X Close

by Bethany Elliott
Wednesday, 28
June 2023

Will Yevgeny Prigozhin become the new Alexei Navalny?

Putin would be unwise to make a martyr of the Wagner chief
by Bethany Elliott
Is Prigozhin a dead man walking? Credit: AFP

How do you solve a problem like Yevgeny Prigozhin? The thief-turned-hot dog seller, restauranteur, warlord and — most recently — insurrectionist looked set to end his ascent as leader of Russia at certain points during Saturday’s armed rebellion, yet now finds himself searching for a new role.  

Yesterday the President of Belarus, Alexander Lukashenko, announced that Prigozhin had arrived in the country, as agreed under the terms of the deal that Lukashenko himself brokered to quell the revolt. The mercenary boss is not arriving alone. Russian President Vladimir Putin confirmed on Monday that Wagner fighters could join the Ministry of Defence or another security agency, return home, or go to Belarus. 

Lukashenko noted yesterday that, while his country is not building camps or recruitment centres for Wagner forces, it can provide an abandoned military base. Though it is early to speculate about numbers, independent Russian media sources have reported the construction of a camp with the capacity for 8,000 men in Belarus’s Mogilev region. Meanwhile, Lukashenko added that his Defence Minister Viktor Khrenin has proposed integrating Wagner fighters into the Belarusian Army. 

Given the ruthless and violent tactics routinely employed by Wagner forces in Ukraine, including against the Russian military, the import of ex-convicts skilled in the use of weapons — not to mention feeling thwarted over how close they came to overthrowing a government — presents a clear risk to Lukashenko’s leadership. The strong anti-war feeling among the Belarusian population can only be exacerbated by this influx. For his part, Lukashenko’s statement that he will “keep a close eye” on Wagner forces does not sound wholly reassuring. 

He is not the only one wondering what to do with Prigozhin. Putin suffered the greatest challenge to his rule yet on Saturday, and has a documented history of eliminating enemies who have crossed him in far less public ways. While Putin may feel that Prigozhin’s death now would serve as a warning to any others who feel like mounting a similar challenge, the eyes of the world are upon him. Kill Prigozhin now and his face will appear on T-shirts, Putin having made a martyr of a man who stills enjoys considerable popularity among his own forces and a dedicated online following.   

Perhaps the closest analogy to what Putin may do now is the treatment of jailed opposition leader Alexei Navalny. Sentenced to an ever-increasing term in prison, Navalny spends his days hidden from public view as the energy gradually drains from a movement deprived of its charismatic figurehead. Though Russia’s federal security service yesterday reported closing the criminal case against the Wagner chief and his mutineers, forcing Prigozhin to maintain a quiet exile in Belarus or opening a seemingly unrelated criminal procedure later on would be a similar tactic. 

While he may not seek to impose a death sentence on Prigozhin now, Putin’s wrath and sense of humiliation are unlikely to abate any time soon — he once commented that the only thing that he cannot forgive is betrayal. Both Sergei Skripal and Alexander Litvinenko discovered that Putin bears grudges against his enemies long after their original treachery. 

“The compensation for a death sentence is knowledge of the exact hour when one is to die,” remarked Vladimir Nabokov in Invitation to a Beheading. It is a luxury which has not been offered to Prigozhin, who now waits to understand the full consequences of provoking Putin’s ire.

Join the discussion

To join the discussion in the comments, become a paid subscriber.

Join like minded readers that support our journalism, read unlimited articles and enjoy other subscriber-only benefits.

Notify of
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
j watson
j watson
5 months ago

Russia is a mafia state. How many of the Capo’s below Putin now see the Head Don as weaker because of his inability to crush Prigozhin? How many are thinking maybe I could be more independent?
And of course Putin can’t put what Prigozhin said about the real reasons for the Invasion and subsequent incompetency back in a box. Soldiers and citizens will gradually see that if not already.
Yeltsin became increasingly ignored and powerless towards end as the Capo’s and Oligarchs ran the show. Does a similar fate await Putin?

martin logan
martin logan
5 months ago

We still don’t realize how close we came to a very bad turn of events.
The generals Prigozhin was touting–Surovikin, Minzintsev, et al–had been promoted during the genuine reform period of Defence Minister Serdyukov. Since he fired so many incompetents, the blow back from the officer corps eventually forced Putin to replace him with the nonentity Shoigu, along with the equally incompetent Gerasimov.
If Surovikin & Minzintsev had been in charge on 24 Feb 2022, it’s doubtful that Ukraine’s successes would have been as dramatic as they have been. Even now, putting competent Russian generals in charge might degrade the Ukrainian offensive.
So better hope the US and NATO do all they can to keep Putin in power. He’s by far our best hope that Russia’s defence forces remain clueless and incompetent.
Any shakeup is a danger to us all.

Last edited 5 months ago by Martin Logan
Fran Martinez
Fran Martinez
5 months ago

I feel this author almost always predicts the exact opposite of what actually happens. But this is just my impression

b blimbax
b blimbax
5 months ago


*(Responding to the title.)

Last edited 5 months ago by bill blax