the anti-Federalists. Think, for a moment, how easy it is to lay your hands on a copy of </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Federalist Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. Now ask if you have ever seen a bound copy of </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Anti-Federalist Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> — the public-essay responses to </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">The Federalist Papers</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. It is so obscure a collection of texts that my copy is a 10-by-10-foot, 30-pound print-on-demand paperback. My mailman dragged it to my door by rope. The only copy of the complete papers issued by a publisher costs $450, from the University of Chicago Press, in PDF form </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">only</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. Yet these are the writings of America’s true founders. These are the disquisitions of America’s original intent, and original </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">dissent</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, and today they read with the prescience of Nostradamus.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The true founders were stolen from us, and the nation was deceived as to Madison et al.’s intentions partially through language. These men (and woman: Mercy Otis Warren of Boston) did not call themselves “anti-Federalists” — the Federalists burdened them with that epithet as a smear. For up until the end of the Convention, the terms “confederation” and “federation” were used interchangeably. A supporter of a confederal system — the original system established by the Articles of Confederation — was a “Federalist” </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">or</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> “Confederalist,” and it meant the same thing. Thus the Philadelphia Convention was alternatively referred to as the </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Federal</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> Convention without indicating profound seismographic change. By branding their opponents anti-Federalists, the supporters of a central (federal) government made </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">them</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> seem like the ones attacking the gains of the Revolution, when the opposite was true. Timorously, I float renaming the anti-Federalists the Confederalists, but one must sail a narrow straight between accuracy and the unrelated implications of “Confederate” and “Confederacy.” So let us continue with the scurrilous though historical “anti-Federalists,” for now. </span></p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">“Despite their tragic foresight, the anti-Federalists failed to stop the Constitution.”</div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Chief among these men were the Founding Fathers Patrick Henry and George Mason of Virginia; George Clinton, the first governor of New York and fourth vice president of the United States; the New York merchant Melancton Smith; the Founding Father and fifth president, James Monroe; Massachusetts writer Mercy Otis Warren; the Maryland super-lawyer Luther Martin; and attorney and Founding Father Robert Yates of New York. The anti-Federalists, often using pseudonyms of  ancient republicans — Agrippa, Brutus, Cato, Centinel IV, Cincinnatus, Columbian Patriot, Philadelphiensis — predicted that the Constitution would lead to civil war, an imperial presidency, the dissolution of individual liberties, a military-industrial complex, limitless taxation, soaring debt, a congress of distant self-enriching aristocrats, and no constraint on the growth of power.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">“What, then, are we to think of the motives and designs of those men who are urging the implicit and immediate adoption of the proposed government?” asked Bryan (“Centinel IV”). “Are they fearful that if you exercise your good sense and discernment, you will discover the masked aristocracy that they are attempting to smuggle upon you under the suspicious garb of republicanism? In many of the states, particularly in this and the Northern states, there are aristocratic juntos of the well-born few who had been zealously endeavoring since the establishment of their constitutions to humble that offensive upstart, equal liberty.”</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Despite their tragic foresight, the anti-Federalists failed to stop the Constitution. They failed, too, to embed themselves in the collective memory of modern America. However, their dissent was powerful enough to force the adoption of the first 10 amendments to the Constitution in the form of the Bill of Rights, a codification of the republican principles of the Articles of Confederation. Many of the supposedly liberty-loving “Federalists” fought tooth and nail against the Bill during ratification and for years afterward, claiming the amendments were redundant and their principles already implicit in the Constitution. Yeah right! </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">Now</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> you may spit out your wine, sir! The Bill of Rights has, of course, been the only legitimate constraint on the entropy of the federal government, the only bulwark we have against censorship and mass surveillance, and even so it buckles. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The anti-Federalists conceived of their Bill of Rights as educative on civil liberty for the succeeding generations of Americans. The amendments “can inspire and conserve the affection for the native country, they will be the first lesson of the young citizens becoming men, to sustain the dignity of their being,” said Melancton Smith. It is the most cited element of the Constitution in legal cases, the foundation of Americans’ conception of their identity, and the basis of international human-rights charters, so ahead of its time that Europe has still never caught up to the First Amendment and routinely and shamefully imprisons its citizens for reposting memes or disparaging religions. Imagine America without these protections. As I write, Congress is trying to do away with the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act’s requirement that the government obtain warrants for surveillance of private citizens, and is trying to forever wed America’s military and intelligence to a foreign nation — that is, replace its yearly funding of the Israeli military with a permanent coordinating office for the purpose in the Pentagon. Compared to the Bill of Rights, it is the Constitution itself that has dissolved: the president may declare war at will, the national-security apparatus forms an illegal fourth branch of government that cannot be voted into or out of power, and so on. </span></p>
<p style="text-align: center;"><strong>* * * * *</strong></p>
<p>And does this not create<span style="font-weight: 400;"> a psychosis in a people: to be lied to, to have buried deep in the unconscious the truth that we are bastard children, that our fathers are false fathers and our true ancestors are hidden from us? The original 10 amendments are our ancient identity, and yet we do not know the names of their authors. </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">We do not quite know they existed</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. The anti-Federalists and their spirit have entered the roll call of oblivion.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">But must we repine? Yes, a little. A little. We must grow drunk. For in our cybernetic age, our synapses grow in arbitrary patterns around unnecessary phone-related cerebrations. We have formed new habits of mind around addictions to stagnation — and only alcohol can destroy enough brain cells to return us to our original minds. So let us drink deep in our cups, and see the paradox of our psychology.</span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/03/why-cormac-mccarthy-stopped-reading-new-novels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/03/why-cormac-mccarthy-stopped-reading-new-novels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/image-11.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/03/why-cormac-mccarthy-stopped-reading-new-novels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author </span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/03/why-cormac-mccarthy-stopped-reading-new-novels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why Cormac McCarthy stopped reading new novels</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/03/why-cormac-mccarthy-stopped-reading-new-novels/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Vincenzo Barney</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Firstly, our debates today about “original intent” begin only after our original intent was forever dissolved. This is not unmystical on the part of the villainous Federalists. The Federalists were the last men of this Earth to </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">create a myth</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. The Theory of Inflation (cosmic, not monetary) teaches us that pre-creation is subject to different laws of physics, so by dissolving the Articles and creating anew, the Federalists called down the deific power to alter the American language, tamper with and rewrite our history, banish the memory of an entire generation of souls, and forge a new American psychology. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Nations have psyches. By consolidating 13 countries down to one, our illegitimate fathers created a single, distant, and unnatural center over which 340 million Americans and counting now shall fight until the end of time, impotently, through two accepted factions that are really but two wings of the same party. Our legislators and officials are aristocratic and do not represent the people but the interests of the ruling class. But this travesty aside, the unnatural American center severely simplifies our openness to political possibility and creates a messianic impulse. It creates a righteous instinct to centralize everyone else. What is more American than to think, “I alone am right, and not only are </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">you</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> wrong, but </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">I</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> have the power to implement what I know to be right </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">over</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> you, even though you are thousands of miles away in an alien clime”? </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">As America expanded into an empire, this centralized psychology followed in lockstep. What was wokeness but the most recent patriotic reflection of the American psyche? What was </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">American democracy</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> but a projection of the fragile American psyche that had to be defended over the course of the past century in such far-flung places as Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, and Kuwait? What is more fragile than, say, a Brooklyner’s temperament, which can only be pacified by forcing blue-collar Texans to use preferred pronouns? No American mind can sleep at night unless the entire world operates according to its wishes — to centralize individual beliefs over a vast foreign territory is America itself!</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">The gravitational field of our fabricated constitutional origin bends all thoughts of what is politically possible to its centralized target and gelds all heterodox political thought. This explains horseshoe theory: it is the consolidation of political possibility into a straight line, warped in a curve around an arbitrary gravitational center. Thus, the Marxist gazes across and is startled to see the libertarian. The uniform perception of a singular origin also works backward in time: the hack historian collectivizes all evils and attributes them to a singular point. The sins of the fathers are applied backward to a false singular origin, a false singular consensus. So whereas Pennsylvania and all of New England had already abolished slavery in their states by the Convention in 1787, they are held equal in guilt to the secessionist South. It becomes educative to tell the children of our nation that </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">all</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> of America is slaverously evil. </span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Once every other generation a historian tries to breathe life back into the anti-Federalists, but even here their breath hiccups in the false language of American centralization. Herbert J. Storing’s </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">What the Anti-Federalists Were For</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, the last to attempt it in 1981, critiques our real fathers for being united in opposition of the Constitution, but without being collectively </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">for </span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">anything. Of course, lack of a positive consensus is only a defect in a centralized framework. The anti-Federalists were united on </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">heterogeneity</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. The political structure they agreed upon was a confederation, in which they enjoyed the freedom of not having to be in agreement across state lines on anything at all. In fact, the nature of a confederation necessitated they </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">not</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;"> be in consensus on imposing a national structure, for such a power was not within the mandate of state constitutions. This is the very soul of </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">decentralization</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">. </span></p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/how-the-constitution-failed-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/how-the-constitution-failed-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/lind-founding.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/how-the-constitution-failed-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/how-the-constitution-failed-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How the Constitution failed America</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2026/06/how-the-constitution-failed-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Michael Lind</a></p></div></a></div>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Yes, the modern American mind is </span><i><span style="font-weight: 400;">centralized</span></i><span style="font-weight: 400;">, and</span> <span style="font-weight: 400;">we also do suffer under the psychosis of false origin and treasonous birth. Add to this the historical fact that centralization kills thinking and leads to postmodernism. Consider: Western philosophy, born in a confederation of disparate Greek city states, was destroyed by Alexander the Great’s centralization of empire. Also, the Hellenistic centralization of learning in Alexandria severed the connection between philosophy and praxis in the city state, and ushered in the defeatist, solipsistic era of Greek postmodernism in the form of the Cynics and Skeptics who ran the Greek Academy until Rome’s capitulation to censorious Christianity and the Dark Ages, in which even Etruria’s arch was gambled away. The American consolidation of 13 countries into one under a single authority was a quasi-imperial act, and killed all political possibility save for accelerated consolidation. Everything we’ve achieved since has been but a caged stride.</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Are you ready to wonder at what America would look like if it had remained a confederation? This is where the ergot kicks in. Perhaps we would have grouped into separate confederacies. Perhaps Aaron Burr would have succeeded in making himself king of Mexico. There being no prohibition on how the states could arrange themselves, perhaps some states would have gone monarchical, while others on the same border went Marxist and still others pushed the bounds of libertarianism further into direct democracy. Perhaps a decentralized confederation is the only political structure in which those red herrings Marxism and libertarianism can be captured. Perhaps Virginia would today be an aristocratic republic and Massachusetts a liberal monarchy. Perhaps it is the bloated gravity of central government that bends the political spectrum into a horseshoe, whereas all forms of government are supposed to exist coterminously, in a constellation. Perhaps the southern states would have resolved slavery of their own volitions, and without ruinous reconstruction imposed upon them, consequently never imbedding in themselves such deep resentful racism. Perhaps Europe would have fought World War I to an even draw all by its lonesome without American interference, and so the scales wouldn’t have been so tipped against Germany that it elected a genocidal Charlie Chaplin impersonator to lead it into even worse rubble. Perhaps, then, the Soviet Union would have collapsed much more quickly and organically, with less harm done on its outskirts. Perhaps now, we would have decentralized finance, without the middlemen of bankers and creditors, such a structure could exist again. Perhaps, when we get to Mars, we could….</span></p>
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">But we must end on the road to this mystery, these cellar stairs down to the founding casks. For if spacetime curves all straight lines and the universe goes on forever, we may find ourselves tracing a circle and thus rounding back on our beginnings, our Greek and Etruscan confederal origins. They once bordered each other on the Italian peninsula, the Etruscans and Greeks. On the boundary of these nations, just as Etruria’s confederation began to wane to Rome, the pre-Socratic philosopher Parmenides was born and lodged the first recorded argument against oblivion. Nothingness does not exist, he said, for that which is not can’t be. The closest counter-argument we have is the oblivious American mind, which can never hold a memory long. But suppose the physicists are right, and something comes from nothing. Come, let us revel. Watch your head on the stairs.</span></p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2026/07/americas-other-constitution/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1065699</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Size mattered for the Founding Fathers</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2026/06/size-mattered-for-the-founding-fathers/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2026/06/size-mattered-for-the-founding-fathers/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/GettyImages-544285512.jpg?w=522</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>America 250</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Andrea Wulf]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/wolfie.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[The Rocky Mountains were symbols of American greatness. (Credit: VCG Wilson/Corbis/Getty)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Andrea Wulf</strong> is a historian and author. Her latest book is <i>The Traveller: The Revolutionary Life of George Forster and His Search for Humanity</i>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>andrea_wulf</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a historian and author. Her latest book is <i>The Traveller: The Revolutionary Life of George Forster and His Search for Humanity</i>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 28 Jun 2026 23:01:45 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 29 Jun 2026 11:54:15 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[America 250]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Founding fathers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://unherd.com/?p=1065057</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Horticultural obsessions sowed the national story]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><img decoding="async" class="alignnone" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/America-250.jpg" alt="America 250" /></p>
<p>In the summer of 1776, just a few weeks after the Thirteen Colonies had declared their independence, George Washington was in New York, preparing for the first and biggest fight of the Revolutionary War. His army was about to face more than 30,000 British troops — the largest enemy fleet ever to reach American shores. He inspected fortifications, monitored British movements on Staten Island, and rallied his men. But, on 19 August, as New York braced itself for battle, Washington put aside his military maps and turned his attention to Mount Vernon, his plantation in Virginia.</p>
<p>That evening, he wrote a long letter to his estate manager, instructing him to design a new garden filled with trees and shrubs from the American forest. With the chaos of cannons and blood looming, the commander-in-chief thought of soaring white pines and tulip trees, alabaster dogwood and stately red cedars. Only American native species should be used, he insisted. As the young nation faced its first military confrontation in the name of liberty, Washington decided that Mount Vernon was to be an American garden where English trees were not allowed to claw their roots in the soil. It was Washington’s horticultural declaration of independence.</p>
<p>This week, the United States celebrates its 250th birthday. There will be flyovers, airshows, historical re-enactments, military parades, concerts, exhibitions and street parties. The Founding Fathers will be quoted, misinterpreted and used for political gain — as they have been for decades. Yet amid the celebrations, there is a very important aspect of these men, in particular the first four presidents, that has largely been forgotten: their love for the natural world.</p>
<p>As Washington’s letter so vividly implies, he grasped the importance of nature for the country’s identity and future. Certainly not everything the Founders did was great — not least given their fields and gardens were tended and cultivated by enslaved workers — but if American conservatives wish to invoke their writings and legacy, they might benefit from taking a broader view of their beliefs.</p>
<p>The Founding Fathers’ vegetable plots, ornamental plants, landscapes and forests played a crucial role in America’s struggle for national identity. Golden cornfields and endless rows of cotton became symbols of America’s economic independence from Britain; towering trees became a reflection of a strong and vigorous nation; native species were imbued with patriotism and proudly planted in gardens. Even political language drew on the natural world: with the Tree of Liberty the most potent example. Indeed, George Washington, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson and James Madison all agreed that agriculture should be the foundation of the new republic. In 1787, Jefferson wrote that “our governments will remain virtuous for many centuries; as long as they are chiefly agricultural”, while Washington dreamed of an agrarian society where “our Swords and Spears have given place to the plough share and pruning hook”. Madison thought agriculture the “surest basis of our national happiness, dignity and independence”, quipping that they were “worshippers of Ceres”, the Roman goddess of agriculture.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;There is a very important aspect of these men, in particular the first four presidents, that has largely been forgotten: their love for the natural world.&#8221;</div>
<p>These were not abstract ideas; the Founders eagerly experimented with crop rotation, soil improvement and new farming methods. Jefferson famously designed the mold board of a plow and with the help of his enslaved workers grew 125 different varieties of fruit trees and 330 varieties of vegetables and herbs, constantly testing new varieties. “The greatest service which can be rendered any country,” he wrote, “is to add an useful plant to its culture.” And today it is almost unimaginable that Washington refused a third presidential term because he wished to return to his fields and gardens. Most Americans expected him to remain in office for life. Instead, he demurred, longing for Mount Vernon’s fields and gardens. Washington was also the first to collect farm dung in a specifically designed building. They were all, in fact, obsessed with manure. Adams experimented extensively, mixing dung with mud, lime and seaweed — and when he was the American minister in London, he even visited a manure heap on the outskirts of the city. While other diplomats rushed powdered and bejeweled through the corridors of St James’s Palace, Adams carefully poked through the stinking pile and clearly didn’t mind the muck on his hands. He noted its ingredients, and triumphantly concluded that it was “not equal to mine”.</p>
<p>To modern readers, this might seem an odd obsession. But it was key to a larger political vision. While agriculture provided the livelihood for most Americans, the Founding Fathers also believed that independent farmers with small self-sufficient farms would be the guardians of liberty. Seemingly mundane tasks such as collecting manure, planting seeds, plowing and improving soils were therefore political acts and elemental parts of nation-building. The more prosperous farmers there were, Madison argued, “the more free, the more independent, and the more happy must be the society itself”.</p>
<p>But there was a geopolitical element to their obsession with nature, too — reaching beyond their shores and freighted with the idea of national identity. Jefferson, in particular, was motivated by this as he took umbrage against what was known as the “degeneracy theory”. Most famously advanced by the French naturalist Comte du Buffon, this theory posited that the New World was inferior to the Old World: American plants, animals and even people were believed to be smaller, weaker and less vigorous than their European counterparts.</p>
<p>They all “shrink and diminish under a niggardly sky &amp; unprolific land”, Buffon claimed. As these theories spread, the natural world of the United States became a metaphor for its political and cultural significance — or insignificance — depending on your viewpoint. Jefferson, naturally, was irked. And if size was Buffon’s measure of superiority, then Jefferson reasoned he only needed to prove that everything was larger and stronger in the New World. He immersed himself in natural history books, collected measurements of American wildlife, and asked correspondents across the country to provide data on the largest specimens they could find.</p>
<p>As part of his campaign to debunk the idea of American degeneracy, he arrived in Paris, in 1784, bearing an “uncommonly large panther skin” in his luggage. He likewise boasted to Buffon that the Scandinavian reindeer “could walk under the belly of our moose” and eventually arranged for an enormous moose from Vermont to be shipped across the Atlantic to prove his point. America’s flora and fauna were enlisted in a patriotic campaign to demonstrate the strength of the republic. Later, as president, Jefferson even briefly kept two live grizzly bears on the grounds of the White House. Under the banner of “the-bigger-the-better”, Jefferson used the size of animals and trees to prove his point — perhaps the one measure of greatness that President Trump would agree with. Yet where Jefferson sought grandeur in forests, wildlife and landscapes, Trump prefers monumental architecture, gold leaf and spectacle.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/californias-woes-were-born-in-england/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/californias-woes-were-born-in-england/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/GettyImages-1258332093.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/californias-woes-were-born-in-england/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/californias-woes-were-born-in-england/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>California&#039;s woes were born in England</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/californias-woes-were-born-in-england/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Leighton Woodhouse</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Following the end of the War of Independence, in 1783, the former colonies had to mature from being a war alliance to being a united nation. The Constitution bound them together politically and legally, but nature provided a transcendent feeling of nationhood, a shared sense of belonging. What previous generations had regarded as a hostile wilderness gradually became an object of national pride. The vast forests, expansive rivers and dramatic mountains became expressions of a singularly American character. The continent’s scale suggested strength and possibility; its wildness was the embodiment of a nation that had freed itself from the shackles of tyranny. Landscape had a political value. And in 1791, Jefferson asked the artist John Trumbull to paint Virginia’s Natural Bridge, so that he could present “to the world this singular landscape, which otherwise some bungling European will misrepresent”.</p>
<p>The return of Meriwether Lewis and William Clark from their expedition across the continent to the Pacific coast in 1806 reinforced these ideas. Primeval forests, vast plains, spectacular waterfalls — all became symbols of national greatness. Americans were convinced that the Rockies were more commanding than the Alps and that the Potomac rivaled the Rhine. John Adams dismissed the Thames as “but a rivulet” compared with the majestic Hudson, while Abigail Adams believed that nature possessed “greater magnificence and sublimity in America than in any part of Europe”.</p>
<p>Besides, America’s landscapes were untainted by centuries of monarchy and despotism. Where Europe’s antiquity became associated with tyranny and corruption, the American wilderness represented freedom and renewal. Why should they admire “the temples which Roman robbers have reared”, wrote the poet Charles Fenno Hoffman, when America’s nature was untouched by the blood of tyrants?  This connection between patriotism and nature remains visible in America’s national mythology. The nation’s hearts are filled with pride as they sing the songs of their beloved landscapes. As “America the Beautiful” describes it: the “amber waves of grain, / For purple mountain majesties / Above the fruited plain!” Or “From the mountains, to the prairies, / To the oceans, white with foam”, in &#8220;God Bless America&#8221;<i>.</i><i></i></p>
<p>It is ironic, then, that the Trump administration, a fervent advocate of bigger-is-better politics, is introducing environmental policies which include major rollbacks of federal regulations, withdrawal from the Paris Agreement, and proposed draconian cuts to the National Park Service. While Republicans frequently refer to the Founders in defense of limited government or gun control, they rarely acknowledge that one of them is also the forgotten father of American environmentalism: James Madison. In 1818, Madison <a href="https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/04-01-02-0244" target="_blank" rel="noopener">delivered a widely published speech</a> to the Albemarle Agricultural Society, which places him at the vanguard of American forest and soil conservation. In this speech, Madison warned about the destructive effect of deforestation and large-scale tobacco cultivation on the environment, challenging the assumption that nature “can be made subservient to the use of man”. At Montpelier, his plantation in Virginia, he even protected a part of the woodlands: the first American politician to preserve a forest.</p>
<p>Though Madison’s speech is largely forgotten today, it deserves recognition as one of the founding documents of the United States. It offers a reminder, as America celebrates its 250th birthday, that the Founders’ vision extended beyond political institutions and the Constitution. They believed that the republic depended not only on laws and liberty — but also on healthy soils, productive farms, thriving forests, and a respect for the natural world. Jefferson held this deeply, expressing it <a href="https://www.colorado.edu/herbst/sites/default/files/attached-files/nov_2_-_constitution.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">in a letter to Madison in 1789</a>. “The earth,” he wrote, “belongs in usufruct to the living”. No generation possesses the right to exhaust or permanently diminish what it has inherited, and each receives the Earth from its predecessors and holds it in trust for those who follow. “The dead have neither powers nor rights over it”, Jefferson explained, “the earth belongs to each of these generations, during its course, fully, and in their own right. The 2d. generation receives it clear of the debts and incumberances [sic] of the 1st. the 3d of the 2d. and so on.” It is an idea that resonates as strongly today as it did at the founding of the republic, whatever the sitting president might claim.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2026/06/size-mattered-for-the-founding-fathers/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1065057</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>John Quincy Adams never stopped fighting</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2025/12/john-quincy-adams-never-stopped-fighting/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2025/12/john-quincy-adams-never-stopped-fighting/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/Screenshot-2025-12-21-at-13.12.16-e1766322942872.jpg?w=519</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Christmas Read</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[William T. Vollmann]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Blue-50-1.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[John Singleton Copley's portrait of John Quincy Adams. (Wikipedia Commons)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>William T. Vollmann</strong> is an American novelist, journalist, war correspondent, short story writer, and essayist.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle></unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an American novelist, journalist, war correspondent, short story writer, and essayist.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 29 Dec 2025 00:02:39 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 30 Dec 2025 08:44:55 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[America]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Civil War]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[diaries]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Founding fathers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[John Quincy Adams]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[slavery]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://unherd.com/?p=1042007</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[His diaries reveal an anti-slavery obsession]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>On the young side of the publisher’s box we see a delicately handsome fellow in v-necked black, with white lace flowering just below his throat. His wig is powdered and he gazes down and away with a quarter-smile. His expression would have been composed by arrangement with the painter, John Singleton Copley. But more than most of us he hated falsity, and the longer I study him the more I intuit some quietly, pleasantly unyielding quality, as might be expected from this brilliantly ambitious gentleman who was born for politics, taught and quizzed by his father’s law clerks, further educated by hearing the cannonade at Bunker Hill, taken to France by his father, who was treating with France, carried home and back again, by which time it was 1779, and John Quincy Adams was 12.</p>
<p>That was when he began his diary: 50 volumes, 14,000 manuscript pages, 69 years. He studied Latin in Holland, became a legate’s interpreter in Russia, whose diplomatic language was fortunately French (he had not yet learned Russian, but would be the only American president who ever troubled to do so); and after jaunting to the Hague, London and France, where his father signed a peace treaty between the United States and His Britannic Majesty, he sailed home and in 1785 was admitted to Harvard. He had gifts, he did.</p>
<p>Copley’s portrait dates from 1796. The subject had become a dour egghead in the Charles Osgood portrait of 1828: balding on top, thickly white-haired from the temples almost down to his naked chin. Old age caught him staring wearily, jowly but still pugnacious at the camera when Matthew Brady took his daguerreotype. The elderly side of the publisher’s box flatters him with the smooth, ruddy baldness of middle age and an almost youthful half-smile, never mind that it is now more tightly accomplished by thinner lips. He was 59, with 40 years to go.</p>
<p>Thus the front and back of his life-box. Within it stand a two-volume selection of his mental remains.</p>
<p>His world is dead, his diplomatic triumphs grown as antique as some oil painting cracked and crazed, his one-term presidency stymied like his father’s, his hopes disappointed, but only provisionally: he being one of those who entrust the future to God. His written thoughts have faded in proportion to their historical context, and his exposition is archaic (Ben Franklin once complained that capitalizing nouns was going out of style in our language, but Adams kept the faith); whenever I tune my eyes to them, they fascinate, then astonish me with true stories of stubborn patience and toilsome courage, <em>for a good cause</em>. There goes Don Quixote Adams again, doing battle with monsters disguised as windmills!</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;There goes Don Quixote Adams again, doing battle with monsters disguised as windmills!&#8221;</div>
<p>I inhabit evil times. I watch the ruination of my planet and the moral suicide of the nation which Adams sometimes fought against to fight for, and it makes me cynical. Being cynical is not all bad. Sometimes it can be fun. But it is mostly sad and tiring to stop believing in whatever it was I believed in, such as that I could still “make a difference”, or could at least be brave. Both of which remained possible, but with everything around me getting worse so rapidly, it was convenient to pretend that trying to do anything worthwhile would be comical. But then I opened the diaries of John Quincy Adams, and met someone who had also sorrowed over the degradation and oncoming violence in the America he loved.</p>
<p>As David Waldstreicher, the diaries’ present editor, tells it: “Confronted by the implications of American expansionism, Adams found his room for maneuver increasingly narrowed… His speeches and messages during the years of his presidency sought to advance union, &#8216;improvement&#8217; and good government while carefully stepping over the trip wires of slavery and partisanship.” In my version, Adams finally stepped off the narrow path, bushwhacked into radical compassion and became a hated heroic failure, or if you like a successful practitioner of moral politics. You see, he got sadder, not least on account of his own disappointments — his political defeats, money troubles, his beloved wife’s miscarriages, the stunted or abbreviated lives of several of their children, his two brothers who drank themselves into the grave — and thanks to these losses he could finally revolt against the stench of injustice. So he turned his back on party loyalty, faced the evil thing, took up arms against it and kept fighting it for the rest of his life. I, his reader, know as he could not that we would eventually see his cause as right and righteous. It made headway in his time, and partially succeeded. Sometimes somebody succeeds. Sometimes a dead man’s words can raise me up by proving that it is not too late to do something right.</p>
<p style="text-align: center">***</p>
<p>Nowadays we would dub him a “workaholic”: Minister Resident to the Netherlands in 1794, Minister Plenipotentiary to Russia three years later, while his father commenced being President; Senator from 1802 until 1808, when he resigned because his party was about to discard him for anti-Federalist heresies. (Throughout his life, with noble disgust, he declined to put himself forward for office. If asked to serve, he would do it, but never stumped or canvassed.  “In the mean time,” he told his diary, “I implore the Spirit from whom every good descends to enable me to render essential Service to my Country, and that I may never be governed in my public conduct by any consideration other than my duty.”)</p>
<p>In 1809, he returned to Saint Petersburg, where he and Tsar Alexander sometimes greeted each other on the street. Declining an appointment to the US Supreme Court, he stayed in place for Napoleon’s invasion. Meanwhile, the War of 1812 was raging, and the British were invading Detroit. We find him in Paris when Napoleon escaped captivity at Elba and began the Hundred Days: “There was a great crowd of People upon the Boulevards; but the cries of Vive l’Empereur had already been substituted for Vive le Roi.” Then at the Court of Saint James, already balding and careworn, Adams negotiated peace with the British at Ghent. The diaries bring to life his exhausting grind of facing down the old enemy’s resentment and contempt. Adams dug in his heels as stubbornly as would the 20th century’s Molotov. In 1817-25, he became President Madison’s Secretary of State, crafting not only the Adams-Onís Treaty that secured Florida from Spain but also the famous Monroe Doctrine: “You Europeans stop meddling on our territory and we’ll return the favor.” He tried and failed to persuade America to adopt the metric system. His baldness widened and elongated.</p>
<p>Then he became a president aspiring to bless his country with canals and roads, a national university, an academy for the young Navy, an astronomical observatory; but got stymied by his enemies, who reveled in accusing this incorruptible man of corruption. Losing his reelection, he retired just in time for the suicide of the son he had named after George Washington. Unmoved by sneers about his fall from president to congressman, in 1831 he entered the House of Representatives, and in 1844 he became its dean, or longest-serving member. They called him “Old Man Eloquent”. He futilely denounced the Mexican War, and opposed slavery in defiance of censure, execration and threats. He worked himself into ancientness, dying of a brain bleed in the Speaker’s chamber of the House. Don’t pity him; his work was his pleasure. In his mid-thirties, he admits to his diary: “&#8230;The interest with which my mind seizes hold of the public business, is greater than suits my comfort or can answer any sort of public utility.”</p>
<p style="text-align: center">***</p>
<p>Before I get down to the diaries themselves, please let me compare them to his public speeches, in which he could be bitterly <em>funny</em>, as in these remarks to other Representatives in 1842:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">He talks to us about the star of Texas, which he calls “the lone star of Liberty.” Liberty of Texas! The star illumined by the radiance of slavery restored!&#8230; [Mexico had recently abolished slavery.] So, I suppose, if war shall come, we shall not only acquire this solitary brilliant star of Texas, but we shall have all Mexico added to the United States. Sir, the Isthmus of Panama will hardly stop our victorious arms, and I really wonder the gentleman did not carry us on to Cape Horn. [A laugh.]. And he means, in this heroic enterprise, to lead on the brave spirits of thousands from the great valley of the Mississippi, inspired by the hope of robbing churches and priests. So it is to be a religious as well as a civil expedition — a sort of crusade, in which the gentleman from Virginia is likely far to transcend the exploits of Tamerlane and Genghis Khan… I look forward to the time when the gentleman’s name shall be placed side by side… with that of a still more glorious conqueror by the name of <em>Tom Thumb</em>. [Roars of laughter, long and loud.]
<p>In distinction to these scintillating razor-cuts, the diaries often come across as melancholy and bitter. John Quincy Adams was so modest that he often disappointed himself. He certainly disappointed others. He and the slave-owning politicos hated one another — and he had a spiteful streak.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/you-cant-steal-a-cossacks-soul/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/you-cant-steal-a-cossacks-soul/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/cossack.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/you-cant-steal-a-cossacks-soul/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/you-cant-steal-a-cossacks-soul/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>You can’t steal a Cossack’s soul</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/you-cant-steal-a-cossacks-soul/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> William Vollmann</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Like his father, he detested Thomas Jefferson, whose assertion in the Declaration of Independence that “all men are created equal” sounded phony — for Adams subscribed to republicanism, not democracy. “And that too great an equality of the Citizens, is prejudicial to the Liberty of the whole, the present alarming Situation of our own Country will I think afford us a sufficient Proof.” In other words, he had made up his mind about equality by the time he was 20 — for this diary entry dates from 1786, a year before the Constitutional Convention drafted its mealymouthed allusion to “the Migration or Importation of such Persons as any of the States now existing shall think proper to admit”, which referred to trafficking slaves from Africa. Though he continued “carefully stepping over the trip wires of slavery and partisanship”, he was, in private, an anti-slavery partisan. That Jefferson was the same in public rendered him to Adams an opportunistic, windy-minded hypocrite. Jefferson prated of emancipation while keeping slaves! In 1802, Adams anonymously published a vicious lampoon about the “sage of Monticello’s” bedroom sports with Sally Hemmings, a woman he owned.</p>
<p>Slavery simply incensed Adams. In 1819, haunted by what he could foresee, he advised the diaries:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">His Declaration of Independence is an abridged Alcoran of political doctrine, laying open the first foundations of civil society — but he does not appear to have been aware that it also laid open a precipice into which the Slave-owning Planters of his Country, sooner or later must fall… Jefferson has been himself all his life a Slave-holder, but has published opinions so blasting to the very existence of Slavery, that however creditable they may be to his candor and humanity, they speak not much for his prudence… The seeds of the Declaration of Independence are yet maturing — The Harvest will be what West the Painter calls the terrible sublime.</p>
<p>These words inspire me with dread. I look around me, awaiting the next visitation of the “terrible sublime.” Nobody can stop it now. Maybe no one ever can. In 1861, Abraham Lincoln could not prevent the Civil War even though he promised never to interfere with slavery. Forty-two years earlier, Adams could not prevent it, either. But I love him because he kept trying. More principled in this than gentle, kindly Lincoln, whose heart bled for the slaves but who put the Union first, he wrote in 1820: “If the Union must be dissolved, Slavery is precisely the question on which it ought to break.”</p>
<p style="text-align: center">***</p>
<p>I love Jefferson for what he wrote. His trust in people’s power is beautifully radical. When I quote him unattributed on, for example, the desirability of periodic revolts against government, some neighbors tell me that I sound kind of like one of them goddamned Communists. Adams was another radical. Why couldn’t those two have “done something?” His diaries ever so logically reply:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">The Declaration of Independence, not only asserts the natural equality of all men, and their unalienable right to Liberty; but that the only <em>just</em> powers of government are derived from the consent of the governed. A power for one part of the people to make slaves of the other cannot be derived from consent, and is therefore not a just power.</p>
<p>Adams was still Secretary of State. Like Lincoln, he expressed his anguish but kept it in its place. But remember, Lincoln did emancipate the slaves. To do so, he needed to be elected President. That meant expressing disgust (which might have been unfeigned) at “Negro equality”. In the Lincoln-Douglas debates of 1857, he could always squeeze laughs out of the electorate at the thought of his marrying a Negro wench — no diamond ring for Sally Hemmings! As for Adams, what was <em>he</em> supposed to do about slavery? How could one even talk about it in government? His Southern colleagues could be charming enough on other subjects:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">But when probed to the quick upon it they show at the bottom of their Souls, pride and vain glory in their very condition of masterdom — They fancy themselves more generous and noble-hearted than the freemen who labor for subsistence — They look down upon the simplicity of a yankey’s manners because he… cannot treat negroes like dogs.</p>
<p>As we have overheard him confessing, Adams was addicted to politics. He might not have been as ambitious as Jefferson, but then again, maybe he was. In that case he’d better be careful.</p>
<p style="text-align: center">***</p>
<p>One of the diaries’ pleasures is watching his empathy grow in private, and discovering that maturation’s public fruits.</p>
<p>He seems to have followed his conscience from the beginning. In 1808, when the Federalists turned him out of the Senate because he supported certain measures of the hated Jefferson, Adams made the following neat dark wormtracks in his diary:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">He said my principles were too pure for those with whom I was acting — and <em>they would not thank me for them</em> — I told him I did not want their thanks — He said they would not value me the more for them — I told him, I cared not whether they valued me for them or not — My character, such as it was, must stand upon its own ground, and not upon the bolstering of any man or party —</p>
<p>He opposed female suffrage. And he had nothing against Indian removal, because why should savages remain in possession of all those unimproved forests?</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">…In repelling an insolent charge of the British Plenipotentiaries against the Government of the United States of a series of perpetual encroachments upon the Indians under the pretense of purchases, I had taken the ground of the moral and religious duty of the Nation to settle, cultivate and improve their territory…</p>
<p>That was in 1814. But by 1839 he had long since woken up to the cruelties contingent on that “moral and religious duty”:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">I told them that the case of the Seneca Indians was hopeless. That a fraudulent Treaty coaxed, and bullied and bribed out of perhaps one tenth part of their chiefs and Warriors, was already sweeping them away beyond the Mississippi… I told them it was painful to me… but it was in vain to disguise or suppress the truth. — An inflexible determination to extirpate the race of Indian Savages was the white [man&#8217;s] law on the continent, and I feared it would be so till the race itself shall be exterminated from the face of the Earth.</p>
<p>That sounded hopeless. Being unable to “do something”, why did “Old Man Eloquent” not quit? A diary entry explains: “I received two days since a Letter from a Stranger” (a threatening letter, I presume) “advising me now to retire from the world, the only reason for my postponement which is that I cannot afford it.” Well, in fact there was a second reason: “More than 60 years of incessant intercourse with the world has made political movement to me as much a necessary of life as atmospheric air — This is the weakness of my nature, which I have intellect enough left to perceive, but not energy to control.”</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;This is the weakness of my nature, which I have intellect enough left to perceive, but not energy to control.”</div>
<p>As I said, John Quincy Adams was modest — more credit to him. His money troubles and addiction to politics were real enough, but so was his noble pugnacity. In 1831, aged 64, he had braced himself up for doom much as might have Odin awaiting the unconquerable monsters of Ragnarok:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">My life has been spent in stemming currents of popular opinions and until lately, with occasional and great success — But the runs of luck in life, are as at whist — The tide in the Affairs of men when it has once begun to ebb, will go down.  This free and bold expression of my opinion which I disdain to withhold will hasten my downward course, and nothing can redeem it — Let me fulfill my destiny; and so far as may be possible sustain my character.</p>
<p>Both of those he did. In 1840 he received petitioners:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">The two Seneca Indian chiefs… came this morning… to urge the presentation [against]&#8230; the fraudulent Treaty, by which they are to be driven like a herd of swine from their homes to a wilderness west of the Mississippi… I promised to speak for them… I was twice in the Supreme Court library room,&#8230; to open a Steam-battery, upon the argument in the case of the Amistad captives — but Oh! how impotent is my voice to fulfill the purpose of my heart!</p>
<p>La Amistad was a slave ship.  Her cargo had risen up, killed most of their tormentors and demanded to be ferried back to Africa. Tricked and captured in America, they were deposited in prison pending their probable extradition to the slavemasters of Spain.</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">[They] urged me to assume as assistant Counsel… the defense of the Africans captured in the Amistad, before the Supreme Court&#8230; — I endeavored to excuse myself upon the plea of my age and insufficiency [for by now Adams was 73]&#8230; — But they urged me so much and represented the case of these unfortunate men as so critical, it being a case of life and death, that I yielded,&#8230; and I implore the mercy of the Almighty God, so to control my temper, to enlighten my Soul and to give me utterance that I may prove myself in every respect equal to the task —</p>
<p>Please remember that this was the infamous “Taney Court”, whose Dred Scott decision of 1857 would decree that slaves remained slaves even where slavery was not the law of the land. Yet despite that, and despite his age, in February 1841, Adams described in his diary what happened.</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">With grateful heart for aid from above, though in humiliation for the weakness incident to the limits of my powers, I spoke for four hours and a half, with sufficient method and order to witness little flagging of attention, by the judges or the auditory… The structure of my argument… is perfectly simple and comprehensive — admitting… one fundamental principle,&#8230; invoking Justice, specially, aware that this was always the duty of the court; but… an immense array of power,&#8230; instigated by the Minister of a foreign Nation has been brought to bear in this case on the side of injustice…</p>
<p>On March 9 Adams “waited upon tenterhooks, half an hour before the meeting of the Court,” until Justice Story pronounced the Amistad mutineers free people. They could go home after all. Meanwhile, Adams was lamenting to his diary: “It is impossible to separate the discussion upon the African slave-trade, from the moral and political aspects of slavery; and that is with us a forbidden topic.”</p>
<p style="text-align: center">***</p>
<p>That was literally true. To prove that America honored equality and freedom of speech, in 1837 a Representative from South Carolina introduced the notorious “gag rule”, which prevented all mention of slavery in the House. With the same tenacity he had shown against the British plenipotentiaries at Ghent, Adams punched back for almost nine years. As he wrote in March 1841:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">I find impulses of duty upon my own conscience, which I cannot resist, while on the other hand,&#8230; the danger, the insurmountable burden of labor to be encountered in the undertaking to touch upon the Slave-trade. No one else will undertake it. — No one but a spirit unconquerable by Man, Woman or Fiend, can undertake it, but with the heart of Martyrdom… Let me but die upon the breach.</p>
<p>So he went on, in April 1841:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">The leading men of the North are all truckling to Southern slavery — They are all willing to desert Seward in the stand he has taken [against extraditing three free blacks to Virginia for helping a slave run away]. I see what it will cost me to stand by him, but I have so little political capital left, that the remnant is not worth saving — Especially at the cost of base desertion from the cause.</p>
<p>And again, on 18 January, 1842:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">I presented the petition of sundry citizens of Massachusetts praying that the benefits of the naturalization Laws may be extended to persons of color — [Virginia Representative Henry] Wise made objection to its reception…</p>
<p>On 24 January:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">. . . And I presented sundry other petitions — One from Benjamin Emerson of 45 others of Haverhill, Massachusetts, praying Congress, to take measures for peacefully dissolving the Union [so that Massachusetts would be no longer slavery-stained]&#8230;. — I moved its reference to a select Committee with instructions to report an answer assigning the reasons why the prayer of the petition should not be granted — Then came another explosion, and after snarling debate a Resolution offered by Thomas W. Gilmer, that I deserved the censure of the house…</p>
<p>The next day:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">At one Gilmer’s resolution of censure upon me was taken up — Thomas F. Marshall offered a much more violent one with a flaming preamble, charging me… with subornation of perjury and high treason… I finished [my reply] and was followed by Henry A. Wise, [who] in a speech of personal invective against me took nearly two hours…</p>
<p>And on into the following month. Here’s an excerpt from 4 February, 1842:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">I occupied the whole of this day in continuing my defense before the house [of Representatives] —… I specially refuted the pretence that the Union could be dissolved only by force, and cited the example of the peaceful dissolution of the confederation Union, by the present Constitution of the United States.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/10/thomas-pynchons-world-of-shadows/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/10/thomas-pynchons-world-of-shadows/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/pynchon.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/10/thomas-pynchons-world-of-shadows/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/10/thomas-pynchons-world-of-shadows/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Thomas Pynchon&#039;s world of shadows</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/10/thomas-pynchons-world-of-shadows/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> William Vollmann</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Two days later, Adams wrote:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">One hundred members of the house, represent Slaves, four fifths of whom [that is, of the members] would crucify me, if their votes could erect the cross — forty members representatives of the free in the league of Slavery and mock democracy, would break me on the wheel if their votes or wishes could turn it round — and four fifths of the other hundred and twenty are either so cold or so lukewarm, that they are ready to desert me at the first scintillation of indiscretion on my part.  The only formidable danger with which I am beset is my own temper.</p>
<p>On 7 February, the Representatives wearied in their persecution and tabled a motion to censure Adams. Yet his enemies weren’t done yet. In May 1842, he described receiving:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">…from the South almost daily letters of insult, profane obscenity and filth… Threats of Lynching and Assassination are the natural offspring of Slave-breeders and Slave-traders…</p>
<p>In September, he had attracted the ire of an even greater foe.</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">I have now on hand a controversial warfare with John Tyler, President of the United States; bitter personal hatred of five of the most depraved, most talented, and most influential men of this Country, four of them open and undisguised…</p>
<p>In October:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">I have deliberately assumed an aggressive position against the President, and his whole executive Administration — against the Supreme Court of the United States, and against the commander in chief of the army — I am at issue with all the organized powers of the Union — with the twelve hundred millions of associated wealth, and with all the rabid democracy of the land… But my cause is the Cause of my Country, and of human liberty. It is the cause of Christian improvement — the fulfillment of the prophecies, that the day shall come when Slavery and War shall be banished from the face of the Earth.</p>
<p>1843 would begin with Adams — now in his 75th year — promising legal advice to one “George Lattimer, arrested and claimed as a slave”. The very next day, a certain Moses Bell, having sued his master, was declared free by an all-white jury, after which the master appealed to the Supreme Court. Adams again “promised to do for him what I could.” Next came John Davies, whose wife’s son Joseph Clark was promised by his master that on the latter’s death he would work three years for a brother, then be freed. But the brother sold him, “and he is now in irredeemable Slavery for life… — Can I not possibly do something for this man?”</p>
<p style="text-align: center">***</p>
<p>On December 3, 1844, Adams moved that the gag rule be rescinded. “The question was then put on the resolution and it was carried 108 to 80 — blessed ever blessed be the name of God!” He finally died, aged 80, in February 1848. He never did see the light when it came to women’s suffrage, and it would surprise me to learn that he desired full social equality for African Americans (his satire against Jefferson and Sally Hemmings had a racist tinge.) He was, then, of his time — yet better than his time.</p>
<p>Let me leave you with one more of his sayings:</p>
<p style="padding-left: 40px">I believe the best guard against prejudice is a frequent examination of our opinions, and a cool estimate of the arguments opposed to them — You must as Cicero says identify yourself in imagination, first with your adversary and then with your judge — and above all you must have resolution to abide by the result even if it should be adverse to your preconceived opinions.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2025/12/john-quincy-adams-never-stopped-fighting/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">1042007</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Why Hamilton offends the Left</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2025/09/why-hamilton-offends-the-left/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2025/09/why-hamilton-offends-the-left/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/hamilton.jpg?w=700</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>10 years on</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Matt Feeney]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Guy-3-300x300-1.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>2</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['Many of Hamilton’s admirers already knew it was wrong.' Credit: Hamilton]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Matt Feeney </strong>is a writer based in California and the author of <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Little-Platoons-Defense-Family-Competitive/dp/1541645596" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Little Platoons: A defense of family in a competitive age.</em></a> You can follow him on X at @MattFeeney510.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle></unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is a writer based in California and the author of <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Little-Platoons-Defense-Family-Competitive/dp/1541645596" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Little Platoons: A defense of family in a competitive age.</em></a> You can follow him on X at @MattFeeney510.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 04 Sep 2025 23:01:39 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 04 Sep 2025 23:01:39 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[America]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Broadway]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Founding fathers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hamilton]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[musical theatre]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Politics]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Race]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://unherd.com/?p=762386</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The musical is free of racial guilt]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>It was via a mix of ubiquity and persistence that Lin-Manuel Miranda’s <em>Hamilton</em> put itself at the edge of my awareness in late 2015 and stayed there through much of the next year. I’d never been an enthusiast of musical theater, or even much interested in it. But<em> Hamilton</em>’s gathering presence as a pop-culture reference carried associations that were souring my passive indifference into something active and unfriendly.</p>
<p>The <em>Hamilton</em> buzz came with distasteful notes of official propriety, the same dead respectability carried by such names as “Barack Obama” and “<em>The New York Times”</em> and “NPR”. Indeed, in my own California neighborhood, a continent away from Broadway, I was beginning to see grey-haired liberal ladies carrying <em>Hamilton</em> tote bags. That the play was supposedly a mashup of the American Founding and hip-hop threatened to spoil both the American Founding and hip-hop for me.</p>
<p>And then, one morning late in 2016, I woke to find songs from <em>Hamilton</em> coming from my own stereo — the official cast recording of <em>Hamilton</em> had become urgently popular among American 10-year-olds, and my oldest child was 10 at the time. The final barrier between me and musical theater had been breached. But I couldn’t disdain those songs as I may have wanted to, since my daughter loved them so much, and since she and her friends were singing and rapping along to them with such charming exuberance. And since, well, some of those songs, some of that Broadway hip-hop, I had to admit I kind of liked. They were like… songs, pretty good songs. There was, for example, the winning Beatles bounce of “Washington on Your Side”, and the ingenious, absurdly infectious rhythms of “Wait for It”.</p>
<p>What really broke my resistance, though, was <em>Hamilton</em>’s hip-hop side. Now, a musical about America’s first secretary of the treasury is obviously miles away, in sensibility and setting and street cred, from what is generally considered hip-hop, which was fine because so am I. What of hip-hop <em>Hamilton</em> does have — rapid-fire rhymes and expert word-play — it has in abundance. I can only imagine how much fun it would be to deliver such lines from a stage. What I do know is it’s consistently a kick to hear them.</p>
<p>It wasn’t until the summer of 2020, though, when Disney Plus released a filmed version of a 2016 stage production of <em>Hamilton,</em> that I saw the play as a single work of musical theater, start to finish. And my official critical assessment of <em>Hamilton</em> would be that, dramatically or narratively, it is somewhat less than the sum of its parts. Still, those parts are pretty great. And the individual scenes built from the dozens of fun songs, the countless witty lines and clever couplets, create their own cumulative pleasure that more than compensates for the narrative flimsiness. (This may be how musical theater works in general. I wouldn’t know.)</p>
<p>By then the play’s public reputation, which had been in flux for several years, was in something like a crisis. Initially, back in 2015 and 2016, it had been an object of fervent public adulation among people with real power, including Obama. Its standing was so exalted that the play’s cast felt entitled to direct a pointed, critical plea at the Vice President-elect of the United States, Mike Pence, when he and his wife attended a <em>Hamilton</em> performance shortly after Donald Trump’s 2016 election victory. Speaking for the entire cast after the show, one actor addressed Pence directly, expressing anxiety that “your new administration will not protect us” — the “diverse America” the mostly black cast took itself to represent — “or defend us and uphold our inalienable rights”. He went on to express “hope” that Pence would be “inspired” by <em>Hamilton</em> “to uphold our American values”. In its melding of patriotic boilerplate and the language of Obama liberalism, this was a very <em>Hamilton</em> sort of message. (In retrospect, Trump’s whining response — saying the cast had “harassed” Pence and violated the “safe place” of the theater — reads as a weirdly literal omen of how New Right Machiavels like Chris Rufo and Stephen Miller would take up the campus Left’s weepy pretexts for punishing wrong-think when the chance arose.)</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/our-future-is-ai-serfdom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/our-future-is-ai-serfdom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/GettyImages-1239416791.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/our-future-is-ai-serfdom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested Reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/our-future-is-ai-serfdom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Our future is AI serfdom</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/08/our-future-is-ai-serfdom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> B. Duncan Moench</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>But by the time I finally watched <em>Hamilton</em> on Disney Plus, not quite four years later, America was two months into the “racial reckoning” incited by the killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer. An unprecedented moral pageantry of protest and public kneeling and rote apologies had just been underwritten by the strange but effective teamwork of multinational corporations and urban rioters. The play’s affirming take on the American Founding, with its multicultural casting and its fond portrayal of Alexander Hamilton and George Washington, had been a perfect sendoff for the Obama years, but it didn’t fit so well with this puritanical moment. Openly conjuring the Founding Fathers so as to adulate the nation they wrought was the sort of thing that could get you cancelled — and indeed, the hashtag #cancelhamilton was briefly a thing on Twitter. Miranda was accordingly scolded by <a href="https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2020/12/9/unpop-opinion-color-blind-casting/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Harvard students</a> and lectured by <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/05/opinions/hamilton-movie-mixed-messages-black-lives-matter-morales" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Columbia lecturers</a>. The 2020 backlash was not huge, but it was big enough that Miranda embarked on a minor apology tour that summer, in which he absorbed without complaint every bit of criticism that came his way and, of course, promised to do better.</p>
<p>In fact, a small number of people had been finding <em>Hamilton</em> problematic more or less from the beginning, and for reasons of simple historical fact that are pretty sound. For example, shortly after the show began its massive run at the Richard Rodgers Theatre on Broadway, in August 2015, the black novelist Ishmael Reed wrote a long and (characteristically) angry <a href="https://www.counterpunch.org/2015/08/21/hamilton-the-musical-black-actors-dress-up-like-slave-tradersand-its-not-halloween/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">essay</a> pointing out the historical errors and evasions that enable both Miranda and Ron Chernow, author of the bestselling <em>Alexander Hamilton</em> biography on which the play is based, to portray Hamilton as an early abolitionist. Hamilton does indeed seem to have disliked slavery and looked forward to its dissolution, and he was close friends with abolitionist dreamer John Laurens, and he was a founding member of the New York Manumission Society, which advocated the voluntary freeing of slaves by slaveowners. But, as Reed and others have pointed out, he married into a slave-owning family, seems to have <a href="https://parks.ny.gov/documents/historic-sites/SchuylerMansionAlexanderHamiltonsHiddenHistoryasanEnslaver.pdf" target="_blank" rel="noopener">owned slaves himself</a>, brokered the sale of other slaves, and represented slave-owners in his capacity as a lawyer. Hamilton disliked slavery, but not enough to take a stand against it in his personal and professional life.</p>
<p>In his biography, Chernow deals with these inconvenient facts by laboring to discover a sort of heroic ambivalence in Hamilton’s heart for which, in the documentary record, evidence is scarce. Miranda deals with them by briefly, glancingly, playing up Hamilton’s anti-slavery side and otherwise rushing past the whole topic. In a cabinet debate over government debt, Hamilton mocks the Virginia planter Thomas Jefferson: “A civics lesson from a slaver. Hey neighbor/Your debts are paid cuz you don’t pay for labor.” And earlier, in the rousing anthem “My Shot”, Hamilton identifies himself and his fellow rebellious New Yorkers, and Laurens, as “A bunch of revolutionary manumission abolitionists”. The couplet’s second line — which clinches a killer bit of wordplay — is heading elsewhere in a hurry: “Give me a position, show me where the ammunition is.”</p>
<p>For Hamilton’s harshest critics, though, invoking the play’s historical evasions and exaggerations is merely a way of prosecuting a deeper case against it. Miranda’s undergrad critic from Harvard accuses him of “blindly ask[ing] BIPOC performers to act in a piece detailing historical events benefiting their oppressors”. (That “blindly” is a very undergrad touch. The notion that contemporary actors are being oppressed by men from the 18th century nicely illustrates the collapsed version of historical time that operates in the minds of certain progressive commentators on race in America.) For Ishmael Reed, <em>Hamilton</em>’s historical characters are so fundamentally defined by their involvement in slavery that it should blot out all other ways of talking about these men.</p>
<p>In other words, it’s the implicit optimism of the play that is unacceptable to these critics. Historical details about Hamilton merely confirm this prior conviction. In the event that someone like Miranda stirs up a hopeful mood about America, a battalion of academic historians stands on call to provide these details, with angry writers ready to send them through their megaphones. Cornily, Miranda grants American Founder Alexander Hamilton the liberal honor of being an “immigrant”, because he came from a different part of the British Empire, and he lets the word “abolitionist” hang in the air like a sort of Kantian cologne for Hamilton and his revolutionary friends to pass through and bear the smell of for the rest of the play. And then the historians and professional pessimists step in to say: Wrong! Racism! Slavery!</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;In other words, it’s the implicit optimism of the play that is unacceptable to these critics.&#8221;</div>
<p>But many of <em>Hamilton</em>’s admirers already knew it was wrong, or at least a happy distortion of a darker history. The play’s most famous and powerful admirer, Obama, was surely not duped into beliefs contrary to the historical record after seeing it, formed as he was by the more radical traditions of black thought and black struggle. But I imagine that, as president of the country whose founding was being portrayed in that delightful and hugely successful musical, Obama welcomed the opportunity to indulge the happy distortion for as long as the inertial forces of public discourse would allow. I imagine him thinking, &#8220;It’s healthy and useful to think about it this way for a while. No doubt we’ll have to go back to thinking about it the other way at some point.&#8221;</p>
<p>That is, the warm reception given to <em>Hamilton</em> by influential and historically savvy people like Obama, and indeed the writing of the play by the Puerto Rican phenom Miranda, are examples of what Benedict Anderson calls “memory and forgetting” in <em>Imagined Communities</em>, his great book on the origins and moral logic of nationalism. Since nation states were typically put together and solidified through enormous violence, often fueled by ethnic or racial hostility, they bear these injuries and outrages as undeniable facts of their national histories. But — unlike the multinational agglomerations known as empires — the nation state carries a civic and communal promise, in its very form, to all those contained within its borders, including those who were gathered in and politically domesticated through conquest and violence: “You are members of this national community, brothers in nationhood.” Because this promise and this history are radically at odds with each other, those who generate the legitimating stories of these nations are forced into an almost comically impossible task. They can’t simply engage in perpetual remembering of the formative outrages, since this contradicts the unifying conceit of nationhood and threatens to undo this work of unifying and legitimating. But they can’t simply forget these outrages since they’re too well-remembered, especially by the groups whose ancestors bore this formative violence, and they remain communally important for those groups. And so the nation’s legitimating stories, and everyone who imbibes them in moments of national affirmation, do both. They forget and remember at the same time, or they forget and then later they remember, or vice versa.</p>
<p>Anderson’s great example comes from his own people, the English, whose founding hero arrived from a different country and indeed bears this alienness in his name: William the Conqueror. But the name is rendered blurry in national myth, so that one can imagine William, touched with some primordial Englishness back in France, conquering not England but someone else on England’s behalf. As Anderson writes, the sobriquet “‘the Conqueror’ operates as [a] kind of ellipses… to remind one of something which it is immediately obligatory to forget”.</p>
<p>“The American national myth,” I wrote in that earlier article, “reflects an even more vigorous effort of memory and forgetting, in which&#8230; the enslavement of Africans serves as mere prelude to their emancipation into civic brotherhood.” Yes, the enslavement of hundreds of thousands of black people was a founding fact of American history, but so was their eventual, inevitable emancipation into membership in this great nation, thanks to the elevated sentiment and noble political philosophy of founding Americans like Hamilton. Yes, our greatest Founding Father George Washington owned slaves at Mount Vernon, but, in an almost perfect working-out of this mythic logic of founding and emancipation, he also freed those slaves when he died. It feels almost Christ-like in the national telling, as if Washington died <em>in order to </em>free his slaves. This is how it works.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/03/how-dei-killed-the-race-debate/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/03/how-dei-killed-the-race-debate/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/gay.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/03/how-dei-killed-the-race-debate/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/03/how-dei-killed-the-race-debate/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How DEI killed the race debate</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2025/03/how-dei-killed-the-race-debate/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Matt Feeney</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Critics accused Miranda of ignoring or downplaying slavery in <em>Hamilton</em>, of forgetting it if you will. This was true, sort of. He definitely didn’t dwell on it — except that, in the small matter of casting his play almost entirely with descendants of its victims, and having them perform in a musical style invented by other such descendants, he was very much remembering American slavery. The play wasn’t about slavery in its text, but in the subtext or metatext of its casting and music, it was about slavery quite powerfully, and quite obviously. In this way, <em>Hamilton</em> is one of America’s most pointed and elegant and self-aware achievements in memory and forgetting.</p>
<p>Of course, this is what its critics dislike about it. The funny practice of memory and forgetting, even if it contains ample portions of regret and self-critique, generally sustains the national myth and thus serves the national project. Otherwise, it would just be memory, bitter remembering as perpetual critique, cynical rebuke to the claim of belonging. (You might say that America’s racial pessimists are “all memory”, in which case Trump, who recently complained that America’s national museums focus too much on “how bad slavery was”, would accurately be described as “all forgetting”.)</p>
<p>And, of course, this balance of symbolic influences, along with those songs and that quasi-hip-hop wordplay, was another reason why I liked that corny musical when my daughter started playing it on my stereo. It felt like a healthy antidote to the dominant way of thinking about race in America at the time — the post-Ferguson years when activists had turned their flamboyant pessimism into an ongoing business, latching onto ambiguous individual tragedies as iron confirmation of a sort of paranoid metaphysics of racist oppression. It’s a convenient and profitable circularity, in which murky events, interpreted according to those invidious assumptions, are pointed to as proving those assumptions. In casting the American Founders in his hip-hop musical with black actors, Hamilton conveyed that adopting such blanket convictions about America’s “structural” and “systematic” — and thus permanent, unchanging, and inexpugnable — racial guilt was a political choice, and that other choices were available. There were other ways for black Americans to look at and inhabit their country.</p>
<p>And these ways are better. It’s not that the stance of pessimism and stubborn aggrievement has nothing behind it. This attitude must be especially hard to shake for a satirical writer like Reed. The satirist’s state of inflamed skepticism has an easy foil in America, with its vanity and vaulting ideals, on one hand, and its much less ideal history and sometimes ridiculous present, on the other. The satirical novelist looks upon such a nation and sees nothing redeemable, only a rich cast of targets — everyone appearing a clownish agent of racist evil or patriotic delusion or both. This harsh outlook serves the satirist, as it serves the activist with her hands out for the philanthropy of racial guilt, but it’s hard to imagine that it serves the material interests of everyday black people.</p>
<p>I’ll give an example of what I mean. At a middle school I’ve visited for my children’s football matches, a school in the poor and violent “Deep East” of my town Oakland, an exterior wall is adorned with a quotation. The quotation — an official message or motto of the school itself, though it’s spray-painted in a graffiti-style script — is from Huey P. Newton, co-founder of the Black Panthers, who said: “Youths are passed through schools that don’t teach, then forced to search for jobs that don’t exist and finally left stranded in the street to stare at the glamorous lies advertised around them.” This is the perverse endpoint of racial cynicism, a middle school’s leadership sending a hopeless message about school itself to their impressionable students — many of them restless boys who, like me at that age, are already looking for reasons to shed the burdens of school and to avoid caring about anything but themselves.</p>
<p>The pedagogical and political wisdom of <em>Hamilton</em> lay in rejecting this dispiriting attitude while allowing the history behind it to function as musical suggestion and visible specter. It took the material Reed turns into bitter satire and made something much less bitter of it. In doing so it revealed that, despite the cynicism dominant in commentary about America by high-status black figures, most black Americans would prefer to inhabit their country uncynically, at least some of the time. They loved <em>Hamilton</em> as much as everyone else. The black Harvard historian Annette Gordon-Reed was one of the scholars who felt compelled to remind everyone that Hamilton was less of an abolitionist than Miranda implied, and yet she also loved <em>Hamilton</em>. “Evidently,” <a href="https://www.vox.com/the-big-idea/2016/9/13/12894934/hamilton-debates-history-race-politics-literature" target="_blank" rel="noopener">she wrote in 2016</a>, “many of us enjoy feeling good about America.” “It makes perfect sense,” she went on, that people would want “to celebrate” as well as “to complicate” their national story. It makes perfect sense that black Americans — like everyone else who seeks a citizen’s spiritual home in a flawed nation — would find it worthwhile to forget sometimes, even as they remember.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2025/09/why-hamilton-offends-the-left/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">762386</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Donald Trump&#8217;s cultural renaissance</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2024/12/donald-trumps-cultural-renaissance/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2024/12/donald-trumps-cultural-renaissance/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/GettyImages-2023794826.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Weekend Essay</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[David Samuels]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/b-1.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>1</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Trump is loyal to the American covenant. Jon Cherry/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>David Samuels</strong> is a writer who lives in upstate New York.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle></unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a writer who lives in upstate New York.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 22 Dec 2024 00:30:06 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Sun, 22 Dec 2024 10:04:49 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[American culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Americana]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[City on a hill]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Culture]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Founding fathers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://unherd.com/?p=644696</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[He will lead by example]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>It is certainly possible to hope that the inauguration of Donald J. Trump will be greeted by a resurgence of the American spirit, from new inventions to a revival of entrepreneurial drive and the renewal of American industry and crafts. Trump may well be right that the mere threat of tariffs may reverse the flow of blue-collar jobs abroad while helping ensure the safety and integrity of vital supply chains that are essential to 21st-century industrial production.</p>
<p>He is certainly right that restoring competitive balance between America and its trade partners abroad, and between monopolistic corporations and small producers at home, is essential to growing and maintaining healthy communities where Americans can work and raise children, who in turn might better their communities. It is hard to argue with the idea that reforming the country’s disastrous attempts at trade and industrial policy while getting poisons out of its food, water and air are necessary steps towards a better American future.</p>
<p>Whether tariffs and better trade deals will heal the deeper fractures in the American spirit seems much harder to predict, though. Having grown used to self-determining with bureaucratically defined “identity groups” whose purpose is to legitimise unequal treatment under the law, it is no surprise that Americans have also grown suspicious of each other and of institutions that have schooled them in a vision of the country, its history, and its laws as all being varying shades of deplorable. Without a usable common past, or shared values, it is hard to imagine a shared future – which is why the rise of “woke” thought in schools and workplaces was accompanied by a sudden and startling decline in the American birthrate. Why have kids, if the country you live in is evil, and the future is bleak?</p>
<p>It is also no surprise that the number of watchable films and television shows created by incredibly wealthy techno-monopolies such as Amazon, Netflix and Apple over the past decade can be counted on the fingers of one hand. American publishers, meanwhile, print thousands of books that no one in the world reads, while routinely losing money on over 95% of their titles. Here, the villain isn’t necessarily wokeness: it’s the monopolistic, profit-free structure of the culture industries, which made paint-by-numbers ideology an easy substitute for appealing voices, characters and plots. In a moment where no one could agree on what Americans shared in common, it was also no wonder that an ever-expanding class of DEI bureaucrats, sensitivity readers, and the like appeared to be in danger of replacing actual writers and scholars and editors at movie studios and universities and publishing houses.</p>
<p>“Wokeness” was ultimately a symptom of the ills of America’s culture industries rather than its cause. The cause was the monopolistic structure of the culture business. By using tech cash to take-over the culture business, which they repurposed as a way of providing free content to keep users penned inside their gated monopolies, where they could drop more cash, Amazon, Netflix and Apple cut the connection between cultural products and the marketplace — substituting in its place the taste of layers of cubicle-dwellers with fancy resumes from Ivy League schools. In doing so, they are responsible for perhaps the single most vacant decade in American cultural history.</p>
<p>Name an American band, or an American director, or an American novelist, who has authentically captured the imaginations of even a small number of dedicated fans over the past decade. Instead, content producers of all races and genders, working under the censorious eyes of Ivy League race-class-and-gender twits, turned out indistinguishable widgets for zombie-like viewers who unsurprisingly seemed to have little idea of what they were watching or why they should care about it.</p>
<p>The cratering of American accomplishment in the popular arts, like music, movies and cartoons — with the exception of rap music, whose markets remained stubbornly local, and therefore immune to bureaucratic intervention from above — arguably poses more of a threat to the American future than the fact that low-cost washing machines are being assembled in Mexico. To turn that around, America needs a cultural renaissance of the type it enjoyed during the 1850s, the 1890s and Twenties and the Fifties. That, in turn, requires a shared vision of the country and its future that inspires or at least infuriates large numbers of people.</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;America needs a cultural renaissance of the type it enjoyed during the 1850s, the 1890s and Twenties and the Fifties.&#8221;</div>
<p>What Trump’s election shows is not that we have arrived at such a moment, but that we are ripe for one. What it will look like remains a mystery, though. The alt-culture of the Right is every bit as polluted and stupid — and every bit as anti-American — as the repetitive conformity-culture of the woke Left. If you doubt that, take a look at the fearful idiocy of the New Christian Right, led by Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens; their ignorance of basic Christian theology, resentful hatred of Jews and Israel, and cosplay affinity for eastern orthodox churches is matched only by their desire to replace the common history of the West with bizarre revisionist nonsense, such as the idea that Winston Churchill was the great villain of the Second World War ; or that Bashar al-Assad was the Middle East’s great protector of Christians and a steely foe of Barack Obama, who sought to overthrow him; or that the nuke that the US dropped on Nagasaki targeting poor Japanese Christians praying in church. J.D. Vance’s celebration of the loserdom of poor whites — on whose behalf he opposes automation of loading docks at ports, and protests non-existent “massacres” of Christians in Syria — is in fact the mirror-image of the resentment-based identity politics he claims to oppose, in which Hillary Clinton’s white “deplorables” are substituted for the Left’s “people of colour” as objects of sectarian pity. The idea that a usable American culture can be extracted from such dregs is clearly a non-starter, since at its root it seeks to replace America and its founding exceptionalist doctrines with something else. So where might a true American Renaissance come from?</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">* * *</p>
<p>As social animals, individuals are reflections of the cultures that produced them. Whether they grew up rich or poor, or light-skinned or dark, or gay or straight, matters much less than where they grew up, and how they understood and reacted to the choices presented by the world around them. Michelangelo could not have been Dutch, any more than Rembrandt could have been an Italian, or Steve Jobs could have been a Frenchman, or Adam Smith could have been Russian, or Freud could have been a Catholic priest. The fact that human cultures are often not contiguous with national borders doesn’t make them any less powerful in determining how people imagine themselves and their place in the world — which in turn determines how they do business, raise children, pray, think, write and paint.</p>
<p>Starting in the Sixties, however, culture became a dirty word — a back-door for racism to re-enter academic disciplines that were eager to free themselves from the taint of past national colonial enterprises, which were now understood as the height of wrongdoing. Anthropology, which had been a fruitful meeting place for open-minded students of history, philosophy, linguistics and other disciplines including Claude Levi-Strauss, Edward Evan Evans-Pritchard, Ruth Benedict, Margaret Mead and Clifford and Hilda Geertz, many of whom were also terrific writers, now re-defined as the handmaiden of colonialism, became a dead field of study, overtaken by narcissistic first-person meditations on the observer-position and other forms of post-colonial apologetics.</p>
<p>The reluctance to see culture as the governing force in human behaviour did more than deaden what was once one of the more rewarding sections of any university course catalogue. It is also the cause of some of the most obvious large-scale social failures of the past century, whether spearheaded by utopian Maoist revolutionaries, Islamist political actors, or liberal welfare state bureaucrats. Look at American inner cities, whose ills remain all but untouched by multi-billion dollar social welfare campaigns that began over a half century ago, or the continuing disaster of large-scale immigration from Muslim countries to Europe. This is the human price of ignoring the determining influence of culture in favour of universalist fantasies of whatever colour or stripe.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/donald-trumps-strange-sincerity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/donald-trumps-strange-sincerity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/gettyimages-1965959342-612x612-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/donald-trumps-strange-sincerity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/donald-trumps-strange-sincerity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Donald Trump&#039;s strange sincerity</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/10/donald-trumps-strange-sincerity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Christopher Caldwell</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Conversely, the ability to see through the governing frames of deterministic materialism and other faddish universalisms to the case-specific strengths and weaknesses of underlying cultures turns out to be a pretty reliable way of picking winners and building wealth — whether by investing in culturally advantaged, though resource-poor territories such as Singapore, Israel and Taiwan, or by betting on Silicon Valley upstarts like Microsoft, Apple and Google over the once-dominant IBM and Bell Labs.</p>
<p>Even before its emergence in the late 18th and early 19th centuries as an independent political force, America had emerged as an independent global cultural vector that sought to lead the world through the force of its unique example. The 1,000 or so Puritan colonists who traveled from England to North America in 1630 under the auspices of the Massachusetts Bay Company imagined themselves as the founders of “a city on a hill”, in the phrase of the Puritan John Winthrop; the Puritans hoped their example would inspire 17th-century Europeans to end their destructive religious wars and live peacefully together.</p>
<p>In reality, neither the Protestant nor the Catholic side of Europe’s religious wars gave a hoot about 1,000 English Puritans who had taken up subsistence farming in the North American wilderness. As a result of this failure of the European imagination, the attention of the Puritans and their progeny turned inward, seeking to discover the glaring faults that had led God to abandon them and their mission — thereby inculcating the still-recognisable American traits of communal self-obsession and soul-searching narcissism, according to the great Harvard scholar Perry Miller. Yet nearly four centuries later, it can still plausibly be argued that the global impact of American culture has been more significant than America’s direct attempts at conquest and colonial rule, which by traditional European (or Arab, or Chinese, or Mongol) standards have been relatively few and far-between.</p>
<p>America was the world’s first successful post-colonial state, separating itself from its European progenitors — who included not only Great Britain, the largest sponsor of colonies in North America, but also Holland, France and Spain. It was also the first state born of Enlightenment principles and aspirations, which were reflected in its democratic and anti-monarchical state structure, making it a uniquely welcoming home for immigrants of all cultural and religious — and eventually, racial — backgrounds. Because America was founded according to 18th-century Enlightenment principles, and not in 19th century romantic ideas of being rooted in the soil or in particular bloodlines, American nationalism has always been different from European-style nationalism. This is much to the displeasure of America’s home-grown blood-and-soil types, who look in vain to the national compact for invocations of native folk traditions or the privileging of English or European bloodlines or racial preferences or mandates for particular forms of worship. Unfortunately for them, these things don’t exist – because America was never that type of nation. Yes, America declared themselves to be one nation under God. Yet Jesus Christ, let alone the guidance or sovereignty of any particular Church established in his name, was notably absent from the country’s founding deliberations and documents.</p>
<p>America has also maintained a unique and particular affinity for the Jews. This affinity, which began with the Puritan colonists, who modeled their endeavor on the Old Testament Israelites, proclaimed themselves to have joined in a new covenant with the Israelite God, and taught their children to read and write Hebrew, was hardly just a passing metaphor. Absent the reality of God’s covenant with Israel, the Puritan mission to the American wilderness was meaningless. The American affinity for Jews, and with the Jewish relationship with the God of Israel, also extended itself to living Jewish refugees from European persecution, who arrived in the colonies in the mid 17th century, shortly after the Puritans, though they were strictly forbidden from settling in England; When the American nation was born, Jews were formally welcomed as citizens by George Washington, with open arms and none of the national soul-searching that accompanied the granting of citizenship to Jews in England or in revolutionary France, where it took the National Assembly three months of debate to finally decide the issue.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/11/how-trump-crushed-obamas-legacy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/11/how-trump-crushed-obamas-legacy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Obama.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/11/how-trump-crushed-obamas-legacy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/11/how-trump-crushed-obamas-legacy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How Trump crushed Obama&#039;s legacy</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/11/how-trump-crushed-obamas-legacy/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> David Samuels</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The New Israel founded by the Puritans, to which the Founding Fathers gave life through the Enlightenment forms of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, quite deliberately separated itself from the European kingdoms and empires that came before it, and the nation-states that came after it, in that it was never defined by race, religion, or by the soil. American culture remains rooted precisely in the covenants and affinities of its founders, who made a determined break with Old Europe and its divisions and hatreds and form a new covenant, that might serve as an example to all of mankind.</p>
<p>Whether Americans choose to accept or reject the covenant made by their forebears is a question that every generation of Americans until now has always answered in the affirmative. That’s where American art and culture come from. Walt Whitman set out walking to discover America and his fellow Americans. Herman Melville sent Ishmael — if that was his name — to sea on a whaling ship. Mark Twain sent Huck Finn down the Mississippi River, with the success of his journey resting on his ability to escape from his father. Gatsby’s failure to banish the past may have been fated, but it meant his death — just as William Faulkner’s Quentin Compson’s attachment to his family past means his death. Augie March seizes his own life in his hands by leaving Chicago. Not even the most casual student of American culture can understand the future as anything other than the idol of every American, and the past as anything other than a trap.</p>
<p>Americans are free to reject the idea of a national covenant with God as nonsense and become more like the rest of the world, by hating Jews, celebrating strange Churches, embracing manufactured sectarian divisions on the basis of skin colour, religion, race and sexual preferences, and clinging to other ancient or post-colonial hatreds, whether in the name of the Left or the Right. But what both the anti-American factions of the American Left and Right should bear in mind is that you can’t have America without the covenant: the decision to reject the covenant, which gave birth to the idea of American exceptionalism, whether understood in its Puritan or Enlightenment forms, means the end of the American story.</p>
<p>It is indeed the adherence to and championing of the uniqueness of the American covenant that separates Donald Trump from both his ostensible allies such as Tucker Carlson and J.D. Vance on the Right, and his anti-exceptionalist opponents and critics such as Barack Obama and his progressive allies on the Left. If a renewal of American culture is indeed in the offing, it is likely to come from neither side in the present-day culture wars. Hilariously enough, it will come from the man at the top, leading by example.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2024/12/donald-trumps-cultural-renaissance/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">644696</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Is Trump a perverted Emersonian?</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2024/08/is-trump-a-perverted-emersonian/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2024/08/is-trump-a-perverted-emersonian/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Meaningless-e1721928933113.jpg?w=490</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme>Summer Reads</unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Sam Jennings]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Headshot-1.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking>3</unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['The man who totally exemplifies his moment, no matter how shallow or disgusting, will get everything he wants.' (Photo by Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images)]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Sam Jennings</strong> is an American writer and musician living in London. More of his writing can be found at his Substack, <a href="https://samueljennings9.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Vita Contemplativa</a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>samueljennings9</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an American writer and musician living in London. More of his writing can be found at his Substack, <a href="https://samueljennings9.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Vita Contemplativa</a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 12 Aug 2024 23:00:37 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 12 Aug 2024 23:00:37 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[America]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Founding fathers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Literature]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Society]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://unherd.com/?p=612196</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The great writer is as contradictory as America]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p style="text-align: left; padding-left: 40px;">A man should learn to detect and watch that gleam of light<br />
which flashes across his mind from within, more than the<br />
lustre of the firmament of bards and sages. Yet he dismisses<br />
without notice his thought, because it is his. In every work<br />
of genius we recognize our own rejected thoughts:<br />
they come back to us with a certain alienated majesty.</p>
<p style="text-align: left; padding-left: 40px;">— Emerson, “Self-Reliance”, 1841</p>
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<p>America — the real, the messy, the <em>absurd</em> America — didn’t really begin in 1776. The real America is not a set of documents, or a people, or a big landmass. Even in decline, America is a maze of dizzying and lethal ideals. An untameable instinct to escape<em>: </em>to escape society, history, other people, ourselves. It’s a never-ending yearning for newness and a primal horror at repetition, which stretched across and conquered a continent, before it doubled back on itself and spilled out like a flood over the world. America is extraordinary; America is terrible. Like everywhere else, it drives its citizens nuts. But the whole world knows Americans are crazy in a uniquely grand, stupid way.</p>
<p>The degree to which I can even write those words has much more to do with the mind of Ralph Waldo Emerson than with any Founding Father. In rhetoric, in spirit, the one writer who fixed all the most difficult American paradoxes, like guiding stars for centuries after, was Emerson.</p>
<p>Growing up in Middle America, going to public schools, I never had to read Emerson. My first encounter with him was a sparsely-attended state university survey, which I took to satisfy a requirement. In one semester we blitzed through the first “half” of American literature (from John Winthrop’s Puritan speeches to <em>Uncle Tom’s Cabin</em>) landing briefly on Emerson’s one or two most famous essays. I take this as more or less the normative experience: since then, I’ve met only a handful of Americans who’ve read much of Emerson’s work. My more personal encounters with his writings came later, and they came to me when I was alone. I think it tends to be like this. Emerson still doesn’t quite work in the classroom. Like Michel de Montaigne, like Dr Johnson, or Friedrich Nietzsche (who profoundly admired him), he remains resistant to all but the most single-minded, solitary reader, privately seeking out the man called “the Mind of America”.</p>
<p>But there are always intimations of the Emersonian. There are for each American, whether they know it or not. My father, a liberal Presbyterian minister, had something of the Emersonian in him before he retired. In his tempered and essentially universalist preaching, wherein the Bible was an imperfect human document and there was resolutely no Hell: the mind, the heart, Nature itself — everything was radiant and testified to God. And this God was, in the theologian Paul Tillich’s sense, the “ground of being”, a foundation of love and faith.</p>
<p>A calm, scholarly kind of Protestantism, in other words — hardly the charismatic or enthusiastic Evangelism I saw in other churches. Places where you’d find a very <em>American</em> Christ: a demigod Jesus, with whom the faithful spoke daily, whose powers were the sole arbiter of safety or success in a world largely governed by demons. But I recognise, now, that even these separable styles were intertwined at base, with the same sense of very <em>personal</em> religious revelation: what the critic Harold Bloom once called the American Religion. He meant a religious and political style in which morality came down to individual souls in direct communication with God, not community or society. European Protestantism had become something stranger on the American continent, something intimately wrapped up in the colonisation of the land, the search for a wilderness Eden, the sacrosanctity of individual rights inscribed in the laws. And who was it Bloom identified the American Religion with most? Hart Crane, Walt Whitman, Emily Dickinson, Herman Melville…but, above all, Emerson.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/capitalism-killed-the-american-west/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/capitalism-killed-the-american-west/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/5-2.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/capitalism-killed-the-american-west/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/capitalism-killed-the-american-west/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Capitalism killed the American West</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/capitalism-killed-the-american-west/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> James Pogue</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>For those new to Emerson’s writings, the easiest starting points are his first published essay, “Nature” (1836), and the great addresses at Cambridge (“The American Scholar”, 1837) and the Harvard Divinity School (1838). Emerson as a lecturer was a product of the liberal literature of Boston and Concord, and of his own father’s Unitarianism — his Transcendentalism coming out of a collision of Kant, Berkleyan idealism, Coleridge, some pilfered Hinduism. He made his name as a public speaker and co-founder of <em>The Dial </em>(he would later help found <em>The Atlantic</em> in 1857), advocating a radical break from Europe, from past philosophies, even from traditional Christianity. But it was the first <em>Essays</em>, published in 1841, refined from his lectures, which laid out his own paradoxical philosophy.</p>
<p>If you can call it a philosophy, that is. Emerson was a philosopher without a system, and after reading him long enough, I think clearly by design. He is as formless, as disturbingly innocent, as America is — he is as fervently contradictory. When Walt Whitman came to his own apothegm — “Do I contradict myself? Very well then I contradict myself, (I am large, I contain multitudes)” — he was, after all, reappropriating the Emerson of “Self-Reliance”: “Suppose you should contradict yourself; what then?&#8230;A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.” Whitman’s poetry became the great vehicle of the Emersonian spirit into the broader world. But what was that spirit?</p>
<p>It helps to start with a sense of the freshness of his moment, as Emerson found it. In his classic <em>American Renaissance</em>, F.O. Matthiessen grounded Emerson’s appearance in two historical zeitgeists. First, the genuine “novel idea given birth”, the <em>esprit</em> which Alexis de Tocqueville had observed in postrevolutionary America. Second, the post-Kantian expansion of rhetorical concepts in the early Romantic era. For Matthiessen, this last was typified by Samuel Taylor Coleridge, who as a coiner of critical terms has no real rival in modern English. Matthiessen writes with awe of the many new Coleridgean terms: “…all of which are so familiar to us that it is hard to conceive how anyone ever discussed literature without them…<em>aesthetic, intuitive, idealize, intellectualize, organic, organization, </em>and <em>self-conscious.</em>” Coleridge had even been the first to use the term <em>psychological</em>, in describing Shakespeare’s characters. And this aspect of Shakespeare was deeply important to Emerson, who often read the Bard as a manifestation of the world-soul itself, in literature.</p>
<p>Emerson, the American Coleridge, may very well have been suffering some anxiety of influence when he struck out so plainly at Old World art. Still, Emerson does not coin terms: he rushes to capitalise, to abstract things into expressive monoliths — like Nature, Truth, Time, Love. The first <em>Essays </em>are all so many enormous nouns: “History”, “Self-Reliance”, “Compensation”, “Spiritual Laws”, “Love”, “Friendship”, “Prudence”, “Heroism”, “The Over-Soul”, “Circles”, “Intellect”, “Art”. There are, in between, almost shades of the Keatsian “negative capability”, a slippery anonymity with which that poet described Shakespeare’s genius. The negative capability reflects in Emerson, who is much the opposite: he is all positive: he finds everything in himself.</p>
<p>This is best represented in the most famous of the <em>Essays</em>: “History” and “Self-Reliance”. Of these it’s almost easiest to just hurl quotes. From the first: “All history becomes subjective: in other words, there is properly no history; only biography”; “Every mind must know the whole history for itself.” From the second: “Society everywhere is in conspiracy against the manhood of every one of its members”; “Whoso would be a man must be a nonconformist”. In “Nature”, Emerson had concocted the image of himself as an all-seeing, transparent eyeball — here that eyeball is trained on the world, and in the world he finds an immense, constant affirmation of his subjectivity: a total sympathy of all things, leading back to a primal unity, the God within, what he called the Over-Soul.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/06/the-vacuous-politics-of-franz-kafka/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/06/the-vacuous-politics-of-franz-kafka/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/GettyImages-1397366639-e1717509299548.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/06/the-vacuous-politics-of-franz-kafka/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/06/the-vacuous-politics-of-franz-kafka/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The vacuous politics of Franz Kafka</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2024/06/the-vacuous-politics-of-franz-kafka/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Pratinav Anil</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Have I failed to give a picture of the man’s ideas? That may be inevitable. How many people have read “Self-Reliance” and taken from it <em>very</em> different pictures of what an American should be? “Self-Reliance” is — I’m not exaggerating — the real founding American document. Just as all history for Emerson was a litany of texts leading us back to ourselves, to our judgments — so each person is, in his or herself, the sole subjective judge and creator of the cosmos. Each is to listen to their own self, and to their own self alone. There is no salvation in society. Only in solitude are we finally equal to others. “Self-Reliance” on its own gives us the whole tradition of American arts; uncreatively read, it gives us Andrew Carnegie, John D. Rockefeller, and Henry Ford, who posted quotes from Emerson in his factories (right next to copies of <em>The Protocols of the Elders of Zion</em>). Get at that wild doubling, and you’ll start to get at the magnetically messed-up heart of Emerson’s America.</p>
<p>But read a little deeper: the picture grows bigger. In “Compensation”, Emerson insists that existence rests on the drawing up of cosmic, karmic tables, a reminder that America is founded on a deep sense of injustice (the one thing all Americans may have most in common is the sense that they have been wronged). In “The Over-Soul”, he complicates his own picture, asserting that to be authentically self-reliant is actually to <em>renounce </em>your will, to give yourself up to the universal mind. That when we’re most ourselves, we’re actually in paradoxical sympathy with our most impersonal aspects. Or take the neglected “Friendship”, the rare piece in which the positive Emerson becomes disturbed, ambivalent. He knew very well that a nation of pure individuals would be, essentially, a nation of millions of competing personal religions: as much as the Emersonian listens inwardly for truth, he or she still goes out afterwards, to mingle with a world of strangers doing the same.</p>
<p>Taken together, you can find in the first <em>Essays</em> all the same animating forces which are still churning on in American life today. Every great American is an Emersonian; every terrible American is a perverted, halfway, one. For each extraordinary American quality he helped originate, there are, as Matthiessen wrote, sentiments which, “&#8230;working on temperaments less unworldly than their author’s, have provided a vicious reinforcement to the most ruthless elements in our economic life.” He put such a fine point on our individualism, our aspirations and the anti-social character of our freedoms — like Sigmund Freud’s expression of the unconscious, or Nietzsche’s nihilism, his writing is at once the diagnosis and the disease. Who knows anymore who we were before them?</p>
<div class="su-pullquote su-pullquote-align-left">&#8220;Every great American is an Emersonian; every terrible American is a perverted, halfway, one.&#8221;</div>
<p>Our rural libertarians are half-Emersonians, and so are our terrified conservatives, guarding their house doors like castles and seething at wokescolds, NGOs and kids who call themselves communists (all of them perverted Emersonians, too). Our environmentalists pervert him when their rhetoric swerves from connection or beauty and grows addicted to self-flagellation, to metaphors of human cancers. Consider that Donald Trump himself is a perverted Emersonian: a man who listens only to himself but still has no self-reliance. How desperately he needs public adulation. That icon-like photo of the assassination attempt testifies to an Emersonian, American fact. The man who totally exemplifies his moment, no matter how shallow or disgusting, will get everything he wants, and he will misunderstand it at every turn.</p>
<p>Because for Emerson, the world may be social, yet a person should never prefer a social truth to the spiritual facts he or she holds at heart. As a political doctrine this seems plainly impossible. At its worst, it leads to something like America today: millions of asocial individuals in constant conflict over millions of grievances. Emerson’s ambivalence still haunts us. We feel, deep down, that individual freedom is simply incompatible with society and social responsibility. Emerson’s belief that a great society might be made up entirely of free-thinking individuals reads now as disturbingly naive.</p>
<p>But reading Emerson always brings me to a freeing realisation: that America may not really matter. Sure, America may slowly die of its paradoxes. It just doesn’t matter — only people matter. The simple truth is that most Americans work hard and care about those around them. I’ve seen it first-hand, in families, even in churches. I’ve seen it nurtured by teachers in some of the most segregated schools in America. They are on their way to being genuine Emersonians: they don’t work from a need for approval or salvation, or for the sake of some bigger political picture. The good they do is out of a personal sense — a common sense — that it is <em>right</em>.</p>
<p>Late in “Circles”, in what may be the subtle best of the <em>Essays</em>, Emerson writes: “I unsettle all things. No facts are to me sacred; none are profane; I simply experiment, an endless seeker; with no Past at my back.” That, to me, is so clearly the voice of America, that when I see it, I am myself unsettled. It is beautiful; it is terrifying. This vision of America is equally free, and unmoored. A place without history may be either a hell or a haven: America has always been both. It can always be more of either. We live in a time of isolation and of exhaustive obsession over identity, always selling us on new ways to perform ourselves. But there’s a difference between isolation and solitude, and a difference between selfishness and self-reliance. Even if he cannot help us save modern society, Emerson can at least still teach us how to listen to ourselves in genuine solitude. And that might just be enough.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2024/08/is-trump-a-perverted-emersonian/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">612196</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>America will always fear Caesar</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2022/08/america-will-always-fear-caesar/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2022/08/america-will-always-fear-caesar/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/2Hamilton2-e1660656087970-1.jpg?w=705</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Ross Douthat]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/guy-4.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Hamilton tried to steal the 1800 election. Hamilton/Joan Marcus]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Ross Douthat </strong>is a <em>New York Times</em> columnist and a <em>National Review</em> film critic. His latest book is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Dark-Wood-Five-Year-Disease-Doesnt/dp/0593237366/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Deep Places: A Memoir of Illness and Discovery</em></a>. He also writes on <a href="https://douthat.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Substack</a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>DouthatNYT</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[is a <em>New York Times</em> columnist and a <em>National Review</em> film critic. His latest book is <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Dark-Wood-Five-Year-Disease-Doesnt/dp/0593237366/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Deep Places: A Memoir of Illness and Discovery</em></a>. He also writes on <a href="https://douthat.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Substack</a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 18 Aug 2022 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 26 Aug 2022 16:04:13 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[America]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Books]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Don't miss]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Founding fathers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[George Washington]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Gore Vidal]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[History]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Summer reads 2022]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Thomas Jefferson]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[US Politics]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=441261</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Gore Vidal: ‘Burr’ ]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>In my own unreliable cultural memory, the age of <em>Hamilton</em> enthusiasm in American life belongs emphatically to Barack Obama’s presidency in its optimistic phase — to the last period of unabashed liberal patriotism and confidence.</p>
<p>In reality, though, Lin-Manuel Miranda’s musical didn’t premiere until early in 2015, just four short months before Donald Trump descended the Trump Tower escalator and inaugurated the age of populism. This means that <em>Hamilton</em> enthusiasm was partially a lagging indicator, and partially just something for stunned liberals to desperately grasp onto, a thread running backward to the cosmopolitan American future they had lost.</p>
<div class="ad-insert"></div>
<p>I do not come to bury this kind of fandom: the Miranda musical is terrific no matter its ideological baggage. But it still might have been more intellectually productive if the Trump era had inspired its fans to turn from Miranda’s version of the Founding to the one found in Gore Vidal’s 1973 novel <em>Burr</em>.</p>
<p><em>Burr</em> already had one cultural moment, dropping originally amid the squalor of Watergate, when its dose of cold-eyed iconoclasm was well-received by critics and bookbuyers alike. But today the novel can be read or re-read with new eyes, outside the long shadow cast by its late author’s famous media persona, and in a landscape where its vision has just as much to offer.</p>
<p>That vision is cynical on the surface. Vidal retells the story of the Founding era from the perspective of what one of Aaron Burr’s biographers called the “Fallen Founder” — the almost-president of 1800, the slayer of Alexander Hamilton in their 1804 duel, the man tried for treason for a supposed scheme to detach the western states from the Union.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-last-american-aristocrat/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-last-american-aristocrat/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/GettyImages-515513432-copy-scaled.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-last-american-aristocrat/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-last-american-aristocrat/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The last American aristocrat</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-last-american-aristocrat/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Phil Klay</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The treason trial ended in acquittal but also ended Burr’s public political career; he bounced around Europe unhappily in search of patronage and then ended up back in New York City, where he lived quietly as a lawyer until a late marriage to a wealthy widow in 1837. That’s the point at which the novel picks up, through the agency of its narrator, Charles Schuyler, a young journalist on the make who befriends the aged Burr but also agrees to betray him, by gathering evidence intended to prove that the disreputable killer of Hamilton and famous ladies’ man is also the secret father of Vice President Martin Van Buren, whose pending ascent to the presidency Schuyler’s patrons hope to block.</p>
<p>With this hope in mind, the journalist induces the aging Burr to share his own unfinished memoirs, granting us first-person flashbacks to the Revolutionary War and early republic, in which Burr describes his own rise and fall while settling accounts with all his former friends and rivals.</p>
<p>Compared to the pieties of conservative founder-worship or even of Lin-Manuel Miranda’s musical, these portraits can seem savage. George Washington is an incompetent general who, as president, obsesses over his own quasi-royal dignity. Hamilton, of course, is everything that he accused Burr of being: A man of vaulting ambition, eager for aristocratic style and monarchical power, “capable of any illegality including a military coup&#8221;, who actually engaged in an attempt to steal the 1800 election. (Vidal’s Burr writes: “I suspect that when Hamilton looked at me he saw, in some magical way, himself reflected. And so if one is an embryo-Caesar, accuse the looking-glass of that high treason and divert thereby the wrath of the plebes.”)</p>
<p>Finally Jefferson, in Burr’s telling, is expedience and ambition personified — a man who had the gift “at one time or another to put with eloquence the ‘right’ answer to every moral question”, even as in practice “he seldom deviated from an opportunistic course, calculated to bring him power&#8221;. A man whose principles committed him to an agrarian and decentralised confederacy, but whose presidency settled “with suspicious ease” on empire-building and executive power. A better Napoleon than Napoleon himself<b>,</b> since his empire-building in the vast Louisiana territory actually endured.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-prophets-of-our-economic-doom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-prophets-of-our-economic-doom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/GettyImages-1229053751-e1659975945166.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-prophets-of-our-economic-doom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-prophets-of-our-economic-doom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Will we escape our age of failure?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2022/08/the-prophets-of-our-economic-doom/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Martin Gurri</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>As readers we need not accept that Burr-the-narrator is reliable in all these details, or buy all of his extensive self-justifications. We only have to accept his unique observer’s position, as a man interested in his own honour and prospects but not especially keen on any grand ideological project, at a time when one of history’s grandest ideological projects — the age of revolution — was getting underway.</p>
<p>From that perspective, Burr’s account is cynical and deflating relative to mythmakers and ideological historians — and one of the points of setting the novel’s framing narrative in the 1830s is to see how quickly American mythmaking took hold. But even through the eyes of the Fallen Founder there is no escaping the fact that what he describes is a political success story: a republic established and then expanded, various disasters and civil wars avoided, the Caesarist appetites of even the most powerful figures checked and limited, and at least some revolutionary ideals put into political practice.</p>
<p>Indeed, the novel’s Burr often circles back to acknowledge as much. All his barbed comments about Washington culminate in the observation that: “He was the supreme creator of his union &#8230; [whose] powerful will and serpentine cunning made of a loose confederation of sovereign states a strong federal government graven to this day in Washington’s sombre Roman imperial image.” His war with Hamilton doesn’t conceal his partial liking for his rival, and his sneers at the self-made immigrant double as an acknowledgment of the Horatio Alger qualities celebrated on Broadway.</p>
<p>Even Jefferson, Burr’s final enemy and the instigator of his treason trial, is presented as, well, what he was — a dreadful hypocrite, with a tangle of competing motivations and ideals slicked over by self-interest, but also a remarkably effective politician who adapted himself to the new republic’s presidency rather than being carried into disasters by his radical inclinations.</p>
<p>So what is the novel’s un-cynical message? Perhaps that politics is an always unfinished and ambiguous vocation, whose moments of moral clarity are inherently exceptional, and whose normal workings require a constant balancing-act between idealism and realism, private probity and public vision, the necessary and the possible.</p>
<p>This balance needs to be struck within the individual statesman, first. The reader will observe that Burr falters and falls, relative to the other Founders, not because he’s worse and they’re better, but because he has the wrong proportions: too much concern for his private honour, which makes him miss crucial opportunities and also carries him into the fateful duel, and not quite enough concern for public ideals and great causes, which makes him an insufficiently inspiring leader for any of the new country’s clashing factions.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/02/has-our-decadent-society-ground-to-a-halt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/02/has-our-decadent-society-ground-to-a-halt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/GettyImages-113493815-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/02/has-our-decadent-society-ground-to-a-halt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/02/has-our-decadent-society-ground-to-a-halt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Our decadent society has ground to a halt</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/02/has-our-decadent-society-ground-to-a-halt/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Niall Gooch</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>But then, in good Madisonian terms, the balance also needs to be struck between competing statesmen. The great good fortune of America in the Revolutionary era, in Vidal’s portrait, was not that all its leaders were uniquely public-spirited but rather that their talents and rivalries interacted in such a way as to mostly stabilise and strengthen the young country. Which is to say, while everyone was accusing everyone else of being a monarchist or Caesar in the making, the republic took form and proved stronger than any individual or faction.</p>
<p>This brings us to the book’s relevance for our own political era, in which accusations of incipient autocracy fly as freely as they did in the United States of 1800. There is a certain relief in recognising this similarity. It’s a reminder, among other things, that periods of stable consensus politics are almost as exceptional as moments of total moral clarity, and that the people who have constantly asserted <em>this-is-not-normal</em> about some feature of the age of populism are mistaken. It’s quite normal for small-r republican politics to be shadowed by the fear of tyranny, corrupted elections, misinformation, destabilising foreign influence, the fate of Rome. (Before there was the <em>reductio ad Hitlerum</em> there was the<em> reductio ad Rubicon</em> — and perhaps the exhausted response: “A Catiline-conspiracy analogy, again, really?”)</p>
<p>These similarities also hint that the politics of the late-18th and 19th centuries may be more relevant to our own fragmented era than the mass movements and ideological tyrannies of the early 20th century. The category to which Burr belongs, the political adventurer — the none-too-principled but also none-too-ideological figure seizing opportunities as they come to him — seems especially relevant to the rise of Trump or, for that matter, Boris Johnson. And of course Andrew Jackson, hovering in the wings of <em>Burr</em>, remains the crucial antecedent for all American populism, past, present and yet to come.</p>
<p>But to the extent that aspects of our own era can be glimpsed in Vidal’s vision of the American Founding, the recognition also brings with it a sense of the depressing difference. We have the adventurers, the fears of Caesarism, the conspiracy theories and fake news, but the qualities of leadership and vision that Burr grudgingly acknowledges in his rivals seem altogether absent. Instead of vaulting ambition counteracting vaulting ambition, our adventurers stand out, clownishly, amid a landscape of greying mediocrity. This is far less dangerous than the alternative, but it is a sign of decay rather than life.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2022/08/america-will-always-fear-caesar/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">441261</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>America has always been a basket case</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2021/04/america-has-always-been-a-basket-case/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2021/04/america-has-always-been-a-basket-case/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/gettyimages-180216257-594x594-1.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Justin Webb]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/justin.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[How is America coping, post-Trump? Credit: Spencer Platt/Getty]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Justin Webb</strong> presents the Americast podcast and Today on Radio Four. His Panorama documentary “Trump the Sequel&#8221;, is available now on  Iplayer</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>JustinOnWeb</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ presents the Americast podcast and Today on Radio Four. His Panorama documentary “Trump the Sequel", is available now on  Iplayer]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 13 Apr 2021 23:00:20 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 13 Apr 2021 23:00:20 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[America]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Constitution]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Democracy]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Democrats]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Founding fathers]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Jefferson]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Republicans]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[USA]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Washington]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=102886</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The nation often appears deranged and unstable — only to come up trumps]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>All British foreign correspondents who live in America for more than a few years write a book about it. It’s compulsory. They are invariably fuzzy focus takes on road-trips in which our charmed modern-day de Tocqueville meets a range of characters chewing corn dogs in the sun and declares that America, while barmy, and without a functioning health service, is still quite fun.</p>
<p>I wrote two of them, both hugely optimistic about the place. One is literally called <a href="https://www.waterstones.com/book/have-a-nice-day/justin-webb/9781906021702" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Have A Nice Day</em></a>. I hailed Americans’ sobriety and the gentle virtues of their system of government. It was published in 2009. How was I to know they were about to get high on Fentanyl and elect Donald Trump?</p>
<p>Anyway, it is with some annoyance that I have to tell you my friend Nick Bryant, the BBC’s New York correspondent, has written the antidote to all these vapid takes, mine included. Nick comes across on the news as a bit of a lad — actually he <em>is</em> a bit of a lad — but he is also a historian with a deep understanding of what makes America tick. And <em><a href="https://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/when-america-stopped-being-great-9781472985484/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">When America Stopped Being Great</a> </em>is an absolutely belting achievement for a hack, and an Englishman to boot. It is, as the title suggests, an elegy for a lost nation and a lost cause. The <em>Washington Post </em>gave the book a long and favourable <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/a-modern-day-historian-writes-the-timeline-of-american-decline/2021/03/31/f8a6b536-88ef-11eb-bfdf-4d36dab83a6d_story.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener">review</a>, calling it, “riveting, often revelatory, crammed with facts, occasionally personal, and almost always depressing”.</p>
<p>It is also wrong.</p>
<div class="ad-insert"></div>
<p>Not in its description of modern-day America, which Bryant knows well and captures superbly. The inequality, the intellectual poverty, the extremism, the mass shootings, the end of civility in debates on abortion or guns or anything. But he is wrong about the constitution. He points out — rightly — that it’s under pressure from modernity. A good example: Democrats can win the popular vote in seven of the last eight presidential elections, but the Republicans have nominated 15 of the last 19 Supreme Court justices. “That is why,” Bryant writes, “talk of a reboot or a reset of the current obsolete operating system is so misplaced.”</p>
<p>Really? Tinkering could sort things for another hundred years or so. Fixing the Senate to reduce the impact of the rural minority won’t be decorous or easy, but is it impossible? Might an America that conquered the empty(ish) spaces in the first place not manage to reinvigorate them, repopulate them with businesses no longer tethered to coasts — or physical places at all — and so rebalance political power?</p>
<p>Others have also thought the place was going to the dogs. I mean properly believing the system to be broken. So perhaps the answer to the current crisis, as Dennis Rasmussen suggests in his thought-provoking book <em><a href="https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691210230/fears-of-a-setting-sun" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Fears of a Setting Sun</a></em>, can be found in the fears of her founders. The men who invented America mostly thought their invention a disaster, a mess from the start. As Rasmussen points out, even in George Washington’s time hatred poisoned everything: “The two main parties saw and treated each other not just as opponents who advocated the wrong policies, but rather as enemies of the Constitution who actively sought to subvert the basic principles of the Revolution… Newspaper polemics included ‘some of the ripest vituperation in American literary history’, in the words of one scholar. Cries of treason entered virtually every political debate, fears of foreign plots abounded, and physical violence was lamentably commonplace.”</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2021/03/the-death-of-american-dignity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2021/03/the-death-of-american-dignity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/GettyImages-1228928008-1.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2021/03/the-death-of-american-dignity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2021/03/the-death-of-american-dignity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The death of American dignity</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2021/03/the-death-of-american-dignity/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Justin Webb</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Perhaps we became too used to the idea, in the post-Watergate era, of America as stable. A nation always there, indispensable, wise, mostly well run. But it was not in its early years and it has not been oftentimes in its history. Nevertheless: hey, it survives. And, with a few twists and turns, it prospers.</p>
<p>Rasmussen’s book is important because it reminds us not only that the founding fathers were disappointed with their creation but that they had reason to be. It really was a basket case (a “shithole country”, to use <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/white-house/trump-referred-haiti-african-countries-shithole-nations-n836946" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Trump’s terminology</a>). With the notable exception of James Madison, Rasmussen writes, all of America’s early leaders, including Washington, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, and Alexander Hamilton, were pessimistic that the American experiment in republican democracy would endure. They thought that Americans were too venal or stupid to cope with politics. They thought the federal system would buckle. They thought factions would bring the whole edifice down.</p>
<p>“The founders,” Rasmussen tells us, “frequently predicted that the republic that they had established would not last beyond their own generation — that the union would soon be sundered, that a new constitutional convention would have be to called, or that the government would gradually lapse into a hereditary monarchy.”</p>
<p>They also thought foreigners would interfere with American elections and affect the results. Ok, not Russia, but still, the idea of &#8220;intrigue&#8221; from abroad is not new. Nor is the idea of hereditary rule — of the kind that pits Trump children against Biden children or Clinton children or perhaps even Obama children into the distant decades. Adams predicted it; he thought it inevitable. He would not be delighted by the news that Rudy Giuliani’s son Andrew wants to be New York state’s next Governor, but he would not be surprised.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/06/covid-has-exposed-america-as-a-failed-state/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/06/covid-has-exposed-america-as-a-failed-state/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/GettyImages-1235424618.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/06/covid-has-exposed-america-as-a-failed-state/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/06/covid-has-exposed-america-as-a-failed-state/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Covid has exposed America as a failed state</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/06/covid-has-exposed-america-as-a-failed-state/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Aris Roussinos</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>And on and on the jeremiads go; down the ages they echo. Even Jefferson, the most optimistic of the founders, succumbs to disillusion in old age. Only Madison stands up for America and thinks it might work out alright, and he does so because, Rasmussen says, he compares the place to other regimes, not to some idealised perfect system of government.</p>
<p>Perhaps that is the key.</p>
<p>So how are they doing now, the Americans, post Trump? Better or worse than China on freedom; than Russia on state sponsored crime; than the EU on technological achievement? America is indeed badly governed and horribly divided, but is it moribund, as Nick Bryant argues, or merely troubled? Bryant suggests that if his young daughter wanted to see the most thrusting nation in the world, China might be the place to visit — though he hopes she would recognise the cruel authoritarianism of its system. Otherwise she could go to Australia for its lifestyle, an Asian mega-city for a glimpse of the future.</p>
<p>These places all have their strengths — though China will strike many as a pretty unconvincing role model — but none is anything like as vibrant as America, where everyone has come to play. America, where anything might happen — from a school shooting to the conquest of cancer. A nation that can combust with coronavirus but then invent and manufacture multiple vaccines and distribute them in huge numbers. A nation that can delegitimise government and then (perhaps, under Biden) rediscover its importance. A nation often deranged, but seldom stumped for long.</p>
<p>Madison’s other gift to modernity was a belief that politics could be a constant, unending argument without any shared understanding of the common good — but still work. He saw all America’s bipartisan talk as nice to have but unnecessary. Perhaps America was never meant to be united, free from factions, common in purpose. Perhaps it was always best seen as a herding of political cats, hissing and fissiparous from the start.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/where-the-american-dream-goes-to-die/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/where-the-american-dream-goes-to-die/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/IMG_4862-scaled.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/where-the-american-dream-goes-to-die/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/where-the-american-dream-goes-to-die/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Where the American Dream goes to die</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/where-the-american-dream-goes-to-die/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Ian Birrell</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Seen through that lens, Donald Trump looks less frightening. As Rasmussen suggests of the modern era: “We no longer face repeated, serious threats of secession and civil war. Political violence is far less common today … No contemporary election can compare with the presidential election of 1800 — a contest between Jefferson and Adams, two of our most revered founders — in terms of sheer viciousness. Today’s much-maligned &#8216;mainstream media’ is in reality far more responsible and fact based than the newspapers of the 1790s.”</p>
<p>America’s problems are more intractable but less existentially threatening than many suppose. They were there from the start. They are there today. And tomorrow?</p>
<p>I am not betting against the place. Nick Bryant says he fears more American Carnage, to use Donald Trump’s memorable phrase from his inaugural speech. It is true that some on the American Right have given up on their fellow citizens — particularly those with darker skin who have more recently arrived. It is also true that plenty on the Left have done the same thing, with rural white folk, whose &#8220;deaths of despair&#8221; can feel rooted more in lost status than lost life chances. It is true, too, that too many people are shot — or shoot themselves — though you have to be careful here. Most American lives are free of violence and the number of households with guns — around 42% — is not much changed from decades ago: they just have more of them.</p>
<p>Neither Rasmussen nor Bryant reach firm conclusions. This is wise. There is no American denouement in the offing. Any properly terminal decline, or reset towards revivification, will be imperceptible at first, and argued over forever. That’s always been the point of the place. The argument about the best path to political progress is not always edifying but is always, and forever, worth having. And America, forever, will be the place to have it.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2021/04/america-has-always-been-a-basket-case/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">102886</post-id>				</item>
						</channel>
</rss>
