<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	xmlns:unherd="https://www.unherd.com"
	>

	<channel>
		<title>Alt Histories - UnHerd</title>
		<atom:link href="https://unherd.com/tag/alt-histories/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
		<link>https://unherd.com/tag/alt-histories/</link>
		<description>think again</description>
		<lastBuildDate>Wed, 21 Oct 2020 13:05:15 +0000</lastBuildDate>
		<language>en-US</language>
		<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
		<sy:updateFrequency>12</sy:updateFrequency>
		<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4</generator>

 
<site xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">241381703</site>				<item>
					<title>Europe&#8217;s Islamic golden age</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-the-franks-had-lost-the-battle-of-tours/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-the-franks-had-lost-the-battle-of-tours/?edition=us#respond</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Steuben_-_Bataille_de_Poitiers.png?w=426</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Justin Marozzi]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/justin.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[The AD 732 Interfaith Festival gets off to a rocky start]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Justin Marozzi</strong> is a journalist, historian and travel writer.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>justinmarozzi</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a journalist, historian and travel writer.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 22 Sep 2020 23:07:16 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 25 Sep 2020 11:39:42 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt-history]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Charles Martel]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[The Battle of Tours]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=46789</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[If an Arab army had defeated the Franks in 732, the history of Christendom would have been drastically altered]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>“Bring me his head!” The order came from Abd al Rahman al Ghafiq, the ebullient governor of Al Andalus. The date was 10 October 732, the place was open ground between Tours and Poitiers in western France. It was a gusty day, and to the howls of wind which swept the plain were added the groans of the dying and wounded. Many more bodies, struck down in the fiercest fighting, lay perfectly still and silent.</p>
<p>Abd al Rahman al Ghafiq was exhilarated. Allah had just favoured him with the most exalted victory over the infidel Franks in the heart of Europe. His Arab army, according to the eighth-century Mozarabic Chronicle, had remained “immobile as a wall” against the enemy’s advances and had held together “like a glacier”. Then, “In the blink of an eye, they annihilated the Franks with the sword.”</p>
<p>The Muslim army, once again, was victorious, and in frenzied hand-to-hand fighting the Frankish leader was hacked down and beheaded. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Martel" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">His name was Charles, duke and prince of the Franks.</a> A few hours later one of his senior commanders presented the governor with his blood-smeared trophy. He nodded with satisfaction. “Praise to God. It is done.”</p>
<p>There could be no doubt that God was on the Muslims’ side. Ever since the Prophet Mohammed had first unified the squabbling pagan tribes of the Arabian Peninsula under the banner of Islam, the new faith and its warriors had never looked back. Mohammed had died in 632, a century before the Battle of Tours, and the procession of victories had begun immediately after his death.</p>
<p>In 634 Damascus had fallen, and three years later the hoary old Patriarch of Jerusalem surrendered the Holy City to the Muslim caliph Umar, and by 641 Byzantine Egypt had folded. In 651, Yazdgird III, Persian King of Kings, was killed at Merv in Turkmenistan and the once mighty Sasanian Empire had been toppled. The Byzantines were flattened, too. Out of nowhere the Islamic Empire was rampant and resplendent — but there was more, much more, to come.</p>
<p>From the 670s, Muslim armies fanned across North Africa and swathes of Central Asia. In 711, the Berber commander Tariq ibn Ziyad crossed the Straits of Gibraltar with Muslim forces and landed on the Iberian Peninsula. Within five years the majority of it acknowledged Muslim authority. Coins were issued with a Latin inscription proclaiming the Islamic creed, modelled on Byzantine issues in North Africa: <em>In nomine Dei Non Deus Nisi Deus Solus Non Deus Alius</em>. In the Name of God, There is no God but God.</p>
<p>The Muslim victory at Tours was a turning-point. Had the Christians prevailed at the battle, the 14th-century Egyptian historian Maqrizi imagined, an Arabian fleet might never have sailed unchallenged into the Thames. “Perhaps the interpretation of the Bible, not the Quran, would still be taught in the schools of Oxford, and her pulpits might demonstrate to a God-fearing people the sanctity and truth of the Holy Trinity,” he wrote in <em>The Decline and Fall of the Roman Infidels</em>.</p>
<p>Tours was no one-off raid on the Franks — it marked instead the beginning of Islamic consolidation and expansion in western Europe. For the Iberian Peninsula that the Arabs had travelled through to fight at Tours, the consequences were profound. Starting in the eighth century, droves of Christians converted to the new faith and the sound of church bells tolling became a thing of the past. Jews remained a tolerated minority for centuries to come; they were not hounded out of the Peninsula by the resurgent kingdoms of Castile, Léon, Navarre and Aragón because there was no Reconquista, and there was no Spain. The formerly Christian Hispania of Romans and Visigoths remained proudly Muslim Al Andalus.</p>
<p>The messenger sent to bring the Umayyad caliph Hisham ibn Abd al Malik the stirring news of the victory at Tours failed to find the leader of the Islamic world in his palace in Damascus. He was instead besporting himself in his vast desert palace-fortress of Qasr al Hayr al Sharqi, near Palmyra, where he loved to hunt, listen to music, drink copious bumpers of red wine and seek pleasure in the arms of his concubines. The caliph appeared unimpressed by the Muslim triumph almost three thousand miles to the west.</p>
<p>“It is well,” he said, waving the messenger away. “Let them continue north.”</p>
<p>They followed his command and did just that. After Tours, the Umayyad army under Abd al Rahman al Ghafiq, swelled by defectors, pressed north and east. Over successive  generations, Muslim armies continued the <em>jihad</em>. Many Christians converted at the point of a sword, many more — together with growing numbers of Jews — took up the faith voluntarily.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/unnamed-file.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The greatest stories never told</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Peter Franklin</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Born a decade after Tours, Charles&#8217;s grandson <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlemagne" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Charlemagne</a> grew up in its shadow. As king of the Franks from 771, his energies were consumed not so much by imperial and religious expansion — uniting all the Germanic peoples into one kingdom and converting his subjects to Christianity — but in desperate attempts to resist the mighty Islamic wave crashing over western Christendom. Exalted in his aims, however, he was unsuccessful on the battlefield.</p>
<p>He lived just long enough to see Paris fall to Muslim forces. A year later, in 814, the self-styled Emperor of the Romans died, plunging his embattled kingdom — and much of Europe — into internecine strife, energetically stoked by Umayyad leaders. Bruges fell in 847. By 900 Rome, Genoa, Milan, Florence and Venice had either fallen to the Muslims after fighting or had surrendered voluntarily to avoid further bloodshed. Puppet popes, shorn of real power, henceforth were the order of the day.</p>
<p>There was no Carolingian Renaissance to illuminate the continent. Instead that role fell to those fortune-seeking Muslim scholars who followed in the wake of the Arab warriors. After their lightning campaigns across the continent, the great European monasteries, formerly illustrious centres of learning, were either torched or converted to Islamic <em>madrassas, </em>colleges where students learned the sacred truths of the <em>Quran</em> and <em>fikh</em>, Islamic jurisprudence.</p>
<p>Arab science, medicine and mathematics broke new ground in Muslim Europe. Beginning in the tenth century, Rome, once the fortress of western Christendom, emerged as a powerhouse of Islamic philosophy, law, astronomy, history, geography, cartography and calligraphy. Scholars from as far afield as Damascus, Cairo and Baghdad flocked there to find imperial patronage, translating some of the great works of classical Greek, Hindu and Persian scholarship into Arabic. Seminal works by Plato, Aristotle, Euclid, Hippocrates, Galen and others found their way onto the bookshelves of generations of Umayyad Muslim emirs (princes) in their Roman palaces.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/MV5BMTc0MjQzOTEwMV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwMzE2NTIyMw@@._V1_SX1777_CR001777947_AL_.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>History began with a counterfactual</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom Holland</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Portraiture became virtually unknown in Europe. Learned scholars spoke mysteriously of ancient Persian miniatures depicting images of men, women and animals, but these were frowned upon as the impious works of artists who had lost their way and departed from the true faith. Sculpture died out completely and, led by the Arabs, artistic life focused on architecture, calligraphy, mosaics, pottery, embroidery and carpet-weaving.</p>
<p>Over several centuries, Umayyad power expanded across Europe. Christendom found itself increasingly hemmed in and hard-pressed within the southeastern rump of the continent, harried by ever more damaging Ottoman incursions. Christians no longer looked to compromised Rome for spiritual leadership and salvation, but east to Constantinople, last independent bastion of the faith. There were no Crusades in the Middle East because there were no Christian armies left to fight them.</p>
<p>Then, in 1453, calamity struck. Constantinople had resisted foreign invaders for more than 1,000 years. The long line of would-be conquerors included Attila the Hun (447), the Avars (626), the Umayyad caliph Muawiya (674–678) and the Russians (860). But on 29 May, the 21-year-old Ottoman Sultan Mehmed II finally succeeded where all before him had failed. The Byzantine emperor Constantine XI, &#8220;Constantine Palaiologos, in Christ true Emperor and Autocrat of the Romans&#8221;, to give him his official title, was killed and beheaded in a frantic defence of eastern Christendom’s millennial headquarters.</p>
<p>Orthodox Constantinople, “City of the World’s Desire”, became Muslim Istanbul. The Balkans, much of which had already been conquered, were completely overrun. From one end of the continent to the other, the Muslim crescent, rather than the Christian cross, now dominated the skyline.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Family_of_Henry_VIII_an_Allegory_of_the_Tudor_Succession-1.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The glorious reign of King Henry IX</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Suzannah Lipscomb</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Those who had prayed that peace and prosperity might finally flow from a united Sunni Muslim Europe soon discovered that their hopes and dreams had been illusory. True, there were no sectarian wars pitting Catholics against Protestants, but far worse was to follow.</p>
<p>Arabs and Ottomans may both have been Muslim, but that was all that bound them together. During the Forty Years War, which began in 1460, Arab armies fought repeated campaigns against the Ottomans as Islamic Europe tore itself apart. Muslims, alongside those Jews and Christians who had chosen to retain their faiths and remained <em>dhimmi </em>protected persons in return for payment of the <em>jizya</em> capitation tax, watched aghast as the continent immiserated itself.</p>
<p>There was no Reformation and there was no Renaissance. Western Europe had been gobbled up by Arab Muslim armies, Eastern Europe had succumbed to Ottoman steel and artillery and now the two Muslim forces battled it out for supremacy. For many Europeans, whatever their religion, it seemed as though the Dark Ages had returned.</p>
<p><strong>Justin Marozzi is the author of <em>Islamic Empires: Fifteen Cities that Define a Civilization</em>, published by Penguin.</strong></p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-the-franks-had-lost-the-battle-of-tours/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">46789</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Alaska could have ended history</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/how-alaska-could-have-ended-history/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/how-alaska-could-have-ended-history/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/GettyImages-527005012.jpg?w=526</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Daniel Kalder]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Kalder.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Russian Border guards patrolling along the Bering Sea. Credit: Robert Wallis/Corbis via Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Daniel Kalder</strong> is an author based in Texas. Previously, he spent ten years living in the former Soviet bloc. His latest book, Dictator Literature, is published by Oneworld. He also writes on Substack: <a href="https://danielkalder.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://danielkalder.substack.com/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1659599626668000&amp;usg=AOvVaw1SVxJxNJeN7WjWbgiXHYiX">Thus Spake Daniel Kalder</a>.</p>
<div>
<div class="adL">
<div class="yj6qo"></div>
<div class="adL"></div>
</div>
</div>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>DanielKalder</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is an author based in Texas. Previously, he spent ten years living in the former Soviet bloc. His latest book, Dictator Literature, is published by Oneworld. He also writes on Substack: <a href="https://danielkalder.substack.com/" target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-saferedirecturl="https://www.google.com/url?q=https://danielkalder.substack.com/&amp;source=gmail&amp;ust=1659599626668000&amp;usg=AOvVaw1SVxJxNJeN7WjWbgiXHYiX">Thus Spake Daniel Kalder</a>.
<div>
<div class="adL">
<div class="yj6qo"></div>
<div class="adL"></div>
</div>
</div>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 20 Sep 2020 23:00:04 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Mon, 21 Sep 2020 10:53:52 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alaska]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alexander II]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Cold War]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Khruschev]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Lenin]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Soviet Union]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Stalin]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[USA]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[USSR]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=46588</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[If Russia hadn't sold the territory to the USA, the Cold War might have heated up]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Imagine that in 1867 Alexander II of Russia did not sell Alaska to the USA for $7.2 million (roughly one-third of the budget of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/28/movies/avengers-endgame-box-office.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><em>Avengers: Endgame</em></a> in <a href="https://www.historytoday.com/archive/months-past/alaska-purchase#:~:text=After%20an%20all%2Dnight%20negotiating,about%20two%20cents%20an%20acre." target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">today’s money</a>). It’s easy if you try: just shift the gold rush of 1896 back in time 30 years and suddenly the Tsar has a strong incentive to hang on to his American territories.</p>
<p>From this point we can construct an alternative timeline for the territory, which retains the name Russian America, while <a href="https://www.britannica.com/place/Sitka" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Novo-Arkhangelsk</a> remains the administrative capital. Prospectors arrive <em>en masse</em>, along with religious nonconformists seeking to practice their beliefs free of repression. Thus, the region quickly becomes home to thousands of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skoptsy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Skopts</a>, members of a millenarian sect whose goal was to hasten Christ’s return by initiating 144,000 people into the “fiery baptism” of castration.</p>
<p>Then comes the Bolshevik coup of 1917. Lenin publishes his <em>American Theses </em>in which he argues that “Soviet America” will serve as the spearhead of the (imminent) world revolution as it spreads to the Americas. Instead, civil war breaks out and the White Army seizes control, forcing the indigenous population to dig for gold to fund weapons purchases. The Whites remain in power until <a href="https://www.britannica.com/biography/Mikhail-Vasilyevich-Frunze" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Mikhail Frunze</a>, fresh from his victories over Kolchak and Wrangel, overthrows their regime in early 1921. Refugees pour across the border into Canada, among them thousands of Skopts, who seek new candidates for castration in the Yukon and British Columbia.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/MV5BMTc0MjQzOTEwMV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwMzE2NTIyMw@@._V1_SX1777_CR001777947_AL_.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this series</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>History began with a counterfactual</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom Holland</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Russian America now becomes the American Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic (ASSR) within the <a href="https://www.britannica.com/place/Russia/Government-and-society" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Russian Soviet Federated Socialist Republic</a> (RSFSR). The indigenous peoples are promised equal rights, Novo-Arkhangelsk becomes a naval base, and the inland Skopt settlement of Oskupitel becomes the new capital. It is renamed Londonsk in honour of Jack London, one of Lenin’s favourite authors. Chekists are everywhere.</p>
<p>Following the abortive San Francisco uprising of 1922, Warren G. Harding demands that Lenin stop sending his agents into the US to foment revolution; while dictating his official denial of involvement, the Soviet leader suffers a debilitating stroke. In the following months, Lenin’s would-be successors deliver speeches on the crucial role the American ASSR will play in the coming global revolution. Stalin reissues his <em>Marxism and the National Question </em>with a new postscript on the indigenous peoples of Soviet America. When Lenin dies in 1924, Trotsky is in Londonsk.</p>
<p>By 1927 Stalin has established absolute power over the USSR. He upgrades the American ASSR to a full union republic and nation-building begins in earnest. Stalin’s <em>Foundations of Leninism </em>is translated into Aleut, Tlingit and other local languages. Londonsk acquires broad avenues, theatres, factories (including a <a href="https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/ford-signs-agreement-with-soviet-union" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Ford auto plant</a>), a university and a circus while Le Corbusier designs a never-to-be-completed House of the Soviets.</p>
<p>Anti-US provocations are of course a major part of Soviet foreign policy. In 1929, Stalin establishes the Nat Turner Autonomous Oblast, named in honour of the leader of the <a href="https://www.britannica.com/biography/Nat-Turner" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">1831 slave rebellion</a>, in the southwestern ASSR as a new homeland for the descendants of slaves; Svoboda —“Freedom” — is its capital. Stalin invites all who endure racist oppression in the US to start new lives there, promising them full participation in a “prosperous and cultured society”. Tens of thousands of black Americans take him up on the offer, only for many to find themselves enslaved in the Arctic gulags of the John Reed oblast a few years later.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/the-secrets-of-scotlands-ancient-capital/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/the-secrets-of-scotlands-ancient-capital/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/GettyImages-90734989-e1597932178442.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/the-secrets-of-scotlands-ancient-capital/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/the-secrets-of-scotlands-ancient-capital/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The secrets of Scotland&#039;s ancient capital</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/the-secrets-of-scotlands-ancient-capital/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Daniel Kalder</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Stories of the terrible sufferings of the ASSR’s black émigrés first appear in the foreign press around 1933, but the US — still a deeply racist country — shows little interest in their fate. Meanwhile, Western journalists and useful idiots provide cover for the Soviet regime. In 1935 Walter Duranty of <em>The New York Times </em>wins a Pulitzer for his article proclaiming the success of the “Turner Experiment”; that same year George Bernard Shaw pays a visit and declares that he has never heard so many joyful songs sung so exquisitely as he did in the factories of Svoboda.</p>
<p>The ASSR’s close proximity to the US exacerbates Stalin’s paranoia, and he attempts to turn Canada into a buffer state. When prime minister William Lyon McKenzie King dies suddenly in 1937 and is replaced by a pro-Moscow politician, the US protests vociferously — and suddenly takes an interest in the fate of the black émigrés to the ASSR. By 1941 war appears imminent, but when Hitler invades the USSR Stalin turns away from Canada to focus his attention on the Western Front. In 1942, Japan bombs Pearl Harbour and the two rival powers find themselves fighting alongside each other.</p>
<p>After the war, relations between the USA and the USSR are frostily cordial until 1949, when the Soviets successfully test an atomic bomb in Kazakhstan; the uranium comes from a mine on <a href="https://www.alaskapublic.org/2020/07/12/feds-announce-7-million-plan-to-seal-prince-of-wales-island-uranium-mine/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Mayakovsky Island</a> in the American SSR. The US enters a period of profound existential crisis and Senator Joseph McCarthy leads a mass purge of communist intellectuals and other “enemies of the state” that meets with broad public support.</p>
<p>Following Stalin’s death in 1953, hopes of a thaw are dashed when the new Soviet leader, Nikita Khruschev, denies that the USSR has any nuclear missiles in North America, although Stalin has been stockpiling them since 1949. Khruschev presents himself as the heir to Lenin, and even the independently minded Mao Zedong (grudgingly) falls in line behind this strong horse. Identifying the American SSR as the most significant showroom for what “full communism” will look like, Khruschev pours resources into the region, with the intent of turning Londonsk into the “most advanced, most communist” city in the world. The Yankees, he declares, will “cry like tiny babies” in their jealous rage. Khruschev also permits black émigrés to return to the Nat Turner Autonomous Oblast, although he will not allow repatriations to the US or communication with their families.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/06/the-lessons-communism-left-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/06/the-lessons-communism-left-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/GettyImages-612576242.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/06/the-lessons-communism-left-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/06/the-lessons-communism-left-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Can Europe learn from communism?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/06/the-lessons-communism-left-europe/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Roger Scruton</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>When the hapless JFK is assassinated in 1963, it seems that America may be on the losing side of history. The USSR has put a man in space, extended its influence in Latin America and it also has a large nuclear arsenal in the American SSR. The explosion of the Apollo 11 rocket on the launchpad in 1969, killing everyone on board, set against a background of civil unrest and the disastrous war in Vietnam, becomes a bitterly potent symbol of a nation that has lost its way. A year later Alexei Leonov, the first man to walk in space, becomes the first man to walk on the moon.</p>
<p>In 1971, the ailing Khruschev successfully manages a transition of power to the youthful 57-year-old KGB boss, Yuri Andropov, who has a long track record of quelling dissent both within the USSR and among its satellites. Andropov curtails spending on the “showroom” of the American SSR and redirects that money towards the USSR’s defense capabilities. The Nixon and then Carter administrations make various overtures towards Andropov which are rebuffed. The humiliations of the US reach an apex with the Iranian Revolution in 1979, which ends with Andropov sending in Soviet forces to install the communist <a href="https://www.tudehpartyiran.org/en/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Tudeh Party</a> in power and then magnanimously freeing the hostages held hostage by Islamic radicals in the US embassy. The rage against Jimmy Carter is overwhelming; hardline anti-communist Ronald Reagan is elected with a landslide on the promise that he will reverse two decades of decline and restore America’s honour.</p>
<p>Restoring that honour, of course, entails ramping up weapons production to face the threat (almost) next door. Reagan delivers speech after speech denouncing the USSR for its crimes against the African-Americans it lured to its territory in the 1930s, for its interference in Canadian politics and its belligerence. Andropov, startled by this sudden change in tone from a US that was previously always seeking to strike some kind of deal, responds in kind, and is backed by a wave of op-eds in the elite media from American intellectuals who blame Reagan for stoking tensions between the two superpowers. This reinvigorated cold war turns suddenly hot in 1983, when a siren rings at a base in the American SSR, indicating that the United States has launched a missile strike on the Soviet Union.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/12/nasas-greatest-gamble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/12/nasas-greatest-gamble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/apollo08_earthrise.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/12/nasas-greatest-gamble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/12/nasas-greatest-gamble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Nasa&#039;s greatest gamble</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/12/nasas-greatest-gamble/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Gerard DeGroot</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Now <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-24280831" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">when a similar event happened</a> in our timeline, Stanislav Petrov, the steely-nerved officer on duty thought that it was likely a false alarm and decided against informing his superiors. But we should not allow survivor’s bias to seduce us into thinking that our escape from fiery Armageddon was inevitable. In this alternative timeline, a different man is on duty, and, obeying protocol, he reports the missiles to his superiors. Andropov — who is chronically ill and on the verge of death — launches a retaliatory strike, leading to a full-scale nuclear war. This moment coincides with the Skopts in Canada achieving their long-desired goal of castrating their 144,000th convert. Alas, Christ does not return.</p>
<p>When we imagine alternative outcomes we base our speculations on things that we have seen before, and everything in this essay up to this point is inspired by an event or action that actually took place in the USSR or the US throughout their long rivalry. Soviet propaganda highlighted American racism from its earliest days, and the Nat Turner Autonomous Oblast is based on the Jewish Autonomous Oblast that Stalin established in Russia’s far east. Khruschev’s challenge to US global economic hegemony is imaginatively explored in Francis Spufford’s <a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Red-Plenty-Francis-Spufford/dp/0571225241" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><em>Red Plenty</em></a>. The Skopts persisted in their millenarian quest for over a century. Russia’s need to establish buffer states predates the USSR — and continues to this day. Each superpower saw the other as its shadow; how much more intense would the rivalry and paranoia been had the two rivals been <em>de facto</em> neighbours? If anything, war might have broken out earlier.</p>
<p>But nuclear war? We have never seen that, other than in science fiction. So as much as I am tempted to introduce talking apes or <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjcR9iYj6UQ" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">telepathic dogs</a> into the narrative, such phenomena have no analogues in our species’ experience. What happens next, in truth, is unimaginable. And so, we reach the End of History — and not in the Francis Fukuyama sense, either.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/how-alaska-could-have-ended-history/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">46588</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>History began with a counterfactual</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/MV5BMTc0MjQzOTEwMV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwMzE2NTIyMw@@._V1_SX1777_CR001777947_AL_.jpg?w=657</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Tom Holland]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/tomholland.png?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Athens could easily never have made a comeback after the defeat of the 300. Credit: IMDB]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Tom Holland</strong> is a writer, popular historian and cricketer. He is not an actor. His most recent book is <a href="https://www.tom-holland.org" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>PAX</em></a></p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>holland_tom</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a writer, popular historian and cricketer. He is not an actor. His most recent book is <a href="https://www.tom-holland.org" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>PAX</em></a>]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2020 23:20:21 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Wed, 21 Oct 2020 13:05:15 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Athens]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Greece]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Persia]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Sparta]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Thermopylae]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Xerxes]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=46433</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[If Athens had been wiped out by Persia, perhaps none of us would study the past]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Counter-factuals are as old as history itself. The first historian to imagine an altered timeline was the first historian. Herodotus, whose ‘<em>historia</em>’ — ‘enquiries’ — into the great events that had recently shaken the Greek world served to establish history as an entire new genre, knew that some of his perspectives on the past were bound to prove controversial. Of these, the one he evidently felt most uncomfortable expressing was his conviction that the Athenians ranked as the saviours of Greece. This was, he freely admitted, “an opinion which most people will find hard to stomach.” Nevertheless, he stuck to it. Not only that, but he also sought to justify it in a most novel way.</p>
<p>Herodotus’ high estimation of the debt owed by Greece to the Athenians rested on his interpretation of the epic events of the year that we commemorate as 480 BC. 2,500 years ago this summer, the King of Persia crossed the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dardanelles" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Hellespont</a> at the head of a massive army and fleet. Xerxes ruled the largest empire that the world had ever seen, and the resources available to him seemed so stupefying to the Greeks as to appear effectively limitless. Many, convinced that they had no prospect of resisting such an adversary, scrambled to collaborate.</p>
<p>Only a few cities, headed by Athens and the peerless warrior-state of Sparta, refused to surrender. At Thermopylae, a pass to the north of Athens, a Greek holding-force led by a Spartan king was dislodged after three days’ brutal fighting, and the Spartan king killed. Athens fell soon afterwards. The Acropolis was stormed and burned. But then, in the waters off a nearby island called Salamis, the Greek fleet won an unexpected victory. The following summer, an alliance of various Greek cities routed the Persian land forces. The liberty of mainland Greece was definitively secured. To the Greeks themselves it seemed a barely believable triumph: the most astounding victory of all time.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Family_of_Henry_VIII_an_Allegory_of_the_Tudor_Succession-1.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this series</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The glorious reign of King Henry IX</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Suzannah Lipscomb</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Who, though, had best earned the bragging rights? Since it was the Athenians who had provided by far the largest contingent of ships at Salamis, and it was Salamis that had proved the decisive engagement, no one could really deny that their role in defeating the Persian invasion had been a significant one. Nevertheless, over the course of the decades that followed, patience with the notion loudly trumpeted by the Athenians that Greece owed them her freedom came to wear very thin. Athenian triumphalism proved as wearying to other Greeks as English chants about the Second World War tend to be today to continental football fans. Nor was boasting all the Athenians did to make themselves unpopular. Cities liberated from Persian rule in the wake of Xerxes’ defeat increasingly found themselves the victims of an Athenian extortion racket. Sparta, the city that alongside Athens had led the resistance to the Persian invasion, grew ever more alarmed. Relations between the erstwhile allies fell apart. In 431, cold war exploded into open conflict — destined to rage for decades to come. The whole Greek world was made to bleed. Such was the background against which Herodotus wrote his history.</p>
<p>So it was, painfully conscious of making a case that was bound to infuriate many, he invented alternative history. Suppose, he pondered, that the Athenians had refused to fight Xerxes. Suppose instead that they had set sail in their fleet for some distant land, or had actively collaborated.</p>
<p>Both options had certainly been open to them. The Persian king had gone to considerable efforts to win them over to his side. His terms had been generous in the extreme. The Athenians might well have succumbed to temptation. In that event, so Herodotus argued, the fight for Greek liberty would have been doomed. Sparta’s allies would have surrendered. The Spartans themselves might have done the same. Alternatively — following the example set by their compatriots at Thermopylae — they might have opted to stand alone, and then, “after displays of prodigious valour, gone down in a blaze of glory.” Either way, the King of Kings would have succeeded in adding a further satrapy to his immense dominion. Greece would have ceased to be free.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/04/britains-first-brexit-was-the-hardest/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/04/britains-first-brexit-was-the-hardest/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Screen-Shot-2019-04-08-at-13.49.17-e1610309074159.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/04/britains-first-brexit-was-the-hardest/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/04/britains-first-brexit-was-the-hardest/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Britain&#039;s first Brexit was the hardest</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/04/britains-first-brexit-was-the-hardest/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Tom Holland</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>That this in turn would have had implications for the entire world was something that Herodotus never doubted. Indeed, it was precisely his conviction that the great war between the Greeks and the Persians had also been a global war that first inspired him to embark on his masterwork — and which led him, in the course of writing it, to range in his subject matter as far afield as Ethiopia and India. Many historians since have concurred with him that the Greek victory over the Persian invasion force was indeed one of the key turning points in world history.</p>
<p>If Salamis has been enshrined as a particularly decisive moment, then so too has the victory won by the Athenians 10 years earlier, when a Persian expeditionary force sent to burn their city and transport the survivors into slavery had been defeated <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Marathon" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">on the plain of Marathon</a>. John Stuart Mill famously claimed that the battle, “even as an event in British history, is more important than the Battle of Hastings.”</p>
<p>Unsurprisingly, then, timelines in which Athens is wiped from the face of the earth have long been a popular feature of alternative history. Mill himself imagined one in which Britons and Saxons continued to wander like savages in woods. Others — drawing on a counterfactual proposed by Livy, in which Alexander the Great was imagined confronting Rome — have portrayed a Mediterranean fought over by Persian kings and Roman consuls. Others yet portray a world converted to Zoroastrianism, or without democracy, or in which Christianity and Islam were never born. All these various alternative histories, despite running in a bewildering array of directions, bear witness to the same founding conviction: that a war in which the Persians had succeeded in conquering Greece would have echoed in eternity.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/what-does-my-gladiator-dream-mean/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/what-does-my-gladiator-dream-mean/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/GettyImages-520720601.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/what-does-my-gladiator-dream-mean/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/what-does-my-gladiator-dream-mean/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>What does my gladiator dream mean?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/what-does-my-gladiator-dream-mean/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Daniel Kalder</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Perhaps — or perhaps not. Conjecture on such a theme can hardly help but shade into fantasy. In sombre truth, we know far too little about what did actually happen in the Persian Wars to speculate — except on the most tentative basis — about what failed to happen. This is why Herodotus’ own attempt at a counterfactual is so valuable. While it tells us nothing about the possible impact of a Greek defeat on Rome or Christianity or the Anglo-Saxons, it does provide us with a near-contemporary perspective on how the Persians might have won.</p>
<p>Herodotus’ alternative history is one in which a new Athens is founded far distant from the soil of Attica, perhaps in Sicily or Italy, or else endures in pampered slavery, as a client of the King of the Kings. The Spartans, humbled or destroyed, can no longer continue with the merciless exploitation of their neighbours that had been the foundation of their pre-eminence. The Persian monarchy, brilliantly subtle as it was in the exploitation of its subjects’ rivalries, would doubtless have made sure to grant patronage to cities long resentful of Athenian and Spartan greatness. Perhaps, over the course of the century that followed Xerxes’ victory, Greece would have experienced an unprecedented period of peace. Or perhaps, resentful of barbarian rule, and seeking to take advantage of their distance from the Persian centre of power, the Greeks would have risen in revolt, bringing yet further war to their cities, and suffering on a scale greater even than they were to endure as the result of the great war between Athens and Sparta. It is impossible to know. The path not travelled is a path inevitably lost to oblivion.</p>
<p>For all that, though, the value of Herodotus’ counter-factual does not lie merely in its elucidation of the role played by the Athenian fleet in the ultimate victory of the Greeks. It also focuses for us a question that can risk otherwise, perhaps, remaining obscured. What was it, precisely, that made Athens Athens? Would an Athenian demos that had transplanted itself to foreign soil or submitted to barbarian rule still have ranked as an Athenian demos at all? To what extent were the achievements of the restless, turbulent and self-confident democracy of the fifth century BC dependent on its successful defiance of the most powerful ruler on the face of the earth? “Only the gods did more.” Such was Herodotus’ judgement on the record of the Athenians in the Persian wars. We might be tempted to brush such a comment aside as a mere platitude — but that would be a mistake.</p>
<p>Athenian democracy was founded neither on a secular model of governance nor on any abstract understanding of individual rights. Both concepts, as distinctive products of Christian civilisation, would have meant precisely nothing to an ancient Greek. What sustained Athenian democracy instead was — in the words of Greg Anderson — “a primordial cosmic ecology of gods, land, and people.” This is why to imagine an Athens transplanted from Attic soil to some distant land or under the imperious sway of a satrap is to imagine a city very different from the one that emerged triumphant from the epic ordeal of the Persian invasion. Its democracy would, perhaps, have continued to function; but it would not have been the democracy that provided a stage for the tragedies of Aeschylus, the comedies of Aristophanes, the philosophy of Socrates. Nor, indeed, for the history of Thucydides.</p>
<p>Perhaps Herodotus himself, born a subject of the King of Kings though he was, might never have been inspired to write about “the glory of those exploits which served to display Greeks and barbarians alike to such effect” had the Athenians themselves ended up subject to Persian rule. His counter-factual, then, implies a truly disorienting possibility: a world in which history — and counter-factuals — never came to exist.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-there-were-no-athens/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">46433</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>What if Magna Carta had died (in vain)?</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-magna-carta-had-died-in-vain/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-magna-carta-had-died-in-vain/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/GettyImages-463963413.jpg?w=541</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Polly Mackenzie]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/POlly.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA['If you could just sign above where it says "King John". The date? 15th June I believe.' Photo: The Print Collector/Print Collector/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Polly Mackenzie</strong> is Director of Demos, a leading cross-party think tank. She served as Director of Policy to the Deputy Prime Minister from 2010-2015.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>pollymackenzie</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is Director of Demos, a leading cross-party think tank. She served as Director of Policy to the Deputy Prime Minister from 2010-2015.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2020 10:51:36 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 17 Sep 2020 11:10:41 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alfred the Great]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt-history]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[King John]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Last Kingdom]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Magna Carta]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Runnymede]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=46483</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[The agreement between King John and the barons has become part of the English national myth]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>It is June 1215. Thousands of tents line the water meadows of Runnymede, on the banks of the Thames, as England’s worst ever King, John, meets the ranks of his rebellious barons, to negotiate peace. Drafts of a treaty are circulated, setting out what will become foundational principles of our nation-state in the document known as Magna Carta.</p>
<p>King John is reluctant to accept the idea that the monarch should be subject to the rule of law, and he believes God — at least in the form of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Innocent_III" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Pope Innocent</a> — is on his side. But John is at an impasse. He cannot defeat the barons, who now hold London. And Pope Innocent is far away.</p>
<p>The worst clause in Magna Carta, from John’s perspective, is the one which gives authority to 24 Barons to adjudicate disputes, and overrule the king if they believe he is breaking the law — known to us as <a href="https://www.salisburycathedral.org.uk/magna-carta-what-magna-carta/key-clauses-magna-carta" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">&#8220;Security Clause&#8221;,</a> or Clause 61. So, John pulls off one last trick: he attaches his seal to the document before the barons have chosen their 24 names. The chance to name them in writing is gone, and by the time John’s son Henry III re-issues Magna Carta in November 1216, after his father’s death, that crucial clause is gone. Yes: the king is subject to the law in theory. But there is no mechanism to enforce that law.</p>
<p>Despite its flaws, we British love Magna Carta. But what if John, who reignited the civil war by trying to flout its restrictions almost immediately, had never agreed to it?</p>
<p>The barons hated their king. The medieval chronicler Matthew Paris gave a good sense of the esteem in which the monarch was held when he wrote upon his death in October 1216: “Foul as it is, hell itself is defiled by the foulness of John.” John’s greatest predilections were for arbitrary justice and punitive taxation, much of which might have been forgiven if he hadn’t also had a remarkable ability to lose the expensive wars on which he embarked.</p>
<p>He lost all the territory in France that his father, Henry II, had conquered, and when he attempted to retake those lands in the Anglo-French War of 1213-14, he was comprehensively defeated at the Battle of Bouvines in July 1214. The barons, who had been taxed through the nose to pay for this war, were furious. It is hard to overstate their determination to bring the king under the rule of law.</p>
<p>To do so they forged allegiances with Alexander II, King of Scotland, and Llewelyn the Great, the Welsh Prince, and both rulers took up arms against John — despite the fact that each was married to one of his daughters.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/unnamed-file.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The greatest stories never told</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Peter Franklin</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>If John had refused to agree to Magna Carta, the rebellion would have continued, and the determination to shift the balance of power against the monarch would have deepened still further. John had castles, and armies — largely of French mercenaries — but with Alexander to the north, and Llewelyn to the west, he was in trouble. Llewelyn’s wife Joan had already told her father in 1212 that he was likely to be killed by the Welsh if he tried to take their lands. So it is not hard to imagine the assassination, or death in battle, of the king, if the war had continued.</p>
<p>You might argue that, given John died of dysentery the following year anyway, history would have plotted a very similar course. Prior to his death, half the barons had turned to Prince Louis of France as an alternate monarch, and invited him to invade, which he did. When John died, allegiances shifted to Prince Henry, John’s nine-year old son, as he looked easier to control than an ambitious French prince. In the end Louis had to be bribed to give up his claim and go home, becoming King <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louis_VIII_of_France" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Louis VIII</a> of France the following decade.</p>
<p>But without a legal declaration of Magna Carta, I believe history would have played out very differently. The terms of peace treaties are settled by power. With John dead and only a boy prince to turn to, the barons would never have dropped their demand for that crucial legal power: the right to overrule the king. This would have made us unique across Europe, effectively giving us a constitutional monarchy 400 years early.</p>
<p>First: this would have put us at odds with the most powerful man in Europe, Pope Innocent III. Innocent issued a papal bull annulling even the watered-down Magna Carta: he condemned it as &#8220;illegal, unjust, harmful to royal rights and shameful to the English people&#8221;, and declared it &#8220;null, and void of all validity for ever&#8221;. He would have been horrified by the complete version — as would Prince Louis, who I doubt would have taken up the invitation to invade if it had come at such a cost.</p>
<p>As Henry VIII discovered 300 years later, disagreeing with the Pope is rather a slippery slope. If he’s wrong, why agree with anything inconvenient about the hegemony of the Catholic church? Why have a king at all, even one you can control, if you can just agree the laws among yourselves?</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Family_of_Henry_VIII_an_Allegory_of_the_Tudor_Succession-1.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The glorious reign of King Henry IX</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Suzannah Lipscomb</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Those 24 barons could have formed a different way of running the state — similar, perhaps to the system developed by the Swiss Confederacy a hundred or so years later. An oligarchy of the great families, each with their own dominion, and an Extra-Magna Carta to take the rule of law to an even higher level. Llewelyn and Alexander might have joined as equals, or partners. Instead of the nation of England dominating these islands, we might have seen England fragment to a loose alliance between micro-nations like Northumbria, Cornwall, Mercia and Yorkshire, living largely peaceably with the other small nations of Ireland, Scotland and Wales.</p>
<p>If that sounds outlandish, remember that most of Europe was made of tiny states for the first 800 years of the last millennium. Of course, the Holy Roman Empire brought many nations — including the Swiss confederacy — under its orbit, but the countries it comprised still existed, and were small. A confederated realm of German princedoms existed until 1871, when it united as a nation-state. The unification of Italy’s city-states and princedoms was completed in 1861. France consolidated earlier, but its territorial history remains immensely complex, including unification with Brittany, Burgundy and Savoy, and various degrees of autonomy in more remote regions. England didn’t have to be England.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/GettyImages-150616205-1-e1599727567165.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Imagine a world without the USA...</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> James Kirkup</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Would the British confederacy have been as ambitious in its colonial ambitions? It seems unlikely. The baronial oligarchy would have been established as a direct result of failed attempts at territorial expansion in France; it seems likely they would have given up on expensive wars at least for a time, not least because any attempt to take their pioneering system of government across the channel might have brought papal authority down upon them. Simply defending their shores, and ironing out the inevitable inter-baronial disputes, would have been the priority.</p>
<p>In our national myth, we think of England as manifest destiny: it’s there in the Arthurian legend. The formation of Albion, as John Hurt endlessly intoned in BBC adaptation of Merlin a decade ago. It’s King Alfred’s tireless goal in the <em>Last Kingdom</em> series, adapted from Bernard Cornwell’s novels about a Viking warrior who fights alongside the West Saxon king.</p>
<p>But the reality is that England is too big for these islands. Its size is what makes the Union impossible. England has about 56 million inhabitants, 84% of the UK’s population, and 78% of all those living in the British Isles, including the Republic of Ireland. We cannot have an English Parliament, because it would so absurdly dominate the Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish equivalents. And that leaves the English with a sense of national identity that has been sold in myth and legend for 800 years, but no government of their own.</p>
<p>If the British confederacy had been founded back in 1215, it might have unified like Germany and Italy in the nineteenth century. But it would have been a partnership of many equals, instead of a single giant state setting out to dominate its smaller neighbours. England might not be England. But, unlike our current, fracturing union, my hypothetical Union of the British Isles might have a chance of remaining united. It might even have stayed in the European Union.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-magna-carta-had-died-in-vain/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">46483</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Did the French Revolution cause Nazism?</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/how-the-french-revolution-caused-nazism/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/how-the-french-revolution-caused-nazism/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/GettyImages-113448824-e1600096291227.jpg?w=561</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[John Lewis-Stempel]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/johnlewisstempel.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[The French Revolution unleashed tyranny in Europe. Credit: Universal History Archive/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>John Lewis-Stempel</strong> is a farmer and writer on nature and history. His most recent books are <a href="https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/441214/the-sheeps-tale-by-lewis-stempel-john/9781804991145" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Sheep&#8217;s Tale</em></a> and <a href="https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/451867/nightwalking-by-lewis-stempel-john/9780857529114" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Nightwalking</em></a>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>JLewisStempel</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a farmer and writer on nature and history. His most recent books are <a href="https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/441214/the-sheeps-tale-by-lewis-stempel-john/9781804991145" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>The Sheep's Tale</em></a> and <a href="https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/451867/nightwalking-by-lewis-stempel-john/9780857529114" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em>Nightwalking</em></a>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Mon, 14 Sep 2020 23:04:04 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 15 Sep 2020 11:00:58 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Communism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Fascism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[French Revolution]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hitler]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Jacobins]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Marie Antoinette]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Marx]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Nazism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Robespierre]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Socialism]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=46323</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[If Louis XVI had hung onto his throne, Europe wouldn't have been overrun by tyranny]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>For the want of a fast coach, the Kingdom of France was lost. For the want of a Kingdom, the French Revolution succeeded. And so Europe was put on the long and bloody path from guillotine to gulag.</p>
<p>You didn&#8217;t really think the French Revolution was a force for good, did you? As if. All the great political woes of the modern era — Communism, Fascism, and its German <em>bier</em> and swastika variant, Nazism — have their tangled, bitter beginnings in the storming of the Bastille. The French Revolution was the<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>taproot of Tyranny in our time. No French Revolution, no Marx, no Hitler. <em>Voila</em>!</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/GettyImages-150616205-1-e1599727567165.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this series</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Imagine a world without the USA...</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> James Kirkup</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The French Revolution began in 1789 as an Enlightenment experiment.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>In 1793, however, the Jacobins, led by Robespierre, tried to<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>turn<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>France<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>into a Rousseauian theme park — where the people were<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span><i>sans</i> private possessions and <i>sans</i><span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>self-interest,<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>but were suborned to the state (&#8220;the general will&#8221;) — by destroying the rich. The Jacobins also wanted to export the &#8216;benedictions&#8217; of Revolution via the barrel of a cannon.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p>Sound familiar? Yes, it is the same millenarian collectivist philosophy of Marx, Lenin, Stalin, Mussolini, Hitler, Pol Pot, Osama Bin Laden. The accompanying <i>praxis </i>was, and is, murder. Mass murder. As Robespierre so delightfully put it: “We must smother the internal and external enemies of the Republic or perish with them…Terror is nothing but prompt, severe, inflexible justice; it is therefore an emanation of virtue.” Before 1793, Europe<span class="Apple-converted-space">  </span>was no stranger to violence, but not until the French Revolution was murder used systematically<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>to erase a designated<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>internal enemy from its existence. The Jacobin&#8217;s mass firing squads<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>anticipated absolutely the Nazis’ <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einsatzgruppen" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><em>Einsatzgruppen</em></a>.</p>
<p>The Jacobins desired<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>“Year One,” a cheerless utopia in which individual freedom was rescinded in the name of the commune, and where the people<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>were dosed<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>daily with propaganda<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>to rid them of their vices — such as the desire to own a home of their own (&#8220;Property is theft!&#8221;), to possess freedom of thought or to enjoy a private life. The Jacobins and their descendant mini-mes, in their thirst and thrust for absolute power, have disavowed all ordinary amusements. Hence the purist, monkish public image cultivated by Robespierre, Hitler, Mao, et al.</p>
<p>It could have been so different.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>In June 1791 Louis XVI was about to flee Paris in a fast carriage; at the last moment, MarieAntoinette (and her voluminous baggage) insisted on accompanying him, rather than travelling separately. Uxorious to the nth degree, the king agreed. Consequently, they took the big and literal slow coach instead of the speedy light one — and were intercepted by revolutionaries a mere 25 miles from the safety of the Belgian border. The royal couple were then returned to Paris to be shortened by Madame Guillotine.</p>
<p>But in a parallel universe, there exist <i>Les Annals Alternatives de la France </i>and they tell of Europe&#8217;s avoidance of the nightmare of tyranny: the right, fast route taken. The relevant extract follows.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/frances-african-forever-war/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/frances-african-forever-war/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/GettyImages-1184517941.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/frances-african-forever-war/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/frances-african-forever-war/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>France&#039;s African forever war</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/frances-african-forever-war/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> John Lewis-Stempel</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>On the night of 20/21 June 1791 in the Tuileries Palace, Louis XVI<span class="Apple-converted-space">  </span>patted his powdered wig and said to the queen: &#8220;Don&#8217;t be daft, <em>ma petite chou</em>, one valise only! <em>Vite</em>!&#8221; Their light coach sped from Paris, to meet loyal soldiers, who escorted the royal family over the border into Belgium. The king, who was a <i>realiste</i>, understood there was<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>only one power that could<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>truly aid him. Thus he swallowed his pride and sailed across <em>La Manche</em> to perfidious Albion, where he was welcomed with wide arms and pawky eyes.</p>
<p>From Britain, Louis XVI sowed discord in France, and eventually reinvaded successfully in 1794. But there was a cost: to pay for his fomenting of counter-revolution he hocked Louisiana and other French properties to Britain. With France disengaged from North America, Britain  had the whip hand over the uppity colonials and won the War of 1812, controlling all of North America into the late 21st Century (latterly on a Canadian &#8220;member of Empire&#8221; model, rather than direct rule). Britain henceforth not only ruled the waves (having sequestered the French fleet): it ruled half of <i>terra firma. </i></p>
<p>Louis<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>XVI reinstalled himself as a reforming monarch and the Revolution stalled, spluttered and died. Louis, a convinced Catholic, retained strong support from the powerful and fiercely anti-revolutionary Church, while his encouragement of legislative self-government separated the mass of revolutionaries from the Jacobin hardliners. Thus, he commanded majority support. However, bound to the Church as the new France was, it made stony ground for science, and France&#8217;s Industrial Revolution was henceforth a stuttering affair similar to that of its southern neighbour, Spain. (Britain, meanwhile, boomed.)</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/05/what-does-it-mean-to-be-french/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/05/what-does-it-mean-to-be-french/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/GettyImages-672021820.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/05/what-does-it-mean-to-be-french/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/05/what-does-it-mean-to-be-french/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>What does it mean to be French?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/05/what-does-it-mean-to-be-french/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> John Lichfield</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The &#8220;proto-communists&#8221; of the Revolution did not disappear entirely: their creed was taken up by an obscure German PhD student called Karl Marx. However,<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>he failed to find a following outside students in the newer universities and &#8220;polytechnics&#8221;. Moderate socialism, however, became a mass force, under the banner &#8220;Reform not Revolution!&#8221; Indeed, this became the mantra of the entire of Europe. &#8220;Ink not Blood!&#8221;<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>was another popular slogan.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p>The definitive termination of the revolutionary mindset in France itself came with<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>Louis XVI&#8217;s exiling of<span class="Apple-converted-space"> &#8220;</span>The 500&#8243; (the principal leaders of the Revolution) to the island of<span class="Apple-converted-space">  </span>New Caledonia where, deprived of<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span><em>vin rouge</em> and tobacco, the scarlet and the black, they withered and died.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>Louis&#8217;s political adroitness — the exile was torture which appeared to be clemency — was compared to that of Machiavelli&#8217;s <em>Prince</em>.</p>
<p>Inevitably, monarchist France, isolated and enfeebled militarily, produced no <i>sturm und drang </i>reaction in its Germanic neighbours, who failed to proceed beyond a loose federation of Ruritanians. (Essentially, there was nothing for them to unite against; as the saying goes, no grit, no oyster.)<span class="Apple-converted-space"> &#8220;</span>Romanticism&#8221; achieved a certain following in Germanic coffee houses and <em>bierkellers</em>. But no more than that.</p>
<p>In a <i>cause célèbre</i> one such Romantic, Adolf Hitler, fell off his ladder in 1967 while<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>daubing anti-Jewish slogans on the walls of the Reichstag. His 30-person strong National Socialist Party claimed he was pushed by agents of the Rothschild banking dynasty. The pathologist&#8217;s report determined that Herr Hitler had suffered an aneurism, which was accepted by the house painter&#8217;s lover, Bruno, 72.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/why-europes-last-dictator-has-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/why-europes-last-dictator-has-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/GettyImages-1212264092.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/why-europes-last-dictator-has-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/why-europes-last-dictator-has-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>How Europe&#039;s Last Dictator survived</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/why-europes-last-dictator-has-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Daniel Kalder</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Curiously, despite its diminished standing in Europe, there were two spheres in which France led the continent post-Restoration, these being philosophy and music. With the planet dominated by three centuries of<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>the British political model of safely safely pragmatism, French<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span><i>philosophes </i>continually<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>engaged with what 20th Century Parisian academic Jean-Paul Sartre termed<span class="Apple-converted-space"> &#8220;</span>The Ennui of Anglicisation&#8221; in his book <i>Critique de la raison Britannique</i>. (In his suicide note Sartre declared &#8220;The British Way is So Boring I Revolt by Self-Murder&#8221;; a number of other <i>philosophes</i> imitated him, including the Marxist adherent Louis Althusser, who strangled himself with his wife&#8217;s stocking.)</p>
<p>To the disappointment — and contempt — of the <i>philosophes,</i><span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>the people showed no inclination to either rise in rebellion or to self-annihilate. Latent hankerings for the excitement of revolution in <em>This Most Boring of All Possible Worlds</em> (see Jacques Derrida, <i>Writing and Indifference</i>, 1962) were ultimately diverted into &#8220;pop rock&#8221;, the ultimate Anglo-Saxon cultural victory. And so French entertainer Johnny Hallyday became the biggest-selling singer on the planet in the second half of the 20th century, after re-releasing all his songs in English.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/how-the-french-revolution-caused-nazism/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">46323</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>What if the feminists had won?</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-the-feminists-had-won/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-the-feminists-had-won/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/GettyImages-154420575.jpg?w=449</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Mary Harrington]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/mary.jpeg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Women workers at the Small Arms Cartridge Factory No.3 at Woolwich Arsenal, London. Employment opportunities were opened up by the fact that most men were getting shot at by Germans. Photo by G P Lewis/ Imperial War Museums via Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Mary Harrington</strong> is a contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>moveincircles</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is a contributing editor at <em>UnHerd</em>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Sun, 13 Sep 2020 23:04:50 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Sun, 13 Sep 2020 23:04:50 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt-history]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Eleanor Rathbone]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Feminism]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[First World War]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Second World War]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=46224</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Eleanor Rathbone's proposal to pay women for housework and childcare was just too ahead of its time]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>Who could have predicted that the competing demands of industry, trade unions and the indefatigable feminist Eleanor Rathbone would end up saving Britain and its empire from war in 1939?</p>
<p>As Britain industrialised during the 19<sup>th</sup> century, work increasingly happened outside the home. This in turn split the roles of men and women. Whereas a pre-industrial England household might combine subsistence farming with artisan trades, with both men and women working, industrialisation made it much more difficult to combine out-of-home work with the care of dependent children. Thus what had once been the situation for only the wealthiest women became a new aspirational standard: a &#8220;<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cult_of_Domesticity">cult of domesticity&#8221;</a> in which women did not work but rather were responsible for &#8220;higher&#8221; moral and emotional values.</p>
<p>The evangelical writer Thomas Gisborne’s 1797 <a href="https://books.google.co.uk/books/about/An_Enquiry_Into_the_Duties_of_the_Female.html?id=oDMEAAAAYAAJ&amp;redir_esc=y"><em>An Enquiry into the Duties of the Female Sex</em></a> sums up this moral framework. The duty of women, he wrote, is “to give delight in the affectionate intercourse of domestic society;…to smooth the bed of sickness…and to promote useful institutions…for the instruction of children”. And the place of women is in the home.</p>
<p>As Gisborne puts it:</p>
<blockquote><p><em>“Home is the centre round which the influence of every married woman is accumulated. It is there that she will naturally be known and respected the most; it is there, at least, that she may be more known and more respected than she can be in any other place.”</em></p></blockquote>
<p>Wives who &#8220;had to go out to work&#8221; were a source of shame in this new society of &#8220;<a href="https://www.bl.uk/romantics-and-victorians/articles/gender-roles-in-the-19th-century">separate spheres&#8221;</a>. But as the 19<sup>th</sup> century wore on, this moral framework faced a new, double threat. On the one hand groups such as the <a href="https://first100years.org.uk/the-langham-place-group/">Langham Place Circle</a> began to campaign for women’s entry into academia and professional life. On the other, industrialists — whose factories had been instrumental in creating the split between home and work in the first place — began to see the advantage of hiring women.</p>
<p>By the beginning of the 20<sup>th</sup> century British industry was increasingly worried by manufacturing competition from overseas, and this was exacerbated by another downward pressure on manufacturing profits: the emerging trade union movement. In a manufacturing world where many jobs were highly skilled, striking workers couldn’t easily be replaced. Those workers began to use their power.</p>
<p>Privately, leaders of industry identified women as a solution to both problems. Because for the most part women only worked until they got married, you could pay them less, as unmarried women did not have families to support.</p>
<p>Women were less physically strong than men, but they would tolerate repetitive and dull work for the shorter duration of their working lives. So manufacturing jobs could be broken down into less demanding tasks — &#8220;diluted&#8221; — for female employees, making processes more efficient and lowering costs. This change also weakened male labour unions, by sharpening wage competition as well as reducing the bargaining power of skilled workers.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/GettyImages-150616205-1-e1599727567165.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this series</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Imagine a world without the USA...</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> James Kirkup</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Here the economic interests of the industrialists aligned with those of a growing chorus of women. Being &#8220;Angel of the House&#8221; was all very well if your husband was both well-paid and inclined to pass his earnings on to his wife and children. But it was less idyllic for those women married to men whose work was sporadic, or to men who gambled or drank their salaries and left their families to go hungry. Such women joined the more middle-class feminist campaigns for women’s education and voting rights, calling for equal pay for equal work.</p>
<p>When war broke out in 1914, the twin drive by feminists and industrialists for women’s greater access to the workplace was accelerated by the disappearance of much of the male workforce into military service. In July 1914, 3.3 million women worked in paid employment in Britain; <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/27508026">by 1917, 4.7 million women worked</a>, a jump from 24% of the total workforce to 37%.</p>
<p>It was in this context that feminist Eleanor Rathbone wrote her 1917 essay <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/172376"><em>On the Remuneration of Women</em></a>. Rathbone foresaw the rise in women working during the war as a potential threat to the wellbeing of women and children throughout the country.</p>
<p>The main beneficiaries of women’s employment in manufacturing, she argued, would be industrialists. These individuals could boost their profits by hiring young women on a rapid-turnover basis, rather than highly skilled men on a long-term permanent basis. But this change ran counter to the interests of both men (most of whom had families to support) and also the non-working women — which in practice usually meant married mothers — who relied on these men’s salaries. Rathbone foresaw a looming post-war conflict between employers keen to save money by hiring unmarried women, and the trade unions keen to protect their male members’ careers.</p>
<p>A second wartime phenomenon was the &#8220;separation allowance&#8221; paid by the Government to non-working wives of serving soldiers to ensure dependent women and children were not left to starve in their husbands’ absence. Rathbone identified the separation allowance as a model for solving these impending conflicts.</p>
<p>She argued that the work of rearing and caring for the next generation was of such profound national importance that women should be supported by the government for doing it. The separation allowance was in effect a government payment to women for motherhood, and Rathbone suggested that such an allowance should be extended beyond wartime, for all married mothers. This, she argued, would not only acknowledge the value of motherhood but also provide women with an incentive to focus on family life instead of on a wage competition with men that degraded employment conditions for everyone.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Family_of_Henry_VIII_an_Allegory_of_the_Tudor_Succession-1.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this series</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The glorious reign of King Henry IX</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Susannah Lipscomb</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Rathbone’s arguments initially fell on deaf ears; returning soldiers got their jobs back, by and large, and most women left manufacturing. But the stigma on factory work had been broken. In 1923, <a href="https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1923/mar/21/domestic-service-committee-appointed">a government enquiry</a> investigated the now acute shortage of domestic servants. The committee reported that it was driven by the growing availability and &#8220;respectability&#8221; of manufacturing work: girls no longer sought work as housemaids but on assembly lines. This revelation, combined with a wave of strikes across the North-West over &#8220;female blacklegs&#8221;, prompted action by newly-elected Conservative Prime Minister Stanley Baldwin.</p>
<p>Baldwin was under pressure on many fronts. With cheaper imported goods driving down prices and profits, manufacturers were laying off workers, and Baldwin faced calls for a return to protectionist tariffs to defend British industry. After meeting Rathbone through <a href="https://illustratedwomeninhistory.com/eleanor-rathbone-was-an-independent-british-mp">her key role negotiating women’s partial inclusion in the 1918 Representation of the People Act</a>, he took a different approach. Baldwin’s 1923 Mothers’ Allowance Bill used the separation allowance as a model for a universal payment to married or widowed mothers with dependent children.</p>
<p>In private letters, Baldwin acknowledged his calculation that the Mothers’ Allowance would serve in part as a subsidy on the wages of married men, thus enabling manufacturers to keep wages lower. His gamble worked. Wages dropped, male employment rose, prices remained low and foreign imports lost competitiveness. Baldwin evaded a fight within the Conservative Party on tariffs that he feared he would not win.</p>
<p>The policy was wildly popular across the electorate, playing well with both conservative sensibilities on the proper roles of men and women, but also with newly-enfranchised women voters. Feminists argued that this remuneration for motherhood represented recognition for the first time of women’s &#8220;different but equal&#8221; contribution to the national interest.</p>
<p>This was reinforced when Baldwin rapidly followed the Mothers’ Allowance legislation with a second Bill enfranchising women on an equal basis with men. In his speech welcoming the Representation of Women Act (1924), Baldwin stated that “The work of women in the family and household, while different to that of men, carries equal weight and is of equal national value. We have now corrected a longstanding injustice that weighed women as lesser in the scales to men.”</p>
<p>Not all feminists were supportive. Millicent Fawcett criticised the 1924 Act as a sop thrown to women to offset “the permanent thwarting of women’s aspirations to higher employment or public life”, ensuring that instead women would be “locked forever in a gilded domestic cage, bought and paid by Mr Baldwin’s forty pieces of silver”. She was mocked at the time for decrying the very franchise she had long campaigned for, with what the <em>Spectator</em> called &#8220;the gracelessness we’ve come to expect from that most graceless of creatures, the Feminist&#8221;.</p>
<p>But Fawcett was in a minority. The entitlement was taken up near-universally, and by the mid-1930s less than 2% of married British women were in paid employment; one consequence was that voluntary work blossomed and charitable and educational endeavours of every kind filled all strata of society.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/unnamed-file.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this series</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The greatest stories never told</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Peter Franklin</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>The change also drove a backlash against the &#8220;loose&#8221; morals perceived to have flourished during the war years: taboos rapidly emerged against behaviour by mothers that could be understood as abusing Mothers’ Allowance. The 1930s saw a tightening in public morals, with growing social stigma against child neglect, idleness, pre-marital sex and unmarried &#8220;fraternising&#8221; in general. The culture of &#8220;anything goes&#8221; America, with its jazz clubs and rising hemlines, became a watchword for degeneracy, as did what one commentator called the &#8220;inhuman sex egalitarianism&#8221; of the Soviet Union.</p>
<p>The Mothers’ Union became immensely influential, with representatives in some areas of Britain gaining the power almost of parallel MPs. The <a href="https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/W/bo3624725.html">Mothers’ Movement</a> founded in America by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Dilling">Elizabeth Dilling</a> was heavily shaped by its work. As the clouds of conflict gathered across Europe, the Mothers’ Union in Britain and Mothers’ Movement in the United States campaigned successfully against joining the war, arguing that the principal enemy was communism. Eventually a treaty was brokered with German leader Adolf Hitler — perhaps ironically, with <a href="https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2003/03/eleanor-rathbone.html">fierce opposition</a> from Eleanor Rathbone, now an MP for the Combined English Universities — that evaded the need for subsequent conflict.</p>
<p>Some historians have argued that the British women’s pacifist campaign of the 1930s was motivated less by opposition to the horrors of war as such than a fear that the immense cost of war would threaten the Mothers’ Allowance. Certainly it is likely that had Britain entered the war when Germany annexed Poland in 1939, the situation could have escalated, risking a global conflict whose costs might well have compromised the wealth and stability of the British Empire.</p>
<p>Some again have argued that joining the conflict would have been the right thing to do, especially considering information that came to light about the horrors committed in Greater Germany under Mr Hitler, following his assassination in 1951. But that is not how history unfolded. Instead, Britain watched while Germany and Russia wore out their territorial ambitions against one another, in a horrific conflict that cost millions of lives and which saw the eventual collapse of the Soviet Union — decades before the much-delayed fall of the British Empire.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-the-feminists-had-won/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">46224</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>Imagine a world without the USA&#8230;</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us#respond</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/GettyImages-150616205-1-e1599727567165.jpg?w=800</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[James Kirkup]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/kirkup.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[Didn't happen. British General John Burgoyne surrenders. Photo: DeAgostini/Getty Images]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>James Kirkup</strong> is Director of the London-based Social Market Foundation</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>jameskirkup</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is Director of the London-based Social Market Foundation]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Wed, 09 Sep 2020 23:25:31 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Thu, 10 Sep 2020 10:00:21 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt-history]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[American Revolution]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[French Revolution]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[History]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Mississippi Bubble]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=46063</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[France and Britain have reached a stalemate in North America and no colonial rebellion ensues]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>John Law is possibly the most important man in history you’ve never heard of. He’s also the sort of character you’d find implausible if you read about him in a novel. A gambler who killed a man in a duel in Bloomsbury Square then escaped from jail and fled Britain. A Scottish economist who helped create modern finance, paved the way for Britain’s global domination and maybe even caused the French Revolution.</p>
<p>The story of John Law and the Mississippi Bubble is fascinating, dramatic and intriguing. It also offers a wonderful counterfactual. What if the bubble hadn’t burst? What if Law’s gamble with the finances of 1720s France had paid off? With a few tweaks in the course of events, it’s just possible to imagine a world where the French didn’t rebel against their king, where Britannia didn’t rule the waves, and where the United States of America was never founded.</p>
<p>Law was born in Edinburgh in 1671, the son of a banker. Having learned the family trade, like many clever, educated Scots he then left the country seeking advantage elsewhere. In the first instance, that meant London. But after a row about a woman, he fought Edward Wilson in an (illegal) duel in 1694 and killed him with a single thrust of his rapier.</p>
<p>Imprisoned, he escaped and fled to the Continent, where his story really begins. Flitting between Amsterdam and Paris for almost twenty years, Law established himself as an early economist and advocate of financial innovation, as well as a fixture in aristocratic circles where his charm and intellect were highly prized. His greatest argument was that states should move away from money based on precious metal and instead adopt paper currencies based on government debt. By increasing the amount of money in circulation, Law reckoned, rulers could allow traders and investors to do more business, make more money and so pay more taxes.</p>
<p>That was a fanciful notion until 1715. That year, King Louis XIV of France died, leaving behind a country impoverished by years of his profligate spending and foreign wars and ruled by a child, five-year-old Louis XV. His regent was the Duke of Orleans, an acquaintance of Law.</p>
<p>Law persuaded Orleans to let him establish the Banque Générale, which was permitted to issue paper notes backed by gold and silver. It worked, so Law upped the stakes and bet again. He convinced Orleans to let him go global, and the result was the Company of the West, France’s first joint stock company. It controlled trade between France and its holdings in North America, a huge territory along 3,000 miles of the Mississippi from New Orleans to Quebec.</p>
<p>This wasn’t really new, of course. Britain had established joint stock companies in the previous century and the Bank of England, set up after the Glorious Revolution, had been printing paper money for 20 years by then. Meanwhile, the British and Dutch had long-established companies controlling their foreign dominions.</p>
<p>So Law’s innovations allowed a poor and backward France to begin catching up with the global leaders. And for a time afterwards, it looked like it might even overtake them.</p>
<p>Law sold shares in the Company of the West, and the French appetite for them was insatiable. The profits of early colonial settlements, rumours of gold and silver deposits in American soil and Law’s charisma combined to create a feeding frenzy.   Demand drove prices up and up. Shares worth 500 livres at the start of 1719 were worth 10,000 by the year’s end.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Family_of_Henry_VIII_an_Allegory_of_the_Tudor_Succession-1.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The glorious reign of King Henry IX</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Suzannah Lipscomb</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Shareholders became hugely rich, at least on paper. The word “millionaire” was coined for those who achieved great wealth from the Mississippi company.</p>
<p>Orleans was delighted, because Law insisted shares could only be bought with outstanding French government loan notes: people piling into the company shares were effectively helping to pay off the crippling national debt.</p>
<p>So delighted that he granted Law first control over all France’s foreign conquests and trade, and then effective command of the French economy. First his bank was taken over by the crown, which guaranteed its paper currency, though Law remained in control of what was effectively the country’s first central bank. Then in January 1720, Law became the Controller-General and Superintendent-General of Finance.</p>
<p>Law’s historic error was to use his bank — renamed the Banque Royale —  to create too much new paper money to allow people to buy yet more shares in the Company of the West. The paper gains created by ever-rising share prices naturally persuaded some investors to seek to cash in by selling shares and convert their gains into gold.</p>
<p>As share prices began to fall in early 1721, the sell-off accelerated. Neither Law’s bank nor the French crown had enough gold to cover the sales, of course, so Law doubled down again. He banned payments in gold of more than 100 livres and made the paper notes issued by his bank legal tender; his hope was to persuade the French to accept paper instead of gold and it was briefly successful as shareholders did indeed exchange notes for shares.</p>
<p>What followed, of course, was rampant inflation. Law’s last gamble was to devalue his notes by 50%, a policy that saw him dismissed from his post and eventually forced to flee France. Shares in what was generally known as the Mississippi Company, meanwhile, fell back to their original value of 500 livres, wiping out the wealth of the millionaires and many others.</p>
<p>The consequences of the Mississippi Bubble were vast. The financial pain experienced by many of the French helped turn the country firmly against paper money and other suspiciously complex financial novelties: it would be 80 years before the country accepted another paper currency.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/unnamed-file.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The greatest stories never told</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Peter Franklin</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Notably, the French response to a bursting bubble was very different to the British reaction to similar events. For, at around the same time as Law was at work in France, Britain was experiencing the better-known South Sea Bubble, a scheme partly inspired by Law’s apparent early success.</p>
<p>However that financial disaster persuaded the British to strengthen the Bank of England to control the money supply and allow the country to use paper money with confidence. The BoE’s new power helped Britain to borrow at low rates and finance both global military expansion and domestic industry: <em>Rule, Britannia!</em> was written in 1745, celebrating imperial power based on sound finance. These are the foundations of London as a global financial centre.</p>
<p>France, by contrast, stuck to gold and stagnated. Unable to raise capital, French industry struggled and the economy failed to develop. The monarchy was likewise short of cash, able to raise money only by imposing ever higher taxes on people ever less able to pay. The national trauma of the Mississippi Bubble also shattered public trust and confidence in the crown; bursting the bubble cost French rulers not just money but authority.</p>
<p>In 1763, the Seven Years War ended with France humiliated and broke. Louisiana east of the Mississippi river went to Great Britain; Louisiana west of the Mississippi and the Isle of Orleans went to Spain. Defeated on land by Robert Clive and its navy shattered, France abandoned any claim to India, clearing the way for what would become the British Raj.</p>
<p>The following decade, France backed the American revolutionaries challenging British rule in America, in the hope of denting its rival&#8217;s global domination. But the cost of that successful effort was the final straw for the A<em>ncien Régime</em>, helping to bring about revolution in 1789.  In due course, French leadership fell to Napoleon Bonaparte, who ended French claims in North America by agreeing the Louisiana Land Purchase with Thomas Jefferson.</p>
<p>All of this, the founding of our modern world, can be partly traced back to that bitter French experience of financial engineering. So what if Law had avoided inflating and bursting his bubble? What if he had resisted the temptation to print more money to fund more share purchases? There’s an important distinction to be drawn between Mississippi and the South Sea Bubble. The British scheme was fraudulent but Law was genuinely trying to improve France’s finances and economy. His failure was not inevitable.</p>
<p>Let’s say Law had found a way to stabilise the Mississippi share price without disaster. France in the 1720s would have had the basic elements of a modern capitalist economy: paper money and joint-stock companies. Such a nation would very likely have been a more effective rival to Great Britain during the 18th Century. A better-equipped and funded French military might well have secured a stalemate in India; Britain’s empire would have been a very different, and smaller, affair.</p>
<p>A more even outcome to the Seven Years War might well have seen France keep at least some of its Louisiana territories. Perhaps the same forces that brought about the American War of Independence against Britain would also have triggered an uprising against France there too. But with the two countries united by the desire to maintain control over their American colonies, would the rebels have succeeded?</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Screen-Shot-2019-11-26-at-5.19.20-PM.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Britain&#039;s divisions go way, way back</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Ed West</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>In our universe, French support for the revolution helped bring about the birth of the USA.  In the world where John Law’s gamble paid off, the French would have been colonial powers in North America alongside the British, and unlikely to support revolutionary forces there. Similarly, while the removal of the French threat in 1763 fed support for American independence, in a world where the hated rival still fields troops across the frontier the colonists&#8217; desire for separaton would is far more limited.</p>
<p>It seems likely that both the British and French American colonies would still eventually gain their independence, but not as a single, continent-straddling republic and eventual superpower.</p>
<p>Meanwhile, a French domestic population enjoying greater economic growth and international success would have less reason to rise up against the monarchy in 1789, though doubtless the idea of absolute monarchy would still have crumbled eventually. A French revolution in the mid 19th Century, perhaps in 1848?</p>
<p>And in this alternative history, Napoleon Boneparte would still rise to prominence, albeit as the general commanding Royal French forces in a prolonged war with Britain in the early 19th Century. Who would have won those wars? If John Law’s gamble had paid off, it would be hard to bet against France.</p>
<p>If the Mississippi Bubble had not burst, today half the world would speak French, Paris would be a financial powerhouse, and the Gare du Nord would be the Gare du Waterloo, named in honour of the military victory that secured France’s place as the world’s first superpower.</p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/imagine-a-world-without-the-united-states-of-america/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">46063</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The glorious reign of King Henry IX</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us#respond</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Family_of_Henry_VIII_an_Allegory_of_the_Tudor_Succession-1.png?w=484</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Suzannah Lipscomb]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/lipscomb.jpg?w=94</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA["The Family of Henry VIII: an Allegory of the Tudor Succession", a 16th century painting depicting the king and his three surviving children. But what might have been had his eldest, Henry, survived?]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Suzannah Lipscomb</strong> is Professor Emerita of History at the University of Roehampton and the host of the <em>Not Just The Tudors</em> podcast from History Hit. She has written numerous books, including <em>The King is Dead: The Last Will and Testament of Henry VIII</em> and <em>The Voices of Nîmes: Women, Sex, and Marriage in Reformation Languedoc</em>.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>sixteenthCgirl</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is Professor Emerita of History at the University of Roehampton and the host of the <em>Not Just The Tudors</em> podcast from History Hit. She has written numerous books, including <em>The King is Dead: The Last Will and Testament of Henry VIII</em> and <em>The Voices of Nîmes: Women, Sex, and Marriage in Reformation Languedoc</em>.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 08 Sep 2020 23:04:21 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Fri, 25 Sep 2020 11:38:33 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Henry VIII]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Reformation]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=45956</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[What if Henry VIII's son by Katherine of Aragon had survived?]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p><em>How can we explain the seeming paradox of King Henry IX — the son of the most Catholic Defender of the Faith King Henry VIII and pious Queen Katherine of Aragon — breaking with the Roman Catholic Church in 1558?</em><em> </em></p>
<p>To understand this, we need to consider Henry IX’s formation. Just 18 months after his parents’ glittering joint coronation at Westminster Abbey, Prince Henry was born on New Year’s Day 1511 to Henry VIII and Katherine of Aragon.</p>
<p>The romance between Henry and Katherine is one of the great love stories of history, so it is easily forgotten that she had previously been married to Henry&#8217;s brother, Arthur: at their wedding at St Paul’s Cathedral in 1501, the young Henry had walked Katherine down the aisle, and it is probably at that point that he conceived his desire for her.</p>
<p>She was his first love and marrying her was one of the first acts of his new reign. Until her death in 1536, he demonstrated his utter devotion to her by inscribing their intertwined initials on his armour, featuring her badge — the pomegranate — alongside his rose throughout his palaces, and even defying convention by wearing her favours in the lists.</p>
<p>The couple shared a love of music, dancing, entertainments and magnificence. Henry liked to hunt, Katherine to hawk; both rode fearlessly. They had both been highly educated and could converse in Latin and French as well as English, as some rueful ambassadors discovered. Their shared love of learning and patronage, and their mutual taste in devotional and theological works, explains many of the riches of the Royal Collection today.</p>
<p>In 1524 Venetian <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marino_Sanuto_the_Younger" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Marino Sanuto</a> observed that Henry and Katherine were two separate bodies animated by one spirit and one mind. Theirs was almost a joint rulership: Henry trusted Katherine and was advised by her. Katherine’s parents, Isabel of Castile and Ferdinand of Aragon, had adopted the motto <em>tanto monta</em> — each as important as the other — and it could equally have been applied to Henry and Katherine.</p>
<p>The history of the enduring affection and friendship between England and Spain can be traced to their marriage, as can England’s continuing Hispanophilia. Katherine was so revered by the women of the court that they adopted the Spanish style of dress: fitted bodices, wide sleeves, full skirts over farthingales, high-heeled clogs and the veil or <em>mantilla</em>, dispensing with the unattractive gable hoods that predated her.</p>
<p>Their union was consolidated by the arrival of their son and heir, and to mark the birth, guns rang out from the Tower, bells pealed, bonfires were lit in the streets of London, and wine flowed freely. After Prince Henry’s christening, his father rode to Walsingham to give thanks to Our Lady and held a great tournament at Westminster to celebrate, jousting astride a charger splendidly trapped in a caparison decorated with the initials &#8220;H&#8221; and &#8220;K&#8221;.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/unnamed-file.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The greatest stories never told</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Peter Franklin</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>As the young prince grew into a sturdy boy, universally praised by foreign visitors to the court for his beauty, wit and strength, Katherine endured a further four pregnancies, but of them, only a daughter, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_I_of_England" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Mary</a>, would survive. We know her as Mary of England, Holy Roman Empress, beloved wife of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_V,_Holy_Roman_Emperor" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Charles V</a>, after their marriage in 1530.</p>
<p>But Prince Henry also had at least two half-siblings, since the king’s love for Katherine did not preclude the taking of mistresses: the beautiful Elizabeth Blount bore the king a son in 1519. The brothers were close, and Prince Henry suffered great grief when the younger boy died in 1536. Meanwhile, Anne Boleyn — former lady-in-waiting to the queen, wife of James Butler, 9<sup>th</sup> Earl of Ormond, and the king’s mistress from 1527 — gave birth to a girl, Elizabeth, in 1533. Some historians have posited that the red-haired Lady Elizabeth Butler was the king’s daughter, but we will never know for certain. After Katherine of Aragon’s death in 1536, Henry VIII’s new wife Jane bore him a further son, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_VI_of_England" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Prince Edward</a>, a year later.</p>
<p>Katherine’s influence can perhaps most be seen on Henry VIII’s religiosity. It was inspired by and to impress her that Henry wrote his book,<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defence_of_the_Seven_Sacraments" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><em> Disputation on the Sacraments</em>,</a> refuting Luther and earning his title &#8220;Defender of the Faith&#8221;. Under the influence of Sir Thomas More, Henry VIII also presided over the burnings of heretics in the 1530s and 1540s, including sacramentarian John Lambert and a married cleric called Thomas Cranmer.</p>
<p>On the same day as Henry VIII married for the third time to the young Catherine Howard (a marriage that would later be annulled by the pope when Catherine was discovered to have been pre-contracted in marriage), Henry had renowned heretic and former servant to Wolsey, Thomas Cromwell, burnt at Smithfield. Recent research has suggested, however, that Henry’s fourth and final wife, Kateryn Parr, may have been a Lutheran. She successfully hid her heresy from the king, but her influence on the young Prince Edward was strong. By his early teens, he showed dangerous signs of Lutheran leanings.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/10/anne-boleyn-whore-witch-or-cinderella/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/10/anne-boleyn-whore-witch-or-cinderella/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Screen-Shot-2019-10-28-at-1.33.13-PM.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/10/anne-boleyn-whore-witch-or-cinderella/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">More from this author</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/10/anne-boleyn-whore-witch-or-cinderella/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Anne Boleyn: whore, witch or Cinderella?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/10/anne-boleyn-whore-witch-or-cinderella/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Suzannah Lipscomb</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>In 1539, Prince Henry married Anne,<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne_of_Cleves" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"> a young duchess from Cleves</a> who was just four years his junior. Their betrothal portraits by Hans Holbein show Anne’s attractive face, dark brown eyes under long lashes, and alluring half-smile, and Prince Henry, then in his late 20s. He is auburn-haired like his parents, with pale skin, a round face, blue eyes and a long nose reminiscent of his maternal grandmother,<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isabella_I_of_Castile" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"> Isabel of Castile.</a></p>
<p>When Henry VIII died in January 1547, the prince acceded to the throne as King Henry IX at the age of 35. Tall, winsome and popular, he and his much-loved Queen were already parents to four daughters: Isabella — named for both her great-grandmothers — Maria, Sybille and Katherine. Henry IX was therefore the first adult married king with heirs to inherit the throne since Henry V, demonstrating the success of the Tudor succession.</p>
<p>Prince Edward remained Henry’s heir presumptive until his death in 1553 (their siister Mary died in 1558), but Henry and Anne had prepared for any eventuality and, inspired by the long traditions of female rule in both their families, they raised their daughters to be queens. The girls were polyglots, educated in Latin, Greek, French, German and Spanish; they were exposed early to the strategies and realities of rule.</p>
<p>Following the observance of the Trastámara family of his mother and the example of his father, Henry IX was a devoutly Catholic king. His piety can be traced from his youth: the Library of England has an autographed copy of a prayer in an illustrated devotional Book of Hours, inscribed in a childish hand &#8220;The prayer of Sainte Thomas of Aquine translated out of Latine into Englyshe by ye most exselent Prince Henry son to the most high and mighty Prynce and Prynces Kyng Henry the VIII and Quene Kateryne hys wyfe&#8221;. Both Henry and Anne had been raised as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erasmus" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Erasmian</a> Catholics, while Henry received a humanist education at his mother’s hands.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/GettyImages-610374920.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Suggested reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Who do the English think they are?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Razib Khan</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>As a result, he came to be one of Europe’s great reforming Catholic monarchs. Many of the abuses of the late medieval Church, such as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simony" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">simony</a> and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefice#Pluralism" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">pluralism</a>, were tackled by the king’s Court of Reformation. Decrees were issued on clerical morals, seminaries were established and doctrinal statements reaffirmed the importance of the Mass, pilgrimages and the veneration of saints and relics. The reform of the monasteries in the 1550s explains why the monastic tradition in England remains so rich today, and why our great medieval libraries, such as that at Glastonbury, continue to attract scholars from around the world.</p>
<p>Unlike his parents, however, Henry IX immediately ended the execution of heretics, and sponsored the translation of the Bible into English – the King Henry Bible. And it was this, and the extent of his reforms, that led to the clash with Rome. Urging further reform and tolerance on the Vatican, Henry IX ran into opposition from the austere, anti-Semitic Pope Paul IV, who was a bitter enemy of Catholic humanism. The English king was publicly accused of harbouring heretics and was privately suspected to be a hidden Lutheran. Establishing himself as Supreme Governor of the Church in England in 1558 was the only way for Henry IX to protect the advances that had been made. This was a fundamental step in the shaping of English national identity as a land of liberal, tolerant and catholic — but not Roman Catholic — believers.</p>
<p>So it was that a most Catholic king, from most Catholic parents, came to break with Rome. When Henry died 30 years later, aged 77, and was succeeded by his daughter, Queen Isabella I — England’s first queen regnant — she could unproblematically adopt the iconography of the Virgin Mary, while reigning as Supreme Governor of the Church.</p>
<p><em>Historical note:</em> <em>On 22 February 1511, Prince Henry, the firstborn son of King Henry VIII and Queen Katherine of Aragon, died at the age of seven weeks.</em></p>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/what-if-henry-viiis-son-by-katherine-of-aragon-survived/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">45956</post-id>				</item>
									<item>
					<title>The greatest stories never told</title>
					<link>https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us</link>
											<comments>https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us#comments</comments>
										<unherd:featured_image>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/unnamed-file.jpg?w=525</unherd:featured_image>
										<unherd:main_theme></unherd:main_theme>
					<dc:creator>
						<![CDATA[Peter Franklin]]>
					</dc:creator>
					<unherd:creator_img>https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Peter-F.jpg?w=96</unherd:creator_img>
																<unherd:article_ranking></unherd:article_ranking>
																<unherd:image_caption>
							<![CDATA[It could happen here... although it didn't. John Turturro in The Plot Against America. Photo: HBO]]>
						</unherd:image_caption>
						<unherd:twitter_bio>
							<![CDATA[<p><strong>Peter Franklin</strong> is Associate Editor of <em>UnHerd</em>. He was previously a policy advisor and speechwriter on environmental and social issues.</p>
]]>
						</unherd:twitter_bio>
						<unherd:twitter_handle>peterfranklin_</unherd:twitter_handle>
															<unherd:author_bio>
						<![CDATA[ is Associate Editor of <em>UnHerd</em>. He was previously a policy advisor and speechwriter on environmental and social issues.]]>
					</unherd:author_bio>
										<pubDate>Tue, 08 Sep 2020 10:50:05 +0000</pubDate>
					<updated>Tue, 08 Sep 2020 21:29:47 +0000</updated>
							<category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt Histories]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Alt-history]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[American Civil War]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Brexit]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Dinosaurs]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Donald Trump]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Hillary Clinton]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[History]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[novels]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Roman Empire]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[science fiction]]></category>
					<guid isPermaLink="false">https://old.unherd.com/?p=45673</guid>
																												<description>
								<![CDATA[Introducing ‘Alt Histories’ – a series in which we explore what we can learn from what didn't happen]]>
							</description>
												
																									<content:encoded>
								<![CDATA[<p>This week <em>UnHerd</em> begins a series of ‘alt histories’. For your reading pleasure, our finest contributors will be deliberately making things up about the past. But, then, that’s was alternate or ‘counterfactual’ history is — the exploration of things that <em>could</em> have happened, even though they didn’t.</p>
<p>But their non-historicity being the case, what’s the point of writing about them?</p>
<p>If history teaches us anything it’s that we should expect the unexpected. But history, unlike the news, is something that’s already happened. Historians, unlike journalists, see events in the rearview mirror. As a result, they’re rather prone to deterministic explanations. For instance, there’s the Whig view of history with its narratives of ever-increasing freedom. Marxists, meanwhile, situate historical events within an overarching process of class struggle. Indeed, from millenarians to environmentalists to the <a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/the-myth-of-anglo-america/">friends and foes of the Anglosphere</a>, everyone’s trying to bend the arc of history.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/the-myth-of-anglo-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/the-myth-of-anglo-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/GettyImages-88847743-e1595328692347.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/the-myth-of-anglo-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Further reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/the-myth-of-anglo-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>The myth of ‘Anglo-America’</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/07/the-myth-of-anglo-america/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Peter Franklin</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>They can’t all be right, but they can all be wrong. That’s not just because of the dodgy interpretations they put on historical events, but also the significance they attach to them. Even if a particular development is accurately interpreted, it doesn’t lend much credence to your favoured narrative if it could have easily gone another way.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p>Just because we can be certain that something did happen it doesn&#8217;t mean that it <i>had</i> to happen. And that’s why alt history is so valuable. If we accept that the past could have followed a different path, then perhaps we won’t be quite so blasé about the future.</p>
<p>The historian <a href="https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=w8hcDwAAQBAJ&amp;pg=PT179&amp;lpg=PT179&amp;dq=%E2%80%9C...one+can+always+play+a+parlour+game+with+the+might-have-beens+of+history.+But+they+have+nothing+to+do+with+determinism;+for+the+determinist+will+only+reply+that,+for+these+things+to+have+happened,+the+causes+would+also+have+had+to+be+different.+Nor+have+they+anything+to+do+with+history.%E2%80%9D&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=2lH59JdMD1&amp;sig=ACfU3U2WEf93QTJfv2M1cDM7U2CbJAUPMQ&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=2ahUKEwjh74Hf7NHrAhWI5KQKHf07Bi8Q6AEwAHoECAMQAQ#v=onepage&amp;q=%E2%80%9C...one%20can%20always%20play%20a%20parlour%20game%20with%20the%20might-have-beens%20of%20history.%20But%20they%20have%20nothing%20to%20do%20with%20determinism;%20for%20the%20determinist%20will%20only%20reply%20that,%20for%20these%20things%20to%20have%20happened,%20the%20causes%20would%20also%20have%20had%20to%20be%20different.%20Nor%20have%20they%20anything%20to%20do%20with%20history.%E2%80%9D&amp;f=false">E.H. Carr</a> was was not a fan of alt history:</p>
<blockquote><p>“&#8230;one can always play a parlour game with the might-have-beens of history. But they have nothing to do with determinism; for the determinist will only reply that, for these things to have happened, the causes would also have had to be different. Nor have they anything to do with history.”</p></blockquote>
<p>Of course, being a Marxist, he would say that, wouldn&#8217;t he? An ideologically-trammelled thought process is pre-determined by where it starts from. The same, however, cannot be said for what happens outside our heads. That’s why Carr&#8217;s contemporary, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Trevor-Roper">Hugh Trevor-Roper</a>, believed that one can&#8217;t fully understand a period of history without considering all the other ways it might have turned out.</p>
<p>For instance, why didn&#8217;t the Roman Empire conquer the German lands beyond the Rhine? A determinist might reach for some geographical explanation — the territory was inhospitable and the locals scary. And yet similar obstacles didn’t stop the the Romans from assimilating Britannia, so why not Germania too?</p>
<p style="text-align: left;">Well, because three Roman legions were wiped out at the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Teutoburg_Forest">Battle of the Teutoburg Forest</a>, that&#8217;s why — and there was nothing pre-determined about that catastrophe. It required the mother of all ambushes, made possible by the extreme cunning of the German chieftain Arminius and the extreme gullibility of the Roman commander Varus. It could easily not have happened – and thus, untraumatised by such an unexpected and total defeat, the Romans might have extended the northern frontier to the Elbe or beyond.</p>
<p>What would a Romanised Germania have meant for the rest of history? It’s impossible to say, but we can imagine an unRomanised Gaul. The existence of France (and the French language) as we know it today depends on the fact that, two thousand years ago, the Romans conquered Gaul, but not Germania. Had things gone differently, French (and therefore British and therefore American) history would have developed along a very different path.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Screen-Shot-2019-11-26-at-5.19.20-PM.png?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Further reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Britain&#039;s divisions go way, way back</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2019/11/britains-divisions-go-way-way-back/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Ed West</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>What this example also tells us is just how much of history depends on the character, abilities and decisions of particular individuals (contrast the ruthless brilliance of Julius Caesar in the case of Gaul with the trusting foolishness of Varus in the case of Germania). There’s something called the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_man_theory">great man theory</a> of history. It’s was a 19th Century idea and deeply unfashionable today, but while the individuals who change the course of history aren’t necessarily ‘great’ or, indeed, men — there’s no doubting their existence.</p>
<p>They don’t have to be heroes or villains. In fact, they don’t have to have much authority of any kind. Their impact doesn’t even have to be the result of a deliberate decision. They just have to do the right (wrong) thing in the right (wrong) place at the right (wrong) time. For instance, someone, somewhere, did something that introduced the Covid-19 virus to the human population. Whether that was eating a bowl of bat soup or dropping a test tube in a laboratory we’ll probably never know; but whatever it was, it made all the difference.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p>That’s why we can’t leave alt history to the historians alone. While some of them might see merit in exploring counterfactuals, their commitment to academic rigour acts as a constraint upon their speculations. Quite right too, but there’s also a case for letting our imaginations run riot — and for that we need story-tellers.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">*</p>
<p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RwMwrft7So8"><em>The Plot Against America</em></a>, is a critically acclaimed TV adaptation of Philip Roth’s <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/703.The_Plot_Against_America">novel</a> of the same name. The point of divergence from our actual history comes when the isolationist Charles Lindbergh becomes President in 1940. It’s a warning that no country is immune to tyranny.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p>The rise to power of a populist celebrity has obvious contemporary resonances. Too obvious, perhaps. In drawing parallels we shouldn’t overlook differences. I also have my doubts about alt history as wish-fulfilment. Curtis Sittenfeld had a best-seller this year with her novel <em><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/50253429-rodham">Rodham</a></em> — which re-imagines Hillary Clinton’s life and career if she had never married Bill. Amazingly, it turns out that she does better (in politics) without him — which, for a politician so inept in real life that she lost an election to Donald Trump, is stretching credulity.</p>
<p>Another example of alt history as political therapy is Ian McEwan’s <em><a href="https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/111/1117889/machines-like-me/9781529111255.html">Machines Like Me</a> </em>(2019). The novel’s setting is 1980s London. But in this version of history, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Turing">Alan Turing</a> has survived the homophobic persecution of 1950s and, as a result, the progress of technology has been greatly accelerated – with dramatic consequences. For instance, the Argentinians have AI-enhanced Exocet missiles and therefore win the Falklands War. Margaret Thatcher is thus defeated at the next election — by, er, Tony Benn. (Imagine an alt history in which a left-wing writer manages to portray our first female Prime Minister without humiliating her.)</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/are-humans-heading-for-the-knackers-yard/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/are-humans-heading-for-the-knackers-yard/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/GettyImages-160881338.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/are-humans-heading-for-the-knackers-yard/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Further reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/are-humans-heading-for-the-knackers-yard/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Are humans heading for the knacker’s yard?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/03/are-humans-heading-for-the-knackers-yard/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Peter Franklin</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>McEwen also supposes that Turing would have created an artificial, but conscious, mind — and, furthermore, one housed within an artificial, but lifelike, human body. It’s true that Turing and his colleagues really did think that artificial intelligence was within reach; but, genius though he was, he turned out to be colossally wrong about that. A more insightful novel might have explored how — or if — he would have realised his error.</p>
<p>For an ‘alt technology’ novel that does convince, I’d recommend Kazuo Ishiguro’s <a href="https://www.faber.co.uk/9780571258093-never-let-me-go.html"><i>Never Let Me Go</i></a> (2005). This one’s set in a late 20th century England where medical science has taken a different and disturbing turn. Individuals are cloned and their ‘offspring’ — in effect, their twin siblings — raised in secluded institutions. Eventually, in young adulthood, the clones make a series of compulsory ‘donations’ — the basis of medical treatment for their ‘models’. Just how science and society developed in this direction, we’re never really told. Ishiguro keeps most of the details from us — and what he does reveal comes slowly. In this way, the readers’ experience parallels that of the clones, whose story this is.</p>
<p>In its mannered intimacy, Ishiguro’s prose creates a world as confined and claustrophobic as that imposed upon the protagonists, but without ever hiding the entire universe contained within each and every human being. And thus we’re lead gently by the hand to the story’s devastating conclusion.</p>
<p>Ishiguro&#8217;s minimalist approach is one way to do alt history — the other is to go all out and show us events unfolding on an epic scale. Instead of describing one small corner of the altered world, we get the panoramic view. Indeed, we might see the consequences of a point of divergence playing out over decades or even centuries. I’ve previously written about <em><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/10/must-suppress-technological-progress/">Pavane</a></em> by Keith Roberts in which the Catholic Church defeats the Reformation and goes on to deliberately slow down the pace of technological change — with justification, perhaps.</p>
<p><em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Man_in_the_High_Castle">The Man in the High Castle</a></em> by Philip K Dick is set in a world in which the Germany and Japan win the Second World War and divide America between them. But more than that, the author shows us parallel realities. There is, for instance, a story within the story — a banned book in which the Allies won the war — except not as they did in our timeline.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/10/must-suppress-technological-progress/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/10/must-suppress-technological-progress/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/GettyImages-89611833-scaled.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/10/must-suppress-technological-progress/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Further reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/10/must-suppress-technological-progress/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Why we must suppress technological progress</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2018/10/must-suppress-technological-progress/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Peter Franklin</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>Then there’s the master of the maximalist approach — Harry Turtledove. In his novel <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_Few_Remain"><i>How Few Remain</i></a> (1997) a missing message from General Lee is recovered by the Confederacy (instead of falling into Union hands, as it did in reality). From that small change, the author develops — in lavish detail — a timeline that extends into the 1940s. It’s not just that the South wins the Civil War, but that the two sides (the Confederate States and the rump United States) go on to fight the First and Second World Wars on America soil. By the end of eleventh novel in the series, the North nukes the South and America is finally reunified, sort of. <span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p style="text-align: center;">*</p>
<p>Fully fictional alt history can therefore go where scholarly investigation can’t. While there’s merit in<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span>examining the immediate consequences of a counterfactual, there’s only so far a serious historian can take the speculation. Once you get into second or third order effects, the mounting uncertainties overwhelm academic credibility. The novelist, though, can keep going — perhaps into the far future.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p>This allows us to ask an important question, which is whether the underlying forces of history would eventually reassert themselves. Even if certain details were changed, with short-term consequences, would the world end up in much the same place over the longer-term? For the historical determinist the answer is yes. If ‘great men’ like Julius Caesar or Martin Luther had died in infancy, there&#8217;d have been other Caesars, other Luthers. As for wars, some of them could have gone the other way, but for how long would that truly matter? Consider the Wars of the Roses, for instance. How many of us today know — or care — which side won?</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/GettyImages-610374920.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Further reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Who do the English think they are?</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/who-do-the-english-think-they-are/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Razib Khan</a></p></div></a></div>
<p>But at this point we need to let science intrude upon the humanities. Chaos theory, for instance, teaches us that tiny differences in starting conditions can create hugely different outcomes. It’s a phenomenon known as the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butterfly_effect">butterfly effect</a> — so-called because, conceivably, the flap of butterfly&#8217;s wings on one side of the world could lead to a hurricane on the other. If that seems far fetched, then think about the comet that wiped out the dinosaurs. With the slightest change to its starting trajectory, it would have missed Earth and human history wouldn’t have happened at all.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p>The determinists, therefore, have missed something rather big. While the passage of time may erase some events, others are magnified.</p>
<p><em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Sound_of_Thunder">A Sound of Thunder</a></em> is a short story by <a href="https://raybradbury.com">Ray Bradbury</a>. It’s a sci-fi scenario in which big game hunters travel back in time to shoot dinosaurs. The trip organisers are very careful about not altering the past. For instance, the only animals that get shot are ones that were about to die anyway. Furthermore, the time travellers are told to stick to a special raised platform, so that  they don’t even leave footprints behind. But then on one trip, a hunter panics — he steps off the platform and crushes an insect. When he gets back home, he finds that his carelessness has changed the course history — and not for the better. A fascistic presidential candidate who was all set to lose the election is now the winner. Oops.</p>
<p>That crushed insect, by the way, was a butterfly.<span class="Apple-converted-space"> </span></p>
<p style="text-align: center;">*</p>
<p>This then is what I think alt history teaches us about real history: not that it is without pattern or meaning, but that it is fragile.</p>
<p>The things that we may regard as progress or count as our achievements, hang by a thread — a sequence of events, anyone of which could have turned out differently.</p>
<p>That&#8217;s worth bearing in mind as we congratulate ourselves on our comforts and liberties. That they were gained at all was not inevitable — and nor is their survival.</p>
<p>Whether or not one sees the hand of providence at work in human history, we should never take what we&#8217;ve got for granted.</p>
<div class="ref-ar"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/abingdon-is-proof-that-life-goes-on/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/abingdon-is-proof-that-life-goes-on/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><img decoding="async" src="https://unherd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/GettyImages-961477196.jpg?w=300" /></a><div class="content"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/abingdon-is-proof-that-life-goes-on/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span class="meta">Further reading</span></a><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/abingdon-is-proof-that-life-goes-on/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><h5>Don&#039;t call Abingdon ordinary</h5></a><p class="author"><a href="https://unherd.com/2020/08/abingdon-is-proof-that-life-goes-on/?edition=us&#038;ref=refinnar" class="text-decoration-none border-0"><span>By</span> Eleanor Parker</a></p></div></a></div>
]]>
							</content:encoded>
																											<wfw:commentRss>https://unherd.com/2020/09/the-greatest-stories-never-told/?edition=us/feed/</wfw:commentRss>
															<post-id xmlns="com-wordpress:feed-additions:1">45673</post-id>				</item>
						</channel>
</rss>
