Subscribe
Notify of
guest
47 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
hayden eastwood
hayden eastwood
7 months ago

I have listened to an interview with Le Pen and found her to be remarkably down to earth and practical. Nothing she said came across to me as particularly right wing, much less “extreme right wing”.
If she had been standing in the 1930s she would have been considered a wet centrist.
The label “far right” appears now to be applied to anyone who is remotely patriotic, or against mass migration, or who believes that people with XY chromosomes are men.
Crying wolf in this way means that we will be unable to distinguish between real far right lunatics and those who simply disagree with the current woke madness.

Michael K
Michael K
7 months ago

What do you think about the fact that she’s essentially from a political dynasty? I have a very bad view of politicians who are in there full time. I believe they have no idea of real world issues and have had more time than others to build up corrupt contact networks. Look at the Clintons, Bidens, Trudeaus, Bushes and so on.
Edit: Just to clarify, I believe Macron is the worst possible choice.

Last edited 7 months ago by Michael K
ARNAUD ALMARIC
ARNAUD ALMARIC
7 months ago
Reply to  Michael K

By comparison with those other parasites you mention, the Le Pen Dynasty is somewhat amateur wouldn’t you not say?

Dennis Boylon
Dennis Boylon
7 months ago
Reply to  ARNAUD ALMARIC

Exactly

Michael K
Michael K
7 months ago
Reply to  ARNAUD ALMARIC

I have to admit to lacking the background knowledge necessary for such a judgement. But thank you for stating your views.

Last edited 7 months ago by Michael K
Allison Barrows
Allison Barrows
7 months ago

I wish someone could explain to me why the desire to protect one’s national identity is “fascistic”. Victor Orban won his fourth election in a landslide. Isn’t it obvious that no one wants Klaus Schwab running their country?

Warren T
Warren T
7 months ago

Agreed. But it shows just how far left the entire spectrum has shifted during our lifetime. Flying the flag of MY country, believing that marriage is between a man and a woman and thinking that you can’t decide your gender at will all get me in huge trouble with my younger relatives today.

Dennis Boylon
Dennis Boylon
7 months ago

You stupids plebes are not meant to decide. You follow your betters or else

János Klein
János Klein
7 months ago

White Christian Europeans are not allowed to feel proud of their national identity. It smacks of racism and may remind people about the Afrikaners in former South Africa.

Simon Denis
Simon Denis
7 months ago

Well said.

Bruno Lucy
Bruno Lucy
7 months ago

Well….then just have a look at her program regarding the economy, the ties with Russia and the exit from NATO.
If this is not enough to make you scream……then you certainly do not live in France.

Graham Stull
Graham Stull
7 months ago

Yet another superficial election piece from a Périph Insider, who has spent zero hours of her life in a HLM, or in a run-down brick terraced house in Valenciennes, or a grimy maison villagoise halfway up the hillside in Languedoc.
If she had done, she would have written this: Prices in France are spiralling out of control, people are hurting. The Gilets Jaunes never went away. They have been joined by those who care about the fundamental rights and freedoms that Macron holds in such contempt. To say Macron’s handling of the pandemic was ‘no worse than anywhere else’ is a slap in the face to everyone who marched, relentlessly, against vaccine passports, mask mandates for children and needless lockdowns.
I don’t know what the result of this election will be, but whoever survives the first round, I sincerely hope and pray that smug, petty little globalist tyrant gets thrown out of the Elysée Palace and faces real consequences for what he has done to France and to Europe.

leculdesac suburbia
leculdesac suburbia
7 months ago
Reply to  Graham Stull

It sounds like the only part of this piece, which you’ve called “superficial,” with which you take issue is saying Macron’s “handing of the pandemic was ‘no worse than anywhere else.'”
Considering totalitarian measures in China, New Zealand and Australia, occasional totalitarian measures in Germany, the UK, and Canada, and a patchwork of chaotic, state by state disasters in the US as well as its bizarrely authoritarian, unfounded, censorious regime at the federal level, I’d have to agree with the author. “Average” leadership in this context is a low bar. His leadership could suck and still not reach the insanity of New Zealand. And the French have a habit of working class protests, which says more (good) about France than that the violence and poverty the lower classes experience is much worse than in the US. Even the poorest French citizen has a greater safety net than a middle-class American who can still lose everything if they ever need home healthcare or have to manage a severe chronic illness.

Last edited 7 months ago by leculdesac suburbia
Dennis Boylon
Dennis Boylon
7 months ago

There is no healthcare. These people do more harm than good

Graham Stull
Graham Stull
7 months ago

The pandemic handling was bad precisely because it reinforces the entreched inequality of opportunity that makes France’s inequality so bad (read Piketty, for example). Unlike the US or the UK, escaping from the banlieus is nearly mission impossible. Power is so concentrated in a fistful of elites who control government and state enterprises alike. Outside of that, the private sector economy is like a game of musical chairs, and every bad policy decision takes away an extra chair. This is why the pandemic policies have hurt the Gilets Jaunes class so badly – when the poor in France feel the squeeze, they know they have nowhere else to go.
Of course you’re right: there are other problems in other countries. The US Rust Belt, Council Estate England, West Dublin. But since this article was about France, I decided to do the radical thing and talk about … France.

Dennis Boylon
Dennis Boylon
7 months ago
Reply to  Graham Stull

God bless you. Macron has done great evil in this world and deserves punishment

Last edited 7 months ago by Dennis Boylon
JP Martin
JP Martin
7 months ago

This is an insightful piece. I always enjoy reading Anne-Elisabeth Moutet because she combines cold, rational analysis with a powerful sense of intuition.

Jeremy Bray
Jeremy Bray
7 months ago
Reply to  JP Martin

On verra bien!

JP Martin
JP Martin
7 months ago
Reply to  Jeremy Bray

Yes, we will know soon! It has been a strange campaign time so who knows what to expect.

Katharine Eyre
Katharine Eyre
7 months ago

Macron’s hubris reminds me of Gerhard Schröder in the 2005 federal election in Germany. He thought he had it all sown up, behaved in an arrogant, entitled fashion and ended up being swept unceremoniously out of office. And I bet at the time he didn’t understand what he’d done wrong.

Graham Stull
Graham Stull
7 months ago
Reply to  Katharine Eyre

I’m really hoping you’re right.

Christopher Barclay
Christopher Barclay
7 months ago
Reply to  Katharine Eyre

Schroder did of course then go to work for Gazprom for Euro 1m pa reportedly.

Katharine Eyre
Katharine Eyre
7 months ago

I do you know what? I’m not sure whether he understands what he’s done wrong there either. The fact that he’s currently on his 5th wife speaks volumes.

Keith Johnson
Keith Johnson
7 months ago
Reply to  Katharine Eyre

Hilary Clinton also comes to mind.

Ron Wigley
Ron Wigley
7 months ago
Reply to  Katharine Eyre

Here in the U.K. it reminds me of the Remainer Elites talking to themselves and the Pollsters about the result of the imminent EU referendum, then were shocked by the voters deciding otherwise.

Lesley van Reenen
Lesley van Reenen
7 months ago

A very interesting read… I am no lover of Macron but know little about French politics. This fleshes things out a bit. Plus I’m a proud cat lady myself!

ARNAUD ALMARIC
ARNAUD ALMARIC
7 months ago

Very glad to see you have returned to the fray!
I was beginning to wonder if you had been “hoovered up” by a passing Great White, off that fabled beach of yours.

Lesley van Reenen
Lesley van Reenen
7 months ago
Reply to  ARNAUD ALMARIC

Here I am – just in a very busy phase to start re-engineering my life so that I can perhaps enjoy a constant beach lifestyle.
I do idly wonder at times if those with strange names in caps are one and the same person!

ARNAUD ALMARIC
ARNAUD ALMARIC
7 months ago

How very perceptive of you. Covid-19 and the Censor have felled a fair few, but the power of Resurrection knows no bounds.

AC Harper
AC Harper
7 months ago

Interesting times bring forth interesting politicians. The corollary also applies… interesting times expose the weaknesses of run-of-the-mill politicians.
Has Macron done enough? Will Le Pen be able to seize the opportunity? Whoever wins will be informative, either confirming the French Deep State or confirming the rebirth of populism. Interesting times, indeed.

Christopher Barclay
Christopher Barclay
7 months ago

It’s difficult to portray Le Pen as ‘Far Right’ when Zemmour is around. This has made her ‘respectable’. She has gained more votes in the centre-left to centre-right than she has lost on the far right.

Nicky Samengo-Turner
Nicky Samengo-Turner
7 months ago

Superb! Oh for a Marine Le Pen in woke nu britn

Dennis Boylon
Dennis Boylon
7 months ago

God Bless Marine Le Pen. She is with the people. The Globalists are humanities enemies. They are our modern day Hitlers, Maos, Stalins. Gates, Schwab, Fauci, Biden, Johnson, Macron. These evil satanists must be defeated or all of humanity may be lost

Samir Iker
Samir Iker
7 months ago

What is fascinating is how fascism has been attached to people who merely want to curb immigration.
As if the fuhrer was famous for turning away those millions of muslims and Jews queung up to enter the Reich.

leculdesac suburbia
leculdesac suburbia
7 months ago

As an American, I find this a very helpful piece.
I wonder if “formal feminist statements” can be contrasted with being “the one most perceived by public opinion surveys as having womanly, even motherly traits.” I guess that depends on how one defines feminism, which has now become as broad a term as humanism, secularism, or even liberalism, in that it’s typically used these days by different people to describe positions that are polar opposites.
My understanding of the French–especially traditionally French men–is that they’re perfectly happy to support an attractive, middle-aged, traditionally feminine woman, particularly if she’s an avowed nationalist. That means she’s not questioning features of French culture that tend to really piss off Anglo-American feminists (like the normalization–even expectation– of straight male marital infidelity because men are considered powerless over sexual desire, or double standards for female behavior like drinking, that sort of thing.) So avowed French nationalism in a sense is inherently perceived as non, if not anti-feminist.
The traditional benefit of French–even European–culture over American is that they don’t have outrageous, youth-obsessed, plastic surgeried, pornified standards for female “beauty,” but instead believe that une belle femme d’une age certaine is still beautiful, if she takes care of herself. It seems to me that French women don’t become as invisible as they age as women do in America; part of that is their attitude and self-care, and part of it is again, this assumption/expectation that straight men are always attracted to well-kempt women of most ages. So older attractive French women still carry themselves (and dress) as if they’re still relevant–and men treat them that way. European American men I know who’ve spent time in France are always commenting on the many attractive older women they see just walking down the rue. Le Pen comes across as another Deneuve, or Helen Mirren–a pretty middle-aged nurturing Mom who’s pleasant to gaze at but not distractingly sexual.
Of course, it’s outrageous that women’s appearance figures this much into political leadership in the first place, but having said that, one has to deal with the reality on the ground.

Sean Meister
Sean Meister
7 months ago

A Le Pen presidency with a Zemmour first ministership would certainly be a French Right dreamteam. Still can’t see Macron losing it though.

jane wilde
jane wilde
7 months ago
Reply to  Sean Meister

Gosh Sean I sincerely hope that you are wrong…
Macron is already the most arrogant of people…I do not use the appellation ‘of men’ because he is not a man in any sense of the word… a schoolboy who seduced his class mistress, whom he married as a foil to hide his queer tendancies, which in fact he conceals so poorly that one of his boyfriends nearly ended up in jail for assault and battery, but somehow managed to beat the rap due to his closeness to ‘notre cher president’…does one need to elaborate further?
Macron is a usurper of the true role of the leader of the French people…he slid in by the back door and may God forbid that he manages to repeat this trick…
Marine Le Pen is a decent person, with good intent…she deserves the chance to lead us back to sanity…
I am sure she will spend a huge amount less than the macons on their hair and make up or a start…give the lady a break…
Vive Marine!!!

Dennis Boylon
Dennis Boylon
7 months ago
Reply to  jane wilde

God bless Marine and you too!

János Klein
János Klein
7 months ago
Reply to  jane wilde

Very amusing but though I dislike Macron nearly as much as you seem to do, I find it very odd that in all this time, we’ve had only gossip and rumours about his sexuality, but no hard facts, no leaks.
It seems he’ll inevitably make it through the first round voting but after that, who knows what might happen?

Ethniciodo Rodenydo
Ethniciodo Rodenydo
7 months ago
Reply to  Sean Meister

Economic hardship may, I think, mean that Macron has an uphill struggle

Zorro Tomorrow
Zorro Tomorrow
7 months ago

A country which could fall for Macron must either be simple minded or indifferent. Times have changed and it would appear Zemmour peaked too early. The French, as a race, are unpredictable and Paris is very much like our London Islington set with mental boundaries limited to inside the North Circular. Maybe the Périphique will reveal a Red Wall. She has my vote but I still have no idea if she means us well. I’m pretty sure the other contenders do not.

Jane H
Jane H
7 months ago

Being a former investment banker with Rothschilds, Macron is merely a political puppet to further the elitist agenda.

Ian Barton
Ian Barton
7 months ago

I wonder if Macrons team is intentionally trying to encourage the voters to select her – rather than any of the others – as his opponent for the run off.

Nicky Samengo-Turner
Nicky Samengo-Turner
7 months ago

“Barrister by trade” surely not? Solicitors are trade, Barristers are a noble profession?!

ARNAUD ALMARIC
ARNAUD ALMARIC
7 months ago

“Inner for the rich, Middle for the scholar, Greys for the w***e and Lincoln for the ******”.

Bruno Lucy
Bruno Lucy
7 months ago

I like tha way Anne Marie Moutet writes. However, I strongly disagree when it comes to who is responsible for the yellow jackets uprising.
I find it particularly shocking that the then Prime Minister Eduard Philippe comes out of this clean as a whistle when in fact, it is HE who was, against Macron’s advice, pig headed in introducing this fuel tax that was never going to fund environment protection, as well as this ludicrous 80 km/h speed limit from 90 km/h.
I remember vividly this Sunday evening watching the national news with Philippe full of arrogance tried to sell that this tax was for the common good as well as 10 km /h was going to save thousands of lives.
When Macron tried to diffuse the crisis right off his plane from Argentina…….it was too late.
People have no memory and the press, a very selective one. Édouard Philippd is now hailed as the French’s favorite political figure.
What a tragic farce……even more tragic if this leads to Le Pen election.

János Klein
János Klein
7 months ago

A very interesting and knowledgeable essay on the forthcoming French election vis-à-vis Marine le Pen, Zemmour and Macron.

I would disagree with you however, when you say MLP’s party (le RN) isn’t fascist any more. Despite her new and softer, cat-loving image and some newish members, I think her old party-base is still very right-wing with fascist tendencies – which is why Pécresse’s LR party (the Conservatives) wouldn’t touch it with a barge-pole. Zemmour is far more able to unite both strands on the Right, but if opinion polls are to be believed, he won’t make it to the second round – which is a pity because, unlike Le Pen, he could really give Macron a worthy opponent.